Re: Trying plane *LINK*
Larry Williams
"...A worker who has learned to use a double iron is able to plane "difficult grain" without "problems"."
Hmmm, can I assume you think I'm incompetent? That all those producing single iron planes aren't able to master double irons?
Okay, how about some photos of your planes and close-ups of the irons? Maybe a description of how you tune set your cap iron. I'm hoping you have sharpened your iron and reset the cap iron more recently than 40 years ago and may possibly remember how you do it.
I will admit you have an advantage over me. You've used one of our smooth planes. However, by the time you used it, that plane had seen a lot of use during the previous two and a half days of the Valley Forge WIA. It was hardly fresh from the stones sharp. You pulled out a small piece of curly hard maple and took a couple passes. The only comment I heard you make to the guy with you was, "Sweet."
I will also admit I haven't studied cap irons to the extent of Steve Elliot but I've certainly paid attention to his information and the chip breaker study of Professor Chutaro Kato (link below). I don't necessarily agree with all they've concluded but the information is useful. They both agree that optimum effectiveness requires the cap iron being set at .004" (the thickness of a dollar bill) or less. I kind of question the practical application of those tolerances especially when one considers cambered irons. Are you working to this kind of tolerance? What angle do you deflect shavings to? Do you camber your irons?
The very slight raised grain left by steeper pitches is the result of increased visco-elastic deflection of the wood fibers ahead of the cutting edge. Cap irons, when set very close to the cutting edge emulate steeper pitches by using the beam strength of even fine shavings to achieve the same kind of deflection. Can you explain why this doesn't leave the same surface quality? I think it does.
How about a nice tutorial with photos, Warren?
"Effect of chipbreakers"