New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

C&W videos

Posts

C&W videos

#1

C&W videos

ThomD

In a recent article about C&W, there was mention of the intention to issue more plane making videos possibly free online. Has anyone seen any sign of these, will they be on the LN website, or youtube? The molding plane video is complete, but I would love to see more info on the bench planes.

Re: C&W videos

#2

Re: C&W videos

David Weaver

I don't know anything about those videos, but I have been bugging (on the forums) for a comparable video for bench planes and smoothers.

Anyway, Gary Roberts reprints a book that has a five or six page (or maybe it's 3 or 12) brief discussion of how to make wooden planes, how to set up templates, etc. I can't remember which one of the books it is, but it's related to western new york planemakers and has a gray cover.

That's probably totally worthless advice unless:

1) you want such a book, which focuses more (IIRC) on the planmakers and less on the plane making

2) Gary Roberts remembers which one its in

3) 1 and 2 are true and the book is still available

Anyway, I think it would be very helpful if you can't find the discussion anywhere else, if for nothing else other than the very general layout aid and jig discussion.

If it helps at all, and it probably doesn't, I think the book details Chapin planes just because of their location, and a lot of the discussion centers around what it took to find the people, arrange agreements and living quarters etc to run a business. Not sure why the "how" section was added, but I was glad to see it.

Re: C&W videos

#3

Re: C&W videos

ThomD

Thanks for those thoughts. i have been making planes for 30 odd years, and pretty much know how to do it, but only recently with the kind of planes C&W makes, sorta a return to my roots kind of thing. I have a ton of beech wood that is curing away.

Over the years I have picked up some local planes at flea markets etc: There is suprisingly little consistency about how their details were handled in the mouth, lower abutment, wedge area. Some of this may have to do with how they have been treated over the years, but for the most part it appears to be original intent. So I am looking forward to how the C&W team will explain best practices in this area.

I am pretty happy with how my coarser planes work at the moment, but the rounded blades make for few problems escaping shavings compared to finer work. The two main types I built earlier in my work, Krenov, and Japanese style planes, do not have these issues.

Re: C&W videos

#4

Re: C&W videos

David Weaver

It's hard to tell with old planes sometimes if they were made loose or if a lot of their mouth has been lashed away by trips over a jointer or belt sander.

I haven't yet found one that I'd copy, and I've probably had....a dozen, maybe?

I see your point. It's hard to figure out what you want to do exactly without something to copy.

I have not made krenov style planes, but have put together three infills, soon four, and the little bit of time I experimented trying to make the style of planes clark and williams makes, as well as trying to get a few craftsman-made planes to feed well makes me think I'll keep making infills - it seems easier to get the mouth and bedding details exactly the way you want because there is room to work and you're forced to work slower with steel, a file, marking fluid and scribes around the mouth.

Share the pictures and details if you have some success before anything new comes out.

EDIT: upon coming home, it's in the WPINCA book, which is a nice book to have if you're building planes in general. There are a lot of profile pictures, etc in it. I don't know if it can be gotten anywhere.

Re: C&W videos

#5

Re: C&W videos *LINK*

Peter Evans

The book you are looking for on wooden plane making (Gary was selling NOS volumes he had, long out of print) is:

Ken Roberts, Wooden Planes in 19th Century America vol 2, 1983, chapter II, pp18-66

The book is mainly about the Chapin company. The chapter on plane making was by other authors , not Roberts.

When Roberts died his remaining book and reprint stocks were dispatched to John McDonald in Canberra, Australia. These were destroyed in a huge bushfire in 2003 that burned hundreds of houses, including that of John McDonald. So you need to either find a library with a copy on WorldCat, or Abebooks (http://www.abebooks.com/servlet/SearchEntry) or similar.

Cheers

Peter


http://www.worldcat.org/

Re: C&W videos

#6

Re: C&W videos

David Weaver

I had no idea it was that long out of print. I got one of the NOS copies that was sold this past year.

Re: C&W videos

#7

Re: C&W videos

ThomD

I've made a bunch of planes inspired by the old C&W jack planes design, with the usual proviso that anything good about them is probably because I plagerised, and anything bad about them is probably because I had never seen a C&W plane and didn't make it properly. :) I have a lot of my own ideas in them though, and this has created problems when it turned out certain beding angles didn't work with certain handle designs. Also, now that I am on hiatus as I wait for my plane wood to dry out, I am spending more time on blades. I never bothered with tapering originally since it doesn't ad that much to what I do, but it will make for a more refined plane with greater longvity, which is good in the abstract. I am also working on making more floats. The hand made ones have been relatively successful, but I find it difficult to do the full width ones by hand, so I am gearing up for that. Overall the more info I have, the less time I will waste on blind alleys.

It would be cool to know a little more about the kinds of tools used to make the cuts on these planes; I am experimenting with wedge fit laterally to stop the points from hanging up, so I would love to know more about that, wedges being the least likely parts to remain original; I would like to know more about whether the shaving escapement should be full width or not, it seems to vary so more than one thing will work, but might as well hear about the history of all that; I would like to know the best way to secure handles, though I have an updated method and probably won't change it.

The Krenov planes are pretty good, but they operate mostly with light cuts since he did his roughing by machine. A lot of modern planes are designed around machines, which is fine, but if one makes cuts outside that range it may reveal problems in the overall design.

Re: C&W videos

#8

I've been watching this thread

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and I know "C&W" refers to our respected colleagues Bill Clark and Larry Williams, but every time I open this messageboard, a little part of my brain says, "Country and Western? Did I go to the right board?"

Bill, grateful to have seen Bill Monroe (in his 80s, he made the rest of the musicians on stage at the Opry that night look like beginners with Sears instruments); and to have sat ten feet from Doc Watson while he sang his lovely songs

Re: C&W videos

#9

Re: I've been watching this thread

ThomD

Never thought of that, I guess for some of us our esteemed collegues are more prominent than the whole CW industry. I did go to Nashville once for a guitar conference, and was most impressed at the idea that there is a city that has music in it's skyline like mine has banking...

Re: C&W videos

#10

Re: C&W videos

Larry Williams

Thom.

Our plans are still to get videos up but we don't plan to cover the information you're looking for. At least if I understand your post right. The portion of the plane you have questions about is, I think, one of the problems with double irons that was never solved. The point where the tips of the wedge meet the abutment and the highest spot on the cap iron needs to be a perfect match to avoid creating a shaving trap. Obviously sharpening the iron, adjusting the cap iron, wear or even varying wedge pressure changes one or all of these points. I don't think it's a coincidence that, historically, planes and irons suddenly seem to get wider as soon double irons were adopted. This allows cambering of irons to keep shavings away from these choke traps. it's another example of why double irons weren't an improvement for the user.

I've included an image of the inside of an old Baldwin try plane that shows these points misaligned.


Sorry this is such a brief reply but I'm posting from a motel room on a netbook with a too-small screen on my way to WIA.

Re: C&W videos

#11

Re: I've been watching this thread

David Weaver

It's funny that you mentioned doc. When I see CW, I think of clarence white.

Re: C&W videos

#12

Great musicians in small settings

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I used to think that I lived in a smaller, long-since-lost world, in my youth - I saw Doc Watson and his son in Ann Arbor, in a little coffee house; and Dave Van Ronk in the same coffee house on another night. Seating capacity was maybe 50 people, if they were all friendly-like; I think there were maybe 30 in each show. Like a lot of musicians, they'd play little gigs on Thursday night in little towns near the main Friday night gig.

I was comforted that the musical world can still be small when I took my son (this is years ago now) to see John Lee Hooker in a venue not much larger than that coffee house; and Carlos Santana, who gave Mr. Hooker a lot of support in his later years, showed up to sit in, in the background, halfway through the set.

Re: C&W videos

#13

Re: That's a stinkin Gloat!!

ThomD

Re: C&W videos

#14

Re: C&W videos

ThomD

Thank you Larry, that is an interesting perspective on the double irons. I dropped those decades ago when I noticed they didn't really seem to affect my cut much though they do interesting things for the shaving. With Japanese planes they could be independantly adjusted with occasionally spectacular results. One oddity of the modern world is that whiile wood gets less and less available, it is also more and more available. So while there is less, for instnace, musical instrument grade wood out there, weird stuff keeps happening, people find new ways to exploit old logs, or open up russia, or just pay more for wood on the internet. The result is that we have access to any wood we could possibly want, at some cost. Imagine trying to make arrows out of backyard wood, relative to calling up rose city in oregon. Then there is just the extremist thing, people just insist on perfect stock because their time is precious and they won't even undertake the first plane of their whole career without perfect wood. So to some extent we have undergone a regresion to the point where whatever it is the breaker was supposed to acheive it isn't needed just as theoretically it evolved to deal with more complex woods. Of course there are still burls and such out there...

Interesting photo. Is that abutment at a side angle to retain the wedge? That sounds like two more specialized floats a person would need to have...

I feel your pain about the netbook, I just bought one the other day in order to get a computer with XP. I l love it, but I am also a guy with aging eyes and some days it works for me better than others...

Re: C&W videos

#15

Who?  Me?  Gloat? Why, I'd never do that

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: C&W videos

#16

The joy of small venues

Bob Hackett

Some of my more memorable nights out involving music have been in very small clubs or halls where big names came to either warm up or wind down.

I saw Stevie Ray Vaughn play in couple of roadhouses after concerts and the shows were more from the heart.You could tell he was playing because he wanted to not because he had to,just for the joy of it.Johnny Winter was the same way.

When the opera house in Boothbay Harbor(the next town over from us) was being bought by a non-profit association they put a call out to whoever they could think of to help pay for the cost of buying and renovating the old building.

People like Jackson Brown,Johnny Winter and Mark Knopfler of Dire Straits were some of the artists we saw in that hall that held less than 500 people max.Those nights were far more memorable than any of the big concerts I went to.

All the artists acted like hosts at a party and took time to talk with the audience and ask what they wanted to hear and how they felt about the opera house coming back to the community.They said they were glad they had taken the opportunity to come play for us and thanked us for bringing them to Maine.

Outstanding people giving back what they could where they could after folks like us had made them famous.

Re: C&W videos

#17

Trying plane picture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The double iron trying plane that I have used for more than thirty years doesn't look anything at all like that. If the plane you picture is the kind of double iron plane you have tried, it is no wonder that you have had problems getting it to work. If a fellow wants to use this type of plane he has to be able to solve problems and make adjustments.

Re: C&W videos

#18

Re: Trying plane picture

Larry Williams

Warren,

I don't tend to travel with a huge number of old planes to photograph in motel rooms for an unexpected opportunity to post something. I just happened to have that photo on the netbook I travel with. Not that I'd be likely to have a real good example of an old double-iron plane, I sold off those long ago unless they had some special feature worthy of in-depth study.

Still this photo does clearly show the three critical points I mentioned and has a mouth big enough they can be photographed.

I'm not surprised you don't have a plane that has all the features shown in the photo. The reason I kept this plane is that it's an example of EW Carpenter's 1849 patent for a wooden plane with a mouth closing second wedge that's visible behind the iron. While these aren't super rare, they're not all that common. Still, I thought you might be familiar with this since EW Carpenter was also from Lancaster.

Even though this plane does have both a big mouth and an adjustable mouth, the mouth adjusting feature was never used because the second wedge is still secured in its original location with the original screw in the original holes.

Re: C&W videos

#19

Re: Trying plane picture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for your reply, Larry. Yes, I am familiar with the Carpenter patent. EW Carpenter planes are common and very popular among collectors in this area. For those who are interested there is also a picture of one of these planes in Roger Smith's Patented Plane book.

What I was referring to was the condition of the plane. My trying plane wouldn't work either if it was in that condition. One can't take a plane that has been so abused and expect the shavings to pass smoothly through the orifice. It is like buying a car at a junk yard and wondering why it doesn't run. One has to be able to solve any escapement problems in order to use these planes.

Re: C&W videos

#20

Re: Trying plane picture

Larry Williams

Warren,

You didn't mention what exactly is your cure for the problem of differing locations of the tips of the horns on the wedges. With the abutment ends sitting up in the middle of the escapement sides, the tapered iron changing thickness with each sharpening, changing wood dimension with differing humidity, variable cap iron location and variable wedge pressure maintaining the exact location of the wedge tips, the thickest part of the iron/cap iron assembly and the end of the abutments becomes quite an issue. There are an awful lot of variables but the end location of those three points aren't variable if one wants to avoid a shaving trapping choke problem.

The one consistency I see in old double iron planes and even those used by people like Roy Underhill and Adam Cherubini is that irons are sharpened so that only the center portion of the iron is actually taking a shaving. I believe that's why planes suddenly became wider, heavier and more clumsy with the introduction of the double iron.

If you've found a cure that makes all the variables consistent, I'd sure appreciate an explanation.

Re: C&W videos

#21

Re: Trying plane picture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have to say that I don't have a formula for bringing a plane into fine regulation. I have used the same bench planes since the 1970's and problems since then have been rare. Perhaps if I were a collector or a manufacturer who was constantly dealing with this I could catalogue the problems and devise a scheme. My advice is to see where problems are occurring and make adjustments. My attitude has long been that guys were doing this in 1790, why can't I? What I don't advise is throwing up one's hands and saying "nobody has ever figured this out".

My trying plane is 2 15/16 wide, the iron 2 3/8. I would not mind using one with a 2 1/4 or even 2 inch iron because it would make the plane somewhat lighter. I can't see that there would be any problem getting a narrower width to work nicely.

Re: C&W videos

#22

Re: Trying plane picture

Larry Williams

There is no problem with narrower planes, they're more agile and easier to use.

I see no reason to foist the problems of double irons on customers when cutting geometry is more effective at controlling difficult grain situations. Even as problematic as bevel-up planes are, they've proven that cutting geometry is more effective with difficult grain than cap irons. The simple fact that most contemporary infill makers have followed our lead and are producing single iron planes with a variety of steeper angles shows the effectiveness of using cutting geometry to control difficult grain has a lot of merit. The abutments of single iron wooden planes can run the length of the escapement and don't have the issue of a hump in the iron so all the problems of double iron wooden planes vanish in single iron planes. Plus one also gets the advantage of using the whole iron width so planes can be narrower and easier to use.

Re: C&W videos

#23

Re: Trying plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

High cutting angles are more effective for those workers who have not learned to use a double iron. However, there are some disadvantages to high angle planing.

1) Higher angles are much more abusive to the edge because the force is closer to perpendicular. This shortens edge life. Most workers would never abuse the edge of chisel in such a scraping manner.

2) Because it is more of a scraping action, higher angles also leave a poorer surface which lacks the silkiness, clarity, and sheen of one which has been planed at a low angle.

A worker who has learned to use a double iron is able to plane "difficult grain" without "problems".

Re: C&W videos

#24

Re: Trying plane

David Weaver

There are those of us who can use a double iron with proper effect who still choose a tight mouth and a steeper single iron instead, because it is less trouble in plane setup and maintenance.

There are not many woods that refuse to be smoothed in any direction with a 55 degree single iron and a tight mouth, and the modern irons hold up very well at 55 degrees (much better, actually, than the older irons hold up at 45). 60+, maybe not as well, but 55 and below, they hold up very well.

I can tell the difference in the surface between my 55 degree smoothers and a 40 degree kanna on agreeable wood, but if a workpiece is getting any finish, I'm not sure anyone anywhere could tell, especially if there is no sample piece of wood and raking light to compare it.

It just isn't worth fooling with a double iron unless a properly made single-iron plane is not available or not affordable. They do eject chips more effectly, maybe - can't deny that.

Re: C&W videos

#25

Re: Trying plane  *LINK*

Larry Williams

"...A worker who has learned to use a double iron is able to plane "difficult grain" without "problems"."

Hmmm, can I assume you think I'm incompetent? That all those producing single iron planes aren't able to master double irons?

Okay, how about some photos of your planes and close-ups of the irons? Maybe a description of how you tune set your cap iron. I'm hoping you have sharpened your iron and reset the cap iron more recently than 40 years ago and may possibly remember how you do it.

I will admit you have an advantage over me. You've used one of our smooth planes. However, by the time you used it, that plane had seen a lot of use during the previous two and a half days of the Valley Forge WIA. It was hardly fresh from the stones sharp. You pulled out a small piece of curly hard maple and took a couple passes. The only comment I heard you make to the guy with you was, "Sweet."

I will also admit I haven't studied cap irons to the extent of Steve Elliot but I've certainly paid attention to his information and the chip breaker study of Professor Chutaro Kato (link below). I don't necessarily agree with all they've concluded but the information is useful. They both agree that optimum effectiveness requires the cap iron being set at .004" (the thickness of a dollar bill) or less. I kind of question the practical application of those tolerances especially when one considers cambered irons. Are you working to this kind of tolerance? What angle do you deflect shavings to? Do you camber your irons?

The very slight raised grain left by steeper pitches is the result of increased visco-elastic deflection of the wood fibers ahead of the cutting edge. Cap irons, when set very close to the cutting edge emulate steeper pitches by using the beam strength of even fine shavings to achieve the same kind of deflection. Can you explain why this doesn't leave the same surface quality? I think it does.

How about a nice tutorial with photos, Warren?


"Effect of chipbreakers"