Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

sharpening

Posts

Re: sharpening

#26

That's my point

Neal in San Jose

Re-read the second paragraph in my first posting. What I'm saying is that magnification will reveal what you are really doing. It is very easy to get misled by poorly understood feedback, especially as a beginner. The loupe is simply an easy, affordable and easy to understand method of seeing what is going on. Once you have a method that works for you and you understand the variables, toss the loupe in the drawer and only get it out when something doesn't seem to be working.

Re: sharpening

#27

Perfectly well said!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The loupe lets you see with your eyes what's going on at the blade edge. It's a diagnostic to use when something is amiss, or when you're setting up a new system. It saves time by eliminating guesswork--once you see the problem, you know the solution.

As Neal said, put it back in the drawer once your procedures are set.

Wiley

Re: sharpening

#28

Re: Perfectly well said!!

ThomD

If we are talking scratch patterns not reaching the edge, that is called no wire edge. You can sort that problem out without a loup and probably should. I do agree that looking at stuff through any sort of magnification can prove interesting, but I also agree with the point of view that suggests working on fundamentals.

Re: sharpening

#29

Re: That's my point

David Weaver

I agree with this exactly. I have two loupes floating around my shop somewhere. I don't know when the last time was that I used one, and I doubt I or anyone else is in danger of becoming overly anal retentive with one because it's work to use them when you don't need to.

But when you change methods or first pick up something like a kanna and prep a new iron entirely freehand, it's nice to check that the scratches get all the way to the edge the first time. Once you're there, then you probably never need to look again, but you can save some work with it by seeing what you're doing and then stopping as soon as you get where you want to be.

Re: sharpening

#30

So...

Bob Hackett

What you`re saying is it`s looking to clue you in and open the door to knowing.

I will totally agree with that.We are after all,mostly visually oriented creatures.

As to the concerns about people taking the concept of magnification and running off the edge of the earth with it.Some people were just born to be the human equivalent of lemmings.Nothing we can do to save them,it`s imprinted in their genes.

Our time would be better spent washing pelicans.

Re: sharpening

#31

Re: Perfectly well said!!

wilbur

"If we are talking scratch patterns not reaching the edge, that is called no wire edge. You can sort that problem out without a loupe and probably should."

(emphasis added)

Why? What is wrong with using a loupe? I would argue that using a loupe is nothing more than a quick and direct way of figuring out if your scratch patterns reach the edge or not, that it's much easier for a beginner to grasp and get feedback, and that even experienced sharpeners can check an edge just as quickly with a loupe as feeling for the wire edge.

As for me, I think that my edge are pretty passable, and although I don't always do this, I still use a loupe if I think I am having problems with a particular tool after my usual sharpening routine. If that is the case, I'll use the loupe to check my scratch patterns after my 1000 grit waterstone, my 5000 grit waterstone, and my 8000 grit waterstone. Each time I use the loupe, I can easily assess the edge in 5-10 seconds easily, which means that at most I've added a whopping half a minute to my sharpening routine. I don't see how this somehow leads to an obsession with sharpening.

In fact, I think that using a loupe has made me more efficient at sharpening, because I've developed a really good feel for how long each successive stage of sharpening should take to establish its scratch pattern. With the loupe, I learned that I was spending more time on my middle stone than I had to, since the loupe told me that my scratch pattern reached the edge nicely before I could feel a wire edge. Without the loupe, I would have continued to spend more time on that middle stone than I needed to.

It's not that feeling for a wire edge is wrong, nor is looking for the disappearance of the line of light a bad thing to do. They are all different ways of accomplishing the same thing. But using a loupe gets a bad rap, while the other methods don't, and I'm puzzled as to why that is the case. If one is of the mindset that he/she will become obsessed with sharpening to the detriment of making projects, I really don't think that using a loupe or not will somehow prevent that from happening.

A loupe may not be the traditional way to check your sharpening, but you can't deny that it is an effective and efficient way to do so.

Re: sharpening

#32

Re: Perfectly well said!!

ThomD

My knock on a loup is that it is one more thing. If one could sharpen without it, how often would one use it just because it's fun to look at stuff? So it seems like another crutch. Crutches tend to stop one from learning better methods. But obviously there is no reason not to do it if you are inclined to do it, and I have heard that people at the upper end of peformance use microscopes because it is slow going and one often will not find an edge by other means, and then need to know whether they are where they need to be on the 20K stone. But that is not the performance level the OP is at. My feeling is he needs to form a wire edge, which is also a crutch of sorts, just not an extra gear one. I'm trying to drop as many unecesarry steps as I can.

Re: sharpening

#33

Re: Perfectly well said!!

wilbur

"If one could sharpen without it, how often would one use it just because it's fun to look at stuff?"

Speaking from my experience, I don't use it, other than checking my edges when I think I need to.

As for the extra gear issue, I keep my loupe on a little shelf right above my sharpening area. It's handy, easy to get to, quick to use and put away, and it doesn't get lost.

And as far as the extra steps issue goes, by this logic, one could say that it's unnecessary to have anything more than a smoothing plane, since it's possible to flatten a board using just a #4 without using a try or a jack plane for the initial steps, and that the jack and try planes are extra gear. I'll reiterate that using the loupe has saved me many steps in the long run, by showing me that I was oversharpening on my middle stone.

Re: sharpening

#34

Re: Perfectly well said!!

bugbear

Crutches tend to stop one from learning better methods.

I'd call that a generalisation too far. In many cases, crutches that make a skill easier, or address PART of a skill, allow a smoother, and possibly faster, learning curve.

You learn to juggle with bean bags, not chainsaws.

BugBear

Re: sharpening

#35

Wire Edges & Magnification

Steve Elliott

First let me plead guilty to being someone who has spent more time on sharpening than was strictly necessary for productive woodworking. I've gone to higher magnification than a loupe and I think I've learned things that might be useful to more practical craftsmen (and women).

Regarding wire edges, I've found that when sharpening a fairly dull blade it's not enough to use the coarse stone until a wire edge forms. To remove the wear surface from the back of the blade some additional work is required. It took me some head-scratching and a digital microscope to convince myself of that, but now I know to check the back of the blade before going on to finer honing stones. If I hone the blade back on my finest stone to remove the wire edge and there's still a shiny line at the edge, I need to remove more from the bevel.

On finer stones reaching a wire edge is a good indication of having honed enough.