Re: How to determine flat
wilbur
Hi Brent,
I guess that this is one of those "it works for me" situations. Or as the great philosopher Yogi Berra once said, "In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is."
I think that if you have the coordination to use a chisel to trim a tenon, you have enough coordination so that you don't have to worry about putting a convexity on a waterstone using this method.
Periodically I do check my waterstone with a straight edge after flattening this way, and if there ever is an issue, it's always that there is a residual dish to the stone, which happened to me on occasion early on when I was more concerned about "wasting" the waterstone and not flattening for long enough. I haven't had a residual concavity in a very long time, and I have never gotten a convexity.
I do have one natural Japanese waterstone that came to me flat in the center and slightly convex on the sides. It isn't that hard to concentrate your sharpening in the middle area -- after all, that's why waterstones develop a dish in the first place.
The specific reason why I like this method is that it is the most convenient way of flattening a waterstone for me. That diamond plate sits by my sharpening pond all the time, and I don't have to move the waterstone. 30 seconds and the waterstone is flat.
I do have a flattening plate, and to use it I have to get it out, set it up, pick up the waterstone, flatten it, clean and dry the flattening plate off, and put it away. Of course, if I had a bigger sharpening pond I could leave it set up all the time, but it still would be less convenient than my current method. And with sharpening, I have found that convenience is key.