Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

sharpening

Posts

sharpening

#1

Bob

sharpening

Bob

I use a diamond stone and waterstones (2000 grit and 8000 grit) to sharpen chisels ,plane blades, and knives. I have reasonably good results and I dont have to fiddle too much after I put a good bevel on the tool.

I finish the job by hitting the edge with a buffing wheel.This makes a huge difference in the final result.

The question I have is what am I not doing using the manual techniques that requires the use of the buffing wheel. My edges coming off the 8000 grit will cut hair on my arms say 50% of the time. After the buffing wheel, the hair falls off in fear of the edge. I have tried a strop after the 8000 grit but it does not compare to the buffing wheel. Any recommendations? I would like to keep the whole process manual.

Thanks,

Bob

Re: sharpening

#2

Questions

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Do you hone the whole bevel, or just a micro-bevel?

Do you hone freehand, or use a honing jig?

Do you keep your waterstone flat?

I hone a micro-bevel freehand on a 8000 waterstone, and I can shave my hair easily. I know I didn't do a good job when the hair won't shave and/or the shaving leaves the skin irritated.

DC

Re: sharpening

#3

Re: sharpening

Tony - Memphis

Hmm. I'd be afraid that the buffing process would kind of curl the edge over. I use the Norton 1000/4000/8000 stones. I also use a jig (Lee Valley and recently the side grab jig). I don't do anything special or unique. I do find that keeping the stones (via a diamond Duo Stone blue and black) flat made a big difference. I finish up with green stuff (Lee Valley) or yellow stuff (depends on the mood) on a piece of MDF. I can shave off the 8000, but I think the "hard strop" makes a difference. I sometimes use a secondary bevel, but always because sometimes, I like to touch up by hand and find it easier without a secondary bevel. But the secondary is much faster for me. Anyway, not sure this helps, but keep at it and you'll find the right technique for you. Amazing what a difference sharp tools (and flat stones) make.

Tony

Re: sharpening

#4

Re: sharpening

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bob,

You can figure out what's going on at the edge with a 10X or 15X loupe. Look at the edge after each sharpening stage, to see what scratches are there, as well as whether the scratches from the last stone have been removed. Compare the final edge you are getting off the buffer as opposed to the strop.

To illustrate what I'm talking about, I'll offer my guess as to what you'll find, using a loupe.....The diamond stone (what grit is it?) is likely leaving deep scratches--that is characteristic of diamond, and the better the diamond stone, the deeper and sharper the scratches. The 2000g stone is not able to remove the diamond scratches--it is sharpening over them, resulting in an edge which is reflecting light well, but which is still slightly ragged from the deep diamond scratches. The 8000g stone likewise will brighten the edge to your eye, but will not remove the original diamond scratches. Nor will a hand strop. So you have an edge which feels sharp to your touch, but which is still a little "toothy" from the diamond.

Now when you put the motorized wheel to it, you probably are removing the previous scratches right at the edge, bearing in mind that the wheel is likely rounding the edge over a bit and removing metal as it does it.

The above is just my guess based on what I've seen diamond do, when you look up close. You can find out right away by looking--it will be very clear to you and not the least bit mysterious.

Wiley

Re: sharpening

#5

Re: sharpening

wilbur

Ditto on getting a jeweler's loupe. I got a 20X version on eBay that comes with 2 LED lights, and learned more about my sharpening technique from using that thing than anything else that I have.

Given that you can get one shipped to your door for under $12, it's kind of a no-brainer purchase.

Re: sharpening

#6

Shaving is easy

Neal in San Jose

Commercial razor blades are only sharpened to about a 1200 grit waterstone, so just because you can shave, your edge isn't necessarily very sharp, but if you can't, you know it is seriously dull. I agree with the idea of getting a loupe. Do a search over on the bay for a "lighted microscope". Mine is a 30 power, and I really learned a lot when I upgraded from a regular 10 power magnifying glass. My friend, Don Naples, who developed and sells the "Lap Sharp" and knows more about sharpening than anyone I know uses an adjustable 60 to 100 power. I've used his, and I may add one of those to my tool kit. You can get them for less than $10 plus shipping. Watch the shipping costs; some are coming from Hong Kong or elswhere and the shipping is way more than the cost of the microscope.

The point is that without good feedback, you really don't know what you are doing. Then, once you get a good method to see what you are really doing and use it to correct your sharpening process, you don't need to use it except when something isn't working well.

My guess is that under magnification, you will see the finer scratch pattern isn't going all the way to the edge; you are leaving some of the previous coarse scratches untouched right at the edge either due to technique or a slightly dished stone. Then the motorized wheel is removing enough metal to get a pretty sharp edge, but also dubbing the edge over and not really correcting the problem.

Re: sharpening

#7

Bob

Re: Shaving is easy

Bob

The diamond stone is the roughest I could find. I dont recall the grit but it may be 60 or 80 grit.I try to keep my stones flat but I also think try to do everything correctly.How do I determine flat? I use the flattening stone and there dont appear to be any dips when I am done. Analysis of the edge is exactly what I need . I have used cheap magnifying glasses in the past and could not really tell much. I will look for the loupe or microscope you have recommended.

I dont use a jig and try to get to sharp quickly so I think your analysis re ragged edge is probably correct.

Thanks,

Bob

Re: sharpening

#8

How to determine flat

Joe

Take a pencil and scribble over the entire face of the stone, making sure that you get near the four edges as well as across the entire stone. Now flatten the stone as you normally do and look at the face. Anywhere there are still pencil marks indicates a shallow and lets you know that your stone is not flat. Once you rub the stone flat on your flattening media and all of the pencil marks are gone, you know that the stone is flat.

Re: sharpening

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: Shaving is easy

Leo Cuellar

Have you flattened and polished the backs of your plane blades, etc? Scratches or waviness could be causing the mixed results you get. I am a big fan of buffing for a final edge, and get fantastically long use times with a few seconds buffing at intervals during use.

Re: sharpening

#10

Re: How to determine flat *LINK*

wilbur

I have a short video on how to quickly flatten a waterstone using a diamond plate, using the technique that Joe describes. It doesn't take too long, maybe about a minute if it's your first time doing it and if your waterstone needs a lot of rehab. The link is below.


How to flatten a waterstone

Re: sharpening

#11

Trust but verify

Neal in San Jose

Back when I was getting started, I bought a full set of waterstones and a flattening stone from Japan Woodworker and was good to go. Or, so I thought. I spent good money, and this stuff was good and accurate, right? After months of frustration and inconsistent results, a friend finally suggested that perhaps my flattening stone wasn't flat. I checked, and it was badly dished in the middle. I'm a pretty slow study, apparently. I was using the method Joe describes, but since my flattening stone was dished, I was making my waterstones convex. With great care and concentration you could use a humped waterstone, but it wouldn't be fun.

I stopped using the flattening stone and switched to coarse sandpaper on float glass to flatten my waterstones, and my sharpening improved remarkably. It's possible to have issues with the sandpaper on glass (and I have found them all) but with care it's a good method.

I also have a coarse diamond stone that isn't flat!!! It is sort of shaped like a potato chip. It was expensive. And worthless for what I wanted to use it for.

A good method for checking the flatness of your blade is to color the area in question with a Magic Marker then draw it carefully one pass across your verified flat surface. The high points will be rubbed clean and the low points will still be colored. You can do this with the unaided eye or low magnification.

I hope that somewhere in the advise you are getting there's going to be an "Aha" moment when you suddenly realize what you need to change to improve your results. Keep checking back in!

Re: sharpening

#12

Re: Shaving is easy

David Weaver

I think Brent Beach covered the job done on a commercial razor blade and concluded that right at the edge, it's honed by something finer than 0.5 micron paper.

...

found it:

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/qx3.html#Razor%20Blade%20Images

The general thought on the straight razor pages (at least when I looked last time) was that when you hone and strop a straight razor blade, you will likely get it as sharp as a feather commercial blade that has been used a few times, but that the commercial blades are maybe "too sharp" for a beginner. I don't know how much of that is due to grit size vs. edge geometry.

Clearly, it's easier to shave hair with a lower bevel angle given the same size scratches from final honing.

Re: sharpening

#13

Trust but verify redux

Neal in San Jose

Someone I trusted told me that razor blades are only sharpened to a 1200 waterstone and I never bothered to check. My bad! From the pictures, it looks like that's about what the primary bevel is, and then they go further.

My contention is still the same: just because you can shave your arm, doesn't necessarily mean the edge is ready for wood. Cutting hair is a different and I'm not convinced related operaton. Back in my wayward youth I built model airplanes. I had a plane that used a double edge razor blade which worked really well on balsa wood, and I'd bet it would work on my arm, but it was worthless on wood harder than balsa.

I think we should apply for a government grant to study this question, tho.

Re: sharpening

#14

Re: Trust but verify redux

David Weaver

You can definitely shave your arm with an edge that will still leave lines across your work or leave a dull surface.

If you looked at a razor blade without magnification, it probably would look like a 1200 edge. that polished edge is probably tiny - I'd think that they aren't going to do any more honing than they absolutely have to even though the price of the razor blades seems to double every four years.

When I was in college, you could get mach 3 heads for 75 cents each, and I thought that was really expensive then. I haven't even looked what the latest whiz bang razor costs now for refills, but I recall seeing a LOT of reports that gillettes earnings were up on strong razor sales, and they made the statement that basically as long as people kept buying razors, they'd keep up the price increases at a fast pace. The investors probably like that kind of talk, but it sure keeps me from ever looking at their razors when there are bic disposable triples for less than 50 cents at sams and a straight edge in the basement bathroom that costs me nothing but some glycerin soap and an alum bar to use for a very long time.

Re: sharpening

#15

Re: How to determine flat

Brent Smith in Montreal

Hi Wilbur,

I've always felt that moving a flattening plate (of any kind) over a stone is asking for problems. Varying force applied by different sections of the hand, coupled with keeping the motion of the hand perfectly coplanar to the face of the stone can easily lead to a convex stone. I prefer to have my plate stationary and move the stone over it. While I may not end up with a coplanar stone I do end up with a flat surface. Do you have a specific reason for doing as you do, or is it just a case of 'it works for me' ? BTW, I put in an order with Hida for a plate :).

Re: sharpening

#16

Re: Shaving is easy

ThomD

The two test for a razor are to lick your fingernail and see if the edge catches at a low angle. This is probably you 1200 grit and wire edge removed stage/washita stone. High razor is lick your finger tip and try for a catch, this takes a very sharp edge to do. These methods do not scratch or hurt the finger allowing the barber to repeat them as required, without resorting to microscope or hairy arms.

Re: sharpening

#17

Re: sharpening

ThomD

Main issues are you need to complete sharpening at each grit before you move on (look for the wire edge, however slight), and you need to sharpen with correct angles. Jigs can help you with both. I learned by sharpening freehand, and then returning to the jig if I couldn't get the right results. Say, if I rounded over the edge.

Buff will bail you out because they can deal with slightly rounded edges so you can not work through the grits and still get an edge. I can get a fair edge straight from the coarse grinder, with a buff.

Re: sharpening

#18

Re: How to determine flat

ThomD

Simplest method I have found when using water stones is to get 2 800 grit stones, and just rub them together, then rub the 800 on the 1500, etc... Some people say this contaminates the finer stones, which could be true but it doesn't cause ill effects as far as I can tell, and some fairly develped folks use this method.

Re: sharpening

#19

Re: How to determine flat

wilbur

Hi Brent,

I guess that this is one of those "it works for me" situations. Or as the great philosopher Yogi Berra once said, "In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is." ;) I think that if you have the coordination to use a chisel to trim a tenon, you have enough coordination so that you don't have to worry about putting a convexity on a waterstone using this method.

Periodically I do check my waterstone with a straight edge after flattening this way, and if there ever is an issue, it's always that there is a residual dish to the stone, which happened to me on occasion early on when I was more concerned about "wasting" the waterstone and not flattening for long enough. I haven't had a residual concavity in a very long time, and I have never gotten a convexity.

I do have one natural Japanese waterstone that came to me flat in the center and slightly convex on the sides. It isn't that hard to concentrate your sharpening in the middle area -- after all, that's why waterstones develop a dish in the first place.

The specific reason why I like this method is that it is the most convenient way of flattening a waterstone for me. That diamond plate sits by my sharpening pond all the time, and I don't have to move the waterstone. 30 seconds and the waterstone is flat.

I do have a flattening plate, and to use it I have to get it out, set it up, pick up the waterstone, flatten it, clean and dry the flattening plate off, and put it away. Of course, if I had a bigger sharpening pond I could leave it set up all the time, but it still would be less convenient than my current method. And with sharpening, I have found that convenience is key.

Re: sharpening

#20

Do the math...

James Watriss

Think of the physics involved... a buffing wheel has 6-8" diameter, gives a circumference of around 18-24".

It rotates at around 1800 rpm, if you're using a slow speed grinder. That gives you something between 2700-3600 feet per minute. Or, if you buff for one second, that's 45-60 linear feet that has gone past the edge in one second. Considering that it takes me about 2 seconds to carefully slide a blade down 8" of polishing stone, that's about 4 feet per second. If I'm in a hurry, it's about half a second for 8", or 16 inches per second. The short math is that I would need to sharpen for 11 to 15 times longer at normal speed on the finest stone I have, or 3 to 4 times as long if I was in a hurry, to get the equivalent rub on the stone as I'd get from a buffing wheel.

But you're also getting the light, light touch of a much softer surface, which very much lessens the damage possible from a stray piece of grit from an earlier step, or from general contamination. One of the other problems with sharpening manually is all of the little glitches and hand movement errors, and other things... and if you were going to spend the 15 times longer to do it that way, you run the risk of introducing a lot more potential error.

So... if you want a strictly manual method, I guess you'll just have to take a lot more time.

But realistically... you have a very, very efficient and effective system to sharpen your tools. I say don't fix something that isn't broken.

I think it was Tage Frid who was known for doing his sharpening with a belt grinder and a buffer. Until today, I'd never really thought about why. Now I'm going to have to go look for a buffing wheel.

Re: sharpening

#21

Re: Shaving is easy... keep sharpening

James Watriss

The proof is in the pudding: how does the wood cut?

You can spend all day with loupes and such, but it's one more way to move towards obsession.

Don't get me wrong, I think there's a time and a place to get obsessed about a good edge. But I think that loupes take it a little too far.

Work the wood until the blade is dull, and try to do a better job of sharpening next time. Which is more important, the edge, or the surface it creates? And is the steel you're using really going to hold up that much longer at such a refined state?

If you're really going to obsess that much, I suggest you use the loupe twice. Once to check the finished edge, and once to check it after only one swipe with the plane, or one chop with the chisel. The latter will give you a better gauge of working sharpness. A polished edge on a softer steel will definitely degrade much faster, but still be workable for a long time.

My concern with the loupe is that it could lead the truly obsessed to take up a "chop once, strop twice" kind of lifestyle that's more concerned with the tool than with productivity. Work for a while, and buff for a second is a much more productive way to go.

Re: sharpening

#22

Re: Shaving is easy... keep sharpening

Dean J in MN

Spot on James!

Sharpening should be a means to an end, not a hobby in and of itself (well, I suppose you could make it your hobby).

No need to go overboard, not every tool needs to be sharpened to the same level. Sharpen only as sharp as required, no more. Fore planes sure don't require the attention a smoothing plane would. This isn't to say I don't take take care when I sharpen my fore plan iron, rather it means I spend extra time with my smoothing plain iron, knowing the extra effort is worth it. If I were to polish my fore plane iron to the degree I do my smoother's iron I'm afraid all that effort would be gone in about 3 passes over rough stock.

So, if there are new woodworkers reading this thread -- you don't need to go out and by a microscope to sharpen well enough to work. There is a learning curve, but it isn't that steep. Keep working, sharpen each time your tool gets dull (and watch your definition of dull change as your skills improve). Before you know it you won't even think about the process.

-D

Re: sharpening

#23

Leo Cuellar

Well said!

Leo Cuellar

Re: sharpening

#24

Re: Shaving is easy... keep sharpening

wilbur

I don't think that the loupes are taking it too far. I was able to get sharp edges and fluffy shavings from my first pass at learning sharpening, and thought I was doing well enough. Then I picked up a loupe, and saw that despite what I thought I was doing, that my scratch patterns on the lower grits were not getting all the way to the edge of my tool, even though I could not see the "line of light" that I was told to make disappear.

After using a loupe as a check to ensure that the scratch pattern did indeed reach to the edge of the tool, I found that I still could make fluffy shavings, but my tools did work better in terms of how much effort they took to use, and they held their edge longer.

The loupe is just another way to check what you are doing when sharpening. If looking for the line of light, or feeling for the burr are acceptable ways of checking your sharpening progress, then so is using a loupe. In fact, I would argue that using a loupe is easier than either the line of light or feeling for the burr methods, and it takes seconds to use, and requires no learning curve in terms of knowing what a burr feels like, or holding the tool the right way to catch the line of light.

Re: sharpening

#25

My Objection...

James Watriss

Hi Wilbur...

I don't object to the use of any methods available to check your work. I was merely observing that there are folks who get so wound up over sharpening that they take it too far... to the detriment of their ability to do useful work with that microscopically perfect edge. And using a loupe could encourage that kind of obsessive behavior even more by revealing a surface that's not as clean as it is to the naked eye.

There are times... rare, mind you, but they do exist... when a *perfect* edge is a real necessity. For people using woods that are obnoxiously prone to tear-out, using planes with hard and tough enough steel that the edge will actually hold up for more than a few inches, who are making the absolute final polishing pass... then yes, by all means. The last pass is the one that matters, and it's all in support of providing the best possible finish. But for those who are meticulously slaving away for however long on softer chisels, or on something like a mortise chisel... which is about to get brutally abused... a loupe is really overkill. In addition, I feel like I own very few tools that actually reward that degree of fussiness... the rest of them have steel that is soft enough that the first stroke of the mallet will ruin the pristine sharpening job. (Most of those tools are Japanese in origin... jury's still out on the Holtey iron in my #4.)

In the context of those woodworkers who are prone to going overboard on sharpening, I think the loupe runs the risk of encouraging a high level of OCD.

Sharpen the chisel, check the stove, sharpen the chisel, check the stove, sharpen the chisel, check the stove...