New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

The halfback saw project

Posts

Re: The halfback saw project

#26

Re: I read somewhere....

Bob Hackett

Two questions;where`d you hear that and was one leg longer than the other after you were told that? :D

Re: The halfback saw project

#27

Re: I read somewhere....

Marv

Bob,

I didn't hear it, I read it somewhere. I do live on the side of a hill and my memory is consistant with the length of my uphill leg.

Lets give it a couple days, maybe someone here will relate a personal experience.

I should google it.

Marv

Re: The halfback saw project

#28

More HB saw progress: Cutting the plates

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Hi gang,

I got some time this weekend and figured what with it being about 95 deg in the shade what better thing to do than work out in the garage cutting metal.

I drew up a profile for the halfback saw profile and then marked up the saw plates. Then it was a simple matter to score along the line with a abrasive disk equipped Dremel. I didn't cut all the way through, just scored it. Then I clamped the waste side in a metal vice and snapped it like a sheet of glass. After that I cleaned up the cuts at my belt sander.

I also cut up the brass for the backs. After some cleaning, it'll be ready to be epoxied in place. Then'll I'll drill for the brass screws, cut off the heads, and peen them over.

saw plates cut to size

Just as a teaser, here's a shot of the saw plate and the handle to show the final configuration (without the brass spine of course)

halfback saw mockup

If I can get the saws plated cleaned up, I plan on epoxying the brass spines in place some time this week so I can get to work on the handles.

More progress to follow.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: The halfback saw project

#29

Well Dom...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Those cow skulls are coming to life! How did you get the blade shape? Did you pattern it after another saw?

Great work, please keep us posted.

Re: The halfback saw project

#30

Re: Well Dom...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

The teeth were cut/punched, but not sharpened. I'll sharpen them myself after I'm done fitting the handle and before I do the final assembly.

Re: The halfback saw project

#31

Actually...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I was asking about the shape of the saw blade it's self, not the teeth. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

Re: The halfback saw project

#32

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Actually...

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Scott,

From the first thread in this new entry:

"I drew up a profile for the halfback saw profile and then marked up the saw plates. Then it was a simple matter to score along the line with a abrasive disk equipped Dremel. I didn't cut all the way through, just scored it. Then I clamped the waste side in a metal vice and snapped it like a sheet of glass. After that I cleaned up the cuts at my belt sander."

ok? If you're wondering, the dimensions came from Mike Wenzloff's reproduction of the original Disston Halfback. I tell you, Mike helped me out a ton!

Dominic

Re: The halfback saw project

#34

More Halfback saw progress: making the brass spine

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Hi gang,

In this installment of my "Halfback saw saga", we move on to making and installing the brass backs.

Now as you already know, I NEVER do anything the easy way. And this part of the project is no different. You see, I had three halfback saw plates so I figured that I'd make laminated spines for all three. And I went as far as cutting up the brass and drilling the holes. But a bad glue up on my part lead to a failure of the bond. I twas then I decided to rethink my strategy.

Pedder (whose Dovetail saws were recently featured in Mike Wenzloff's Blog) had sent me a pre-slit piece of brass. All I needed to do was cut it down and I'd be able to use that. And I had some 1/8" thick brass plate. So I had the raw materials to make a folded back. Therefore, why not make each saw have a different style brass spine? One laminated, one folded, and one slit. So that's what I did.

Laminated and Slit Spine

The laminated one was the most labor intensive. You need to cut two strips of brass to the same size. Taping them together helps you out a bit here. Then you drill one side, transfer the holes to the saw plate, drill that, then transfer the holes to the other piece of brass. Oh, and you have to make sure that they all line up! Then you epoxy it all together, install the brass rod or brass machine screws you'll be peening over, and allow it to dry. That's pretty much the way I handled it. Drilling the saw plate was a royal PITA. This stuff is HARD and I dulles a lot of bits. Enough so that I went and purchased a Drill Doctor to bring them back to life (how's THAT for rationalizing a tool purchase?). About this time Jack (Timberwolf from WoodNet) clued me into a cool technique for softening the spring steel so it'd be easier to drill. It's called "spot annealing". You get a HSS drill rod and install it in your drill press. Set the press for high speed, mark your hole loactions on your saw plate, clamp the plate down (a really important step!!) and bring the end of the rod in contact with the hole location and hold it there until it turns red hot. Presto! You now have a soft soft to drill!

Here's a shot of the spine and machine screws all glued in place. I used JB Weld for the bond.


At this point I started work on installing the slit spine. I drilled the holes the same way as the laminated spine and then expoxied it in place. Since you are dealing with one piece it was a much less labor intensive install. I imagine if I had slit the back I'd have to add that labor into the mix. But overall I liked this a bit better than the laminated method.

Here's a shot of the slit spine all epoxied in place and drying. No need for clamps on this one! :yes:


After letting them sit overnight I had to clean off the excess epoxy. I used a piece of brass (another Timberwolf tidbit!) that I shaped into a scraper blade. The brass was hard enough to scrape off the glue, but soft enough so that it would not mark the spring steel. I also used blue painter's tape to protect the spring steel from scratches while I was peening the screws over, and then filing and sanding the surfaces smooth.



After that it was a simple matter to sand the surfaces to about 1500 grit then buff with Tripoli


Formed (folded) Spine

This is the "old method" that Distton used on their back saws back in the day. Of course, they probably had an industrial sized bar folder. Since I didn't have access to this I had to go all old school and form it by hand. I started off by rumaging through my scrap bin and coming up with a nice piece of 1/8" thk brass. I wished I had 0.090", but you work with what ya' got on hand! Let me tell you, there is a reason why those brass spines are NOT made of 1/8" brass! Folding that stuff over is no picnic!

Once again I went to Jack and he advised me to anneal and quench the brass before bending. So I got out the torch, an cinder block to work on, and a bucket of water.


After that I set up my metal vise and went to work. As you can see below I had to use one of my "small" hammers.


The bar got folded over 90 deg, then it was folded over some more until the edges touched. I then got a scrap piece of 0.032" thk spring steel and slipped that between the fold. I then beat the living hell out of that brass bar. I'd beat it, lift up check my progress, check to see if it was still straight, and then beat it some more. In the end I got it folded over nice and flat. I removed the scrap spring steel and then filed and sanded the spine. Lucky for me that I used 1/8" thick stock! I had to remove a good amount to get rid of the hammer marks! But the end result was worth it. I made this down and dirty jig from a piece of 2x4 to hold the spine while I sanded it.


Then I sanded it to 1500 and buffed it with a Tripoli compound.


After that it was a simple matter to install the spine on the back of the plate. Working from one corner, I tapped it in place with a rubber mallet until it was set. Then I worked my way down.


Here's a shot of all three saw plates. From the top it's, Slit Spine, Laminated, then Folded

I know that there are those who can make those laminated spines in their sleep. But after trying all three methods I think that the folded spine and slit spine were the easiest. If I can make (like the one on Leif's site) or buy a nice bar bender, I think I'll be using the folded method more.

Thanks for viewing.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: The halfback saw project

#35

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Joe

Dom, as usual an excellent job! Now for the hard question: How do they saw? Is there any difference in use with the three spines? Inquiring minds want to know.

Re: The halfback saw project

#36

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Joe,

Thanks for the compliments!

You wrote:

"Now for the hard question: How do they saw? Is there any difference in use with the three spines? Inquiring minds want to know."

Only time will tell my friend! I still need to drill the holes for the saw nuts, let in for the spine and plate, and then shape the handles. After that I need to sharpen them all!

I'm thinking of filing one as a rip saw. Any thoughts on that?

Re: The halfback saw project

#37

Filing one rip

Bob Hackett

You know if you don`t do it then you`ll immediately find a need for it. ;^)

You do after all have 3. :)

Re: The halfback saw project

#38

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Marv

Hi Dom,

Nice job you are doing on those saws. Looking forward to the finished versions. :)

By the way....for drilling holes in saw plates, use a "solid carbide drill." You can buy them cheaper at ENCO. www.use-enco.com And use a cutting fluid when you drill. The secret to extending your drill life is to keep the cutting edge cool. You can get the cutting fluid at ENCO also. They sell it in small amounts. Spot annealing for drilling gets the job done, but is a brutal way to do it. When drilling the larger holes for the handle screws, it will be much easier with a carbide drill, believe me.

Marv

Re: The halfback saw project

#39

Re: Filing one rip

Dominic in Buck's County PA

My thoughts exactly! :D

I mean, what can it hurt? If I don't like it i can always file it cross cut.

Re: The halfback saw project

#40

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Thanks for the compliments Marv!

You wrote:

"By the way....for drilling holes in saw plates, use a "solid carbide drill." You can buy them cheaper at ENCO. www.use-enco.com And use a cutting fluid when you drill."

I'll take your word for it Marv! I needed a couple things from ENCO anyway. :D

Re: The halfback saw project

#41

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Marv

Hi Dom,

You probably already know to do this, but when you drill your saw plates in your drillpress, clamp the plate on top of a piece of soft steel so the drill has something to drill into as it exits the bottom side of the plate. This will produce a clean hole with minimum burr and will drill a round hole instead of one thats misshapen.

When making saw plates and handles/totes, theres always the question which to drill first, the plate or the handle. The old saw makers drilled the handles first, then used the handle as a template, hence, no two sets of holes are the same. The handles are usually not interchangable. I've seen a varience as much as a 1/4". The handles are usually difficult to pull off due to huge burrs on the exit side of the holes in the plate.

If your method of drilling the holes in the plate is accurate, you can use your tote as a template, but I would not do the drilling with the plate in the slot of the handle. I always mark where the holes should be, center punch the location, then clamp the plate in my drillpress as I described above.

The other way to do it is to just drill the holes in the plate first and use the plate as a template, being careful to line the top pf the handle up with the top edge of the plate or in your case, the brass back. This is my preferred method. This way, if by chance a drill decides to not drill exactly where I expect it to, I can still make it match the holes in the tote.

The present day saw makers probably use a punching method for doing the holes in the plate. Thats the way I'd do it if I had lots of plates to do. Punching the holes is the most accurate and quickest method.

Marv

Re: The halfback saw project

#42

Nice progress report

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Excellent Dom. I for one appreciate your efforts and your complete documentation of your quest.

:D

Re: The halfback saw project

#43

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Thanks for the input Marv. I planned on using the handles as a template for marking and then punching/drilling the holes in the saw plate (I've been told by a couple people that Harbor Freight has one of those punches that will work perfect for this). And since I work off of a handle template I drew up I found that my hole placement is close enough so that the handles can be interchanged.

BUT having said that I am seriously considering taking your advise and drilling/punching the saw plate first. I can see where this would make it a lot more accurate.

Re: The halfback saw project

#44

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s *LINK*

Marv

Dom,

If you haven't already bought your saw screws and if you haven't already heard of Bad Axe Tool Works, Mark Harrell has come up with a very nice selection of various screws and nuts that he uses on his new saws. He sells the screw sets at a reasonable price. And he gives you a choice of different metals and finishes. For a final touch of personalization, you could buy his blank medallions, send them to Catherine Kennedy and have her carve your initials or name on them. Your three saws will be an accomplishment to behold.

Marv


Screw Sets

Re: The halfback saw project

#45

Re: More Halfback saw progress: making the brass s

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Marv,

i already bought a set from TFWW. But sending a couple to Catherine is a GREAT idea! I may do just that!