New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The halfback saw project

Posts

The halfback saw project

#1

The halfback saw project

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Well folks, I finally started on my much awaited (for me anyway) halfback saw project. And like everything else "new" I do, it's more than one. You know, in order to overcome my eventual screw up. Because the minute I get cocky and think I can do it the first time out, BAM! I screw up big time. So I'm making 3 (count em' 3!) halfback saws. Two will be 10 TPI, and one will be 9 TPI. I may make one of the 10 TPI rip and the other cross cut. But that remains to be seen.

I've always liked the design of a Wenzloff Halfback. I think the size if perfect for the kind of work I do. it's especially handy for work around the house, or when you're up on a ladder. But from what I understand, they are especially useful for cutting BIG tenons. Like the kind you see on a Roubo bench (oh snap! I think that's a dead give away!)

I started on the handles about 2 weeks ago but did't get around to downloading the pics until tonight. I chose some Apple, Walnut, and Gonsalo Alves. All the handle blanks were then surfaced to just a tad over 7/8" thick.

Halfback saw - Handles

I worked on the handle profile in AutoCad and made sure to show the centers of each curve and circle. Having the center point allows me to use an appropriately sized Forstner bit to drill out that section of the curve. The patterns were printed out full scale and then, after the grain was aligned correctly, I used 3M spray adhesive to glue them to the blanks. After drilling I bandsawed out the exterior curves. I still need to use my bowsaw to get rid of the waste at the hand hole. That'll probably be after I complete the saw plates

Halfback saw - Handles

Halfback saw - Handles

Two of the saws plates were made from 1095 blue polished spring steel that I got from work. I sent these to my buddy John Payne (jcav8ter from Woodnet) and he used his Foley Re-toother to form teeth at 10 TPI. I intend to use the glue, screw, and peen method to attach the brass back on these two.

The third saw plate was a gift from Pedder (also from WoodNet) and was sent with 9 TPI teeth already cut into it. Pedder also sent me a pre-sit brass back.

But first the "bluing" had to be removed on the two 1095 saw plates. It's tough bluing. Nothing seemed to want to get rid of it. It sneered at Tripoli, and other rouges. Trying to use regular gun bluing to repair a scratch made the scratch stand out like a sore thumb. So I resorted to trying to sand it off. That seemed to work. But it was pretty labor intensive. So I whimped out and bought a $50 Ryobi belt sander to use just for this purpose (and to clean up the side of one of those foam core doors I have on a closet in my house. (What, you think I'd use a hand plane on THAT junk?).

Before I started using the belt sander I made a simple jig that consisted of a 8" wide x 30" long piece of 3/4"MDF. I screwed a 1" cleat to the base, and then clamped in in my work bench. Some doubled sided carpet tape held the saw plate just fine.

Halfback saw - Saw plate

Well, that belt sander made short work of the bluing!

Halfback saw - Saw plate

I was careful not to stay in one place long and switched to hand sanding for the area long the edges. I just sanded to 80 grit all the way up to 400 grit and look how it turned out!

Halfback saw - Saw plate

Before trying this technique out on my saw plates, I actually started with a scrap piece. But it came out so nice I think it'll be made into a large tenon saw!

Halfback saw - Saw plate

Well, that's all for now. Hopefully the rest will progress as fast. Look for more updates soon.

Edit: Leif from the Norse WoodSmith site just notified me that a 10 minute long bath in citric acid followed by some light scrubbing will remove the bluing. I've also been told that vinegar(citric acid) will do the trick as well. If I get a chance I will experiment with this and report back.

Thanks for viewing.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: The halfback saw project

#2

Re: The halfback saw project

Larry Wyatt

These look like very cool projects, Dominic. Nicely done so far! I'd heard of the citric acid/vinegar for rust, but not for bluing! Very cool idea!

Is it me, or do the handles(with the holes bored) look like a bit like cattle with cleft palates? I think it's probably just me. :b

Regards,

Larry Wyatt

aka Cole's Dad

Re: The halfback saw project

#3

Looking intriguing, Dominic

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'll be interested in the final product.

One note: you may have been typing a little fast when you referred to vinegar as citric acid. It's predominantly acetic acid, although Wikipedia does mention that it may contain tartaric and citric acids as well.

I've just started, late to the party I know, experimenting with vinegar for rust removal, and am so far pretty impressed.

Re: The halfback saw project

#4

Re: Looking intriguing, Dominic

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Yes, I typed too fast. If you look on WoodNet you'll see I referred to vinegar as "acetic acid".

Re: The halfback saw project

#5

Nope...

Tony - Memphis

Looked like cow skulls to me too!

Re: The halfback saw project

#6

Re: Nope...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

darn it! I just viewed the photo again and I'll be darned if it doesn't look like cow skulls to me as well! :D :D :D

Re: The halfback saw project

#7

Marketing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Hey, if Woodruff and McParlin could have their Panther saw and Mark Meier his Beagle saw, no reason you shouldn't have a Cattle saw.

Side note, wandering off topic: In doing a little online search to come up with the best term here ("cow skull saw" just didn't have the right ring), Google offered me "cow synchronization" as a search term. Those in cattle country will say, "well of course," since it has to do with getting the breeders in the herd to come into estrus at the same time, no doubt to get the beef to market efficiently.

I was picturing Esther Williams coaching a bunch of cows to turn and amble at the same time and in step.

Re: The halfback saw project

#8

Re: Marketing *LINK*

Paul M.

I too saw cow skulls. The picture showed them at just the right angle.

I don't have a video of synchronized cows, but sheep are pretty close...


Watch the pretty sheep

Re: The halfback saw project

#9

I'm not altogether sure the sheep are synched

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but the collies sure are - but then, they always are; and stoked, too. Our son's girlfriend's dog, Arlo, was a mix of the Aussie and related sheep dogs, who sublimated his herding instinct by chasing balls...all...day...long. We should have purchased one of those tennis ball machines; would have saved our arms.

Re: The halfback saw project

#10

Re: The halfback saw project

Dean J in MN

But first the "bluing" had to be removed on the two 1095 saw plates. It's tough bluing. Nothing seemed to want to get rid of it. It sneered at Tripoli, and other rouges. Trying to use regular gun bluing to repair a scratch made the scratch stand out like a sore thumb. So I resorted to trying to sand it off.

You just need to dip your plate in vinegar; the blue will vanish before your eyes, just like my days in the darkroom watching photographs develop, only in reverse. (I found this out *after* I went through the same pain you did... But in the future, you know the trick!)

Dean

Re: The halfback saw project

#13

Dale Lenz

Re: Marketing 101

Dale Lenz

Call it a Bull Saw. Get ready to start taking orders. Nice work!

Re: The halfback saw project

#14

Bluing kill

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I discovered how to trash bluing by accident, soaked some tools in a vinegar/salt bath to remove rust. Worked perfectly, even though I wasn't trying to kill the bluing. :)

Pam

Re: The halfback saw project

#15

Re: Bluing kill

wilbur

I wonder if vinegar can be used to remove bluing from wood.

Ask Dominic why one would want to do such a thing. ;)

Re: The halfback saw project

#16

I saw smirking steers!

Stuart Hough

Re: The halfback saw project

#17

You bet! 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: The halfback saw project

#18

Removing the bluing

Dominic in Buck's County PA

As an experiment I took several pieces of 1095 blue polished and soaked them in a 10% solution of citric acid/water.

Here's a before shot:

1095 Blue Polished Steel - Before soak

To say it was quick is putting it mildly. Once the steel hit the drink it took less than 2 minutes to get rid of all of the bluing. There were some areas that needed some coaxing. But that was just because I forgot to degrease the steel before immersing it.

1095 Blue Polished Steel - During soak

Here's a shot after I rinsed the pieces off and then dried them with a heat gun. After that they got a coat of oil.

1095 Blue Polished Steel - After soak

Well, Lief certainly supplied one of the best tips I've gotten in a while! Nothing I like more than a solution to a problem that actually reduces the amount of work required.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: The halfback saw project

#19

It does raise the question...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

of what function bluing has, if it's that easy to remove. I've certainly seen enough blued rust in my life to doubt its longterm value as a rust preventive coating.

Re: The halfback saw project

#20

Re: It does raise the question...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

It is a pretty tough covering. But by no means is it a rust preventative. I'd call it a "temporary rust deterrent". :D The company I work for uses this spring steel to make helical spring covers for shafts, cylinder rods, and ball screws. So typically, a cover made from this stuff never sees any kind of acid.

In addition, I've been told that the bluing is NOT a true rust preventative. Nor in our case is it really intended to be so. It is a result or part of the tempering process. Typically to reduce the chances of rusting we recommend wiping them down with a light duty machine oil or RustVeto.

Either way, I'm just glad I found a way to remove the bluing so quickly. It certainly opens up a world of possibilities for me. :D

Re: The halfback saw project

#21

Re: It does raise the question...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Bluing is actually a type of oxidation. It is, as you have found, easy to remove and needs to be treated with some type of anti oxidant coating to prevent rust and pitting. I prefer to think of it as a decorative treatment only.

JR

Re: The halfback saw project

#22

Squirrel Urine

CJ in MPLS

Came home last summer one day to find a plastic shopping bag in the back yard outside the garage door which was weird. I looked inside the bag to find a dead squirrel and some bike parts I hadn't used as yet. When I asked my wife about it she thought that I had put the dead squirrel in the bag. Investigation turned up squirrel shite and urine all over the garage, including on the blued blade of a crown square. After cleaning it everything up, the square has a nice shiny steel spot in an otherwise blued blade. Apparently the squirrel came into the garage when I was working with the overhead door open and became trapped when I closed it. The squirrel hid whenever we came or went over the course of a week but was nice enough to climb into a plastic bag to die. I did have to fish out the bike parts though.

To get back to the topic at hand, urea is readily available, cheap, and other than the ick factor, much safer than industrial acids. ;)

CJ

Re: The halfback saw project

#23

Somehow...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I doubt there'll be long threads on this forum about the best diet to feed your squirrels to maximize rust removal on old tools.

Re: The halfback saw project

#24

I thought...

Bob Hackett

We all agreed to give up squirrels in favor of monkeys.

The monkeys could at least be trained to do the more mundane tasks like flattening the backs of old plane irons and chisels once the pee had removed the rust. :)

Re: The halfback saw project

#25

I read somewhere....

Marv

......that a pregnant women's urine will remove rust from a handsaw.

Anyone with any first hand experience? Or second hand for that matter? :\

Marv