Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

A not so humble pencil

Posts

A not so humble pencil

#1

A not so humble pencil

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I wonder who here appreciates a good pencil?

Wood pencils have long been banished from my shop. In the beginning I used to sharpen them with a chisel. The chisel was replaced with an old school grinder sharpener. And then I replaced the wooden pencils.

These days I use 2mm clutch pencils. The ones I prefer are the Caran d'Ache Fixpencil 22. These have become something of a cult as it was the daddy of clutch pencils.

The lead is sharpened with a Gedess Lead Pointer, which I believe once won an award for design in the 1930s. The one I have dates to the 1950s.

This combination creates a fine point, one that is easy to maintain.



Well they are handtools! :)

Anyone else have a favourite?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A not so humble pencil

#2

David Barnett

Ticonderoga Triconderoga *LINK*

David Barnett

Mechanical lead holders having been my mainstay for decades (except for artists colored and pastel pencils), only recently have I returned to wood pencils for everyday writing, and only the new Triconderoga brand, which complement the triangular file and chisel handles I've been making for years. Thank you Dixon.


Ah... the comfort. And in basic black.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#3

Wood pencils, when I can find them

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

so many of the "wood" pencils these days are made of some plastic, possibly the same stuff they're making fake wine bottle corks from, with all the stiffness of a T-shirt after its 450th washing. They go from full length to short stubs rapidly, because the plastic wood substitute provides no support to the lead, which then snaps into short little chunks.

You have to wonder what the manufacturers are thinking - it's kind of like those block planes that can't possibly be made to plane wood and are sold to people who know they should have one but who will never actually use it. Oh, hey - it's EXACTLY like those block planes...

Re: A not so humble pencil

#4

Business decision

Warren in Lancaster, PA

About six weeks ago I made a business decision for my shop. I changed from cheap pencils @.08 to Ticonderoga @.32 a piece. Well worth the additional expense.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#5

Stuck in the past . . .

steve mackay

Used to use clutches and mechs only. Since I got the shop up and running I've gone to wood. After many, many disapointing brands I've found that good wooden pencils cost as much as, say, Lee Valley's bargan mechanical ones (or more !). I don't know . . . wood pencils just give me a warm fuzzy I guess.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#6

Actually I used those a lot...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

In college. I still have all my old drafting tools. I prefer Koh-I-Noor or Chavese (sp) brand myself. I rarely use them any more. For the wood shop I use 0.5mm and 0.7mm Pentel mechanical pencils with "H" hardness lead.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#7

Perhaps...

Bob Hackett

Those block planes were never meant to shave wood.

Perhaps they were designed to sharpen plastic pencils. :O

I still favor the old,flat carpenter`s pencils.They`re harder to lose,though I still manage it on a regular basis. :(

Re: A not so humble pencil

#8

Left handed pencils

JohnP

I don't know if they still make them, but at one time Ticonderoga made a left-handed pencil. What?, you say. What's different is the printing on the pencil. When a left handed person holds a pencil, the print is upside down. They made a pencil with the printing reading top to bottom so that it was read right side up when held by a left handed person. Always wanted to order some for some left-handed friends, but never did.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#9

Re: A not so humble pencil

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Great topic!

Like Scott, I use mechanical pencils, 0.5mm, 0.7mm, and 0.9mm, depending. HB.

Used Pentels for years, but now prefer Staedtler iRemedy, because of the fatter barrel, and the larger and easier to advance eraser.

Eraser? Sure--otherwise use a knife. For big messy erasures, not unusual for me, I keep White Pearls around.

Now for dark wood (don't use it much), that's a different matter. Don't know what works well there. I use a Pentel rollerball and raking light to try to see it. Bill Tindall solved this problem some time ago, with a magic holographic ballpoint or rollerball, but I forget the brand (which he was very specific about).

Wiley

Re: A not so humble pencil

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: A not so humble pencil

Jack Guzman from Maine

I keep boxes of your basic #2 yellow pencils everywhere.I have 4 antique crank sharpeners in the shop. Cups on various shelves contain pencils.I tried mechanical pencils but I lose them constantly so quantity is my present system.---Jack

Re: A not so humble pencil

#11

I like 'em, too, for carpentry

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sturdy lead, and easy to sharpen with a utility knife.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#12

That explains it!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That explains why my marks are always slightly off - I'm using right-handed pencils! Another manifestation of the vast conspiracy of the right-handed world against me and all my left-handed comrades!

Re: A not so humble pencil

#13

for dark woods...

Sandor in Middletown, DE

I keep a white chalk pice handy for marking dark wood. First I scribe my lines, then I go over them with the chalk. Then I rub away the excess and voila a perfectly thin white line to work to.

Otherwise I have a set of the Koh-I-Nor Rapidomatic (.5mm/.7mm/.9mm) from my college drafting course. I use the .7 the most.

Sandor (who 99.99% of the time just lurks....)

Re: A not so humble pencil

#14

scott grandstaff

Re: A not so humble pencil

scott grandstaff

I only wish I could find a good stash of Koh-i-noor clutch pencils!!

I have one but seldom use it, they are so precious.

Funny part is, I have maybe 6 or 8 boxes of lead for one. About 10 to a box. And 2 or 3 different lead sharpener patents.

I don't much like the Pentel type skinny lead pencils, although I do keep about 10 of them assorted, and lots of lead/erasers, in case I change my mind. ;)

I have a few classic Scripto mechanicals. Also some older, cooler celluloid mechanicals. These are all great, but lead is not as easy to get as it once was.

For regular work I use regular wooden pencils. I am a little bit of a junkie over pencil grinders and have some killer-diller antiques that work spectacular.

Solid elegantly engineered metal with bakelite covers on the reservoir.

I have one from the 60's that is so cute! The shavings cup is a 3-D lions face, blown from soft vinyl. When you turn the crank the lion physically "chews" the pencil for you.

I haven't bought a lead pencil in a long time. I am running kind of low, down to a couple hundred or so.

These, of course, are the choice of thousands upon thousands. Cute names and great colors, hard, soft and fat leads, and well, lots.

If you can't find wooden pencils at every single yard sale you attend?? Every last one?? Kill yourself, you are too stupid to live.

I won't even buy them unless they are at least 50 assorted in a box, for a dime or thereabouts.

I am running low on standard carpenters pencils. Less than 1/4 the case of new ones left. Getting desperate. How many is in a case?? A gross, I think?

I try to keep at least a few in circulation, stashed here and there, at all times.

I use chalk and grease pencils on occasion.

(Well, chalk or soapstone all the time on metal work.)

Both red and black grease comes in handy. White is also available but I don't have any at the moment.

Every once in a blue moon I have to dip into the pastel drawing pencils. Or crayola, even.

Felt tips from, fat-as-a-cow, down to a mm. Assorted ball point and fountain pens I seldom use in the shop, but you never know............

Lets see, there is always a pile in the windowsill and a coffee mug stuffed so I don't have to walk across the room, and then I keep the "reserve" in a top drawer underneath the buffing station.

Its just as bad upstairs, in the house. 3 different writing instrument stashes, a couple of them generous, and then the one drawer of true collectible ones.

yours Scott

Re: A not so humble pencil

#15

Re: for dark woods...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That is a wonderful idea!! These old eyes need contrast, and that method would deliver.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: A not so humble pencil

#16

Thanks for the link

Steve Elliott

For a number of years I've been looking for Ticonderoga 2-1/2 (hardness) pencils, just the regular yellow ones. All the 2-1/2 ones I could find were really bad. Your link shows Ticonderogas in 2-1/2 . . . but they're out of stock. I've bookmarked it.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#17

Re: A not so humble pencil

woodenleg

my father one time told me what the different sides on a carpenter pencil stood for but I can't remember, can anyone?

By the way I like wooden pencils.

Dave

Re: A not so humble pencil

#18

Re: for dark woods...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I use the chalk trick as well.

What I want are reasonably priced white or yellow "leads" for the clutch pencil (in 2mm thickness). They are available but terribly expensive.

Anyone have a source?

One more point (get it? :D ). I gave up on .2 mm and .9 mm leads as these are so fragile. I also have a 5 mm clutch pencil, which is fine for rough marking, but it just does not hold a fine point long enough to be useful for cabinetmaking. The 2mm lead has been a great compromise.

I gave up on wooden pencils because they would inevitably get smaller and smaller, and get lost.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A not so humble pencil

#19

Wiley...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I've never liked Staedtler-Mars brand myself always seemed cheep to me. Sorry. Never the less that it's MHO.

I'm using the Pentel "twist-erase" models. They have a fat barrel with a comfy grip too! Also a good fat eraser that telescopes out the rear of the pencil. Nice feature :)

I prefer the old standard gum erasers when it comes to removing marks on wood. Ya know you can get that big 'ol jumbo belt sander cleaner and it does serve a double duty as well :D

Why do you prefer HB lead? I liked for lettering with it but have found it too soft for wood working, it keep breaking on me.

Re: A not so humble pencil

#20

Crayola!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I used the green crayons all the time to strop. I got into trouble when that 84 color box actually had 83. Then I ordered me one of those big green square ones :D

Re: A not so humble pencil

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re:..even with a block plane....

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A not so humble pencil

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: you mean.....

Jesper, Denmark

...that you have to turn it around to see the instructions "This end up"? :b

Re: A not so humble pencil

#23

Re: A not so humble pencil

Phil Smith

I like to use a mechanical pencils, 0.5 mm with HB, Pentel but typically make a wood barrel to replace the plastic barrel that comes with the pencil. Will this still qualify as wood pencil? It's just a small hollow spindle.


Re: A not so humble pencil

#24

A few images ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A couple of clutch pencils ...

The green one is a Linex, an Australian brand. Very nice but not as nice as the Caran d�Ache Fixpencil. These both use 2mm. The black hefty number is a 5mm clutch pecil, good for marking out rough work, but too thick for fine detail.


An old pencil sharpener ...


I was intriduced to clutch pencils early in my childhood by my father, an architect. He swore by Faber-Castell. Dad retired a long time along (he turned 96 a few weeks ago). One of the items I inherited was this motorised Faber-Castell clutch pencil sharpener in green bakerlite ...



Unfortunately it no longer works (you pop the pencilin and the weight turns the sharpener on). One of these days I will get it repaired. Any one seen one of these before?

Regards from Perth

Derek