Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Apropos of the hardening discussion

Posts

Apropos of the hardening discussion

#1

Ellis Walentine

Apropos of the hardening discussion

Ellis Walentine

I have three questions:

First, I have a couple Japanese plane irons that I retrieved from the ashes of my shop fire 11 years ago and I'm trying to figure out whether or how to restore them to proper temper.

I have a bucket full of monument carvers chisels that I snookered about 30 years ago and don't know what to do with. Any suggestions?

I have a long piece of wrought iron rod, about 3/4" in diameter. Is there some use for that in toolmaking? How long is the learning curve for making forge-welded tools and/or Damascus style blades. I have an anvil and a forge blower, but I need a reality check. Do any of you make your own laminated blades?

Ellis

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#2

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I've never had to retemper Japanese blades, but I'm sure Dave Burnard knows how. If you need someone to build new dai for them, give a yell, I've got the blanks waiting.

As to making laminated blades, the main difficulty is getting the right amount of tool steel to match the amount of iron. But Dave knows a lot more about this, too.

Pam

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#3

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Ron Bauman

I think there at least a couple of Utube videos on Damascus forging. Good-Bad I dunno, usually the masters have 2 other (younger) guys wielding the hammers. Food for thought.

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#4

Must have pressed the wrong button...

Bob Hackett

Had the post disappear on me so here I go again.

Two of the best sites I know of are iforgeiron.com and anvilfire.com.They have multiple sub-forums just like here and the discussions range from blacksmithing to welding/fabrication to sword making and everything in between.Good ,real world advice from some of the best the crafts have to offer both pro and hobbiest,just like here.

I`n no expert on Japanese irons so the only advice I would be comfortable giving is to be as sure of the steel used to make the edge as possible and then to follow the procedures for that steel as to critical temp and what to quench it in.The wrought iron is basically along for the ride on that part of the show as it will not be hardened by the process.I am speaking from my western blade experiences with laminated blades when I say this.

Once the iron has been hardened I place it in a toaster oven set to the correct temp and let it soak as per the guidelines for that particular steel.Once it`s soaked long enough I pull it and immediately quench it.Once cool I test the hardness by way of a file set for testing hardness and then put it to work if it tests where I want it.

The chisels ,if they`re meant for wood and not stone,I would treat as O1 and run one thru the process using oil to quench.If you heat to critical and quench to harden and a common file will still bite into it then it`s time to try again with a water quench.

Remember,as you harden you crank in stresses,plan on and prepare for drawing the temper as quickly as possible.I like to have the toaster oven warmed up and ready so that I can clean off the quenchant and put it directly into the oven.

Hope this has been of some help.

MB

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#5

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

dburnard

Ellis,

As a hobby, I make my own laminated tool blades in the japanese style. I use modern mild steels and older wrought irons for the backing material and various types of high carbon steels for the cutting edges. Laminating small pieces together is not too hard but takes time to learn the appropriate temperatures and techniques to get them to stick cleanly without voids or gaps and without burning/ruining the steel side with too high of a temperature.

Making tools yourself and then using them is quite enjoyable, but it is time consuming and another slippery slope. Good to practice on mild steel and 1095 or O1 until you get the hang of things. 3/4" wrought iron rods are a nice size though, easy to work with a hand hammer and suitable for small knives and chisels (harder to laminate tool steel to though).

If the plane blades are really nice or were favorites of yours you can send them to Japan for "repair", several of the planemakers do blade restoration. Tsunesaburo and Yamamoto come to mind. Since they look at a lot of spark patterns for various plain carbon and chome/vanadium/tungsten alloys it should be possible for them to identify the type of the original steel. As such they would have a much better chance of getting the hardening/tempering times/temperatures just right based on the type of steel in the blade than you or I would. Hida, Kayoko or Harrelson ought to be able to make the necessary arrangements.

If the blades were not so special, you could give it a try yourself, just be prepared to fail, possibly catastrophically (crack!), but with beginner's luck it might also work out fine. I made a rather wide laminated plane blade as one of my very first backyard toolmaking projects, it turned out quite well, only later did I realize how many places along the way things could and probably should have gone wrong. ;) I've not been getting much forge work done lately (day job interfering with hobbies again), but if you're still not in a hurry 11 years after the fire, I could probably take a look at them come winter.

Dave

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#6

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Dave

Ellis Walentine

I appreciate the reality check. Maybe I should take a blacksmithing 101 class at Peter's Valley or somewhere to get the hang of the tools and processes. It sounds like forge welding requires a lot of experimentation to get the temperatures figured out.

I had the feeling that specific alloys require specific hardening/tempering regimes, and I probably shouldn't mess around with something I know this little about, although the irons I'm talking about here are not treasures. Next chance I get, I'm going to sharpen the irons in their existing condition and see how they work. I can't be sure that they are ruined until I try to use them. It would be a good excuse to make new dai for them as well. I need some therapeutic woodworking/toolmaking (although my good half thinks I need some therapeutic kitchen cabinet construction). Never enough hours in the day.

Ellis

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#7

Ellis Walentine

Thank you for the kind offer

Ellis Walentine

I'd be honored to have a new dai for at least one of my irons, but I wouldn't want you to go to any trouble. At one point, I thought I might make non-Japanese style bodies, maybe more along the lines of a Krenov or David Finck plane, although I haven't seen irons that thick in wooden push planes. I guess there's no reason it wouldn't work.

It's a tempting offer...

Ellis

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#8

Re: Thank you for the kind offer

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, the offer is genuine and given freely. I'd love to make you a dai or two, especially since I've made most of the ones I need and still have blanks. I don't think the laminated bodies are quite so good as a mortised dai.

Pam

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#9

Steven Antonucci

There is a Pattern Welding class at PV

Steven Antonucci

If you have ever taken hammer to hot metal, odds are that you can probably bypass the 101 course. I'm sure that there are lots of things that I don't know about blacksmithing, but I've been around the smiths at PV enough to get things done with my basic setup.

The Damascus, or more appropriately pattern welding, class is considered advanced. If you don't own an air hammer, expect to be very, very tired. Like woodturners, blacksmiths are a very helpful bunch. You might want to reach out to Dick Sargeant at PV to bounce some ideas off of him. I know you'll need to get some borax as a flux for welding, and you are going to want a deep pit to reduce the amount of oxygen (and minimize scale formation).

Steve

P.S. hand cranked blowers are so 19th century. I use a small hairdryer :-)

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#10

scott grandstaff

Old Irons

scott grandstaff

Ellis

Take a file to your old irons first. If the file won't cut they are still perfect. If the file digs in easy, they have been annealed by the fire.

Send them to an expert if they are precious.

Rehardening, if you want a go at it, you hardly need much for.

Burgers and cake, are on the menu!

An old barbecue, a hair dryer or other air moving device, and a can of oil. Peanut oil is said to be second best behind sperm oil.

But old used motor oil will do in a pinch or anything else you can get real cheap..

Have a scrap of wood a little bigger than the oilcan handy too.

Get some real charcoal for the grill. Get it going good (use extra charcoal for later)

and ........

after the burgers are done and consumed,

stick your irons on top of and underneath some of the coals.

Rake a few more over top.

After a few minutes preheat time, take the hair dryer and bring one of them up to bright cherry. Some fiddling around with the air and placement of the coals is required and sparks will fly, so at least wear gloves and glasses.

When you get one blade up to bright cherry (dull red won't do, bright cherry looks practically alive), try to hold it there for at last a few seconds (soak time) and then quick, grab it and plunge it straight into the oil, cutting edge first. Sloshing around is good. Use long handled tongs (very large pump pliers, chanellock, will do)

Best to keep your hand away from the oil though, as it is likely to catch fire. Remember the scrap of plywood that is a little bigger than the oilcan??

Um yeah, do not panic!!

calmly,

smother said fire placing the wood gingerly over the can.

Good results can also be had with water but the water has to be HOT!! Cold water is likely to warp or even shatter your iron.

Put pure hot water into your can (a used to be 3 pound, now its 2 1/2 pound, coffee can is very handy). Fill the can from the tap with as hot a water as you got. Place a large piece of scrap steel in the fire with your irons. Before you quench, quench the scrap to bring the temp all the way up.

While you are waiting for the iron to preheat, mix your cake batter and preheat the oven. You don't want to wait too long after hardening your irons to start the tempering "process".

Put the cake in, and the newly hardened irons on the rack right next to it.

If you have a squeemy mate, use misdirection and quickly, hide the irons behind the cake pan. Nobody is going to taste anything "off" in the cake. But sometimes they can't be allowed to see it, to feel ok.

You might have to repeat the slight of hand, fetching them back out when the cake is done.

Eat cake,

sharpen your irons for the desert after the desert.

These methods are not the "tool boutique sales pitch" method. Some steel reacts better with water and some with oil.

But the key word in that sentence is better.

You don't have to have so much "better".

Better is a word people use when they want to sell you something.

People are going to write in and say this can't be done at all.

But I have been actually doing it,

not theory or something I read in a book somewhere,

for years.

Works damn good nearly all the time. ;)

yours Scott

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#11

Re: Old Irons

Bob Hackett

We have an agreement in our home,I don`t put tools in her oven and she doesn`t use my bandsaw to slice the roast.

By abiding with these rules I reap benefits such as her old crock pot to use to heat things like quench water and hide glue and the gift of a $5 thrift store toaster oven to remove the temptation to run upstairs and quickly heat things while she`s not there.

With the addition of the free microwave from the transfer station(the dump) life is grand in our humble abode.

Just don`t tell her about the oil stones in the dishwasher thing. :O

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#12

Ellis Walentine

What a great post!

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Scott. I can combine my love of cooking and toolmaking in one enjoyable session. Excellent.

I will post your instructions right on the refrigerator.

Squeemy indeed. :) Best not tell the good half...

Ellis

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#13

Tempering temperature

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ellis,

Yes indeed, a great post! Course, Scott makes a lot of great posts, so don't want to forget them either.

Scott didn't mention the oven temperature--I"m interested in his thoughts on that. This would be real clean steel I think, unless you know it to be blue steel. If it's white steel (straight high carbon), one smith I know of in Japan uses 180C (~356F) for RC64. It'd still be real hard if you used 375F or 400F.

What do ye say, Scott?

Wiley

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#14

scott grandstaff

Re: Tempering temperature

scott grandstaff

Don't look at me, ask Betty Crocker!! hweehehehe

350 is standard cake temp, but no kitchen oven sticks exactly to that, so it'll variate 25 or more degrees both ways over the 40 minutes.

Close enough for the riff-raff !!

yours Scott

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#15

Re: Old Irons *LINK*

R Payne

That's not too different from how I do my heat treating for plain high carbon stuff.

I use used cooking oil. It is a mix of various vegetable and animal oils and fats. If you use oil, it should be warm to the touch (120-150 F).

If it is bright when you stick the irons in the fire, you won't be able to judge color accurately. Moreover one man's bright cherry is another's dull red and another's sorta orangish.

For knowing when to quench, I put the item to be heated in a piece of pipe (don't use galvanized). I can look in and see the change of the steel as a "shadow" passes over the surface. A few seconds to maybe a half a minute more makes for the correct temp to quench.

Don't waste any time getting to the quench. Some steels have under 1 second to go from really hot (1500 F) to just hot (900 F). From just hot to room temp is less critical (minutes).

If it works I'll include a link to a thread on another forum about heat treating plain high carbon steel.

If you have file you no longer use, it may very well be similar enough you can practice with that to get techinque down.

ron


info on heat treating 1095

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#16

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Ron Hock

Hi Ellis,

See if the info here helps: http://www.hocktools.com/diyht.htm. Re-hardening blades can be tricky but they aren't doing you any good in their current condition. Having the laminated blades hardened by someone who knows those sounds like a good idea. The two different laminated steels will undergo different dimensional changes during hardening which will warp the blades.

Good luck,

Ron

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#17

Re: Thanks, Dave

thomd

You don't need a blacksmithing class to do heat treating it is very easy to do as a beginer project. I would buy some small O1 and make a screw driver etc... or a small chisel. While it is possible to crack blades it has only happened to me once, an that was out of doors in the winter (which notwithsanding what one might think - what is 30 degrees to 1500, it maters). Also, heat treating stuff so long as you don't blow it up, is not a do or die thing, you can often do it over and over again. You will loose carbon, but to a point it doesn't mater.

I would say the real issue is whether the you have a big enough fire, and a big enough grinder. There are redneck forges all over the internet... An oxy torch is also an option. Japanese plane blades are not something one could heat treat with a Bernzo torch. Also, while a little burning out of the carbon is no big deal, the grinding required to get back to the good stuff would be well beyond my patience lever by hand A 1x30, 1x42, or other belt sander would get the job done though.

Another option would be to send it to a pro heat treater in the US. If you know what the steel was, like some cheap white steel, it ought to go with a standard profile. Getting the best out of it can be a little trickier.

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#18

Re: Thank you for the kind offer

thomd

I made a C&W style jack plane using a Japanese blade. worked out really well. I had always thought it would be a problem since the western style plane is flat the full length, and the wedging effect of the blade (greater with depth) could be a problem. I made it anyway, and it works fine. The only problem I had was that I placed the blade a little too close to the handle and it can be difficult to strike with a hammer. Looks and works really nicely though. I think I may have posted a pic here...

Pam, if you want to get rid of any Dai stock, I need a few pieces for some blades I have lying around. Be glad to buy them.

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#19

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Lot of great information, thanks. As I read it, you're saying that if you quench a water-quench blade in oil, the worst that can happen is that it won't harden and you'll have to do it all over in water?

Pam

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#20

Re: Thank you for the kind offer

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I treat my dai blanks as a treasury, kind of hording them for the perfect occasion. I also plan to use several of them as stock for other tools. So, while I'm great with giving one or two completed dai away to help save a blade or two, I don't really want to sell them.

Pam

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#21

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Ron Hock

Yes. An oil quench may harden or at least partially harden water-hardening steel but the thermal shock of quenching oil-hardening steel in water could cause distortion or fracture.

And in the Interest of Safety: along with Very Hot Steel, heat treating may involve Open Flames and Volatile Oils at or beyond their Flash Point. If you must do this (and we know you must), turn your Brain On, wear Protective Gear, keep a Fire Extinguisher and Cordless Phone handy, just in case. And if you do this inside your house, use the Cordless Phone to call a Divorce Lawyer.

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#22

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks; although since it's my kitchen... :)

Pam

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#23

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

wilbur

Hi Ellis,

I don't know anything about heat treating tools, but I just finished watching Larry Williams' DVD on Sharpening Profiled Hand Tools, and in it he does heat treat an old laminated complex molding plane blade so that he can sharpen it with a file, then retreats it. Outside of gathering the equipment needed for heating the blade, it doesn't look that complicated to do, and if your Japanese plane blades were ruined by the shop fire, then there's probably not much to lose if you give it a try.

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#24

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"And if you do this inside your house, use the Cordless Phone to call a Divorce Lawyer."

Or a mental health counselor. Doing work like that inside the house seems like a good setup for the line, "What were you thinking?"

Re: Apropos of the hardening discussion

#25

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Wilbur

Ellis Walentine

I'm just digging back into this after all this time. I am most interested in my full size Japanese block plane -- smoothing plane, really. I dug out one of the irons today and worked on it with a grinder and stationary belt sander and got it down to a reasonable edge -- no stones yet. I ran a file over the cutting edge and it didn't skid but it didn't cut either, so I think it's hard enough, but I don't know if it's too hard. My educated hunch is no. I don't think this steel could have gotten harder than it was, in the progression of my shop fire. It might have gotten softer, which is what you would expect as the temper was drawn. So, I'm going to make a plane out of it (Pam, watch what you wish for :-).

I just hope that at the end of this exercise, I have a sweet block plane again. As much as I love my Western planes, I still appreciate the light weight and responsiveness of a Japanese plane. I think there's a place for both in the toolbox.

Ellis