Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

Posts

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#26

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

Adam Cherubini

I have old ouashita stones and I really like them. Joel recommends a fine india and a fine translucent arkansas I think. I wouldn't be without my ouashita (however you spell it).

Here'e the deal about lubricants:

First, lubrication is the enemy of honing. The "cutting fluid" you use isn't arbitrary or personal preference. It is used to fill in the pores of stones to keep swarf (bits of metal) from clogging hard wearing stones. Cutting with these sorts of stones is not much like water stones.

The viscosity of the fluid is matched to the porosity of the stone. Finer stones needs lighter fluids. If you use a heavier oil on a fine ark stone, the blade will float above the fluid and the stone won't cut well.

So you should be working with your stones and mixing up cutting fluids to achieve the results you are after. I use mineral oil on India and Carburundum stones. On my arkansas (including the soft arks/washitas) I use WD-40 or something similar.

The key is manipulating the surface tension of the fluid. Dextron 3 auto transmission fluid is designed to reduce surface tension to "wet out" transmission parts. Soap is designed to reduce the surface tension of water to slump into pores in your skin and float out dirt. Same same.

Next, you need to keep your stones almost factory clean. Translucent stones that turn black are clogged. They may cut finer than new because they actually burnish edges.

Clean your stones after each use. I wipe mine with ye olde paper towel until they are clean. Then store dry in a dust free environment.

Dont' soak your stones in oil and you don't have to choose water or spit or oil. All will work interchangeably. For super dirty stones, (old stones) clean them by putting them in the dishwasher. I resurface ancient stones with a diamond plate.

Adam

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#27

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Derek -

I did get as far as buying another squirt bottle at the borg yesterday when I was getting some stuff for the yard.

I haven't put soap and water in it yet, but I will give it a try - I haven't disregarded your recommendation, just haven't gotten to it yet.

What little shop time I've gotten this weekend has been spent hard knuckle lapping a nearly finished panel plane from a shepherd kit - a very disappointing experience thus far. Never again on one of those.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#28

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Adam - thanks for that, especially the point about matching grit size to the cutting fluid. I hadn't thought too hard about it, still waiting for the surgical black stone, and maybe didn't think far enough ahead given that mineral oil works really well on the stones up through hard arkansas.

I have a sprayer (like a refillable one) of WD40 on the bench, because I use it with diamonds on a kanaban for pitted iron flattening. When I initially tried it on the coarser stones, I didn't like it that much because it's so slick and it inevitably gets on the end of he chisel where you're applying pressure and makes things more difficult. That probably won't be an issue on a finer stone where the touch will be lighter given that the heavy work is done before you get there.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#29

Stephen Shepherd

An Alternative

Stephen Shepherd

A number of years ago I read an article in [I think] Popular Science magazine on sharpening. There were a number of photomicrographs that showed the edges of a plane blade and chisel that were used in this test.

The contention was that the lubricant, water or oil would hold metal particles in suspension where they collided with the sharp cutting edge causing small irregularities [chips] in the blades.

Showing the blades sharpened with lubricant and without lubricant indicated that using the stone dry produced the best results.

Since that time I don't use anything on my stones as I use them and clean them up with spit or water [if I don't have enough spit] and put them aside. If the stone is particularly glazed I will scrub them with a bristle brush, soap and water.

I do strop after sharpening.

Stephen

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#30

Cheater grips

Bob Hackett

For those of us with grip problems or diminished feeling in our fingers,adding a strip of self stick sandpaper to the top of chisels,etc has been a help for me,especially when using things like soapy water on stones.

For heavier work or badly pitted blades I will sometimes clean the upper face with alcohol and then hot glue either a wood block or auxiliary handle so I can get a grip with more than just my fingertips.A heat gun will get the handle or block to release(usually cleanly) with no harm to the temper of even the thinnest blade.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#31

Barb Siddiqui

Re: An Alternative

Barb Siddiqui

Hello Stephen- that seems very odd, as I've read that a light slurry is what does the actual cutting. Never have tried using the stones dry. I strop too, but have had consistent trouble with rounding over a good edge as Ellis mentioned, and thought I was continuing to do it wrongly. Maybe my belt leather is too soft to use as a strop.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#32

Stephen Shepherd

Re: An Alternative

Stephen Shepherd

Barb,

I had been taught to use oil or water on stones as well. Then I gave this a try and it works and is sure a lot less messy. I do wipe the blades on a cloth as sometimes particles stick to the blade and another reason I don't use magnets to hold my chisels or other metal tools. My English slate is the only stone that doesn't glaze and I have never done more than wipe off the dust [I really should make a box for that stone].

As for the strop I have a piece of oak tanned leather, attached to a flat maple block with hide glue. I use red and white rouge, but rottenstone works too, as does whiting. I would like to find a source of crocus and emery powder.

Stephen

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#33

Barb Siddiqui

Re: An Alternative

Barb Siddiqui

Hmmm, maybe that's it. I'm using the rough side of leather and you are using the tanned side, as is Joel's horse-butt strop. Sounds like I need a 'reversal.' I do have it on backer board. Where did you get your English slate?

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#34

Re: An Alternative

Bob Hackett

The only strop I`ve used consistently is one made with the tools I plan to use.

I usually just get a scrap of maple flooring or other hard maple scrap and cut a series of grooves using the carving chisels or gouges I plan to be using.Once the grooves are cut I charge the grooves with the green polishing compound and have a custom formed strop that offers no chance of dubbing the edge as long as I hold the tools at the proper angle.

Hardwood dowels charged with compound strop insides of the gouges and scraps cut like slip stones handle the rest.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#35

Barb Siddiqui

Re: An Alternative

Barb Siddiqui

I have done that with carving tools, and it works well. Bench chisels are what I am rounding over on leather. I guess the hardwood charged with compound might be best for them, also.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#36

Working Dry

Adam Cherubini

Stephen,

I never saw that article, but it doesn't make sense. Intellectually, the cutting fluid prevents swarf from filling stones' pores. And this is how soap works.

Practically, when working with a light colored stone like a translucent arkansas it sure does appear to be the case that bits of metal and carbon clog the stone causing it to cut slower.

I'm not sure what stone they used in the test. I could see something friable like carborundum working ok dry. I've tried it (as I'm sure we all have). I think it cuts faster with an oily slurry on it's surface. India stones certainly cut faster when clean. I find they clog easily, so using them dry seems to be counterproductive.

As in all things, the details matter. How much honing is needed, the type of steel, the type of stone etc etc. Right off the top of my head, I couldn't recommend working with "oil stones" dry.

For Barb,

I use both sides of Joel's strop regardless of what he insists. I've charged the cut side with that green chromium oxide crayon. When I use a strop, I'm looking to polish the shape I have, not redefine an edge shape. For that reason, I like to have at least one piece of leather that I can form around a tool. Fitting into tight sweeps is a problem. For that I have a piece of shoe leather that I contoured the edges of to fit into veiners.

Adam

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#37

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Working Dry

Barb Siddiqui

Thanks Adam. I've always suspected it didn't matter so much which side of the leather was used, as it did holding the back of the chisel truly flat to the strop, but having so little success with it (rounding over the edge) I wondered if I was doing it wrong. I have since just avoided stropping and gone from Translucent Arkansas to a ceramic stone for final honing. Guess I should experiment more, as I have all of them to play around with.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#38

Re: John Juranitch

bugbear

That sounds like John Juranitch's research.

He was a full time professional knife sharpener for the Chicago meat cutting lines.

His book is still available.

BugBear

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#39

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Well, i finally got all of the stones - a 12x 2 1/2 inch india and carborundum stone from ebay, appears to be an old norton combo.

A hard and soft 10x3 stone from a site called naturalwhetstone - for cheap. I called them after getting my order because the guy sent me an email saying "i'll cut your stone today and get it in the mail tomorrow", and I wanted to see if I could get a bigger stone for a few extra bucks. Sure enough after calling when I ordered a soft arkansas, the guy was going to cut it, and I ordered a hard while I was on the phone with him, too - they were *really* cheap.

And the halls 12x3 surgical black.

All of them are an inch thick - not a fan of thin stones.

The opposite of what I expected occurred - the halls is significantly out of flat on both sides, and it was a bear to get most of one surface on the same plane. I probably spend 20 minutes with it on a dry lap before I put lube on it, but it's fine now.

The two stones from the mine/cutter in arkansas were almost dead flat, and the case is nicer than the halls case.

Exactly what was said here is my experience with the stones - the new soft and hard arkansas cut fast, I probably would only need either the hard or soft arkansas and the surgical black and a strop. The surgical black cut slow and almost felt like it wasn't cutting, but left surprisingly large grooves on the stone under a dissection scope (compared to a 1 micron waterstone or green stuff strop), so it was definitely cutting. Even so, a freshly ground chisel that was honed was still sharp enough to shave at 25 degrees, fairly easy. 5 swipes across the mdf strop with green stuff (I use it like a stone like any normal person would) and a couple of swipes on the back, and it's as sharp as anything I've sharpened with waterstones.

Light mineral oil on everything (including the mdf green charged strop) except the surgical black, wd 40 on that.

They are pleasant to use, especially given the length of the stones. I did not try any hard or high alloy steels on them. Given the mohs #s stated online for the novaculite hardness, that would seem to be dumb.