Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

Posts

Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#1

Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

David Weaver

Arkansas stones are like my final frontier for sharpening. I have two oilstones, but they are indias.

So I finally ordered some arkansas stones - a soft arkansas, a hard arkansas (probably should've just gotten one or the other, they're not much different) and a surgical black. I didn't get a washita because the stones will never see anything other than honing a hollow or freehanding carving tools (that can easily be roughed out on a diamond hone if needed).

I've gotten the first two (the hard and soft arkansas) - they are newly cut stones. The surgical black should be coming any day.

What should I do with them? I've been using food grade light mineral oil on the india stones - just because I have a lot of it and it's cheap ($13 a gallon at food supply places). I don't plan on using the india stone much now if these stones are OK, so it doesn't matter that it's oil and the rest could end up seeing only water.

I see differing opinions on oil vs. water with soap. I have plenty of other fast-cutting stones, so I'm not looking for fast cutting. I've no interest in using WD-40 or kerosene on the stones, either light mineral oil or water with dishsoap.

These stones will pretty much get used for old cast steel plane blades high carbon steel chisels that aren't super hard (Iles english pattern chisels, and some old stanley and buck chisels).

If I'm going to use oil, it's a one time decision. Is there a difference in the fineness of cut? I.e., if I use oil instead of water with soap, will I get a finer cut as a reward for slower sharpening?

Also, if I do choose oil, just oil it each time with use or soak it? I've seen literature either way, but you never know whose opinion you're reading and how legitimate it is.

I always held off on trying them because I have a wide variety of steels, some of which they won't cut, and because I could not for a long time find big ones cheap. I found the surgical black in 12x3x1 in halls brand for $96 shipped last week, which sort of made the whole thing more affordable.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#2

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I use oil (light mineral like you have to use) on my oil stones. I have no water stones so I have to admit my bias in this matter. Not prepping your edge by working through the grits will extend your sharpening time. Start with your India then soft,hard, black a few strokes each. The intermediate stone grits will help refine your edge and I know that going to a fine oil stone before the edge is refined will be frustrating. A touch up can go to the finest stone you have but you have to not let the edge go to far.

I add oil each use and re oil and wipe the stones off after honing.

The natural stones unlike India aren't terribly porous so i don't find an advantage to soaking.

I rationalize the oil over water by having a dislike for rust. Oil stones leave a natural oil residue on tools that helps retard corrosion. YMMV I don't find the oil causes finish issues either.

I love that I don't have to prep(other than cleaning them after use) oil stones. They stay flat. Don't drop them. DAMHIKT >(

JR

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#3

scott grandstaff

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

scott grandstaff

I can't believe I'm talking to a guy who spends 100 for a stone because he thinks its cheap, and now I'm going to tell him how to live with it ???

I never spent any particle of 100 for all the stones I own put together, and that is about a pillowsack full of 'em. :D

So anyway, glosh on a dollop of your mineral oil.

Take your bare finger and wash it around until all old swarf lifts free. Only takes a minute.

Wipe it off with an old T-shirt and go to work.

You don't have to get hysterical with either the washing or the drying. Just in case there was any temptation..... I wouldn't mention that, except anybody who pays 100 dollars..... :D Whaa hhaahahahaha )

If its a long session you may have to go again with the cleaning.

Another moment and a half of your life wasted, I know.

Or, of course, you can puddle up any manner goose grease and make a sloppy mess of your sharpening job if you want and that will also work fine.

Many people do.

but

clean and dry, cuts it

I don't bother cleaning when I'm done, either. Never sharpen anything before I put it away.

I'm going to clean every single time before I start, without fail.

The little bit of time it takes to clean a stone and sharpen a tool is time I use to center my head and make plans for a job ahead.

Cleaning before I put it away??

Hey, I could drop dead tomorrow and I would have cleaned somebody else's stone!!!

What yard sale Bozo deserves that?

Here's a stonebox. Its got a false bottom so its deep enough to grab securely in a bench vise and not be dragging my knuckles.

The lid is shallow enough to fold back out of the way in use.


Here's another


Here is how I stone a drawknife or anything else with tangs that stick out in the way. Make a block to raise your stonebox up to a proper working height.


yours Scott

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#4

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Yeah, nobody else's swarf on my stones - they're new, and all of them are big.

I didn't have delusions about giving them the same level of care that I give to a #30 sized honyama stone or a japanese stone that was mined in the 30s.

But I do like to hear other peoples' opinions before I decide whether or not I'm going to make them permanently oiled, especially given that some people have very strong opinions about using water instead of oil.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#5

So Scott...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

You'd never pay $100 for a stone and yet you'll use $100 worth of wenge and tiger maple to make a box for a yard sale stone. :D

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#6

scott grandstaff

Re: So Scott...

scott grandstaff

You'd never pay $100 for a stone and yet you'll use $100 worth of wenge and tiger maple to make a box for a yard sale stone. :D

That'd be so true, if I ever actually bought wood retail. heeheheh

Even the piano in the paaaaaaaaalah

Baby got for 2 cents on the dolllllllllah

yours Scott

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#7

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Well, they're oil now. The surgical black won't be coming for a while (the "cheap" $96.50 12x3x1 halls stone).

Since I can't tell which is the soft and which is the hard, I put oil on one and used it just now. I'll put oil on the other one later and use it and see which one feels more coarse.

The first one was new and cuts nice and fast, and it's dead flat out of the box.

I can use an mdf strop with green stuff and oil on it until the surgical black shows up. Cuts a bit slow but does fine. Autosol makes a very nice follow-up to it, too, but it leaves a film that is not quite so easy to wipe off, which equals black marks on whatever you're working on afterward.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#8

Arkansas stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I thought I would add some notes. The Arkansas stones cut somewhat more aggressively at first, and less as they wear smooth. Some think they ought to renew that aggressiveness, but the idea is that the stones are supposed to smooth out the scratches of the previous stones and they work best when broken in. Unlike fine water stones which keep on cutting, albeit slowly, Arkansas stones sort of slow down once they have done their job of smoothing the surface.

When I was a teenager I had an oil stone that I started using with lather instead of oil. I had used it for about four years with oil and then about a dozen with the lather. It has been a long time, but I can't remember any problems making the transition. About using a preliminary diamond stone, my hunch is that the soft Arkansas would have trouble removing the deep scratches left by the diamonds.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#9

I said it before...

Bob Hackett

And I`ll say it again,

You are a BAAAAAD man Scott!

I had to go for another handkerchief I was laughing so hard.

Just when you think you have all your ducks in a row,here comes the Scottster to mow them all down with a big dose of reality!

Your sharpening advice should be right up there with the "pointy stick" tutorial,just needs a little dose of grain alcohol to finish(pun intended).

Just another yard sale bozo looking for clean stones,

Your pal,

MB-who nearly busted a gut.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#10

Re: Arkansas stones

David Weaver

Warren - thanks for the advice. I think you're probably right about the scratches from the diamonds being a problem to remove given the shape of the channels that each stone leaves.

I'm assuming the aluminum oxide in an india stone will wear to some extent with use, and not cut like fresh aluminum oxide cuts (deep ruts, sort of like diamonds)?

Now that I've introduced oil to the stones, it's no big deal. I have a good long carborundum coarse and medium india stone that's flat - one of only two oilstones I've gotten used.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#11

Re: I said it before...

David Weaver

I watched a multi-millionaire relative of mine go past the bargain table at tj maxx for weeks (well, heard about it) waiting for a pair of suspenders he really liked that were $6 to get reduced further.

He went back over and over until they were finally a dollar, and he bought them.

Who knows how much in gas and wear and tear go on the cars on unnecessary trips for stuff like that. And all the time. Kind of like running to yard sales if you don't enjoy running to yard sales (and I don't...at all).

I see a 12 inch black surgical that will be something I'll never find in the wild, boom - click - done - on the way. No getting up early, no thinking about whether I want to compromise on an out of flat stone, no miles on a car at an effective 45 cents a mile. Two stones on ebay, 10x3x1, genuine novaculate - dead flat, cut tuesday by a stonemaker. $25 for the soft arky and $29 for the hard arky, in wooden boxes. I can't imagine finding those at a yard sale.

Start finding hard #24 sized nakayama stones at yard sales for $50, and you'll have my ear. I haven't seen those cheap, and they're far enough out of my price range that I don't just click and buy.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#12

Please don`t misunderstand.

Bob Hackett

David,there`s nothing personal intended in either my post or Scott`s and I truly hope you don`t feel like the butt of the joke.

Scott was just being Scott in his usual hilarious way,pouring copious quantities of common sense and real world advice on what could have become a terribly over thought non-problem.

Scott and I go back a ways and if I had asked the same question he would have been even more over the top so rest assured he pulled some punches.

If I had the smarts to post a link I`d steer you toward the pointy stick tutorial,how to make a pointy stick; a guide for aspiring craftsmen.It pokes fun at the questions that are asked over and over again in a very witty and satirical fashion.I personally love the grain alcohol/shellac finishing instruction sequence.I`m sure you would think it hilarious as everyone else does.

Once again,I hope you can see these posts for the humor they were intended to be and understand that in no way was anything intentionally aimed in your direction.

Sorry for any misunderstanding,

Mainely,Bob

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#13

Re: Please don`t misunderstand.

David Weaver

No, no offense at all.

I do spend my money a little more freely than most, which usually seems to get a reaction - too often people think you're a beginner if you're not tight. I'm not exactly new to this game, just haven't used oilstones, and thought it was a worthwhile question given how rabid some of the "don't use water", "don't use mineral oil, it's way too heavy!" crowd is. I always thought was kind of goofy. If it was so bad, why have people been doing it for a couple hundred years?

Not too worried about aspiring to become a craftsman, this is a hobby. Wherever the arrow of curiosity points, go there next. Do it however you want.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#14

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

Hank Knight

David,

You and I have followed the same path. I made the transition from water stones to Arkansas stones a couple of years ago. The maintenance required for the water stones finally got to me. Oil stones are easier. I still use water stones on my Japanese blades.

I don't have much to add to what others have said about oil stones except to suggest that you not throw away your strop. The surgical black Arkansas stone won't give you a polished edge like a Norton 8K. I think it's about the equivalent of a 4K stone, maybe a little finer. The edge it leaves is good for most work, but If you want a really fine, polished edge, you'll need to take it another step or two. I still finish up on my 8K Norton and a plain leather strop aftger the Surgical black Arkansas stone. Even so, the Arkansas system is a lot easier to maintain than the water stones.

I use Norton honing oil because I have a big jug of it on hand and it seems to be a little lighter in texture than regular mineral oil; but I don't have a strong preference for it. I've never used soapy water, so I can't comment on it. I don't think you need to worry about damaging your stones with a wrong lubricant choice. They're rocks, after all. I do apply oil after I finish using them and wipe the swarf off with a clean paper towel or rag so they'll be ready to go next time.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#15

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Thanks for the thoughts hank. Not necessarily worried about ruining the stone with a lubricant, more what people's thoughts are about how the stones cut with different lubricants, and whether it's worth holding off on oil on the stones to try water with soap. In the end, the answer for me is no after the discussion on here. Light mineral oil that I have is probably a lot like the honing oil from norton, and I already have a bottle of tap water, and one of distilled water on the rack next to my sharpening station. I don't want a third of soapy water, it'd just accidentally end up on a natural finishing stone at some point and that would be bad.

I hear you on the final edge - I have some green goo strops laying around that don't see much use with my usual routine being a 1 micron waterstone for the last step, but maybe they will now.

The biggest thing that drew me to try the arkansas stones was to get the feel of a soft waterstone with freehand sharpening (no stiction) without the wear that goes along with it - especially on the lower grit stones.

It's funny that there are a lot of experienced woodworker comments about going from waterstones to oilstones, especially given how much negative press there is about how they "cut slow and don't leave a fine edge".

So many ways to skin a cat, and I guess the problem is they all work pretty well, and the folks who find a favorite without trying the others in earnest always want to figure out what makes their method better. I like them all. A shapton 1 micron stone is great for a smoother iron in a guide. soft waterstones are great for freehand feel and a nice finish level, but they do require dressing often. Natural waterstones are all over the board, but the ones that are good are like several stones wrapped in one depending on the touch of the user, and they have a feel and smell that makes you want to sharpen. I have no real love for diamonds for most things because of the way they cut (narrow and deep), but they have their merits on some stuff, and they don't take much drawer space, anyway.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#16

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The biggest thing that drew me to try the arkansas stones was to get the feel of a soft waterstone with freehand sharpening (no stiction) without the wear that goes along with it - especially on the lower grit stones.

So, David, did you try the Shaptons with soapy water, as I suggested?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#17

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

David Weaver

Derek -

not yet, I knew that post was coming, though!

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#18

Ellis Walentine

Strops

Ellis Walentine

I have a problem with any leather strop. The durometer of the leather is such that the blade necessarily depresses the leather surface as you strop, so the stropping effect is in the nature of dubbing over the edge. It is sharper but dubbed over and more obtuse as a result.

FWIW, I use a strop made of a block of rock maple, planed dead flat and charged with paste from a nagura stone. It puts a serious polish on an 8K grit edge in a couple strokes.

Ellis

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#20

Re: Strops

david weaver

I agree, Ellis. I have hard and soft strops (well, and razor strops).

The place where I like leather, though, is on the disc of a combination sander. Then the belt can be used for rough work - especially on cambered irons, you can head to some harder stones to freehand the iron, and then bring it back to the powered strop and hit it quickly with barely any pressure.

In my head at least, I tell myself that dubs the edge less. I have almost eaten an iron off the leather disc, though, and it wasn't that long ago. that was a clear-head moment for a minute or two after that thinking about how lucky I was that it went off the disc in a different direction than my face, and then bounced on the floor and went a different direction than my legs.

The MDF strop is at my bench. The green stuff has some mineral oil on it, but it's mostly slicked over with swarf. On the MDF, it cuts fast, which may have something to do with the MDF.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#21

Ellis Walentine

Relative grit sizes?

Ellis Walentine

I'm wondering what the grit equivalents of nagura stones, green sticks and other honing/stropping materials might be? Where do glazing compounds and cesium oxide and other fine abrasives fall on this scale? And what about diamonds? I'm very pleased with the natural stone slurry but I'm open to new ideas. For example, I don't want to be honing with something the equivalent of 8000 grit if I've just sharpened to 12,000.

Ellis

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#22

Re: Relative grit sizes?

david weaver

That's a good question. I've looked at what the green stuff does under a microscope, and it always seems like there's a few stray scratches. It certainly feels sharper than most anything I've finished with. Actually, I can't think of anything that feels sharper than an iron finished on a glazed over mdf strop of green stuff, and the razor guys seem OK (and it's been OK when I used a razor).

But when you know diamonds cut deeper than most other abrasives, I wonder what diamond is equivalent.

I thumbed my nose at arkansas stones for a long time because of the grit size, but I can see under the scope that they cut different. Less scratch density and not ravines like diamonds.

At a few microns or less, it probably doesn't really matter what the shape of the ravines, though.

The tormek stuff and autosol (same stuff) are around 3 microns, I think. They do a good job on a strop, but they are obviously not going to refine the edge of a 12k stone.

All the rest of the stuff - the compounds used elsewhere, I don't know if you could ever tell subjectively if you made a blade duller or not when you did a good job with a good 8000 stone and finished with a light touch. Some steels seem to have a wire edge that persists at that size, though, but won't do so at 1 micron, so I guess the strop is still a benefit, even if it changes the geometry and has similar scratch size.

It's all a mind melter. If i can't see any scratches or lines from a smoothing plane, and the surface is shiny, i'm happy with the result.

The naguras are an issue I haven't quite figured out - how fine they are. They came with a 2 micron stone I have, but Alex gilmore says to never use them with his stones because they'll become embedded in the stone and scratch up an iron. I guess they must be a good bit bigger than half a micron or so, which is probably about what particle size might be in the finest natural waterstones.

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#23

Re: Relative grit sizes?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm wondering what the grit equivalents of nagura stones, green sticks and other honing/stropping materials might be? Where do glazing compounds and cesium oxide and other fine abrasives fall on this scale? And what about diamonds? I'm very pleased with the natural stone slurry but I'm open to new ideas. For example, I don't want to be honing with something the equivalent of 8000 grit if I've just sharpened to 12,000.

Hi Ellis

I strop to extend an edge, rather than to create an edge.

I have compared Veritas green rouge (which is 0.5 micron) and a 0.5 micron oil-based diamond paste (from eBay, so who knows the reliability of this one?). This was very subjective - observations based on working with the newly-shaprpened blades rather than photographic images of the edges.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Stroppingwithgreenrougeversesdiamondpaste.html

My conclusion was (for those uninterested in reading the above, although there is also a bit about stropping, per se), "Having gone back-and-forth between the two pastes, I concluded that they appeared to cut almost identically. The green rouge, however, did appear to cut a tad more easily and leave a slightly smoother surface. When stropping it felt smooth, while the diamond paste felt "gritty" ...".

Perhaps the diamond's "grittiness" I observed reflects the deeper scratches reported by David?

Fast forward to the present. I find I strop less now that I have a sharpening centre close to hand. It makes more sense to simply give a Shapton 12000 a misting of water and strop on that. Although I have not experienced any negative effects of the fine dubbing that must occur on leather, even the hard leather of Joel's Horse Butt strops, the flatness of the Shapton is a more predictable variable.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#24

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well David, you really do not know what you are missing. A little soapy water on a Shapton can change your (sharpening) world. It is quite dramatic.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?

#25

craigd

Re: Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Ston

craigd

On a Norton translucent Arkansas, I find that Norton honing (mineral) oil can be a little thick and a plane iron can hydroplane. Mineral spirits works well (I've read that some use just MS on the harder stones, I go back and forth). If you are into bicycles, Shimano disk brake fluid (mineral oil colored red) is quite a bit thinner than the Norton and works well. Haven't tried it but some like ATF.

I use Norton oil on India stones as they are sponges.