Arkansas Stone Experts - Do what with New Stones?
David Weaver
Arkansas stones are like my final frontier for sharpening. I have two oilstones, but they are indias.
So I finally ordered some arkansas stones - a soft arkansas, a hard arkansas (probably should've just gotten one or the other, they're not much different) and a surgical black. I didn't get a washita because the stones will never see anything other than honing a hollow or freehanding carving tools (that can easily be roughed out on a diamond hone if needed).
I've gotten the first two (the hard and soft arkansas) - they are newly cut stones. The surgical black should be coming any day.
What should I do with them? I've been using food grade light mineral oil on the india stones - just because I have a lot of it and it's cheap ($13 a gallon at food supply places). I don't plan on using the india stone much now if these stones are OK, so it doesn't matter that it's oil and the rest could end up seeing only water.
I see differing opinions on oil vs. water with soap. I have plenty of other fast-cutting stones, so I'm not looking for fast cutting. I've no interest in using WD-40 or kerosene on the stones, either light mineral oil or water with dishsoap.
These stones will pretty much get used for old cast steel plane blades high carbon steel chisels that aren't super hard (Iles english pattern chisels, and some old stanley and buck chisels).
If I'm going to use oil, it's a one time decision. Is there a difference in the fineness of cut? I.e., if I use oil instead of water with soap, will I get a finer cut as a reward for slower sharpening?
Also, if I do choose oil, just oil it each time with use or soak it? I've seen literature either way, but you never know whose opinion you're reading and how legitimate it is.
I always held off on trying them because I have a wide variety of steels, some of which they won't cut, and because I could not for a long time find big ones cheap. I found the surgical black in 12x3x1 in halls brand for $96 shipped last week, which sort of made the whole thing more affordable.








