Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Grinding wheels revisited

Posts

Grinding wheels revisited

#1

Grinding wheels revisited

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Dear Galoots,

Recently I've been re-reminded of the need for a hollow-grinding method which can be recommended to newcomers on both price and effectiveness.

I have a Baldor 6" 1800rpm machine with one of Joel's seeded gel (Norton 3X) blue stones on it. Also have a Tormek T-7. Both of these are great machines. However, I can never justify a general recommendation of either the slow-speed Baldor or the Tormek, because of cost. I don't regret the expenditure myself, but that's different from recommending a high dollar item to someone else.

Looking around for practical options, I came across Joel Moskowitz' dry grinding method of using a crowned wheel of the seeded-gel type (Norton blue wheel), on a standard 3600rpm grinder. This gets your attention, because there are excellent quality 3600rpm grinders for not a lot of money. Or folks may have one anyway. Then secondly, related to the idea of crowning the wheel, Bill Tindall has for a long-time proposed the use of narrow grinding wheels, like 1/2" wide, in the softer grades such as G or H. [Bill, correct me if I'm wrong, or if you've changed your recommendations.]

It strikes me that Joel's crowned wheel method would be a natural companion to Bill's narrow wheel method. Because the narrow wheel would be easy to crown. So with a narrow G or H wheel, or a seeded-gel wheel--either of which are crowned--you appear to have an acceptably cool-running setup for a beginner to learn on, even with a 3600rpm grinder. I am assuming a stout blade support--homemade or Wolverine, for example.

I can already hear some snickering from experienced folks, who think nothing of grinding anything at 3600rpm, and no matter what wheel is on the grinder.

But I am suggesting a discussion of a reasonably priced approach to hollow grinding, which would make a good recommendation for someone who is (a) just starting out, and (b) gonna have to learn for themselves, as opposed to having hands-on teaching from someone who already knows how.

What say ye?

Wiley

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#2

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

Joel

When I suggest a crowned wheel it isn't to effectively make a narrower wheel. I recommend a very slight camber. I learned this from Barry Iles. It gives you control. When I first touch the wheel I know I will touch the center of my blade and not the corner but once I have contact I will move the blade back and forth not square to the wheel, more like following the camber. so normally I am grinding with at least half the width of the wheel at any given time.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#3

So when you reverse direction

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

do you always return to the center of the wheel? And if so, do you put one edge on the center of the wheel and work the whole blade width on each pass? Or do you put the center of the blade on the center of the wheel, and work half the blade on each pass, alternating direction?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#4

First thing you do...

Bob Hackett

You take that grey wheel that came on the grinder and put it outside in the yard so you won`t be tempted to use it for anything other than edging concrete or rounding the edges of your granite steps.

If you want to burn steel use a torch,it`ll do the same thing only faster.

Next take an inventory of what you have steel wise and maybe what you`re thinking about getting.Once you`ve made your inventory and know what you`re up against you can then pick an appropriate wheel.

Take the time to research the info the abrasive companies have put out there for you.Focus on what the numbers on a wheel mean and the characteristics those numbers stand for(Leonard Lee`s sharpening manual explains this in detail).

Keep in mind that the purpose of the grinder is to rough out the edge and get it ready to be refined on the stones,sand paper,diamonds.etc.You want something that will cut quickly and cleanly while keeping the steel cool.Your research will tell you what`s best and the numbers will transfer over to a good selection of wheels.The things to remember here are grit size(large is usually good) and friable ,meaning the surface of the stone will fracture or break up while grinding exposing new abrasives rather than loading up or retaining the rounded abrasive grit.The more friable stones shed all(or most) of the stuff that causes you to push harder/linger longer and burn the steel.The grey wheels the factory puts on are the cheap ones that are usually just the opposite of what you really need.

Remember too that grinding wheels are not just sold in WWing catalogs and chain stores.Some of the best and cheapest alternatives come from machinery and industrial suppliers like 3M,Norton,MSC,etc.

Once you know what those numbers mean the grinding world opens up to you and you can make that bench grinder a trusted friend instead of an enemy to your edges.

Quick tip-When shopping for a grinder look for one that uses 5/8-11 nuts to hold the wheels on.When you go to a narrow wheel and thinner nut there will be enough of the threaded shaft sticking out(if you plan it right and measure correctly) to accept standard angle grinder attachments such as a backing disc for sandpaper.Now you have both a benchgrinder and an 8" disc sander,etc for the added price of a thinner nut and the attachment.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#5

Re: So when you reverse direction

joel

Wiley,

I just go back and forth pretty much the entire width of the iron - although I typically leave off the ends until most of the middle is about done. with a very small camber this is easy to do and you use most of the width of the wheel with real control.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#6

Re: So when you reverse direction

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Joel, and thanks for clarifying that the point of cambering the stone is for control, rather than (as I had thought) to focus and limit both the cutting action and heat produced.

How do you put that camber on the stone?

Wiley

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#7

Re: First thing you do... *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bob,

Thanks for the thoughtful reply! Reading your first paragraph, I recalled a WoodCentral article on the subject of grinding wheel selection written by Bill Tindall (linked below). Bill was recommending H hardness wheels in that article with open structure such as V8; I noticed looking around that McMaster Carr even has some F and G wheels. It would be interesting if anyone has compared these softer AlOx wheels with seeded gel (like the Norton 3X) for staying cool.

That is a great suggestion about buying a grinder with a 5/8"-11 threaded spindle!

Wiley


Bill Tindall on Grinding Wheel Selection

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I agree

Jim in Burlington On

Crowning wheels is nothing new IMO. The crown decreases the surface area you can grind at any time which lessens the chance of burning your blade. Anyone that is new to high speed grinding needs a little pratice. Why on earth they take their most expensive piece of steel they own (Plane or chisel blade) and experiment with that is beyond me. The thicker your rest is the better it will be at absorbing heat from grinding also lowering your chance of burning your blade. I also like LV white wheel and picked up a chipped on cheap a few years a go so the blue wheel will have to wait.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#9

you need to look closer, Wiley

Larry Williams

You say you're looking for an affordable entry level grinder and that pretty much limits you to a 6" grinder. Then all these different surface grinder wheel grades are discussed but they're just not available for a 6" grinder. Maybe some day someone will produce a popular 6" wheel surface grinder but that is in the future.

The choices are pretty limited in 6" wheels. I once had a site bookmarked that had a softer 6" wheel but I never bought one due to their high cost. Plus the need never seemed that great.

I'm not sure what others are doing that they want these fine grit wheels. I don't have any trouble removing grinding signatures of the 24 grit wheel I sometimes use. In fact, my problem is the opposite. I work to keep the honed bevel small and it's real easy to make it larger than necessary when honing. Coarse grinding signatures on the bevel are never a problem when I hone, never. If I was only maintaining the tools I work with, I'd change from a medium India to a fine India for a little additional control over honing speed.

For bench chisels and bench plane irons there's no reason to mess around with fine wheels. Bob is a turner and is repeating the turners mantra about grinding wheels. Turners have been a big enough market that there are some 6" friable wheels for them but they're fine grit. Here's a fact: fine wheels generate more heat than coarse wheels. Bob may throw a factory supplied 6" wheel in the back yard but he'll either replace it with one of those 3X wheels like Joel sells or exactly the same thing he tossed out.

Here's what I'd look for in a grinder. I want the shrouds around the wheels to be easily removable with a minimum of tools. I want a two-piece tool rest that's wide enough to grind a skewed plane iron and still offer good support. I'd want the table deep enough to give a good registration but not interfere with handles, sockets or what ever on a relatively short chisel. It'd be ideal if you didn't need a wrench or any other tool to adjust the tool rest but, if it does require a tool, it should be only one. I don't like shouldered arbors that require spacers for thin wheels. I would prefer a grinder with a long enough neck that I never have to struggle with getting the light exactly where I want it. I'd also like a grinder that's quiet enough that I can hear the first contact of a tool to the wheel.

I'm always amazed at how big a deal grinding and sharpening are to people. With a little care and attention it's very easy for all this to fade to an insignificant part of working.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#10

Re: So when you reverse direction

Joel

When you dress the wheel with a multipoint dresser after it's clean you just wiggle it back and forth and you have a cambered wheel (if it wasn't cambered already). For free hand wheel dressing the multipoint dresser is the way to go. There are two kinds the cheap chinese ones (about $7) that have layer of diamond deposited on a bit of steel with a handle. They do not last forever. The expensive ones that have a block of diamond impregnated material that slowly wears and exposes new diamonds. Both work.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#11

Actually Larry...

Bob Hackett

Bob is primarily a metalworker and his recommendations are based on a wide variety of applications,turning being only one of them.

I have a 60 grit white wheel on the fine side of my sharpening grinder.The rest of my grinders(6 at last count) hold everything from a green wheel for carbide to a Scotchbrite fine deburring wheel.There are no factory grey wheels on any of them.I find them too fine,too hard and they glaze too quickly.There are far better wheels out there for short money so why waste time and energy.IMO the only reason to keep a grey AO wheel is so you can use it to replace a good wheel when you sell the grinder.

BTW-all my grinders are 8" or larger.Don`t know why anyone would own a 6" high speed grinder when there are so many good used 8" models around.I`ve gone thru more than a dozen in the past 10 years and never paid more than $35 for a good used one.Never charged anyone more than that when I sold them (unless they had a high dollar wheel on them).

I`d like to think my grinding/sharpening skills are a little more advanced than your average WWer seeing as how I kept just about everything in the yacht yard I worked at a while back sharp and have made tools for myself and other workers to cut everything from teak decking and rotted ship`s planking with iron spikes and bronze screws in them to HSS and carbide machinist bits to cut tough metal alloys.

I fabbed yacht hardware and fittings in bronze,stainless and aluminum and then finished those fittings to a mirror polish so I think I know just a little more about abrasives than your average guy.That`s the basis for my recommendations.

I know and respect your background Larry.Please don`t discount mine.

MB

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#12

this is a little outa hand *LINK*

Larry Williams

Bob,

I have no problem conceding that you're the World's expert in sharpening. But this isn't answering Wiley's question.

So why would a woodworker ever buy a 6" grinder? Well, maybe because a 6" grinder will do everything they're likely to ever need. Maybe because they can walk into their local hardware store or auto parts store and come out with a grinding wheel they can use. Maybe because 6" bench grinders are the most readily available.

I think what Wiley is looking for is what he could advise a new woodworker to get at a reasonable price. I doubt Wiley is interested in becoming a used equipment locator in order to be able to offer help. Below are the current eBay listings found when searching for "8" bench grinder." I don't see anything there I'd recommend. In the past I've used the search capability of a couple used equipment dealers. A search on their sites found no 8" bench grinders under $1000 within 750 miles of my zip code.

I don't sharpen any woodworking tools on a bench grinder and I doubt most woodworkers do unless they turn. I don't sharpen anything with a 60 grit grinding wheel. I sharpen all my woodworking tools on stones of one type or another. Grinding is only a shaping operation. Once a woodworker has the initial tuning of their tools done, grinders and honing stones become a little more aggressive than normally necessary. Once woodworking hand tools have their flat faces flat and their bevels properly shaped, maintenance should remove very little metal. Restraint, caution and attention to detail become the order of the day. Grinding becomes only to manage the size of the honed bevel and shouldn't require the removal of much metal at all. I just don't see where this would over-tax the capability of the basic 6" entry level grinder.


eBay 8" grinders

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#13

What are we sharpening?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I have/use a POS low speed Reliant grinder for years. Anybody need a massage? Come on over and lay on my sharpening table :D

Another poster here turned me on to a '70's high speed grinder equipped with 2 Norton wheels. One 40 and one 80 grit. It's sweet!

All tool steels today can handle the heat of grinding. Just ask a wood turner!

One just needs to take it easy on old steel.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#14

Actually Bob...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Where are all these used 8" grinders? Seriously!?!

I see no problems with a 6" grinder. Sure I'd like an 8" but like I said I see no reason why a 6" grinder won't do anything a woodworker woudl need a grinder for.

Of course we could get into the feet per minute factor between sizes too. ;)

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#15

Outa hand?

Bob Hackett

I don`t understand your need to talk down to folks attempting to present an approach that differs from yours Larry.

If anyone is interested in an admittedly non-expert yet real world approach which costs less than a $1000 entry fee you know where to find me.

MB

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#16

Re: Actually Bob...

Bob Hackett

To answer your question Scott,those used 8" grinders are only as far away as your car.

I find mine at yard and estate sales,on Craigslist,in the want adds and at auctions.I`m to the point now where I don`t actively look for them,I just come across them when I`m out looking for other things.

Some of the reasoning behind buying an 8" over a 6" is that,while there are exceptions,an 8" grinder is generally a better built and more heavy duty machine.They also pack more HP than a smaller grinder and the tool rests and guards are usually of better quality.

If you`re looking for a top of the line,industrial strength,late model 8" grinder with a Baldor or Leeson motor then you will travel for a while and probably pay over $100 for it.

BTW-Made in China(or Taiwan,India,etc) is not an option as far as I`m concerned.These machines are just not quality nor are they durable IME.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#17

Location, location, location

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There do appear to be pretty significant regional differences in what's available in tools at garage/estate sales. Indeed, I find differences even within the county I live in as to what's available.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#18

The car

Bob Hackett

I just posted on a different forum of how I got a $10,000+ motorcycle for $5500.

I had to search craigslist for the urban areas I was willing to drive to and then e-mail a deposit(paypal) and drive 3 1/2 hours each way(Boston) to go pick it up.

Worth it?No doubt!

It`s all a matter of how bad you want something and what you feel your time is worth.I like seeing the countryside and meeting new people so the choice is easy for me.

BTW-We are just talking about an electric motor that spins a wheel here.

There were who knows how many hundreds of thousands(maybe even in the millions) of them made during the heyday of American industrialism and shipped to all points of the country and beyond.

For me driving,cleaning and replacing things like bearings to end up with something I can give to my friend, son or grandson is preferable to buying a cheap imported grinder that may die for no good reason when it`s needed most.

Others may have other priorities and think nothing of pulling China from a box.Different paths to the same destination.

Politics and geography aside,if your`re standing at a grinder(with eye/face protection)with steel in your hand and a goal in sight it`s all good.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#19

Once again HSS vs HCS

Bob Hackett

If what you`re grinding is HCS (like O1) then it will not take heat.Everywhere it turns blue will be considerably softer and more likely to bend and dull more quickly than the rest of the edge.

Likewise,if you grind HSS till red(or less,depending) and then quench it in water it is prone to micro cracking and more likely to chip out more easily.

CPM is not something I know as well as HCS or HSS but I figure if HSS is prone to micro cracking when water quenched then maybe a consolidated particle steel will do the same.Right or wrong I play it safe and let it air cool when it gets hot.

It`s about knowing what it really is you are holding and what it`s limitations are.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#20

So, what bike did you get?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#21

Re: So, what bike did you get?

Bob Hackett

It`s what I call a "circus bike" but others refer to them as "easter eggs" or "billet queens".

It`s a rather gaudy repop softail(candy apple red paint with ghost flames and screaming skulls).The prize inside is the 113 CI S&S sidewinder motor,the custom belt drive primary and competition clutch and the aftermarket 6 speed trans.

The paint will be gone(thinking about Rhino-lining on the tank and fenders) and the billet aluminum bling will be toned down to a satin sheen or covered with powdercoat but now that I have that big motor dialed in the mechanics are staying just the way they are.Think stealth fighter to picture what I have in mind,something radar scattering.

The bike has been named Rex,short for T-Rex which is what it acts like when you dial it on.Bill came back grinning from ear to ear after his first test ride and his first words were "Man,this thing lives to move FORWARD(motions emphatically with both hands at once) QUICKLY!!!

My hotrod shovelhead(named Betty in honor of Betty Paige) has all it can do to stay on it`s heels.

Not bad for the money!

The fellow sold it because his son had an eye to own it and Dad was afraid it would kill him.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#22

What I'd like to see in a grinder

GolfSteve in Calgary

Larry said "Here's what I'd look for in a grinder. I want the shrouds around the wheels to be easily removable with a minimum of tools. I want a two-piece tool rest that's wide enough to grind a skewed plane iron and still offer good support. I'd want the table deep enough to give a good registration but not interfere with handles, sockets or what ever on a relatively short chisel. It'd be ideal if you didn't need a wrench or any other tool to adjust the tool rest but, if it does require a tool, it should be only one. I don't like shouldered arbors that require spacers for thin wheels. I would prefer a grinder with a long enough neck that I never have to struggle with getting the light exactly where I want it. I'd also like a grinder that's quiet enough that I can hear the first contact of a tool to the wheel. "

In addition, I'd like to add:

1. Almost everything Larry mentioned is answered by discarding the factory tool rest and substituting the Oneway Wolverine grinding platform. It's great.

2. I'd like a small diameter motor that does not interfere with grinding long objects (such as lawn mower blades). I have a big Delta 8" grinder and the motor sometimes interferes with what I want to grind.

3. Dust control. I'd like to see integrated dust collection. My delta has connections on the shroud for dust extraction, but obviously I will not connect this to anything that may collect combustible materials (eg. paper shopvac bags, sawdust, etc). I hate truing up a wheel and getting dust all over my shop!!!

4. I'd stick with an 8" grinder - much better selection of wheels. But watch...some 8" grinders (such as one of the General International) do not have enough arbor length to accept 1" wide wheels or aftermarket balancing systems. If you want to investigate alternate wheels, almost all the aftermarket wheels are 1" wide.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#23

Have fun, had to be either a HD or BMW. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#24

Wolverine Grinding Platform

Steve Elliott

I've heard lots of good things about the Wolverine Grinding set-up. Can you tell me what the platform is made of? I'm hoping cast iron instead of aluminum.

Re: Grinding wheels revisited

#25

Or...

Bob Hackett

A Ducati,old Indian or an older British bike.

I wouldn`t turn down a Vincent,Norton or an older Triumph for that matter. :D