Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Difficult woods (timbers)

Posts

Difficult woods (timbers)

#1

Difficult woods (timbers)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Enlightened ones,

Derek has a thread below about a project using jarrah--what is jarrah? And we also have had a thread scroll off down below about high carbon steel and low-alloy tool steel (O1), versus higher-alloy steels.

The recent mention of CPM 3V came out of Australia, where I gather that there are a number of timbers in use which are mean customers. And if true, it may be that special steels could be particularly useful for them. Perhaps they just eat O1 up--I don't know.

To me, sugar maple, including birds-eye maple, is a very hard wood. How do these Aussie woods compare in hardness, density, edge tool wear--compared to sugar maple?

Can anyone comment from experience on these?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#2

Re: Difficult woods (timbers) *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

Cannot comment from experience, but the link is to a table of relative hardness. Of course, this does not necessarily tell the complete story because other factors can affect workability, but this is a start.


Relative wood hardness.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#3

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley and friends

Here is a table that provides some wood hardnesses. What I find helpful here is that this does compare a few on an international basis, which most references do not. What is not helpful is that these figures do not tell the full story. They are an approximation, an average, and of course we know that woods ("timber" in Australia) vary from one region to another. Also it depends how it was dried, how long it was dried, and so on.

Reading these figures is a bit like looking at adverts for houses in the newspaper - two houses both have the same number of rooms, bathrooms, etc, yet are completely different. It is hard to tell from figures alone..

What is omitted here is the abrasiveness of the woods themselves. For example, Jarrah here does not look at hard as I experience it to be. It (and other Ausie hardwoods) contain high levels of silica, and this is very hard on plane blades.

There has been a growing demand in Australia for plane and chisel blades that lasts. Yes there are a great number of woodworkers who continue to use HCS/O1, but A2 is the norm with newer blades, HSS is getting big, and D2 has entered the market (have you seen the blade in my jack!). HNT Gordon supply HSS plane blades and Harold & Saxon supply HSS bench chisels. Japanese tools have a big following.

I have to be careful when I draw conclusions for others based on Aussie hardwoods, but one of the advantages has been that I can test the limits of a tool. On the other hand these limits may never be experienced outside the use of such timbers .. woods.

Yellow is Australia, blue is USA, and others are in white ...


Reference: http://www.worldwideflood.com/ark/wood/timber_list.htm

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#4

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

David Weaver

I generally thickness some macassar ebony and some cocobolo every year - just pieces large enough to make planes or plane parts. It seems like the cocobolo is much more abrasive than the ebony, even though the ebony is probably harder.

I can't thickness a quarter inch off a 5x18 inch cocobolo board sometimes with an A2 iron before it needs sharpened, but I can do the same with a macassar ebony board and go on to the next one.

I've had some cocobolo that dulled an a2 cambered jack iron thicknessing a little more than 1/4" off of a *tote-sized* piece of wood. I'd imagine the difference is the silica content - they're all hard, but some of them have gleaming silica particles.

I have never planed anything domestic that's harder than hard maple, and while it's not always a party to plane, it's not too hard on irons. I haven't planed hickory or locust, but I've never seen anyone have anything good to say about doing that, either.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#5

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

David Weaver

There are several videos of people bucking dry gum logs with high $$ chainsaws on ebay.

It looks like they are cutting stone - the stuff coming out of the chainsaws is more like dust than chips.

Commentary from the uninformed is commonly something about the guy running the chainsaw not knowing what he's doing.

I hope the stuff makes great firewood, because it looks awful to cut.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#6

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

Bob Hackett

What I said in my earier post about chips and sparks together was not a joke.It happens fairly frequently while turning Teak.

Greenheart or Ipe` is being used up here for marine pilings and floats and some waterfront decks too.Carbide blades are what the contractors use for this and they change them often and charge accordingly.

Angelique is another BBing wood that can be terribly abrasive.

As already mentioned it`s the abrasive qualities of the wood rather than the hardness that make a difference and many of the woods coming from Central and South America are just as abrasive as the timber from OZ.

Even here with native US woods you find can see this pop up in woods like Desert Ironwood,Black Maple,Mesquite and some of the Blackjack Oak from the midwest as well as other wood that is not normally commercially available.

If you`d like to experience this for yourself the best bet would be to go to the website of one of the major mobile sawmill companies. Many keep a list of buyers and can direct you to a sawmill owner in your area.Most of those local owners have at least one stack of wood from local trees that they`ve worn out blades on and then once they told the customer about the problems and presented the bill they were stuck with it.

The stuff you get already milled from the lumber yard or large local supplier is the easy stuff.The rest of it goes to the pallet mills or firewood processors.Doesn`t mean it isn`t pretty,much of it is stunning.The reason you don`t see it is because it`s tough on equipment and the steel used in the blades.The lumber mills know it`s trouble and the log yards/graders avoid it or sell it to specialty processors just like they do with their premium graded veneer logs.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#7

The obvious question

wilbur

So how did Australian woodworkers deal with these wood species before CPM steel was invented?

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#8

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

David Weaver

As a kid, we heated with wood. We had a few acres behind the house that were densely wooded, about five or so, with trees that were dead or dying to be taken.

Choice wood to burn was red or white oak - it split easy, it wasn't hard on the chainsaw, and usually the only piece you couldn't easily split by hand was a crotch. Red oak stinks, though, as everyone on here already knows - it smells like you're splitting wood next to someone who has shoes and no socks on a hot summer day.

Anyway, hickory trees are common in PA. At times, we had to take down a hickory tree near the edge of the woods that was dying or dead, and several times we took locusts in the woods, usually let the hickory stand if it was in the woods. Locust was a nice wood for the stove - sort of an ugly wood, though. Dad's thought was that hickory had no redeeming qualities - it was hard to split and it made a lot more ash than red oak, and he didn't like getting off his routine for taking the ash out of the stove (everyone has their quirks).

What I do remember is that if you were cutting locust, you would see sparks from a chainsaw - especially if you were cutting it near dusk. I'm sure it was hard on chains, but it wasn't any worse than the granite rock that peppered our hill (our hill was part of a granite mine at one point) - old railroad tracks still there in some places where they carted the stone down to a local station.

After trying to split hickory a couple of times, I have no intention of working with it with hand tools. And as for the locust, I just remember it feeling a lot harder on the maul than did the oak - much different sound, more of a "clink" type of noise than the hollow knock sound. I don't remember it being that bad to split, but that was a long time ago - just remember sparks. Last time we got hickory was from three trees dying long the driveway at the same time - we rented a splitter that year to do those, and chucked the woodburner the next year - haven't burned wood there since.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#9

Re: The obvious question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wilbur

While many of my past posts have mentioned woods like Jarrah, Karri and She-oak, amongst a few others, it is important to realise that these are local West Australian hardwoods and their availability is one of the reasons I use them. To the rest of Australia these are expensive and speciality woods. On the eastern seaboard you will find a number of gums that are popular - Sydney Blue Gum, Spotted Gum, etc. They are all equally hard and interlocked, however.

Spotted gum ...

Then there are the softer hardwoods, many from Tasmanian such as Tasmanian Blackwood (my favourite ... glorious!), Tasmanian Oak (which is really a gum, also known as Australian Ash), and the wood that most of the early cabinetmakers used, Australian Red Cedar. The trouble is that woods like this are now logged out.

Tasmanian Blackwood ...

Australian Red Cedar ..

Huon Pine, for example, is a stunning softwood, again from Tasmania (the Apple Isle). It was prized for boat building, then furniture, but it is a rain forest wood and now protected. I have a small pile of short boards at home that are reserved for a few boxes.

From a website: "Huon pine contains a natural oil which gives the wood a unique fragrance which is never lost. This oil makes up 7% of the tree�s volume. A box made from this wood will always retain the fragrance of the oil when the lid is opened. This natural oil makes the wood resistant to water penetration and rot, making huon pine an ideal timber for boat building. This has made Tasmania famous for boat building since the days of the early convicts. Because of this unique quality it was felled indiscriminately, and has now become extremely rare. It is now a protected species and can be sourced only from dead fallen trees by specially licensed wood collectors. Huon pine can vary in age from hundreds to thousands of years, and some existing trees may be 5,000 years old. "

Here is one of a couple of bowls I have in huon pine ...


You may recall the Tasmanian Oak armoire I brecently completed ...


And as a reminder, a close up of figured Jarrah (a mirror I built) ..


I have been researching early Australian cabinetmaking. It appears that a lot ... most? .. of the early woods, especially Mahogany, were imported from Europe, and that much of the early furniture was imported, especially from the UK....


My opinion is that these hardwoods are more of a modern phenomenon. They have been used for a long time, but not as much for furniture as in recent times. Jarrah, for example, was used for railway sleepers and jettys. Even until a decade ago it was being used for roofing, as was Karri (absolutely criminal, but that is how I acquire it).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#10

scott grandstaff

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

scott grandstaff

Random thoughts in no particular order.

To me its all about the sand! Or silica if you like.

Seemingly tame woods can be made near impossible by grace of sand in the wood. Mesquite and desert ironwood are famous for this. Purely miserable!

I would rather plane madrone burl with a dull block plane than mesquite with an infill.

Grain stability, or reversal quotient is the other thing.

Maple, even the hardest of it, can be a total delight........

or complete disaster no matter what you do!

Our forefather would just chuck the bad into the stove without a second thought no doubt, but we seldom get that option. Unless you have generous wood providers in your neighborhood.

Hickory has a bad rep, its hard to plane and yet it scrapes like butter! Ash ditto. Both cut very easily with a drawkife and spokeshave, and a scraper is "in its element" like you can't believe. But the face grain doesn't like to be planed.

I have never made a hickory cabinet, and you'll never catch me trying.

But I carve handles all the time.

So American and African tropicals are all over the map. Some are ridiculously hard but work pretty easy. Others much softer but will take off an edge just as if you shoved your chisel into granite.

And this can be the same wood!

One piece tame and the next just awful.

We need better information that just species names

Same with grain reversal, which wouldn't bother a sander, but for the hand worker it can be misery.

The charts and names are never more than guidelines. Just general guidelines at that. Within each "name" there are probably dozens of unnamed sub species.

I have encountered Douglas fir, a normal softwood, that could not be split with 2 steel wedges and a 10 pound maul!!

I got to work a little piece of Huon Pine once. A gift from Peter Mc.

What a delightful piece of timber that!! Butter!! Sweet creamy butter and yet it has strength. No wonder its protected now. It should be up there as one of the most desirable timbers on the planet! Looks like boxwood, works like pine, holds together in a small section, tough and resilient.

You got to love this.

yours Scott

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#11

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have some experience with US woods - maple, cherry, and recently I build a jack plane from a chunk of mesquite that was given to me as a gift. As I recall, this had been "resting" for 30 years. I was very curious how it would work, having heard so many reports of it being a tough wood. Now please don't be offended, but I found it easy to work, definitely softer than jarrah and well-behaved. Give me more! :)



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#12

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here in Pennsylvania, we might have 60 or 70 native tree species that grow large enough for lumber. But if you look at wood inventories of 18th century cabinetmakers, they might have less than half a dozen different woods. Many woods just are not great cabinet woods. Looking at historic furniture, we do not see chairs made from Tsuga canadensis, or high chests made from Gymnocladus dioicus. There would be some novelty to a locust tea table, but who would want to pay the higher labor costs for a wood that is not as handsome as walnut?

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#13

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

David Weaver

I have never touched mesquite, no clue how it is. Hard maple is usually not bad to work with a plane of some mass, the exception being if it is not that straight and no high angle or tight mouthed planes are available. Cherry is very nice to work - there's a reason you'll see planes being demonstrated using cherry - because the shavings hold together nice, but with really thin shavings, it offers almost no resistance (and you can't be accused of using pine, poplar or cedar to stack the deck).

Anyway, what is it that occurs with wood that's old? I always thought wood was harder to work if it was green, but the last piece of cocobolo that I used in a plane that was known to be old was so mellow in how it worked with rasp, sandpaper and plane vs. the other cocobolo that I've used that it makes working with "sort of dry" cocobolo a really disappointing experience. I do not get the chance to work with much old wood - wish I could find more - especially more old blocks of cocobolo that are in the neighborhood of 14x8x5 and properly oriented to make planes.

I've seen mesquite far up on the hardness scale before, but as is being discussed, hard and difficult aren't a guaranteed 1 to 1 correlation.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#14

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

David Weaver

No reason to put it in furniture at all - makes great fence posts, though I guess folks didn't probably have a lot of barbed wire around then.

How much did files cost back then? If locust makes chainsaw chain spark, I can't imagine i'd be really great for spring steel, nor the pocket paying for files to keep the spring steel sharp.

Warren, have you ever had the occasion to work locust in earnest - or for novelty, and if so, what were your thoughts? My mother had a friend whose husband died, and she told me the lady wanted to know if I wanted any of his chunks of turning wood. I don't really like taking things from people if they have economic value (i'd figured it was a bowl blank or a burl or something), and it'd be worth their while to sell, so I said no, but she said the lady already dropped one of the pieces off. It was an old dried up log of locust about 10 inches in diameter. It's still in my garage. I have no idea what to do with it.

We have plenty of locust fence posts still holding rusted away barbed wire in fence rows on our farm back home. Couldn't begin to guess how old they are, but they're a lot older than I am. If the chunk I received was long enough, I'd ram it into the ground somewhere, but it's only about 20 inches long.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#15

scott grandstaff

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

scott grandstaff

Oh, no offense taken. At all.

Just try another 500 bf of it. You'll see.

Much mesquite will be well behaved as you please. Not so hard and nice to work, beautiful colors and lovely in all ways howsoever.

But some will be exactly the same as planing a Norton Carborundum stone! It'll defeat carbide!

I've had pecan the same way.

I see this so much.

Seemingly harmless oak that simply can't be worked, except by scraper at best and cedar that practically explodes.

Next pieces, absolutely as sweet as candy. The surface shimmering and filling the air with perfume.

There is an oak that grows around here. Black oak they call it. This stuff is practically divine! You can work it up and grain and back down and it doesn't even want to tear out a bit. (carves like butter)

Its about the same consistency (hardness) as chestnut, looks like oak that has already been aged 100 years, and smells like some kind of room sachet when you cut it. (unlike many oaks which smell awful)

But then some of it will spin up like a corkscrew the second you cut into it??

You can't even get your saw to the end of a cut before it bites the saw and pulls up a twist 2" in 3 feet!

Or you'll get 1/2 way down the board with a plane and craaaaaaack! Off she goes for no reason whatever.

Wood is so unpredictable.

Man I wish I had a crystal ball to tell in advance. :)

yours Scott

Wood is contrary!

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#16

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

wilbur

I had a chunk of black locust that a neighbor gave me from a tree that came down on his property. I tried to turn a bowl out of it. That experience was so frustrating (my turning tools are cryogenically treated CPM-10V) that I burned the rest of it, along with the bowl.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#17

The old saying is

Neal in San Jose

A locust post will out-last the hole.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#18

Re: The old saying is

David Weaver

Never heard that, but it's a perfect saying.

I debated (given that I was already running on, and declined to keep doing so) mentioning that as a kid when we found a loose post, it was always because the cows had rubbed against it and made it loose in the dirt at some point in the past, never because the posts got punky. We would always try to throw or wedge rocks and dirt in to tigthen the posts, especially in the fences that were out in the open - even though the animals were long gone. Not sure why we did that, but kids always like to "fix things" and then go back to the house and let everyone know that "we fixed the fence".

We (the family at my parents' generation, not me yet, I guess) still own the farm now, but I haven't been there in years - maybe 6 or 7. It's rented to a farmer, and the fences are still there more to help neighbor relations. The land is rented to a local corporate farmer, so there's just not the incentive to "walk the land" and look around like we did with grandpa when I was a kid. Spent a lot of time walking the field roads (for the non-farmers, just a dirt path that was packed down so equipment could drive on it, even if fields were a little wet). Grandpa would walk us around and go through the bears of the day, be it beans in a low spot that didn't grow out, ATV tracks, or a cow from the neighbor's that had been heaved over the fence and covered with poop to avoid paying the rendering truck fee.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#19

I like Mesquite...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Granted I haven't played with a lot of it. I've made a few spokeshaves out of it and it was a pleasure to work with. Now pecan, I'm in the same boat as

Mr. Grandstaff. Nasty stuff.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#20

Ditto for osage orange

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I had a chunk of that once and ended up burning it. Could not do one single thing with it. Too bad I didn't need a chisel handle then.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#21

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, I am sure you would be able work locust, David. I have worked it dry, but probably more often a bit green for outdoor work etc. A few minutes ago I pulled out an old piece of firewood (air dried about twelve years) and planed a flat side and made a mortise for fresh reference. I would say it takes more discipline, patience, and technique compared to what we might call a cabinet wood. The temptation is to really bash on a hard tough wood, but that is rough on the tools. It just isn't nearly as rewarding as working walnut or mahogany.

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#22

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

Christoph Scholz

You can't really talk about difficult woods without mentioning 15th century Ming furniture.

Chris

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#23

Mis-application of available resources

Bob Hackett

That would be mil-speak for using the wrong stuff in the wrong way.

It occurs to me that things only become difficult if we either approach them in the wrong way or ask them to do something they are not well suited to.

A wood that acts like concrete when dry may be a dream to rive.Locust up here would fit that description.BTW-When you say locust are you talking about black locust or honey locust which is more apt to live up to it`s name for flat work but doesn`t last near as long outside.

Likewise a wood with interlocking grain which makes it a real bear to plane,split or work in other ways may be just the ticket for tool handles or the tools themselves.Apple and dogwood come to mind for this.

There are numerous woods that locals know as "ironwood".Up here it`s usually hornbeam but it could be any one of a hundred things outside of the Maine coast.The local names can either stem from the wear characteristics or something simple as the weight.Here hornbeam is called "ironwood " because it "lasts near as long as iron" as boat cradle rollers and in other high wear applications.Despite it`s name I find it easy to work and it`s somewhat bland color takes a nice finish if you like light colored wood.Hornbeam I`ve used in boxes also took dyes and stain well.

How many pieces of traditional furniture/casework have you seen made out of willow?That same willow is a favorite for rustic bent wood furniture and things like hurdles or fencing.The trees are carefully pruned to produce proper canes in some areas.

My point is,if you choose and use wood for it`s outstanding qualities or abilities and then approach the work using the proper technique then what your neighbor finds a "difficult" wood may find favor in your shop.

As a foreman I worked under used to say"I don`t believe there`s anything wrong with the materials,I think the problem may be a loose nut behind the controls". :)

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#24

Huanghuali is a  *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Dalbergia species (rosewood). For those of us not real familiar with it. See link.

Wiley


Classical Chinese furniture wood

Re: Difficult woods (timbers)

#25

Bloodwood..

Normp

I handplaned some figured bloodwood a few months ago and it scratched the soles of every plane that touched the wood. The scratches deep enough to be noticeable with running a fingernail across the sole.

Needless to say, I haven't worked with the rest of that bloodwood since.

Beautiful wood though, when it's smoothed and finished!

Norman