Re: Old Steel
Thomd
"
17th c steel was different from late 18th c steel. But all those early steels semed to have very high carbon contents (like 1% or more) and they were DIRTY! I think the process of shaping the steel involved a fair amount of cold working which had the (possibly unintended) effect of reducing grain size. The reduction in grain size reduced the size of impurities and spread them thoughout the steel making it effectively stronger and better able to take a keen edge. Not all modern steels have such small grains."
This seems to be a variation on the compacting theory popular in knife circles. The idea is that forging creates a finer grain, though normally the idea is hot not cold working. Most metallurgists consider this impossible. And it is less said these days, until someone reads an old book. Something is happening that makes these great blades, but just what it iss is difficult to say. This is why my theory is it is the demand of the end user, not the process. The end users back then wanted different stuff than we want today. Not so long ago it was a competence issue, but there are many very competent users today, but their interests are often nothing much to do with making stuff. I used to fool around with golf gear. Mowst golf gear is designed either to help hopeless hackers out, or to make something extraordinary but ungolflike happen, such as get the longest drive out of a party of 4 in best ball. Not the same gear as required to play a real round for lowest score. But most golfers don't really want to do that. They want 7 irons that hit a ball further than the 6 irons they currently have, and then they want some wedges that will deal with the gap in their low irons...
"This, combined with their inability to consistently heat treat their blades* made edge tools of (in my opinion) superior quality to modern tools. It's likely they didn't know the science behind what they were doing. But what they did made good edge tools. I wouldn't want to build bridges or aircraft out of their steel. But I'm not crazy about making chisels out of some of these new steels. "
I don't doubt that modern computer controlled HT stuff works better than the forge. But it is like anything else, you find a way to get the result you want. I guess somewhere there is a CNC sander that works faster and "better" than a hand tool approach, but I wouldn't bet on the result out-appealing, hand planing, scraping, sanding, and French polishing on a one-off piece... So in the case of a forge you get some process like triple quenching that isn't necessary, but makes up for a variety of things that are difficult to do by eye. The end result is great, and then a myth of mystical quenches builds up further obscuring what was going on. What was going on was finding a way to deal with the fact that manual methods of soaking the steel at trans temp are not accurate, but if you just repeat a few times, along with other tricks, you get a great result anyway.