Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Modern Plane Blades can't do this

Posts

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#26

Or...

Bob Hackett

It could simply be they have a deep commitment to and true understanding of their craft.

From what I`ve seen of people like this it would appear they could excell at just about anything they chose to.They picked the one they found most challenging or attractive, immersed themselves in it and never looked back.

MB

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#27

Old Steel

Adam Cherubini

17th c steel was different from late 18th c steel. But all those early steels semed to have very high carbon contents (like 1% or more) and they were DIRTY! I think the process of shaping the steel involved a fair amount of cold working which had the (possibly unintended) effect of reducing grain size. The reduction in grain size reduced the size of impurities and spread them thoughout the steel making it effectively stronger and better able to take a keen edge. Not all modern steels have such small grains.

This, combined with their inability to consistently heat treat their blades* made edge tools of (in my opinion) superior quality to modern tools. It's likely they didn't know the science behind what they were doing. But what they did made good edge tools. I wouldn't want to build bridges or aircraft out of their steel. But I'm not crazy about making chisels out of some of these new steels.

That said, I have a Hock iron and I like it. I think Ron knows how to make a good plane blade. I have one other new plane blade and I don't care for its blade. It may be be that i haven't found the right sharpening media as Warren says. I sold my last waterstone to Frank Klaus and a CRAFTS auction! He drives a hard bargain.

adam

*None of my solid cast steel blades are heat treated throughout. They seem to have softer centers (for reasons I don't fully understand but may possibly stem from their choice of quenchants) and certainly tangs/tops etc. I feel the combination of hard and soft metal gives tools a "lively" feel and may help maintain edges through shock absorption, reduction of microcracking etc etc. I've tried to copy this in tools I've made and the users of those chisels (which include Schwarz and Warren) would have to report on my success or failure.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#28

Info on old Steel and toolmakers

Bob Hackett

An excellent source to info on old steels and how they were made as well as old tools and toolmakers would be Skip and his crew at the Davistown Museum is Liberty Maine.

You can contact them and order books thru the Museum website.I`d post a link but I have no idea how.Google works to find it if you`re like me, just skimming the surface rather than riding the crest of the high tech wave.

MB

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#29

Book larnin' and experiential larnin'

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't know anyone who's making violins (or cellos for that matter), but my observation of other makers and good mechanics is that they develop deep understanding of what's going on with their materials. Much of this is through practice. Often - not always - practical learning will come to the same place as intellectual analysis of the same issues; sometimes it's superior.

Sometimes it's inferior. The example that surfaces from the sludge I call my brain is the longtime, now discredited, standard practice of filling wound holes (broken branches and such like) in trees with concrete to keep water out and thus forestall rot. I remember thinking about doing that on a tree on our property when we first moved here. Fortunately, I read, somewhere, of the research that had shown this actually led to MORE rot, and the intellectual analysis of the cause: concrete is hygroscopic and will attract and hold water, while keeping air from getting to the wound to dry it out, thus creating the perfect environment for rot organisms. Ever since, I've addressed tree wounds by cleaning up the break and slanting it so water can drain.

I do agree, Warren, that intellectual understanding, and $5 or so will get you a cup of coffee, but won't make a violin. To quote a sage, �In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is.� (Yogi Berra)

But: I've spoken to too many artisans who combine deep practical experience with deep intellectual learning on their subject to think that the two are in some manner mutually exclusive. Ideally, theory and practice teach each other.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#30

Indeed!

Marv

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#31

Stephen Shepherd

Great Post, I am going to quote you.

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#32

Re: Temper?

VT_Andy

Warren,

You are certainly right about the talent and devotion of the greatest contemporary violin builders. However, the use of modern technology certainly plays an important role, at least for Sam Zygmuntowicz. (See story linked below, or even better, find the clip from Jim Lehrer from several more years ago, which showed Sam's use of various scans on historical instruments. Many violinists consider Sam to be the top living violin builder, and one of his instruments attained the highest price at auction for a stringed instrument made by a living builder. YoYo Ma once famously mistook the sound of one of Sam's instruments for a famous antique instrument owned by Isaac Stern. (Ma now plays a cello made by Sam.) I met Sam once when I lived in the same neighborhood in Brooklyn and he is a down-to-earth guy!

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=96708334

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#33

Is Ad Hock Ron Hock's brother?

Neal in San Jose

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#34

Re: Temper?

ThomD

That is undoubtedly true along with the fact they have to have the access and skills to get great players to play their instruments, however they manage that.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#35

Re: Temper?

ThomD

>Johann Christoph Denner of chisels if you will. then it is conceivable that an exceptionally skilled craftsman with many years, if not generations of experience, is capable of crafting products that exceed industrially produced tools.

That is a forgone conclusion. Speaking only of steel, as much as I like O1, it was designed to maintain dimensional specs for gage blocks, or some such. One can't doubt that if Siemmens set itself the task of inovating planes that would take away some market share from boutique makers, they would succeed to some extent, but it will never happen, so we have all the best work being done in small shops. The funny thing is we all believe this at some level, and also the contrary. There is some product the average person believes in in this way like coutourier dresses or hand rolled cigars, and some product where they believe that GMOd factory eggs are just great in a breakfast sandwich.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#36

Re: Old Steel

Thomd

"

17th c steel was different from late 18th c steel. But all those early steels semed to have very high carbon contents (like 1% or more) and they were DIRTY! I think the process of shaping the steel involved a fair amount of cold working which had the (possibly unintended) effect of reducing grain size. The reduction in grain size reduced the size of impurities and spread them thoughout the steel making it effectively stronger and better able to take a keen edge. Not all modern steels have such small grains."

This seems to be a variation on the compacting theory popular in knife circles. The idea is that forging creates a finer grain, though normally the idea is hot not cold working. Most metallurgists consider this impossible. And it is less said these days, until someone reads an old book. Something is happening that makes these great blades, but just what it iss is difficult to say. This is why my theory is it is the demand of the end user, not the process. The end users back then wanted different stuff than we want today. Not so long ago it was a competence issue, but there are many very competent users today, but their interests are often nothing much to do with making stuff. I used to fool around with golf gear. Mowst golf gear is designed either to help hopeless hackers out, or to make something extraordinary but ungolflike happen, such as get the longest drive out of a party of 4 in best ball. Not the same gear as required to play a real round for lowest score. But most golfers don't really want to do that. They want 7 irons that hit a ball further than the 6 irons they currently have, and then they want some wedges that will deal with the gap in their low irons...

"This, combined with their inability to consistently heat treat their blades* made edge tools of (in my opinion) superior quality to modern tools. It's likely they didn't know the science behind what they were doing. But what they did made good edge tools. I wouldn't want to build bridges or aircraft out of their steel. But I'm not crazy about making chisels out of some of these new steels. "

I don't doubt that modern computer controlled HT stuff works better than the forge. But it is like anything else, you find a way to get the result you want. I guess somewhere there is a CNC sander that works faster and "better" than a hand tool approach, but I wouldn't bet on the result out-appealing, hand planing, scraping, sanding, and French polishing on a one-off piece... So in the case of a forge you get some process like triple quenching that isn't necessary, but makes up for a variety of things that are difficult to do by eye. The end result is great, and then a myth of mystical quenches builds up further obscuring what was going on. What was going on was finding a way to deal with the fact that manual methods of soaking the steel at trans temp are not accurate, but if you just repeat a few times, along with other tricks, you get a great result anyway.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#37

Re: Old Steel

R Payne

Metallurgist know that hot working steel refines the grain. There are micrographs that prove it. (I haven't kept links to said pictures, sorry. A search should be able to find them.) What doesn't happen and was once thought to is "packing" the grain. Refining the grain breaks the grain into smaller gains while packing the grain leaves the same number of grains but is suppose to pack them into a smaller volume. Metallurgist also know that the same refining of the grain can be had through heat treat. No hammering required. Depending on exactly what is in the steel, working cold can improve or ruin the steel.

As for old steel blades not being through hardened, that is a combination of alloying elements and quenchant and quenching technique.

The big advantage to laminating simple steel is that it allows for the high carbon portion to be left harder than most people would find acceptable in a single steel. Modern steel allow for differing alloys that mimics the results of laminating without the laminating process.

But as a novice blacksmith, I like what I can do with simple steels that can't be done with alloys I can forge and heat treat with simple tools.

ron p

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#38

Re: Old Steel

ThomD

"The big advantage to laminating simple steel is that it allows for the high carbon portion to be left harder than most people would find acceptable in a single steel."

Yeah, but -

Depends what one means by acceptable. When properly used edge chipping in use isn't a serious issue, the main issue is time to sharpen overly hard metals by hand. Which makes me wonder...

1) I'm not sure about the issue for cast steel where the edge wasn't "that" hard (either to chip or sharpen), and stationary/hollow grinding was the norm. Chris Schwartz did open my eyes, in a recent book, as to how slow even this may have been, so hard to say...

2) On Japanese tools it would all be so convincing except for a few facts:

- They sharpen both sides of the edge (not something shown in most western instruction books prior to the 80s. Most talked only about honing the bevel regularly, the back was set-up. Actually that would be a good question for the historians out there, I remember the 70s when there was lots of open discussion about whether one only pushed a blade one way on stones, and whether one needed to hone both sides of the edge equally, or at all. But what was the norm in the west during the 18th century? Anyway, the way Japanese tools are designed the back is hollow ground essentially. So why not the bevels also. The tools have the marks of extensive stationary hollow grinding so why worry about speed when that is available.

- If one buys the idea that the Japanese tools we know today are the result of blacksmiths migrating from swords, then there are two things about all that. One is that they laminated swords for much the reason you mention, but for an environment totally different from the one that we consider today with hand tools. And the swords were professionally sharpened so who cares how hard it was. Not the same issue as we have to deal with on tools. I do wonder if they were simply made as they were for conventional reasons. That yields a certain result, then one just works that out as best one can. Cost can't be the reason since the very best swords where laminated, and the art level tools are also.