Re: Temper?
Ron Hock
Hi Stephen,
Your post implies that Moxon's heat treatment techniques are applicable today and the fundamentals undoubtedly are. But that assumes we are all using the same steel alloys and constrained by the same technology. It also fails to take into account the enormous amount that we've learned about steel in the last 300 years. While I'm certain that Moxon's book could teach me a lot about woodworking, I'm pretty sure that I could teach him a thing or two about steel. It would be an interesting meeting.
We've learned a lot about metallurgy (and a few other things) since the 17th century. And I've learned a lot about heat treating over the years. One of the things I've learned is that an accurate oven and a hardness tester can be very helpful when accurate, repeatable results are the goal. When I give demonstrations of DIY heat treating, I use a propane torch to temper, heating the hardened piece away from the edge and allowing the colors to run down toward it. If I allow the edge to turn any color at all, the piece will test softer than Rc62 (my goal for plane irons and if I made chisels, those, too.)
A blade tempered to "light straw" will sharpen easily and cut well. You may never notice the Rc-point-or-two difference and use the blade for years, happily. But for manufacturing consistency, and the best product I can offer, I need the consistent, reliable results afforded by contemporary heat treatment equipment (such as atmosphere ovens to control carbon loss) and techniques (such as martempering).
I'm always happy to answer questions about tool steel metallurgy and heat treatment, etc. I devoted a lengthy chapter to the subject in my book on sharpening: The Perfect Edge, which is available at hocktools.com. I'd love to sign a copy for you...
Let me know if you have any questions.
Regards,
Ron