Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Modern Plane Blades can't do this

Posts

Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Modern Plane Blades can't do this

Stephen Shepherd

I just picked up a 3/16" plow blade [I didn't have that size] and it fits my Willard plow plane. I beat the guy up on the price because the blade was 'broken' and got it for a dollar.


It shows up better in this image.


After I finish cleaning the blade, I will heat it up and straighten out the iron so it fits better on the skate of the plow plane.

Had this been a solid steel blade the end would of course be missing, but because it is steel forge welded to wrought iron, only the steel broke.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#2

Not sure I agree

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've picked up a couple of metal planes that appear to have been dropped upside down, or something like, so that the top of the cutting iron is bent down over the frog. They straighten out quite nicely. Granted, this is at the end that doesn't need tempering, and the factory may have hardened and tempered only the cutting end, leaving the rest soft. I also have a 1/4" mortise chisel that has a subtle but discernible curve to its back. Had it started a break, no doubt it would have broken altogether, yes; but it's an interesting question whether a blade composed of a thin section of strong steel welded to a thicker section of soft iron is stronger in shear than a blade composed of a thicker section of strong steel.

I'm unwilling to sacrifice any of my metal to the experiment, though, so unless someone is so willing, I guess it'll remain speculative.

That's a fairly Toddly price, by the way. Hope the seller wasn't a widow.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Not sure I agree

Stephen Shepherd

Bill,

Knowing the properties of wrought iron I made sure I heated it before I did any bending. I would do this to a solid steel blade if I owned one.

After it spent some time in the cleaner and I was sure that there was no more rust in the crack, I heated it up to cherry red and gently tapped it with a light hammer against a flat piece of iron I use for an anvil. It took a couple of heats and gentle tapping but I got it flat.


I then heated up the tip about 3/4" got cherry red and I quenched it in brine.

I will have to take it to the shop to sharpen, a file won't touch the steel now that it is very hard.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#4

Temper?

Bob Hackett

Stephen,you probably already know this but that iron needs to have the hardness drawn down before you use it.If you only harden a blade and not temper it then it`s very likely to chip at the slightest provocation.Some refer to the hardened but not drawn/tempered condition as being"glass hard".

I also think the proof of new irons not being able to do what this one did is proven just by what you see with that plow plane iron.The HCS fractured and if it hadn`t been forge welded to the softer material then it would have been broken clean off and the tip would be missing.

I have a few non-laminated blade chisels that were either used to pry something or had been pounded till they stuck in some timber and then levered in an attempt to extract them and they all obviously broke clean through.I assume the ends are still buried in a timber somewhere.

Squared off and honed they make great scraper chisels for both wood and metal.

MB

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#5

Re: Temper?

Thomd

Most likely the blade wouldn't have broken in the first place if it had been made of solid HC steel. There is a constant argument over the benefits of laminated of diff tempered tools and blades. But the one thing that isn't really open to argument is that a load that will bend a laminated or diff tempered blade will not begin to bend a same section of tempered steel. In the knife biz the whole ABS testing procedure is based on being able to pretzel a blade without harming the edge, but the same knife in unified form probably wouldn't have bent.

However one cuts it, these laminated tools whether western or Japanese just have nicer blades. I think the main issue is for whom they were made rather than how they were made. At the end of the day that is far more important. We have the internet, CNC, etc... these days. What we don't have is a large number of people who don't eat unless they put in 80 hours a week with hand woodworking tools against competition from others in the same situation. Imagine if your best client had the power of life and death. Maybe not specifically relative to your circumstances but someone you wouldn't want to think any the less of you. His business card reads "The Sun King"...

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#6

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

bugbear

Is the hard steel broken, or is the break at the steel/iron transition?

On price, given the amount of work and knowledge needed to make the blade usable, I'd say a dollar is about right. What you have is little more than (good) raw materials.

BugBear

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#7

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Temper?

Stephen Shepherd

Bob,

If it had been solid steel, I would have drawn the temper to a nice straw color, but I wanted the blade 'glass hard'.

I mainly use pine in my work and a hard blade shouldn't be a problem.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#8

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Temper?

Stephen Shepherd

Thom,

'However one cuts it, these laminated tools whether western or Japanese just have nicer blades'

Can't disagree with that.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#9

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

Stephen Shepherd

Bug Bear,

The steel was broken straight across the blade down to where it was forge welded to the wrought iron.

I probably spent more time writing about straightening the blade than the actual operation took.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#10

Re: Another question

ThomD

I bought 4 of these blades at the TOTT show. I paid enough money for them to for Bugbear to retire handily, like 6 bucks each.

So how do they work? There is an article on the C&W site that makes them sound fairly complex. Is making the plane as simple as aligning the bed withe desired angle, and then projecting the skate out a little further but at the same angle, so as to provide support in the V-grove on the back of the blade.

Also, are the wooden depth stops held in place by the same wedge that wedges the forward cross beam?

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#11

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Another question

Stephen Shepherd

Thom,

I am not certain how C&W make their planes, but the plow is a more complex plane. Some wooden depth stops were friction fit, some had thumb screws to hold the stop and some have thumb screws to adjust it as well.

The geometry of the plane blades being thick on the working end with a V groove in the back that rides on the V shaped end of the skate. The skate is in line with the wedge and blade hole and the tapered blade makes up the difference.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#12

Suggestions for making one.

Bob Hackett

I would either invest in the book "Making Traditional Wooden Planes" by John M. Whelan(ISBN 1-879335-69-7) or pick up any old shelled out or worm eaten body to use as an example and scrounge hardware from.

MB

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#13

Re: Another question

Larry Williams

We do make the friction fit depth stop of a plow so that it also secured by the wedge that locks the front arm. I've had early examples of plows that work this way in my hands and I think it's a good idea to make them that way.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#14

Re: Temper?

Ron Hock

In general, however, you must always temper a piece of hardened steel, and immediately after the quench. The phase change induced by quenching isn't finished when the steel cools, it takes more time for the conversion to complete. During this time, there are dimensional changes taking place. If the outer dimension finished first, it can crack while the inner dimensions continue to change. This isn't likely with the thin sections we usually work with but it's one of the rules of heat treatment: temper immediately following the quench. At least minimal temper is recommended; "light straw" would be too much for a plane iron or chisel. You can get Rc62 (for O1) with a 325F temper and not see any "straw". Maximum hardness/minimum temper would be, IMO, 250 to 300F. I think that, even in soft pine, you'll enjoy a longer lasting edge.

Good luck!

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Temper?

Stephen Shepherd

Ron, you said:

'At least minimal temper is recommended; "light straw" would be too much for a plane iron or chisel. You can get Rc62 (for O1) with a 325F temper and not see any "straw".'

According to Moxon:

'The light goldifh Colour is for Files, Cold-chiffels and Punches, that Punch into iron and Steel: The dark goldifh Colour for Punches to use on Brafs, and generally for moft Edge-tools; The blew colour gives the temper to Springs in general,...'

[original spelling, emphasis added]

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#16

Re: Temper?

Ron Hock

Hi Stephen,

Your post implies that Moxon's heat treatment techniques are applicable today and the fundamentals undoubtedly are. But that assumes we are all using the same steel alloys and constrained by the same technology. It also fails to take into account the enormous amount that we've learned about steel in the last 300 years. While I'm certain that Moxon's book could teach me a lot about woodworking, I'm pretty sure that I could teach him a thing or two about steel. It would be an interesting meeting.

We've learned a lot about metallurgy (and a few other things) since the 17th century. And I've learned a lot about heat treating over the years. One of the things I've learned is that an accurate oven and a hardness tester can be very helpful when accurate, repeatable results are the goal. When I give demonstrations of DIY heat treating, I use a propane torch to temper, heating the hardened piece away from the edge and allowing the colors to run down toward it. If I allow the edge to turn any color at all, the piece will test softer than Rc62 (my goal for plane irons and if I made chisels, those, too.)

A blade tempered to "light straw" will sharpen easily and cut well. You may never notice the Rc-point-or-two difference and use the blade for years, happily. But for manufacturing consistency, and the best product I can offer, I need the consistent, reliable results afforded by contemporary heat treatment equipment (such as atmosphere ovens to control carbon loss) and techniques (such as martempering).

I'm always happy to answer questions about tool steel metallurgy and heat treatment, etc. I devoted a lengthy chapter to the subject in my book on sharpening: The Perfect Edge, which is available at hocktools.com. I'd love to sign a copy for you...

Let me know if you have any questions.

Regards,

Ron

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#17

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Temper?

Stephen Shepherd

Ron,

Thank you for your reply. How do you suppose modern steel varies from the ones available in the past. Moxon talks of the difference in quenching English, Flemish [German] and Swedish steel different that Spanish or Venice steel. He also talks of the different English steels, e.g. Yorkshire, Gloucestershire, Suffex and Wild of Kent saying the best was made in the Forrest of Dean.

He also mentions how Damascus Steel is rare in England as well as details about the origins of the steel from the sources.

I presume your harden your tools from solid steel, have you experience with laminated blades?

Thanks again.

Stephen

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#18

Re: Temper?

Ron Hock

I know very little about 17th century steel composition and how they controlled quality and purity, etc. Steels today are made of highly controlled alloys that must comply with strict standards for how much of what's in it. If it is sold as "AISI O1", for example, the alloying elements added to the steel can only be 0.9% carbon, 1.1% manganese, 0.5% chromium and 0.5% Tungsten, all with close allowable tolerances. Some mills add a pinch of Vanadium to control grain growth at high heat but that's always mentioned on the label.

Heat treatment today is much more science than art (though there is still some art to it.) Atmosphere-controlled ovens replaced the forge a long time ago, electronics and computers allow very tight control of all aspects relating to heating and cooling the steel at the proper rate for thorough and precise hardness, etc. But with all that, heat treating procedures are still often called "recipes", a term that acknowledges the experiential nature of the task. Some steels for some applications may perform better with one hardening technique or another.

We've only ever used solid steel for our blades. I see no reason for laminating a plane iron other than to minimize the use of high carbon steel, which was so very rare in the past.

Sorry I can't answer better about historic steels. Perhaps someone can chime in?

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#19

Re: Temper?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

We've only ever used solid steel for our blades. I see no reason for laminating a plane iron other than to minimize the use of high carbon steel, which was so very rare in the past.

I'm pretty convinced by my use of Japanese edge tools that there is some value to the way some of them are still made (forged over open charcoal fire and laminated). Of course, I don't have your knowledge of metal working, my evidence is all empirical; so perhaps I should say that "in my hands, Japanese laminated edge tools work better and easier." They certainly temper their blades.

Pam

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#20

Re: Temper?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It seems like the current idea is to make the tool as hard as possible and as tough and nasty as possible and then worry about how to sharpen it. Every "improvement" in steel spawns a new generation of sharpening media to be able to handle it. I am not sure 18th century workers had the same ideas. I am currently using chisels tempered at 375 side by side with chisels of the same steel tempered at 450. What do I notice in a production situation? I notice that one kind takes more than twice as long to sharpen. I do not notice edge longevity differences. What do my 18th century plane iron and 1820's chisel have in common? They both sharpen like a dream. They just feel terrific on the stone.

Back in 1978 I found my self working in a shop with an older man. The first day he tells me he has never had a chisel sharp enough to shave. I assured him I could do that. Then I had a moment of panic. I could easily shave using my chisels and my stones at home, but what about the stuff there in the shop? I was certainly glad to find a 19th century chisel and an Arkansas stone.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#21

David Barnett

Ad Hock musings on Moxon and 'progress'...

David Barnett

We turned to Exercise pursuits Mechanick,

When Moxon did the temple veil tear,

To print his illustrated tome titanic,

And lay long-guarded guilded secrets bare.

When Tubalcain last chimed the bronze of ancients

To herald the age of Iron alloyed with Life

Man yet would wait past Moxon with impatience,

A hundred years to modernize the knife.

Add wolfram, freyja, manganese, and chrome,

To chill in oil more deeply than in brine,

No more to plunge the glowing bilbo home,

No more to quench in slave's gut swelled with wine.

With all the pleasure lost what's left to do?

Just scrap the metal, Stephen, stick with glue.

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#23

Re: Temper?

Christoph Scholz

Excellent points!

We have gained tremendous insight into steel making and heat treatment since the 17th Century (or since the 11th century from a less Euro-centric point of view). Conventional controls techniques, modern state-space methods, optimal control, robust control, stochastic control, etc. and finally the implementation of such controls theories combined with modern statistical process control methods have made it possible to produce steel of great quality with unprecedented consistency (in other words the fact that an oven uses inert gas and has a digital readout does not make it accurate, precise, repeatable or reproducible). As a result there is no doubt that the average industrially produced steel is by far better than what th 17th century smelter (or Song Dynasty metallurgist) or average hobbyist could ever produce.

Nevertheless, when you are talking about the best possible steel, the Stradivari of plane blades so to speak, Johann Christoph Denner of chisels if you will. then it is conceivable that an exceptionally skilled craftsman with many years, if not generations of experience, is capable of crafting products that exceed industrially produced tools.

Chris

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#24

  Outstanding, Dave

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Modern Plane Blades can't do this

#25

Re: Temper?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think there might be violin makers today who could be favourably compared to the 17th century masters. But if that is the case, I don't think it is because they read the many articles in Scientific American over the last half century. I don't think it is because they have been looking at microscopes or spectroscopes or oscilloscopes or because they have tools hardened to Rc 64. Or are guided by physicists, chemists or engineers. I think there are good makers today because they are very talented people, extremely devoted to their craft, and have a clientele that is willing to reward them for their efforts. They have a vibrant community, are inspired by each others successes, and they get feedback from their ears, of all things.