Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Tote Carving Plus

Posts

Tote Carving Plus

#1

scott grandstaff

Tote Carving Plus

scott grandstaff

I'm not planning to tell you every little thing.

But if you take these basics and experiment, you can have totes, and as many as you want, the likes of which you can never buy for money.

Absolutely and most definitely you drill the long hole first.

Forget anything else, use oversized stock and drill first.

Everything else relates to the hole and there is no way in the world you are drilling an angled 5"+ long hole to fit outer proportions.

I like to go ahead and counterbore the hole for the barrel nut on top and the casting post on the bottom while I'm at it.

Counterbores are wonderful things, but very expensive.

Unless you can find yourself a surplus place near an aircraft manufacturing plant. Then they come by the dozen and very reasonably priced.

20 bucks a dozen instead of 30 dollars apiece.

Once you have the hole prepared, adjust the bottom angles to fit so it sits on the plane well.

Only then, can you begin to design and carve your tote shape.

Since you are carving from scratch, why follow a standard pattern?

Its true the mid period Stanley totes (types 5 to about 8 ) are about the most beautifully proportioned totes ever commercially offered, imo.

But hey, you got more time and you can do at least that good!

I suggest you get a selection of old totes, or at least some decent pictures, which you can copy and save to your files off ebay auctions if nothing else.

So......................

What size do you wear in a glove?? Got size 6??? Size 11??

What you packin' at the end of your arms?

If you are a size 12 you will never fit all your fingers inside a metal plane tote of any kind. But anything less than that, you can accomodate your grip if you work at it.

Then, we move to your work style.

Do you mostly work from a sawhorse where you are leaning over far over the work? Or a high bench where you are mainly pushing forward??

This determines your totes vertical angle, whether leaned forward (if you are over top) or more vertical, if working from a higher bench.

Most totes were made for a reasonably high bench and average height mechanic, btw, so there is your starting place.

Now we come down to grip.

The human hand on a plane handle wants to curl the index and second finger rather tightly. This grips and controls the plane. Like the tiller of a ship.

You don't want too small, nor too large at the throat.

The bottom fingers less so, more just along for the ride.

In the matter of pushing, it all comes down to the heel of the hand. This is where you push through the wood.

Nearly all commercial totes were made from minimum stock. This is a very big deal if you are making 10,000 totes, considering the price of tropical hardwood.

So, Spiers was about the most generous totemaker, weighing in at almost 16/16" stock. Stanley was pretty far down there at under 7/8". The thickness of the stock is important for the grip but also important for the pushing. Pushing hard and long against a skinny narrow tote is not so comfy.

So, for myself, I prefer a narrow throat and wide comfy, cushion-for-the-pushin' style,.............. down below.

This is Stanley, Spiers and mine for comparison.

I start will full 6/4 stock.




Areeeeeeee you gonna take me home tonight?

Fat bottom girls you make you rockin world go round!

yours Scott

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#2

Re: Tote Carving Plus

Bob Hackett

Looks like I`m not the only guy with big mitts and likes something wide to hang on to.What kind wood you got dair,Mon?

My favorite tote is a wide teak one I made for one of my transitionals.

Thanks for the post and pics,Scott.

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#3

scott grandstaff

Re: Tote Carving Plus

scott grandstaff

Why thankee Bob

That particular tote is padouk.

I love padouk.

It starts out practically garish bright orange, but settles down to really deep rich burgundy in time.

Which is what it looks like today. Edging toward burgundy/black. Delicious rich color.

yours Scott

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#4

Useful ideas, thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I may be printing this post out to save for any future tote-making projects - although, so far, I've been happy with the totes that came on the planes.

One comment, Scott. You said, "The human hand on a plane handle wants to curl the index and second finger rather tightly."

I've got fairly large hands - no idea of glove size, I just know I have to get the XL gloves when I buy them at the hardware store - and I find that, on jack and similar (say, No. 4) planes, I have to grip the tote with the thumb and second through little fingers, and extend the first finger up and around the cuttin' iron. I tend, out of habit, to use the same grip on all plane totes of that plane size or larger. For smaller planes, like my No. 10-1/2 bench rabbet*, which lacks the room between tote and frog for my bony fingers, I often cup the tote in an open hand, extending fingers and thumb along both sides of the iron - imagine reaching out to grip a vertical pole, like a pole on a subway, and stopping before you close your hand.

*I'd no doubt use the same grip as described in this sentence if I had a No. 3, 2, or 1 plane, but have yet to find a No. 1 or 2, or a No. 3 that was worth buying, in the wild. Like most bottom feeders, I remain ever optimistic that the next sale around the corner will have a 50 cent No. 1 in pristine condition.

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#5

Re: Tote Carving Plus - the real truth

ThomD

I have been giving some thought to this subject from the perspective of the archer. In archery, one of the main technical contributions to quality shooting is learning to hold the bow in such a way as to minimize torque on the handle. Obviously there is a strong push required with the bow hand, and when the string is loosed the hand is free to push on forward. If torque is not minimized then the bow will track away from the target, among other problems.

The key is aligning the hand lightly rotated inward, so the pressure somewhat follows the life line but to the thumb side, but not on the thumb itself. One can find the low torque position by taking the fingers of the non-bow (strong) hand, and pulling back in the bow (weak) hand along the palm with the tips of the strong hand. When the finger pull is aligned the hand does not twist. Here are some pictures of some guy:

http://s566.photobucket.com/albums/ss102/jmad/

One of the problems with bows as sold is that the correct grip section on a bow is often not the one that companies are able to sell. What feels most comfortable is something hand filling thin at top and fat at the bottom, but it creates terrible torque. Note a competition grip, vs. an OEM grip on a wooden recurve:

http://www.lancasterarchery.com/images/3990024.gif

http://www.shrewdarchery.com/product_image.php?imageid=26

http://ns1.bowsite.org/blackwidow/images/bwbows/PA-Bowphoto.jpg

I think the same issues apply to planes except, possibly, where power is the main issue. But jointing by "eye" or, very fine smoothing, where rotating the bow is disadvantageous, narrow and squared grips seem like a better idea. Granted they may not be all that comfortable, but then they aren't 70 pounds like some bows, and might not be required on planes designed for heavy roughing.

I was recently looking at some 6000 dollar planes, and thought remarkably little thought seemed to have been put into the grips. Right down to quaint little knobs I would probably reject for my bathroom cabinets.

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#7

Wheat carving?  Someone mention wheat carving? 

Marv

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#8

Re: Useful ideas, thanks

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I too buy xl gloves and opt for the index finger on the iron grip. A few years back I picked up a #2 sized sarggent VBM with a corugated sole. I thought I would use it kind of like a block plane. It is an idea the sounds good but in practice but it just dosen't seem to pan out. I have almost sold it a couple of times and I am sure I will eventually.

Robin

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#9

adding few more thoughts to a great post

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It may be common knowledge but it bears repeating. when driling a hole like in a tote it is more acurate to start at each end and meet in the middle. This may sound counter intuitive but it actualy works.

I would also add that comercial plane totes are ambidexterous. if you are making a custom tote you know which hand you will be holding it with so why not make it as such. I am right handed and I find that I like the left side of the tote to be a bit flater and the right side a bit fuller. I also file a little groove for my middle finger and another on the base for the tip of my little finger. when you pick it up with your left hand it does not feel comfortable, but when you grab it with your right hand it fits like a glove.

Robin

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#10

Re: Tote Carving Plus

Tom MacGregor

I've sold off my Stanleys, including my Holy Exalted Bedrocks, in favor of early Lincoln series Vaughan & Bushnell planes in part because of their tall walnut totes that fit my short wide hands better. But I must admit, the most comfortable tote I own is one I made myself out of Bolivian rosewood on a Keen Kutter K5. Drilled the long hole first with a chopped down bell hanger's bit in a salvaged & restored 1944 Delta 17" drill press. Used slow, light pressure and brought the bit up to clear the chips very often. Being able to drill the hole in one shot seemed like a plus to me.

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#11

I have to agree.

Bob Hackett

I start with a very short and rigid drill bit for accuracy and then drill as deep as I can with that bit so it acts as a guide for the longer one I use to finish drilling through.I then use an end mill as a counterbore.I now do this in a bench model milling machine but have done it in a drill press(old iron) in the past.

BTW-If Stanley totes are not tall enough for you you can always make the counterbore deeper and the tote taller.If you absolutely have to have that little brass button flush with the top of the tote then drill the through hole slightly oversize,cut the tie rod in two and use a piece of tubing to extend it.Either tap the inside of the tube and thread the rod ends or just use thin wall tube and either silver solder or braze the 2 pieces into the tube.

Re: Tote Carving Plus

#13

Couple more tricks...

John in NM

Great post Scott!

I counterbore first, using a brad point bit made from an old drill bit. No need for expensive counterbore bits. I needed longer threaded rods last time I made a tote, so I tapped the casting for 1/4-20 with a bottoming tap. I've no idea what the original rod is, but its just a little under 1/4 and it is 20 TPI. Purists won't like this approach :D, but I found it worth the effort to be able to use 1/4-20 all thread and make the rod whatever length I need.