Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

More Addis questions

Posts

More Addis questions

#1

Steven Antonucci

More Addis questions

Steven Antonucci

For you old tool experts:

If you saw my post from the other day, I scored some carving tools last weekend. Robin Correll helped me greatly, and I was looking for a few more pointers?

1.) They seem to be marked J.S. Addis and "10 Prize medals 51 to 89" Does that help date them at all?

2.) The smaller gouges have been ground to a fingernail edge vs. flat across, much like I would grind a spindle gouge for turning. Is this historical, or did the prior owner do this in error? They cut as is, and I don'e want to regrind them unless there is some compelling reason to "correct" the "error"?

Thanks

steve

Re: More Addis questions

#2

scott grandstaff

Re: More Addis questions

scott grandstaff

I am not sure about dating,........ someone else's department. :)

But grinding I know.

Tool cutting profiles are all about scope of work and preference.

Some like a gouge straight across and some like a fingernail profile and some like them ground backwards, with the edge shortest in the middle and projecting points in the corners.

I'd suggest you try what you have for a whole and see if you like it.

If not, it ain't that big a deal to reshape.

The tools you found look to be mostly high detail, 3d, carving small object type tools,

if that helps you at all.

yours Scott

Re: More Addis questions

#3

Re: More Addis questions

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

there are three addis markes J B Addis which stands for James Bacon Addis and he never registered a trade mark. S J Addis which stands for Samuel James adddis and this is the brother of James. prior to Samuels death his tools were marked with an adress and no trade mark. after his death tools marked with S J Addis and a compass and square trademark were made by Ward and Payne. Much rarer are tools make by the two brothers father and these include are usually marked S sens addis.

I am guessing you ment to type S J rather than J S. The olny thing that you can be poitive about is that your tools were made after the early 1880's. Not sure when Ward and Payne stoped making tools.

I do not care for the type of grind you have described. I prfer a neutral grind or one with the edges forward of the middle. The reaon for my prefrense is that I find a fngernail grind can cause rear out on large deep gouges or in wood having rowey grain.

I mentioned how addis numbered their gouges in an earlier post. the numbers on their carving tools are catalog numbers and do not describe the sweep. some of your tools are used up spoon gouges. This is not a bad thing. As you have discovered they are still desirable and useful. As the spoon partion gets used up the tool becomes a different type of tooland they are typicaly used for scraping and cleaning up rather then making cuts. in this use a fingernail grind is the prefered profile. I have a friend who prefers small ball type handles on his scrapers, more like what you see on detail carving sets made by millers falls or general.

Re: More Addis questions

#4

Re: More Addis questions

Don McConnell

Hi Steve,

Your gouges were made by the J. B. Addis & Sons company some time after 1889. James Bacon Addis was making carving tools as early as 1851, in London, where he continued in business until about 1862/3. But, despite earning exhibition medals in 1851 and 1862, he seems to have struggled, financially, declaring bankruptcy in 1855 and 1863.

In 1864, David Ward, of Ward & Payne, brought him to Sheffield to introduce a new approach to forging carving tools there (based, I suspect, on the London Pattern), but the forgers' union denied him membership and the effort never got started. Ward proceeded to hire Addis, anyway, a year or two later, but that arrangement lasted only three or four months due to continued union opposition. Whereupon Ward set Addis up in business for himself, apparently on a very small scale. The entire operation consisting of J. B. Addis and a teenage helper. This all occurred by 1867 when testimony in hearings detailed all of these events, and more. In any event, this whole chapter seems to have ended with Addis declaring bankruptcy, again, in 1868, at which time he was living at 16 Rockingham Street, Sheffield.

By 1870, he was making carving tools again, in Arctic Works, and picked up another prize medal in an exhibition that year. An 1872 advertisement states that all the tools made by the J. B. Addis company were marked: "J. B. Addis, Prize Medals 1851, 1862, 1870 & 1871." The name of the firm changed to J. B. Addis & Sons by about 1873, and it appears that the firm continued adding dates to the mark as it earned additional prizes. For example, I have a back-bent gouge marked "J. B. Addis & Sons, Prize Medals 51, 62, 70, 71, 76 & 78." Based on these dates and information in the next paragraph, it would seem my gouge was likely made some time between 1878 and 1882.

An 1882 advertisement indicates a shift in strategy regarding the mark. It states that tools made by the firm are all marked "J. B. Addis & Sons, 9 Prize Medals, 1851 and 1862." Based on the marks on your gouges, it appears that the mark changed, again, with another medal, to read "10 Prize Medals, 51 to 89." I've also seen them simply marked "10 Prize Medals," or without this wording at all, and assume they're somewhat later.

The firm doesn't seem to have consistently marked their tools according to the London Pattern/Sheffield List system, but when they included numbers, other than those associated with the Prize Medals, they are consistent with that system.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: More Addis questions

#5

Ellis Walentine

Nice bit of history, Don

Ellis Walentine

I'm curious as to how the steel or the forging or tempering may have changed/evolved over that time span -- whether earlier tools were better, or different in some other way, than later versions.

Ellis

Re: More Addis questions

#6

Steven Antonucci

Greatly appreciate, Don.

Steven Antonucci

I will keep this provenance in mind in my future use.

Steve