Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

i think I did pretty good on this one?

Posts

i think I did pretty good on this one?

#1

Steven Antonucci

i think I did pretty good on this one?

Steven Antonucci

I was walking through the vendor area this weekend at Totally Turning when I spied a pile of tools. In sorting through the pile, I knew I'd be buying something, and I tripped across this roll of Addis and Sons carving tools.


Average tool cost was $9/per. They are marked Sheffield. A little bit grimey, so I'll be cleaning them up and getting them ready for use. What would you use to clean the handles (which I think are mahogany?) and the roll itself? I was thinking Murphy on the woods and dish soap and a hose on the roll, air dried if it ever stops raining in NJ.

Steve

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#2

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Why would you buy so many ice picks? Sorry but without a proper pic showing otherwise I'll have to say I think you paid too much for a roll full of ice pics.

I am particularly fond of both JB abd SJ Addis tools and $9 each is a good price for an Addis tool without a handle. I have used orange cleaner with a synthetic scrubbie on really grungy wood . I do not like finish on my tool handles and instead prefer a bit of bees wax. This aids in a good grip and prevents blisters.

Robin

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#3

Steven Antonucci

out of the roll

Steven Antonucci


A nice mix of ice picks and chippers...

grungy as all getout though. Going to take some work to get them cleaned up and properly sharpened. Knew that when I bough them, so no surprises. Largest one on left is about 1/2" wide, but I usually carve very small scale work, so I'm good.

S

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#4

Pretty good suckage, there, Steve

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Will we be seeing carving on turning coming out of your shop soon, then?

Robin's suggestion for cleaning the tools is a good one; mineral spirits and fine steel wool for any rusty spots is another alternative. I use SOS pads and warm water for my tools, but this is probably not the best approach, especially in winter.

For the tool roll, it's time for hand-washing, I think: warm* water and either laundry detergent or dish detergent; agitate the roll with your hands; repeat as needed until it's clean (if it's really filthy, you will probably need to change the water/detergent at least once). Then two or so rinses in warm water, again agitating, wring gently out, and find somewhere for it to drip dry. If you're lucky enough to have your house or water heater in a corner of your basement or in a closet, a line close enough to pick up some of the radiated heat without getting so close as to be a hazard is good.

If you want to ship the tool roll out here, we're getting some warm, sunny days, and I'd be happy to wash and air-dry it for you; but you'd best ship the tools along with it, so I can be sure the tool roll maintains its shape.

*"Warm" using the classic parent's test for baby formula: put a little on your wrist, and, if it feels too warm, cool it down.

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#5

Some pretty cool specialty tools there

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#6

Steven Antonucci

I was pretty sure that was the case...

Steven Antonucci

I do carve a few times a year, and I have been slowly integrating it into my turning, so you are right on track with your assessment. I have a couple of mismatched gouges and I thought this looked like a nice, complete set. There are a couple of bent spoon bits, some under cut skews, and a few other oddballs that I have to go over when I get a night with a couple of hours free.

They will complete my collection for now, unless I see another bargain. My wife jerked back in horrow at $185, but then told me she saw some 6 piece sets for $150 around Christmas, and conceded that I "saved her money!"

S

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#7

Spousal reactions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I continue to believe that the best defense against spousal reactions of horror at money spent on woodworking is encouraging said spouse to get involved in almost any other craft*. There is then a kind of conspiracy between you to accept each other's expenditures.

*There may be some crafts that don't have a lot of associated tools and stuff, but darned few.

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#8

Steven Antonucci

She scrapbooks, and owns a Cricket

Steven Antonucci

which takes a bunch of supplies to keep it fed. I'm still bouncing around the idea of a collaborative with her, the Cricket and some sandblasting or something... (the Cricket will cut a resist material...)

S

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#9

Not, I take it, this type of cricket

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

because I don't think they need much at all - just the occasional lettuce leaf, and your basic bamboo cage.


img

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#11

I think you did pretty well!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Nice score, and of course a big YOU SUCK too. :D

I think in the articles section you'll find a paper on cleaning wood planes. Might be worth a look at it for the handles.

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#12

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

Jay Samuels

Steve: For the handles - 1/3 boiled linseed oil, 1/3 paint thinner, 1/3 white vinegar, shake it up well in an old dishwashing liquid squeeze bottle, use 000 steel wool to apply it and wipe down the handles. Jay

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#13

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

Jorge Casta�eda

Steve,

Good find, I did find something more eclectic, but a lot dirtier several years ago, the roll was helpless, beyond cleaning, The metal was easier than the wood, but finally had good luck using a citrus product, like a cream and rub a dub dub, and wipe until it stop feeling disgusting, you know disgusting is the built in alert to bio hazards, when they were all clean after a day or so of drying, some light sanding and then walnut oil, that was it, nice feel in the hands.

I sharpen with diamond files and slip hones and hone with a leather wheel (strop) in a drill press with a little green compound abrasive, this works in turning tools too if the grinding is not too coarse.

Have fun

Jorge

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#14

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

Charles Jackson III

I think you did a nice job.

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#15

Re: out of the roll

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Nice set. The one with the darker handle is older than the rest, the shape of the handle is how you can tell. If yo are not familiar with Addis tools you are in for a treat. I prefer high carbon tools for their ease of sharpening. The really nice part is that as they get a bit dull but are still sharp a quick wipe across a leather strop and they become razor sharp. That is a trick I have never been able to do with a pefiel or two cherries chisel.

The number on an addis gouge represents the number of blade segments it takes to make a full circle. this means that a #5 sweep in 3/8 and a #5 in 1/2 are two different radii, but 5 repitions of the edge will make a full circle for both gouges.

Everyone has their prefrence for edge tools and mine is for Addis carving tools and E A Berg bench chisels.

Robin

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#16

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one? *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Steven,

I read above that you also live in "sunny" NJ - have you ever thought about joining the CJWA, the Central Jersey Woodworkers Association? Check out the link below for info on this great club.

John

P.S. - great find on the Addis chisels...


http://www.cjwa.org/

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#17

Steven Antonucci

About how old are they?

Steven Antonucci

I bought them as "users", but I also want to be somewhat sensitive to their "historical" value. I sharpened about half of them last night, and they do cut very nicely!

The darker one is not dirtier, but appears to be some kind of rosewood. I didn't pick that up right away. I also recounted them and there were 17, not 20- which bumps the price up to $10 ea.

Steve

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#18

Steven Antonucci

Wilbur keeps bugging me to join too.

Steven Antonucci

I've spoken to a bunch of CJWA folks, and I'd love to join, but you guys meet on Saturday's right? 4 kids, and full weekends have always been the deal killer. I wouldn't want to be a passive member (showing my face once a year...)

Someday. Thanks for the invite.

Steve

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#19

Re: About how old are they?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Tools marked S J ADDDIS without a trademark were made by Samual Addis, brother of J B Addis. These tools are easy to date as they will have an address. the gravel lane tools were made before 1860. I can't remember his other address as I don't have any of those tools. He stayed there until he died in the 1870's. tools marked with S J ADDIS and a compass and square trademark were made by Ward and Payne after 1880 something. J B ADDIS tools are harder to date. You can date them by the addition of "10" prize medals" being present or not but I cant remember when that was added. J B ADDIS tools were made until the mid 1960's

I have always attribited the J B ADDIS chisels with the same handles as those made by S J ADDIS/ with an address as being older. the difference is the older chisels have a tapered handle with a slight eligant ogee type curve and the newer ones have a straight taper.

This last bit about the handles is my observation and may not be accurate.

Robin

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#20

Re: Wilbur keeps bugging me to join too.

John Aniano in Central NJ

Steve,

We meet at the Old Brick Reformed Church meeting room (behind the church) in Marlboro, NJ on the second WEDNESDAY night of the month, not on Saturdays!

See, now there is no reason not to join the club. We are a great bunch of folks, even including Wilbur...

John

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#21

Ellis Walentine

Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

Ellis Walentine

Nice haul. Did you get it from this trustworthy looking vendor?


Re: i think I did pretty good on this one?

#22

Steven Antonucci

that's him ;-)

Steven Antonucci