Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

A2 or O1?

Posts

Re: A2 or O1?

#26

Re: This begs the question...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bob,

You're right. Hitachi white steel is very like W1. Does anyone offer W1 any more? With what carbon content? I still have a couple of LN blades of W1. I think LN can still scuffle up a W1 blade or two from their stockpile, if they're asked nicely.

AISI 1095 is the same thing, but with less carbon content than white steel #1 or #2.

Wiley

Re: A2 or O1?

#27

Tormeks are about 1000 grit, right?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A2 or O1?

#28

Re: How do you hollow grind with water stones?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

When I say "water stone," I mean something much more than an old grindstone or Wiley's Tormek.

Pam

Re: A2 or O1?

#29

Re: Tormeks are about 1000 grit, right?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Pam,

The Tormek aluminum oxide (standard wheel) and silicon carbide wheels are 200g, dressable to 1000g. There is a new japanese wheel, also aluminum oxide I believe, which is rated at 4000g. These wheels are water flooded and slow speed.

Again, I was talking about hollow-grinding _prior to_ using water stones (including ceramic stones) for honing.

The only way I know to use a Japanese type water stone for hollow grinding is to use the edge--the arris--of a coarse stone, run the bevel of the iron right on the arris, and wear a hollow place in the middle of the bevel. This is actually a pretty effective way to get rid of convexity, in situations where the blade has become a bit rounded over. I picked that suggestion up from So Yamashita.

Wiley

Re: A2 or O1?

#30

Jim in Burlington Ont.

PBS Special

Jim in Burlington On

The PBS Samurai sword documentary will explain alot. Top of the line japanese tools are still made this same way.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/samurai/sword.html

Re: A2 or O1?

#31

Re: A2 or O1?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm looking at a low angle smoother from LV. You have a choice between an A2 blade or an O1. I use a lot of curly hardwoods so what are the conventional words of wisdom about either form of steel?

Hi Thomas

I think that you will be happier with A2. It holds an edge longer than O1, and this is an advantage on more abrasive woods.

With current BU smoothers with their 12 degree bed one is restricted to use a honing guide to create high angle secondary microbevels. Since the cutting edge is a microbevel, there is effectively no moire effort in honing A2 over O1.

You may be interested in my article on cambering BU blades, here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html

More on the various issues in comments below.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A2 or O1?

#32

Re: A2 or O1?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm still wondering why there aren't more bevel-up smoothers on the market with a 20-degree bed. I guess that's another debate...

Hi Frank

An exceedingly important question!

There is no reason why a BU plane must have a bed of 12 degrees. That is, I believe, a throwback to the original Stanley LA planes (#62 and #164).

A higher bed of, say, 20 degrees would make a difference for three reasons:

Firstly, a lower bevel angle could be created (towards the included angle) and this would be "sharper" than a higher angle (that is, it would have greater penetration).

Secondly, it would be possible to lower the bevel angle into the range where freehand sharpening is practical. At present the high bevel angles used (commonly 50 degrees on top of a 12 degree bed) demand the use of a honing guide to create a replicatable micro secondary bevel. Of course, this is not an issue if your preference is a honing guide.

I did build a BU smoother with a 25 degree bed. I can use a 35 degree hollow ground blade (= 60 degree cutting angle) and freehand this and include a camber. It is easy to create and easy to maintain. I love this plane.

The third argument for a higher bed is that the "wear bevel" is going to be less intrusive. To be frank, I have not experienced any problems with a wear bevel on my 12 degree beds. That a wear bevel exists is not something that I am attempting to disprove - just that it is not the big issue that some make it out to be.

Will we see BU smoothers coming onto the market with higher beds .... ?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A2 or O1?

#33

Strategies for sharpening A2

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bob

Sharpening A2 is no biggie. I do it all the time - most of my plane blades are A2. I use Shapton waterstones (ceramic stones). I don't think that they cut that much faster than my old Kings. The issue is less about the type of sharpening media and more about the strategy used when sharpening and re-sharpening.

I would not want to sharpen full bevel faces, regardless of the steel type, and especially less so with harder, more abrasion-resistant steel. Only work with microbevels - either when you hollow grind a bevel face or when you add a secondary bevel.

I have D2 and HSS in the shop as well, and this, too, responds well when the working area is kept as small as possible.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A2 or O1?

#34

Re: This begs the question...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

...of what the tool-steel edges of Japanese tools are?

Hi Ellis

There is another factor to consider when comparing O1, A2 verses Japanese tool steel. This is the hardness factor of the latter. The Japanese blades are, as you are well aware, made of a layer of hard steel for cutting and a softer, backing steel or cast iron that provides support. The support of the softer steel actually allows for the harder steel to be so (i.e. it limits chipping from an otherwise brittle edge), and it is this harder steel (typically around the 65 mark) that resists wear - not some magical steel property (as in O1 vs A2 vs HSS, etc)

My favourite chisels are Japanese as they take and hold an incredible edge. I also have a couple of Japanese plane blade (in Western planes) and these are also just amazing.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A2 or O1?

#35

Re: trivial

bugbear

Grinding is done with a wheel (not a flat stone), and hollow grinding simply involves a method of presenting the blade to the wheel.

Indeed, with a wheel, flat grinding involves rather more technique than hollow grinding.

BugBear

Re: A2 or O1?

#36

Why higher angles dull faster...

James Watriss

It's simple geometry. With one leg of the angle lying horizontal, draw a 30 degree angle on a piece of paper using 3 or 4 inch lines. Now draw a 60 degree angle, again with one leg on the horizontal.

Using these as simple visualization tools for what's going on at a more microscopic level. Draw a mark about half an inch back from the vertex of each angle, and make a vertical line upwards. This is the edge being blunted. The higher angle on the 60 degree bevel dictates that the blunted edge will have more surface area once it's been worn back the same amount as the 30 degree angle.

You're right, it can be a PITA to keep these higher angle blades sharpened, but it's possible. A2 holds up longer, particularly longer than HC steel in this application. So, it's worth it to use A2 for this kind of work. It's also worth it to hollow grind, to make touching up a lot faster.

Re: A2 or O1?

#37

Re: This begs the question...

Phil Joines

Most of the machine shop suppliers sell it, MSC, Enco, etc. I use it all the time.

Re: A2 or O1?

#38

Re: A2 or O1?

Rob Lee

Well Rob -

That's a crock.

Brian is an excellent grinder - but he makes neither the steel, nor does the heat treatment...it ain't rocket science - no matter how much people want to imply otherwise.

IBC was a good sub-contractor for us - no doubt - but the blades in our planes were finished here - no matter who did the grinding.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: A2 or O1?

#39

Re: trivial

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Paul, but I knew that. What I was getting at is that water stones, and particularly Japanese natural water stones, available in the US today are not available in large round forms suitable for grinding. Then Wiley pointed out a way to create a hollow using flat stones and blew my proposition altogether.

And, what's more, smaller water stones are available for grinding (although I doubt they are of the natural variety), and I can safely say that I was wrong, wrong, wrong.

Pam

Re: A2 or O1?

#40

Re: trivial

bugbear

Thanks, Paul, but I knew that. What I was getting at is that water stones, and particularly Japanese natural water stones, available in the US today are not available in large round forms suitable for grinding.

Pam - your posts have become increasingly terse, and often your meaning is not explicit. Please take the time to say what you mean in full.

BugBear

Re: A2 or O1?

#41

OK. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A2 or O1?

#42

Presonally I like A2...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I see no real difference in sharpening A2 compares to others. On Christopher Schwarz blog on woodworking mag he recently said he likes O1 for smoothing planes and A2 for all other applications. I can't remember why off the top of my head.

Re: A2 or O1?

#43

Re: A2 or O1? The real world

thomd

In theory you might get a sharper edge on the O1, but I don't really believe it. It is true that not everything they put in HSS steel (A2 in this example) is an asset to ultimate sharpening, but it is also true there are some awesome HSS out there, and in any case the differences are slight. Slight differences show up in tests (when they are actually meaningful), but are not a major issue in real world use.

In this case you are talking about a smoothing plane. Edge wear is a significant factor with a smoothing plane used heavily. Edge wear is also a significant factor in recreational uses that involve playing with tools and figuring out which one is the best performer. Kinda hot rodding. There are other patterns of use, like practical projects in something mild like pine or cherry vs maple, these do not put a premium on ultimate edge wear.

For me there are three deciding factors between A2 and O1, one is how easy a plane is to sharpen, what kind of other tools I own, what kinds of wood I am working.

- With a plane where the blade is easily removed and taken through a sharpening cycle, I like easy to sharpen blades like O1. That would also apply to something like molding planes where I don't want to be using a slip stone on some nasty inside curve on A2. In that case it is an easy in and out, freehand job, and I likely will be using it on cherry, walnut, pine, or poplar. But if I have a plane with a lot of nasty steps to get the blade in and out, and if I sharpened using all kinds of time consuming jigs, I would prefer something that minimized my number of resharpening.

- I don't sharpen all blades the same. I use certain combinations of technique and gear that have proved most effective with certain steels. The more a steel is incredibly abrasion resistant, the more likely I am to use stuff like dry grinding, micro bevels, jigs, and super stones (diamondish). Since those techniques are not appropriate to many tools, using super steels means I have to have more stuff deployed in a cluttered shop (or bought for those who haven't been collecting sharpening gear for 30 years). O1 plays extremely well with Cast Steel in antiques, and Japanese tools etc... So it is far more friendly that way.

- With every durability level in cutter there is some materials threshold where it all of a sudden becomes necessary. I would really prefer not to turn steel with high carbon tools. Luckily machine tool bits are pretty easy to sharpen (or throw away), so HSS fits in well. But there is a level where all of a sudden carbide is necessary. Same thing with woods. If I worked only hard maple, and I use it a lot. I would probably gravitate to HSS steels, but I top out at maple for the most part, and generally do furniture in cherry and walnut. I don't find the resharpening I have to do in those materials excessive with O1, so it isn't a problem.

Re: A2 or O1?

#44

Re: NDOS LV waterstone grinder for sale

ThomD

New dusty old stock grinder that has been sitting in my shop for years. Never used, except possibly once or twice. Very nice LV slow speed water grinder. has simple reduction belts, and pulley. Very solid. I just never have been able to find a place for it in the shop. Also I don't generally hollow grind Japanese tools.

Re: A2 or O1?

#45

Re: This begs the question...

ThomD

"Hand hammering of steel over a fire is going to result in some degree of carbon loss typically, so starting with a bit extra may be a good thing. Perhaps the smiths can elaborate."

The "best" technique is to forge thick, and grind thing. Japanese blades certainly show evidence of lots of post forging grinding, generally, so they could employ that strategy in making them. Another version of that strategy is in the old advice about how the harshness of some Jap. blades decreased with sharpening, essentially leaving the grind thin part to users in the cheaper tools, etc...

Bob,

When I was going through the read-everything phase on toolmaking, I remember coming across a discussion of what the O and W designations where meant for, and how they applied to making knives. Lost in time. But I do remember thinking at the time, "that explains why the Jap. smiths can get away with water hardening".

It was either something like the designation relates to uses that involve thin sections, or something to do with the fact the blades are laminated, therefore the actual part is not all O1-ish or all W1-ish. But it led me to believe it would be possible to try it with O1. I haven't so far got around to it.

I did once cause a blade to split from side to about 1' in when quenching it in pre-heated to 140F oil, which ought to be just righ up it's alley. You never know what will be possible until you really work it.

Re: A2 or O1?

#46

My book-learning (never the whole story!)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"...how the Japanese smiths can get away with water hardening..."

Bob and Thom,

Bob was saying that quenching O1 in water is risky compared to quenching it in oil, which is how I understand it also. Brine is the fastest quench; water the next fastest; then oil.

The cleanest high carbon steels, like W1 and Japanese white steel, require a water quench--a fast quench--in order to through-harden to martensite before softer crystals like pearlite and bainite begin to form. The fast quench causes more deformation and stress in the steel, than a slower quench like oil. The need to use a fast quench and deal with deformation and the possibility of fracturing may be the reason behind the wisdom of 'forge thick and grind thin', especially when discussing low-alloy steel.

Alloying elements, like chromium, tungsten, vanadium, etc., will slow or suppress the formation of pearlite and bainite, and permit the use of an oil quench and still get full hardening to martensite through and through. O1 and Japanese blue steel have enough alloy in them to permit the use of oil as a quench. There is an advantage in using the slower oil quench, because it imparts less stress (and less chance of a quench crack) to the steel being hardened.

So one reason alloy steel is more forgiving to work with, is because the quench is easier. A second reason the alloying is more forgiving to work with occurs when heating the steel to the austenite phase during hot forging (prior to quenching). The alloying suppresses grain growth as the steel is heated. The cleaner the steel, the greater the need to maintain a tight control on the forging temperature to prevent grain growth. Some of the reasons why white steel is more difficult to forge well than blue steel.

For those interested, a good reference on all this stuff is John Verhoeven, "Steel Metallurgy for the Non-Metallurgist", if you can find it at a reasonable price. The material can also be found online for free, if you can bear to read dense material off a computer screen.

Wiley

Re: A2 or O1?

#47

Re: My book-learning (never the whole story!)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My library has a copy of Steel Metallurgy for the Non-Metallurgist.

Also, Yataiki quenched his steel in water, but not cold water, it was at the lowest lukewarm and got hotter as more stuff was quenched.

Pam