Re: A2 or O1? The real world
thomd
In theory you might get a sharper edge on the O1, but I don't really believe it. It is true that not everything they put in HSS steel (A2 in this example) is an asset to ultimate sharpening, but it is also true there are some awesome HSS out there, and in any case the differences are slight. Slight differences show up in tests (when they are actually meaningful), but are not a major issue in real world use.
In this case you are talking about a smoothing plane. Edge wear is a significant factor with a smoothing plane used heavily. Edge wear is also a significant factor in recreational uses that involve playing with tools and figuring out which one is the best performer. Kinda hot rodding. There are other patterns of use, like practical projects in something mild like pine or cherry vs maple, these do not put a premium on ultimate edge wear.
For me there are three deciding factors between A2 and O1, one is how easy a plane is to sharpen, what kind of other tools I own, what kinds of wood I am working.
- With a plane where the blade is easily removed and taken through a sharpening cycle, I like easy to sharpen blades like O1. That would also apply to something like molding planes where I don't want to be using a slip stone on some nasty inside curve on A2. In that case it is an easy in and out, freehand job, and I likely will be using it on cherry, walnut, pine, or poplar. But if I have a plane with a lot of nasty steps to get the blade in and out, and if I sharpened using all kinds of time consuming jigs, I would prefer something that minimized my number of resharpening.
- I don't sharpen all blades the same. I use certain combinations of technique and gear that have proved most effective with certain steels. The more a steel is incredibly abrasion resistant, the more likely I am to use stuff like dry grinding, micro bevels, jigs, and super stones (diamondish). Since those techniques are not appropriate to many tools, using super steels means I have to have more stuff deployed in a cluttered shop (or bought for those who haven't been collecting sharpening gear for 30 years). O1 plays extremely well with Cast Steel in antiques, and Japanese tools etc... So it is far more friendly that way.
- With every durability level in cutter there is some materials threshold where it all of a sudden becomes necessary. I would really prefer not to turn steel with high carbon tools. Luckily machine tool bits are pretty easy to sharpen (or throw away), so HSS fits in well. But there is a level where all of a sudden carbide is necessary. Same thing with woods. If I worked only hard maple, and I use it a lot. I would probably gravitate to HSS steels, but I top out at maple for the most part, and generally do furniture in cherry and walnut. I don't find the resharpening I have to do in those materials excessive with O1, so it isn't a problem.