Re: This begs the question...
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Ellis,
As Pam said, the specialty steel used by Japanese smiths is mostly going to be from Hitachi's Yasugi Specialty Steel (YSS) works, or from the Swedish firm, Uddeholm Bohler. Uddeholm was the original Swedish firm, and was bought by the Austrian firm Bohler. Interestingly, the closest thing that the Japanese smiths can now find which approximates the fabled 'tamahagane', is Bohler 990, according to a knowledgeable source.
When we talk about Japanese steel, though, we are mostly talking about Hitachi's blue, white, and yellow steel, so named because of the color paper they come wrapped in.
Here is a link to the composition of these steels, courtesy of the Paragon Code website:
http://www.paragoncode.com/temp/YSS_HCC_spec.pdf
For comparison, here is the composition of some familiar western steels (I believe these formulas will vary a little according to manufacturer):
http://www.sousacorp.com/ts-comp.htm
In general, the Japanese steels will have a higher carbon content than the western steels. For example, the 'A' ranges of White steel #1 and blue steel #1, each have 1.3 to 1.4% carbon, compared to 0.9 to 1.0% carbon in O1 and A2, respectively. White steel has virtually no alloy, whereas blue steel is a small amount of chromium, and 1.5 to 2 percent tungsten. Super blue adds some molybdenum and vanadium to regular blue steel. You can see from the chart that #2 and #3 white and blue steel have progressively less carbon.
There can be a lengthy discussion of how much carbon can actually be used to form carbides in forged steel, so the percentage differences have to be interpreted in light of how the steel is worked. Hand hammering of steel over a fire is going to result in some degree of carbon loss typically, so starting with a bit extra may be a good thing. Perhaps the smiths can elaborate.
But in any event, the differences in constituents are shown in the
tables linked above. Note that O1, despite being characterized as 'high carbon steel' does have some alloying. It has a little chromium equivalent to blue steel, and a little tungsten (W) as well. O1 is more alloyed than Japanese white steel, but less than blue steel.
Wiley