Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

A2 or O1?

Posts

A2 or O1?

#1

A2 or O1?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I'm looking at a low angle smoother from LV. You have a choice between an A2 blade or an O1. I use a lot of curly hardwoods so what are the conventional words of wisdom about either form of steel?

Thanks

Tom

Re: A2 or O1?

#2

Re: A2 or O1?

Frank D. in Montreal

Conventional wisdom, last time I checked, is that A2 holds up better at higher bevel angles, O1 better at lower angles. Since You'll be using very high bevel angles on the LA smoother (45 degrees or more), I'd go with A2. At "normal" angles (30 degrees) I have no real preference when planing, although I do find that A2 burns less when power grinding and it resists rust a little more than O1.

I'm still wondering why there aren't more bevel-up smoothers on the market with a 20-degree bed. I guess that's another debate...

Re: A2 or O1?

#3

Bed angles

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I suspect you're seeing low bed angles only on the low-angle planes because the current conventional wisdom is that the lower angles permit more range of effective cutting angle, since you can always increase the bevel angle on an iron, but run into fragility problems decreasing it much below 25 degrees.

Re: A2 or O1?

#4

Re: Bed angles

Frank D. in Montreal

True,

But very high bevel angles are a PITA for a few reasons. Working figured tropicals you need really high planing angles, 60 degrees or more. That means you're sharpening your blade with a 50 degree angle...not the easiest thing to do without the the blade trying to flip over on the edge. Another problem is edge retention at such high angles (45 or more, IME). I find that a blade loses it's sharpness noticeably more quickly when the angle is so high (don't know what Brent would have to say about this). So just to leave open the possibility of planing at 35 or 40 degrees (I've needed this on teak, but only once), I'm stuck with a less-than-optimal bed angle for almost all the woods I plane. I'd actually go for a 25-degree bed and a 30-degree blade for almost everything. I've held out on all the LA smoothers for this reason. I guess I'll just have to break out that Shepherd improved miter plane kit...

Re: A2 or O1?

#5

Re: Bed angles

Ron Hock

"conventional wisdom is that the lower angles permit more range of effective cutting angle, since you can always increase the bevel angle on an iron"

You can easily accomplish the same effect on a bevel-down plane with a simple back-bevel on the blade. You can't go below the bed angle (45 degrees for Bailey-types) but you can add to the angle of attack quite easily. Good job for a honing guide. The only down side is that you have to remove the back bevel to return to the bed angle but that's not different from the bevel-up configuration. I know bevel-down users that keep extra irons with specific back bevels on hand for specific tasks, as do the bevel-up users with different bevel angles.

Re: A2 or O1?

#6

Re: A2 or O1?

Bob Hackett

The answer really depends on what you have for refining the edge,how proficient you are at it and whether you consider sharpening a bother or a nice Zen type break from the work.

If you have everything under the sun,know how to use it and consider sharpening one of your least favorite tasks then the A2 is what you want.

On the other hand if you have just what you need to maintain your chisels and other O1 type tools and don`t mind stopping and refreshing an edge once in a while then go with the O1.

With the proper equipment and skills both irons will get equally as sharp.The A2 will take longer to get there but hold the edge longer because it is more resistant to abrasion which is what makes it harder to sharpen(I use diamond paste).

The O1 will sharpen up more quickly(than A2) on either oil or water stones and when it does become dull it can be touched up quickly using the same stones.

For those who don`t know it the A in A2 stands for air quenching steel,second cousin to the high speed steel used in turning tools.

The O in O1 stands for oil quenched steel,more like an old bench chisel steel.

MB

Re: A2 or O1?

#7

Sharpening A2

Frank D. in Montreal

Hi Bob,

I've tried a lot of mediums and I love my water stones, but I mosty use oil stones now (Norton India and a translucent Arkansas) along with a strop and compound (Flexcut), and I have no trouble at all sharpening my A2 blades (most of my blades are A2). Just my experience, but I don't think people should avoid A2 because they don't have diamond plates or paste.

Re: A2 or O1?

#8

Re: A2 or O1?

Rob Cosman

I have been working with Brian Rabinovitch for the past year, he owns IBC, the company that made those blades for Veritas. When asked the question, he would never choose O-1 over Cryo treated A-2. If A-2 can be sharpened in under a minute and holds an edge at least twice as long, what advantage is gained by saving 10 seconds in the sharpening of a blade that does not hold an edge as long? In talking to Brian at length about this I am left feeling there is a lot of misinformation floating around. From someone who has made the blades for the most award winning planes (the reason they won) O-1 blades do not offer any advantages to the hand plane woodworker.

cheers

Rob Cosman

Re: A2 or O1?

#9

scott grandstaff

Re: A2 or O1?

scott grandstaff

I was resistant to A2. Couldn't see the need for it.

We had truly great steel already, and who loves change??

But I got some anyway, and have used it a few years now alongside my regular O-1.

Hey its great steel!!

Its not a lot different, O-1 is hard to top. But its just as good.

Happy to report, to me, A2 is not that much harder to sharpen and doesn't last that much longer. But its very good steel!

Takes a nice edge and holds up.

Kind of a moosh-a-do (much ado) as far as a "great debate" goes.

I like 'em both. I definitely wouldn't pay more for one over the other.

The difference, to me, being only slight.

But I do like them both in a plane blade very much.

Make mine

...either!

I never had an air hardening chisel so can't say how they are in a "pounding with wild abandon" situation.

But decent crowbars and pinch bars are air hardening and they do well enough.

yours Scott

Re: A2 or O1?

#10

Re: Sharpening A2

Bob Hackett

I didn`t mean to say you couldn`t sharpen A2 on the stones you already had,hope it didn`t read like that.

What I was trying to convey was that it will take longer and,especially on water stones,wear the stones more than O1.Meaning that you`ll have to flatten them a bit more often.

Those using Scary Sharp and SC abrasives will be alright too.

I use diamond paste for A2 and all the HSS edges(including CPM alloys) I hone because it just goes faster for me that way.With the diamond paste HSS will hone to as keen an edge as O1 in just about the same time as honing O1 on stones.

Hope that was a little more clear.

MB

Re: A2 or O1?

#11

I misread your post

Frank D. in Montreal

Sorry 'bout that Bob.

But your second post was interesting, so I guess it was all worth it...

Re: A2 or O1?

#12

Re: A2 or O1?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Don't know about conventional wisdom, there really doesn't seem to be any on this topic; so why not get both blades and find out which you like better and why? That way, you'll be better able to make the next choice.

Pam, who never buys A2 because she doesn't see a need to introduce additional variables into her mostly natural water stone sharpening process

Re: A2 or O1?

#13

Besides, Pam, if you use a natural stone,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

it might not produce a mirror edge :D (sorry, Wilbur, couldn't resist)

Re: A2 or O1?

#14

Re: A2 or O1?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Confess....you're getting a kickback from Rob Lee aren't you? ;-)

Re: A2 or O1?

#15

 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A2 or O1?

#16

No, from Cosmo's friend Brian.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

But I'd buy both for at least one tool if I were interested in which one worked better for me. OTOH, if I were to set out to try another steel type, I think I'd be more interested in Tindall's C4PM (or 4CPM or ?).

Pam

Re: A2 or O1?

#17

Ellis Walentine

This begs the question...

Ellis Walentine

...of what the tool-steel edges of Japanese tools are?

Ellis

Re: A2 or O1?

#18

Re: A2 or O1?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Tom,

Two guys who have actually done side-by-side testing of O1 and A2 blades (and other steels) in planing applications are Brent Beach and Steve Elliott. Both found that A2 will plane more feet than O1 for the same amount of dulling--but the differences are not dramatic. Steve tested a range of blades for initial sharpness, and found that they all get the same degree of sharp, to within the ability of his test to differentiate. Here are links to the two sites:

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/summary_of_results.html

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bladetest.html

Brent's and Steve's results are consistent with my anecdotal experience also, with LN A2, Hock O1, C&W O1, and Japanese white and blue steel. This is with respect to both initial sharpness and edge durability in planing. They all get the same sharp, and the durability differences are not dramatic. But in fact, I don't worry about durability at all, because I like to sharpen and tend to sharpen before it's really needed.

Therefore, I would suggest to consider the decision first of all on how you sharpen. If you hollow grind, you won't notice a difference in how quickly A2 and O1 come to their final edge--they're both real fast when you're just sharpening the tip. I know this to be true of water stones, diamond paste, and abrasive paper, and Frank says it is so of oil stones. A2 is more forgiving of heat, so you can grind a little faster.

If you don't hollow grind, you will likely notice that O1 sharpens a little faster, especially if you use oil stones.

But the differences in real life are subtle, sorta like the difference between blue steel (a tungsten steel) and white steel (clean, high carbon) in the Japanese world. The differences between the steels per se are less than the differences between who is doing the forging and heat treating.

I'd say, overall, that if you hollow grind, get the A2 just to see how it works out for you. Think of it like blue steel in the Japanese world (didn't you get a set of Tasai blue steel chisels?). There won't be a sharpening issue, and the guys that have done testing say the A2 lasts a little longer for the same initial sharpness. If you don't hollow grind, and use oil stones, then you may want to go with O1 just to keep your usual working methods intact.

Congratulations on the new plane!

Wiley

Re: A2 or O1?

#19

Re: This begs the question...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

So far as I know, Hitachi and Swedish (Tsunesaburo) steels, which are high carbon and close to O1, except they typically quench in water. But I'm no blacksmith, so someone else, please chime in.

Pam

Re: A2 or O1?

#20

How do you hollow grind with water stones?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A2 or O1?

#21

Stephen Shepherd

Re: How do you hollow grind with water stones?

Stephen Shepherd

I drip water onto the grindstone as I crank the wheel with one hand and sharpen the tool with the other.

Stephen

Re: A2 or O1?

#22

Re: How do you hollow grind with water stones?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Pam,

Should've explained: I was talking about hollow grinding ahead of honing on the stones, using high speed wheel grinder, Tormek, hand cranked grinder, belt sander, whatever.

Those who hollow grind, will grind right to a primary burr or very close to it, and from there will find that either A2 or O1 will hone to a final edge very quickly, like in seconds.

Wiley

Re: A2 or O1?

#23

Re: This begs the question...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ellis,

As Pam said, the specialty steel used by Japanese smiths is mostly going to be from Hitachi's Yasugi Specialty Steel (YSS) works, or from the Swedish firm, Uddeholm Bohler. Uddeholm was the original Swedish firm, and was bought by the Austrian firm Bohler. Interestingly, the closest thing that the Japanese smiths can now find which approximates the fabled 'tamahagane', is Bohler 990, according to a knowledgeable source.

When we talk about Japanese steel, though, we are mostly talking about Hitachi's blue, white, and yellow steel, so named because of the color paper they come wrapped in.

Here is a link to the composition of these steels, courtesy of the Paragon Code website:

http://www.paragoncode.com/temp/YSS_HCC_spec.pdf

For comparison, here is the composition of some familiar western steels (I believe these formulas will vary a little according to manufacturer):

http://www.sousacorp.com/ts-comp.htm

In general, the Japanese steels will have a higher carbon content than the western steels. For example, the 'A' ranges of White steel #1 and blue steel #1, each have 1.3 to 1.4% carbon, compared to 0.9 to 1.0% carbon in O1 and A2, respectively. White steel has virtually no alloy, whereas blue steel is a small amount of chromium, and 1.5 to 2 percent tungsten. Super blue adds some molybdenum and vanadium to regular blue steel. You can see from the chart that #2 and #3 white and blue steel have progressively less carbon.

There can be a lengthy discussion of how much carbon can actually be used to form carbides in forged steel, so the percentage differences have to be interpreted in light of how the steel is worked. Hand hammering of steel over a fire is going to result in some degree of carbon loss typically, so starting with a bit extra may be a good thing. Perhaps the smiths can elaborate.

But in any event, the differences in constituents are shown in the

tables linked above. Note that O1, despite being characterized as 'high carbon steel' does have some alloying. It has a little chromium equivalent to blue steel, and a little tungsten (W) as well. O1 is more alloyed than Japanese white steel, but less than blue steel.

Wiley

Re: A2 or O1?

#24

Re: This begs the question...

Bob Hackett

If they are quenched in water or brine then they would most likely be W1.

You can quench an W type steel in oil but if you try to quench a O type in water it will most likely fail.

MB

Re: A2 or O1?

#25

Re: This begs the question...

Bob Hackett

Can`t get the edit function to work so...

What I wanted the previous post to say was " most like W1" not "most likely be W1".

Sorry for any confusion.Today is just not my day.

MB