Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

Posts

Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#1

Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

wilbur

Last time I posted about my workbench build, I was getting ready to make 8 mortises to receive the double tenons at the top of my workbench legs. I got the last of my 8 mortises finished yesterday, and have been working on the fitting. These mortises are all 1" wide, about 2" deep, and will be how the legs are secured to the benchtop. That exercise gave me a lot of practice trying various methods of making a mortise.

By the way, I never did buy that router I had been considering.

There were three main methods that I used:

1. Chopping with a 1" wide mortise chisel, like I did with the mortises for the leg stretchers. This is the most satisfying for me, because afterwards I can go around saying, "Yup -- I used a 1" wide mortise chisel to cut a 1" wide mortise 2" deep and 5" long." The problem is, the usual response to that is, "What are you -- nucking futz?" ;)

The other problem that I had was that the Douglas fir seems to have become much harder in the time it took me to get around to this step. It seemed to go much more slowly than when I made the leg mortises for the stretchers.

2. Chopping a narrower mortise along each side of the 1" wide mortise with a 1/4" mortise chisel, and then wasting out the middle. Also satisfying, but not as satisfying as using a 1" mortise chisel. It was surprisingly easy to clear out the waste with a regular chisel.

3. Drilling out most of the waste with a brace and bit, and paring/chopping the remaining waste. This was the least satisfying of the options, but it was the fastest. I used a squared up scrap piece of wood as a guide when paring/chopping to help me make sure the sides of the mortise were square.

Regardless of which method I used, I learned the importance of clearing out the chips when making a mortise. Even the drill and pare method slowed down quite a bit when I let the mortise fill up with shavings from drillng and paring. To help me clear out the chips, I used that time honored hand tool -- the shop vac. ;)

In any case, from here on out, making the more normal sized 1/4" wide mortise and tenon joints used in furniture are going to be a piece of cake in comparison.

This picture of the tenons on the top of one of the workbench legs being inserted into the mortises in the workbench top should illustrate what I'm up against with fitting the mortises to the tenons. Multiply this by four to get the full effect.


Because my base is already assembled, I have to fit all 8 mortise and tenon joints simultaneously. Basically, the way I've been going about it is to drop the base into the mortises, marking out the parts of the 8 mortises where it looks like the fit is too tight, and then paring out the mortise at those spots. I started out by trying to adjust the tenons, but fitting the base, marking the tight spots, moving the base out, and rolling the base on its side so I could get at the tenons got old quick.

It's going faster now that I've learned that I can be a bit more aggressive with adjusting the tenons and mortises. On this scale, I don't think that I'll need 0.005" precision, especially since the joints are going to be drawbored, and I expect gravity to be on my side in keeping the top stable when the workbench is finally done. Besides, I know what the fit was like in the leg mortises for the stretchers, and since I had to redo the two stretcher joints thanks to my screw up, I got a real good look as to how much good glue contact you can have with what might look like a sloppy M/T joint, but is actually much tighter than you might think.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operatio

Jack Guzman from Maine

Wilbur,you deserve a lot of credit for attaching your top in that manner.I built a bench with a built-in leg vise. The joint behind the vise was treated as yours to give the vise stability,but the other three legs just dropped into shallow mortises,because that was all that was needed to keep things from moving around. I don't think I'd want to try to get eight mortises to fit all at once. There's just so much room for error and I'm just not that good.

I've been following your progress and enjoy your posts.Good luck with final fit-up.---Jack

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#3

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operatio

David Churnega

About to do the same with a mortice chisel. Not suprisingly, I found the old ones picked up from flea markets work just as well as the new ones. Started doing narrow mortices this way and found it simple, fast and accurate.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#4

Ellis Walentine

Nice shot, Wilbur

Ellis Walentine

I might have missed it in your earlier bench installments, but are you not concerned with wood movement? How far down is the first cross rail? How much expansion/contraction is there likely to be?

Ellis

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#5

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operatio

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"To help me clear out the chips, I used that time honored hand tool -- the shop vac." Historical practice, of course, called for an apprentice with a really big straw :D .

Looking good, Wilbur. Your generous sharing of your experience has been a great addition to the conversation here.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Historically they removed the chips with...

Stephen Shepherd

a blowpipe or hand bellows.

Wilbur,

The task will make you look like Hercules. The wood rings on your legs are a fair match for the rings on the top, except there at the edge. Shouldn't be a problem. I think gravity and your pins will hold it on, see no reason for glue, unless it is hide glue.

Stephen

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#7

Re: Nice shot, Wilbur

wilbur

I'm not really sure how much expansion/contraction there will be. The way I laminated the top, it's essentially a 22" wide piece of quartersawn wood. The grain in the leg laminations are all aligned like you see in this picture, and I did the same things with the stretchers. The legs are mortised into the top, and there are a set of stretchers 5" off the ground.

I do know that in the traditional Roubo design, which this bench is based on, the top was one big thick plank that was likely not completely dry when put into service as a workbench top. As the top dried, the shrinkage in the top would tend to splay the legs outward, resulting in a more stable leg configuration over time.

You can get a sense for how the base and the top look together in this picture:


Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#8

I'm wondering how you're going to

Bruce, a MN Galoot

turn that thing over. :D Man, that is beefy.

That will be one wonderful, steady, stable, massive bench.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#9

Re: I'm wondering how you're going to

wilbur

My carefully thought out strategy for turning this thing over is to go and beg my neighbors for help. ;)

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#10

Easier than getting a forklift in *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

you'll want to talk through sequence before lifting - that beast could do serious orthopedic damage to someone. And hold the beer as a post-job reward, not a pre-job incentive.

Off topic, do I see two old drill presses there in the background? Are you secretly an Old Woodworking Machines guy too? That (below) is just as seductive a forum as this one, in my opinion.


http://www.owwm.org/viewforum.php?f=1

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#11

Re: Nice shot, Wilbur

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Wilbur,

Really beautiful result to justify all that you have put into this beast of a bench.

Just one thought from here....My experience in making big joins like this is that there is no trial fit. Cause how're you gonna back it out? At some point--and you're about there--you get a warm furry feeling that if you can put enough grunt into it, it'll go. Plus you get some lubrication from the glue if you're set up to act fast.

So looking ahead to the moment when you get the glue into those eight mortises, and lift the leg assembly onto it.........I see two possibilities--hit the feet with a big hammer, like 4 lb, or use clamps at each of the four leg points. Or both. If you use the Pony clamps, you can put enough force onto the joint that it will go unless there's something in the bottom of the hole.

How do you figure on driving the legs home? Or is it already a done deal :) ?

Wiley

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#12

Re: Nice shot, Wilbur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Ah, you effete Southern Californians. Up here, we don't consider a hammer big until it passes 8 pounds ;) .

On a more serious note, Wilbur, if you're planning to encourage the fit with a hammer, have some chunks of wood to put on the legs. Better to destroy a couple of chunks of 2x6 than to start splits in the legs.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#13

One man operation

Bob Hackett

As a way for one man to flip that I`d just use 4 of the beam clamps I have to make 4 anchor points in the overhead(you could rig up some home made anchors or rent some too) and then attach 2 of my heavy duty ratcheting tie downs to those anchors after looping them under the bench top to both hoist it up and cradle it.Once you have the bench up and clear of the supports it`s pretty easy to clamp a longer length of lumber to the legs to allow you to spin the completed bench in a controlled manner and then lower it with the ratchets to a working position.

We used to spin hulls,keels and tankage for yachts like this only we used cable hoists and steel for levers with 3 or more men doing the spinning.

MB

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#14

Re: Easier than getting a forklift in

wilbur

I do have some OWWM. The drill presses are a Walker-Turner 15" drill press, and a Delta Homecraft 12" drill press. I also have a Walker-Turner 16" bandsaw, and a Conover lathe, which some people consider to be OWWM. The Conover lathe certainly is OWWM in character, if not in absolute years.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#15

Re: One man operation

wilbur

Boy, that sounds like a piece of cake -- if I had the faith that beam clamps attached to the joists overhead would hold, and if I had the room between the floor joists to place anchors (there is a lot of plumbing and light fixtures sandwiched up between the floor joists), and if I had some ratcheting tie downs. ;)

Seriously, that is a great suggestion. My shop just isn't really conducive to hanging things from the joists overhead. If could see my shop ceiling, you'd understand.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#16

Ta Da!!!!!!!!

wilbur

I can't believe how prescient Wiley is.

The legs are now connected to the top!



After several cycles of adjusting the tenons and/or mortises, test fitting the legs to the top, working the legs out of the top (the hardest part), and adjusting again, I had gotten the legs so that they were fitting to a point that when the leg tenons were inserted into the mortises, the shoulders of the leg tenons were about 3/8" from meeting up with the benchtop. But it seemed that I just needed to to the slightest bit of trimming to get it to fit. But I decided to go with brute force instead. ;)

See the clamps in the pictures? Those are 36" Wetzlers. I placed the clamps across the bottom of the legs and the benchtop, and I used them to force the legs home. The net result is that at least some of those 8 M/T joints are an extremely tight friction fit -- so tight that I decided to let gravity and friction to keep these joints in place. No glue, no drawboring like I had planned. This assembly is not coming apart any time soon. If by chance it does, I'll drawbore and glue the joints then.

Whew!

Next step: making the groove in the bottom of the benchtop for the deadman, and then I can turn this bench over. After begging my neighbors for help, that is. ;)

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#17

Way to go, Wilbur, and for an encore...

Kevin Adams

we want to see an action shot of you and your team of Clydesdales getting that bad boy upright!

It looks great and you are finally there...great job!

Kevin

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#18

Love them Conovers!

Bob Hackett

Old Ernie really did well by updating that design.Despite it`s few quirks my highly modified Conover and I get along just fine.

The rest of my shop consists of mostly restored old iron,my father`s Delta bandsaw,Walker Turner,Oliver,etc to include an old Shopsmith 10 ER that used to belong to my Dad.

MB

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#19

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Ta Da!!!!!!!!

Stephen Shepherd

Nice work wilbur, but did you notice the bench is upside down?

You might consider putting a groove for the deadman in a thin piece of wood and screwing it on the underside front of your bench between the legs.

Stephen

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#20

I thought

Dan Donaldson

When you referred to "conover" that you were talking about "con"ning your neighbors into coming "over" to help get the bench upright ;)

(ducking and running)

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#21

Re: Ta Da!!!!!!!!

wilbur

The plan that I'm working from says that the groove for the deadman should be about 1" deep, which will allow it to be removed if needed. The one thing I can think of is that if I build up the groove with wood, I'll have a 1" lip on the underside of the bench right up front, which might interfere with clamping at some point.

Building up the groove would certainly be the easier thing to do, but I think we've established that I'm well past the point of looking for the easy way to do things as far as this workbench is concerned. ;)

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#22

Re: One man operation

Marv

Wilbur,

I have raised heavy equipment from floor level onto a stand, milling machine for example. And have lowered the same machine from the stand down to the floor.

I used a large pry bar and lots of blocking. To lower something like your bench, you first raise it a little so you can remove the saw horses. This is done with two cross beams. The cross beams are held up with a stack of short 2 x 4,s and 4 x 4,s creating four legs. Then lift one end of the bench and remove one of the 2 x or 4 x,s. Do the same at the other end, then the other end and back and forth until you have the bench down close to the floor. At this point it's just a matter of tipping it over on it's side, then lifting it up onto it's legs. You might need to use blocking again to do the tipping up. It's going to be sturdy enough to withstand some short drops if it's too heavy for you to lift and lower it gently.

However, it's much easier and faster if you have enough people to help you, but it can be done all by yourself. In my case, with heavy machinery, more people usually doesn't help when the machine has to be placed in a spot that doesn't allow forklifts and such.

Question....will you be champfering the edges at the bottom end of the legs to prevent splintering?

Nother question......why the gigantic legs? Is the purpose for all the massive construction so you end up with a heavy bench? A wood lathe is often made heavy to make it stay put by having a sand box inside the legs to keep the machine from moving around.

Marv

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#23

Re: Ta Da!!!!!!!!

Kevin Adams

And just think, if plowing the groove doesn't go quite as planned, you can always remove the top and turn it around...what would be easier than that?!!

Btw, I agree that the groove is the way to go for the clamping reason you cited...and you could always fill it in and start over if it doesn't go as planned.

When do you make the holes for the holdfasts and dogs?

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#24

Bench size

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"why the gigantic legs? Is the purpose for all the massive construction so you end up with a heavy bench?"

If I recall correctly, it's Wilbur who was running a 2x4 to the nearest wall to keep his existing bench still while he planed - I think we may have some over-compensation going on here.

Re: Herculean mortise/tenon joint fitting operation

#25

Re: Love them Conovers!

ThomD

Me too until the cast iron on the rest blew out. In fact my rest was not really a nice piece from the beginning, I guess I should have sent it back. MY Conover was from post Ernie days though.