Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

Posts

Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#1

Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

charlie belden

OK - after some learning curve climbing I've got the first of what may become a library of SketchUp models of joints used in several of the chinese furniture pieces I inherited. While this first model is of a chair, the same Leg-Aprons-Frame & Panel joinery is also used in a sideboard as well as coffee tables and end tables.


And here's a screenshot of the SU model


If you go to the attached page you can download the SU model and play with it.

If you have questions about any of this feel free to ask away - here - or e-mail me

charlieb@accesscom.com.

If there's interest for more models of chinese joinery I'll see about making them. If YOU have a SketchUp model of a chinese joint or two and would like them available on the web, e-mail them to me and I'll add them to my site - with your name as contributor.


Triple Mitered Leg & Apron PLUS

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#2

Chris Scholz

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

Chris Scholz

Charlie,

Sure, I'll contribute one.




Very basic Ming-Table

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#3

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1

charlie belden

Chris:

Thanks for contributing your model. Your's is an older, more complex, version of the one used in the more modern pieces I have. Looks like you're farther up the learning curve than I am ; ).

I've added your contribution to the page posted earlier. Hope that's OK with you. If not, let me know and I'll take it down.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#4

Chris Scholz

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1

Chris Scholz

Yes, your furniture looks like fairly recent vintage; nevertheless, amazing pieces compared to similarly priced Western furniture.

Yes, I have a vested and rather selfish interest in Chinese woodworking and occasionally post an article or two in this and other forums.

Just yesterday I was sitting in a used bookstore in San Diego's Hillcrest District looking at Chippendale's "Gentleman and Cabinet Maker's Director" (as well as some books on Zheng He, but that's a different topic entirely). Amazing and is some way amusing what we believed to be "Chinese" in the 18th century.

Chinese woodworking was fully developed in the 15th century when Chinese craftsmen achieved a level of sophistication that the West was never able to match. Much of the improvements that Japanese woodworking experienced during Edo period was based Chinese technology (at least that's how I understand Kiyosi Seike's comments). These facts are rather unpopular today and quite hard to swallow for us Westerners.

Chris

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#5

Chris Scholz

Charlie, do you plan to BUILD any of these pieces?

Chris Scholz

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#6

uncomfortable facts

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Hell, I'm just trying to figure out how to lay it out, not to mention build it, with anything short of multi-head CNC machine.

Just goes to show what can be accomplished with highly disciplined, specialization of labor.

Amazing!

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#7

Perhaps Starting Another Thread on Chinese Joinery

charlie belden

Chris:

You obviously have gotten a lot farther into Chinese joinery and Chinese furniture making than I. I found Gustav Ecke's book and could afford to buy a copy. Other books on Chinese furniture are too expensive for my budget. Did find a few web sites that had some joinery illustrations, but they're not easy to find without a lot of slogging through a lot of commercial sites with just photos of finished pieces for sale.

Care to start another thread on Chinese furniture in general or at least the joinery?

Michael Fortune has come up with an interesting approach to triple mitered corners - using L-shaped ply loose tenons.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#8

Re: Charlie, do you plan to BUILD any of these pie *LINK*

charlie belden

Probably not - using traditional Chinese joinery. Since loose tenon mortise and tenon joinery can now be done - even by a novice woodworker (see LEIGHT FMT Jig and Festools' DOMINO) I'd go with them instead. I do have an entertainment center I need to make. May go with some Chinese joinery in it.

Could probably do some more Bonsai display tables - oldest son is into bonsai. I've made some semi-quick and dirty tables out of redwood (see attached link). The triple mitered leg-apron joint could be used - mitered in stretchers could be a little trickier with the legs having beaded corners.


Bonsai Display Tables

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#9

Connoisseurship of Chinese Furniture

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

My interest in Chinese furniture comes from a diferent direction so to speak. I am a huge fan of danish modern furniture and much of it was influnced by chinese furniture. For instance Hans Wegner's iconic circle back chair is his interpretation of a Ming dynasty chair. So for me part of being a fan of the danish modern stuff is understanding what influenced it, hence my interest in chinese furniture

About a year and a half ago I was fortunate in being able to buy a two volume set from a friend who was selling off a book colection of a deceased colleage. They are by Wang Shixiang and are titled "Connoisseurship of Chinese Furniture: Ming and Early Qing Dynasties" one volume is pictures of actual pieces and the other is notes about each piece in the other volume, including some constructuion details. the volume with the notes also has a section on history as well as a section on joinery and ornamentation.

I just did a google search and found out the book is still in print and rather expensive ($195-$225). It would still be a worth while book to look for at your library or at any used book stores. You might get lucky like I did and get a set for $50.

Robin

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#10

Chris Scholz

Re: Connoisseurship of Chinese Furniture

Chris Scholz

One of my favorite books is the Zhungguo Gudian Jiaju Shoucang Jianshang Quanji (something along the lines of Complete Works of Classical Chinese Furniture Collection Appreciation); amazing pieces, beautiful photography. Open a page at random and you see stuff like a little footrest made of Huali (type or gnarly old rosewood), asking price $20k to $30k, sold for $59,750 or a cabinet, asking $120k to $150k, sold for $196,500.

It is one of the mysteries of Western woodworking why in Chinese woodworkers are in general considered inferior or primitive. I believe this is about to change.

Chris

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#11

Re: Charlie, do you plan to BUILD any of these pie

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I like those tables; but their design screams "I have slaves to do my housekeeping."

Pam

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#12

Ellis Walentine

Here's another *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

This is an article we did back in the mid 90s that put Yeung Chan on the map.

Ellis


Yeung Chan chair article

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#13

Ellis Walentine

Hey, that was a pretty good issue

Ellis Walentine

I kept reading and noticed there's also an article about Toshio's toolbox, my interview with James Krenov, a chisel comparison test. What fun to reminisce.

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#14

Chris Scholz

Also noteworthy the article on "Period Pulls"

Chris Scholz

The article on Selecting of Period Pulls is interesting, too. The Queen Ann and many of the Chippendales pulls are nothing else but Chinese Buddhist fu symbols (that in fact can mean bat, but also good fortune). Maybe this photograph shows where the fu symbol comes from .

This bat is at the outside wall of one of the many Buddhist temples along the path towards the top of Hengshan. Hengshan is the South Mountain, one of the five sacred mountains of Chinese Buddhism.

It never cease to amaze me how this symbol completely lots it's original meaning and become to represent an entire period of Western woodworking.

The description of the Chinese Chippendale pulls that suggests the roof of a pagoda shows the great imagination of the author of that article.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#15

Re: Charlie, do you plan to BUILD any of these pie

charlie belden

They're for displaying bonsai - outside - in the sun and the rain and the wind and the hail and the lightning and thunder and snow and sleet. OK, this is California - and we don't get any real weather. We get Sunny, Overcast and, occassionally Rain.

They're out of redwood which after being outside for a year or so gets silver gray. And during the warmer weather the bonsai get watered several times a day. If they need "cleaning" you just hose them off. And, other than the legs, which are just Borg bought 2x2s. the rest came from old redwood fence boards so there's not much money in them.

They're easy to make if you use loose tenon joinery and have a bandsaw and router table. Try 'em. You'll like it.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#16

Great link

charlie belden

Ellis:

Thanks for that link. More joints to make SU models for.

I had a half day class with Yeung when he was just getting into "public life" as a teacher and demonstrator. He was nervous as hell and began in Deer In The Headlights. He had his simple, extremely well thought out tool box and tools and as he opened it and set up the included stands the questions started and he started to relax. As the What Wood and How Did You got going he got into it and things went well.

A friend was in one of his weekend classes and learned that starting with REALLY sharp tools makes a big difference in the outcome from using them. He THOUGHT he knew what sharp meant. Yeung showed him that he in fact didn't.

We've got another very accomplished woodworker in the SF Bay Area - John Berg. Like Yeung, he does incredible joinery and hand cuts them with japanese tools. Might pick his brain for some joints to model. He did a Shephard's Crook for a local cardinal with the spiraled top. Looks like it was carved from a single piece of wood - or steam bent. It's neither, though you have to look VERY closely to see the joint lines.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#17

Re: Charlie, do you plan to BUILD any of these pie

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I didn't know the display was outside. Why is that? Why aren't they in the ground? I'll have to revisit my Japanese garden books.

Pam

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#18

That's a great issue, will read it all. Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#19

Bonsai Not Japanese Garden

charlie belden

Even if it's little - if it's in the ground - it's a tree.

If it's in a small pot or bowl or tray - and it looks like a little tree - or makes you think of a full sized tree - even if it could never BE a tree - it's potentially a bonsai. If it hasn't been in the ground for 200 or more years and is still alive - probably a well cared for - by many generations - bonsai.

Will walk down the street sometime today and take some pictures of these stands as they look today - with bonsai on them.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#20

OT: sharpness

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...starting with REALLY sharp tools makes a big difference..."

People sometimes put a lot of energy into plane tune ups. I'm not yet good at sharpening (somewhere in the vicinity of late apprentice beginner), and I'm coming to the conclusion that sharpness is between 90% and 99% of tool tuneup.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#21

Re: Bonsai Not Japanese Garden

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, I've learned something today: there's a difference between dwarfing and bonsai. Thanks.

Pam

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#22

Re: OT: sharpness

charlie belden

Well, you DO have to get the sole FLAT. And it helps to get the sides flat ans square to the sole. And no amount of tuning will make up for a "mouth" opening that's too big to begin with. And a frog with a high point on the surface the iron sits on can make for probelms. And a chip breaker that doesn't make contact with the iron acrossed its front can make for it not working - and time spent digging chips out from under it. And if the chip break ain't close enough to the cutting edge the plane will likely splinter and tear rather than cut and sever.. And if the frog is set back a bit, or foreward a bit you'll probably get chatter in your cut. And if the screw holding the chip breaker is too lose . . .

Really sharp will make up for not tuning the rest of the plane's "adjustables" and "fixeds" - but not quite to 98 or 99%.

With chisels on the other hand you're probably right - SHARP probably accounts for 98 to 99% of the quality of the cut.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#23

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1

John in IN

I recommend Yeung Chan's book in which he shows how to cut these joints using power tools (if that is your cup of tea). I took his class last year at Marc Adams where we made a plant stand using the miter joints.

http://www.amazon.com/Classic-Joints-Power-Tools-Yeung/dp/1579902790/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1269120338&sr=1-1

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#24

Well, yes, you're right

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I was exaggerating, and I was wrong.

But I do think there is such a thing as "adequate" in plane body flatness and other measures of plane condition; but not for sharpness. For that, nothing but "wow really great" is enough.

Re: Chinese Joinery SketchUp Model 1 *LINK*

#25

scott grandstaff

Re: Hey, that was a pretty good issue

scott grandstaff

A truly spectacular issue Ellis!

I didn't even know it (AW) existed at the time.

What a lineup of suspects!!

A completely loverly interview with Jim (nice one) and there's Dunbar lurking,

and lord help us, look how young Frank was!! heehehehehehe

Such a time capsule.

Obviously chopsaws were new and trendy with every manufacturer hustling a full page spread. Cursed battery drills making a big ad splash too. (people want battery drills to work, its sure is too bad they are still so poorly, even now.)

Fein was new-in-there desperately shopping for victims in the worst way, and sharing ad space with several venerable old firms that are long gone now.

Lots of regular content, then.........

We got a guy pouring and scraping babitt into old precision machines and doing it in a page. 127 words on advanced rocket science! heehehehhe

I can't believe that was only 15 years ago. Seems like forever.

Thanks for the good read.

yours Scott