Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Blades for side escapement planes

Posts

Blades for side escapement planes

#1

Blades for side escapement planes

ThomD

I am making up some blades for some hollows and rounds. One thing I noticed was that the taper in the blades from other side escapement planes is mostly in the full width zone. Many examples seemed to follow a pattern where they would taper from 145 thou to 105 thou in the first few inches and remain fairly stable in thickness for the remainder of the blade. I was expecting a more or less constant taper from the edge to the top of the blade. But I can see why this double grind would be more efficient, allowing the taper to be steepest where it does the most good without the blade becoming paper thin at the top end.

When I also looked at bench planes I found similar grinds, though in some cases the tail end taper was just all over the place like they didn't try to hard at all, and some of this was in the abutments where some care would seem to mater...

Anyone else with some info on this stuff? What about the LN stock.

I am working with O1 which has it's own peculiarities. Also, I have the tools required to make either full length or compound tapers, but the shorter the area I need to control I guess the easier it will be to make.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#2

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't remember any taper that Todd Herrli called for in his video on making side escapement plans. Do you mean taper like this?

Pam

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#3

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Brian Sullivan

I've noticed same thing on the few side escapement planes that I have.

I just measured two new Lie Neilson irons. There is a steeper taper in the first inch and then it looks like a fairly constant taper to the end.

Here are the approximate measurements in thou taken every inch starting at the cutter end taken using a inexpensive digital caliper for the two samples

measure point/sample 1/sample 2

0" 0.124" 0.127"

1" 0.110" 0.115"

2" 0.107" 0.110"

3" 0.96" 0.101"

4" 0.88" 0.99"

5" 0.83" 0.91"

6" 0.76" 0.87"

7" 0.68" 0.70"

8" 0.53" 0.59"

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#4

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I measured three of mine, picking ones of different eras. Nothing looks precision ground and all seem to be a little hollow in the middle. I think that when they welded the steel on, the steeled end was thicker and they trued it by grinding or filing into a taper. It is actually helpful if the middle portion of the length is a little hollow because then when it is wedged pressure will be concentrated near the cutting edge. With precision grinding, making the bed a little hollow would give the same effect.

I have often wondered if they made two irons out of a 10 inch piece of stock by welding steel on each end and then the two tangs would lie side by side and need to be cut apart. Perhaps Todd has some ideas on this.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#5

Ellis Walentine

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Ellis Walentine

Thom, could you e-mail me please? your e-mail address is apparently incorrect, and all your e-mail notices are bouncing back to me. I'd like to correct the problem as soon as possible.

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine, host

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#6

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

ThomD

Ellis I am actually at proaconstrictor @ yahoo . ca. My low tech attempt to keep the spam under control.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#7

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

ThomD

Todd used straight taper/parallel stock. This works fine up to a point, but it does have the effect of making removal/loosening less than "professional grade".

The issue isn't covered in Larry Williams' otherwise masterful tape since the assumption is that one is using LN balnks.

Thanks

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#8

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

ThomD

I noticed the same thing about some precision near the edge, and total randomness elsewhere. A little odd as a strategy. I guess I build parts to fit together, but Larry Williams shows fitting the Wedge to the plane then scribing the wedge to the blade. Not a lot lost, except that the some of my old blades are like an anaconda with a fresh kill in the tummy.

Thanks

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#9

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

ThomD

Very thoughtful of you Brian to go to all that trouble. I will CAD those numbers out and see what they reveal. While you were doing the measurements was there an angle anywhere where the taper visibly changed that might not have been at one of your control points.

Many thanks!

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#10

Proaconstrictor? or Proaconstructor?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#11

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Brian Sullivan

Hi Thom - I left out a zero for all the measurements less than 0.1". Here are the corrected measurements:

measure point/sample 1/sample 2

0" 0.124" 0.127"

1" 0.110" 0.115"

2" 0.107" 0.110"

3" 0.096" 0.101"

4" 0.088" 0.099"

5" 0.083" 0.091"

6" 0.076" 0.087"

7" 0.068" 0.070"

8" 0.053" 0.059"

I graphed the measurements and the results are pretty linear. By eye it is hard to judge if there is a inflection point, as both irons have are bent in a very slight arc along the length (I don't consider this to be a defect). I have been so wondering about how the L-N iron were tapered as I've been planing to make some of my own, but I never got around to measure them. I've been thinking about building some sort of jig that will allow me to taper iron blanks on a sander but I don't have a solution yet. How are you planning to taper your irons?

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#12

just for info

Dan Donaldson

I use my address on the boards and basically never get any spam related to it being here.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#13

Re: just for info

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Me either; but I didn't think to put it as part of my name in the new profile. If I change it now will that muck up all kinds of stuff?

Pam

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#14

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

LN says their molding plane blades are tapered from 1/8" at the edge to 1/16" over the full length.

Pam

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#15

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

What about a tapered blade makes handling it more professional? I always approach this type plane expecting the blade to fall out at the most trivial excuse. Why do untapered (straight? flat?) blades do that? Tapered blades, too, for that matter.

Pam

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#16

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

Brian Sullivan

Tapered irons help you out when wedge is stuck. You knock the iron forward, and this releases the pressure and then you can remove the wedge.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#17

Thanks, Brian, very clever.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#18

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

MattinPA

The irons have a uniform taper.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#19

You should be able to make that change

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

as long as you remember the password you established when you built your new profile.

Bill, who's lucky if he can remember his own name from day to day, much less which password goes with which account

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#21

a late reply

Larry Williams

Thom,

Sorry for being so slow responding. I've been trying to get my feet back on the ground and everything caught up after a couple weeks on the road.

I've been trying to figure out what you're looking for. If it's uniformity in thickness in old molding plane irons, it's something I've never seen. My guess is that the smiths who made those irons were more concerned about the quality of the lamination than precise repeatable thickness.

Lie-Nielsen's irons are uniform and taper over their entire 8" length by 1/16". Lie-Nielsen's process is more efficient than when we make our own irons. Those we make have a pretty uniform 1/16" taper over the first 6" and then flair out again slightly to the tang's tip. This gives a uniform taper over the life of the iron and a slightly heavier end where it's adjusted with a hammer. The drawback to the way we machine irons is that it's expensive because it generates a lot of waste. Right at 3/4 of the weight of raw steel we get for molding planes goes out as waste. Getting that waste off is pretty labor intensive.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#22

Re: You should be able to make that change

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, I know I can make the change; but what I don't know are the ramifications of such a change.

Pam

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#23

Re: a late reply

Bob Hackett

I am curious why you couldn`t just make the "stem" of the iron a little longer and then fold it over toward the back to form a sort of sneck if you`re looking for a more substantial striking surface?

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#24

Re: a late reply

Larry Williams

I don't see what would be gained. To make a 180� fold we'd have to add forging to the process and then we'd have to dress it down so the end of the tang would fit through the mouth of the plane. Machining the double taper is easy once you understand the process and, if anything, it reduces the amount of steel removed as waste.

Re: Blades for side escapement planes

#25

Re: a late reply

wilbur

"If it's uniformity in thickness in old molding plane irons, it's something I've never seen. My guess is that the smiths who made those irons were more concerned about the quality of the lamination than precise repeatable thickness."

Hi Larry,

If I understand this right, if I bought a set of H&R's back in the 18th century, from plane to plane there was variation between blades, but each individual blade would have had a smooth taper in the area where the wedge makes contact with the blade, smooth enough so that the wedge used with it would allow for fine adjustments with a plane hammer, and that the back part of the blade where you would tap it might not have the same taper as the part that makes contact with the wedge? That would make sense, because there really is no reason for those blades to be uniform to that degree, since each plane blade would essentially be custom fit to its body and wedge.