Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Blasphemy

Posts

Re: Blasphemy

#26

Re: Not dumb

wilbur

As Wiley said, the design of this bench calls for the legs to be mortised directly into the top. Actually, back in the day, Roubo had the leg tenons go all the way through the top. There aren't any stretchers across the top, so this is what provides support along the top side of the base.

As far as doubling, that might not be completely necessary, but I wanted to see if I could do it. I do plan to pin the top to the legs, once this thing is done.

Re: Blasphemy

#27

Re: Blasphemy

wilbur

Much harder than walnut. As I said, I chopped out a mortise in hard maple a few weeks back, and that was easier than chopping a mortise in the underside of my benchtop.

Re: Blasphemy

#28

Re: Blasphemy

wilbur

To clarify as far as the router goes, I was planning to use it to waste out the majority of the mortise, then clean up with chisels. I guess I could do the same thing with a drill and Forstner bit, although I haven't had good luck with overlapping the Forstner drill holes too much with a drill.

Re: Blasphemy

#29

Dremel Tool

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Just kidding. This is an 18th century design, made to be done efficiently with the tools of the day. When you see drawings of jpiners in the 18th century they have a short handled mallet with a large head. Some pictures show them with the mallet over their head. They hold the chisel by the handle. Wilbur, how heavy is your mallet?

Re: Blasphemy

#30

Am I missing something here ?

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

why not use a smaller mortice chisel, say 1/2" or 3/8", to waste out the bulk of the material � this should give you about twice the penetration per blow compared to the 1"

Then clean up with the 1"

Alternatively use a hand brace and 3/8" forstner to waste out most of the material, then clean up with the 1"

Re: Blasphemy

#31

scott grandstaff

Re: Blasphemy

scott grandstaff

I live in the heart of fir country.

Its mostly red fir (local name) for dozens to hundreds of miles in any direction from where I am typing.

It mostly grows in kind of a narrow strip, 1-200 miles wide, from the Pacific coastal mountains to the central valley.

It starts around Red Bluff Ca, and goes into Canada.

The next valley over, past the central valley, has it too. Some places all the way to the Rocky mountains.

Its a little different over there though.

The particular valley I live in was once known for massive super long beams of it. Before gluelams, if you were building a gymnasium or cathederal, you called us for your beams. Much harder and tougher than the hardest redwood, and some trees almost as big.

Logs 10' and more high, laying down, were once common.

One log loads used to be common around town.

Douglas fir should actually have around 32 other names to be accurate.

Some of it is like paper and could almost go into the balsa/basswood rack. Some of it is so hard it needs to go with the cocobola and bocote!

Forget nails, you can't hardly drive a hardened screw into a pilot hole!

Some of it is so twisted in the grain you can't split a 12" long round of it with a 10 pound splitting maul and 2 steel wedges!

Anything that looks similar standing, gets lumped into the same name, but its actually many different sub-species that don't have a name yet.

The recent fast growing species can have 3/4 between the growth rings.

I have some stuff here you simply cannot count the rings on. You and your magnifying glass will get bored and lose count. The super old growth tight perfect straight grain stuff makes a killer instrument top, but you have to shave it twice as thin as northern spruce to get the same acoustic properties, because its so much harder.

My buddy Mike will search out natural bonsai fir and carves his shovel handles from them. And a shovel is about the hardest use you can put wood to. Especially in these mountains where, if you want to dig a hole 3' deep you end up about 5' wide after you pry all the rocks out.

An 8' tall tree, growing on top of a rock, that is a couple hundred years old??

is unbelievably tough wood.

yours Scott

Re: Blasphemy

#32

And part of the problem

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

for wood with growth rings between the two extremes Scott mentions is that the wood is significantly different in hardness between summer and winter growth, so you're continually struggling through a ring that seems to be as dense as granite, but has insufficient support in the softer wood between rings, so it kind of bounces as you try to chisel.

It can be great wood - vertical grain fir can make ash look positively gauche - but it's not easy to work as furniture wood, or with furniture-ish joints.

But once you're done, Wilbur, you'll have a very, very good bench. I was told once, up in logging country, by the older gentleman at a little one-room museum, that they used to make bridges over ravines, when he was a kid, by felling a convenient Doug fir so it fell over the ravine. They could always be confident that it would remain intact - amazing, when you consider the shock that must have hit the trunk when only the crown was supported as the tree struck ground.

Re: Blasphemy

#33

overlapping holes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You might try drilling holes that don't overlap, with the spaces between being less than the diameter of the bit; then drilling out the remainder, centering your bit on the remaining wood. Part of the difficulty with drilling part of a hole, especially by hand, is that the bit will tend to wander toward the gap, because air puts up little resistance compared to wood. If you have a more or less equal gap each side, you may be able to hold the bit in line more easily.

Even if it doesn't work, if you organize your holes right, the gaps between will be short sections of long grain (as opposed to end grain), which you can remove with the mortise chisel and a certain amount of sweat and/or cursing.

For what this is worth - as you may have already discovered - the sides of the mortises will be easier. Because the density of summer and winter wood is generally very different, side-grain paring is not too hard to do.

Re: Blasphemy

#34

Re: too scary

charlie belden

Plunge routers usually have a depth stop "turret" that let you set three different depths of cut. These depth stops let you make passes at progressively deeper depths.

A half inch shanked up cut spiral bit will let you route mortises to a depth of about 1 1/2"

Re: Blasphemy

#35

Wow, thanks, Scott

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I was astounded to learn a couple or three years ago that plants can mate with most any other plant, therefore, the attempt to label a given tree as one thing or the other is pretty hopeless. This explains so much.

Pam

Re: Blasphemy

#36

All of which is obviated if you use round tenons.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Blasphemy

#37

Re: Blasphemy

ThomD

I've done lots of mortises with a router, but I never use a bit thinner than 1/2" if I can get away with it. I made my first bench that way. I just hate the noise and dust so it has been a while since I deployed the TR12.

I think the best bang for the buck is just drilling out the mortises undersized, and then deploying the chisel, that is how it is done timber framing. A auger in a brace is actually a pretty good method for this, it is reliable to position and works pretty fast. Drilling undersized and chiseling is also basically how it is done with a hollow chisel mortiser. The most fun is a chain mortiser, at least in the sense of something one doesn't see every day. I have 3 mortising machines in the shop, two hollow chisel mortisers and a foot powered sash machine. Mortises by hand get a little tired after a while, I just do them because one has to keep the hand in. But the moment a project requires 32 of them, I use some help.