Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Blasphemy

Posts

Blasphemy

#1

Blasphemy

wilbur

So last night I went to mark and cut the mortises in the underside of the benchtop that will accept the tenons on the top of the legs. As I did before, I sharpened up my trusty 1" mortise chisel that I used to chop the mortises in the legs for the stretchers, drilled a hole for the waste at one end of the mortise, and proceeded to start chopping.

Except.

Anyone who turns up their nose at Douglas fir because it is a softwood can go take a flying leap. Softwood or not, chopping that mortise was like trying to chop through concrete. A little while ago I had, in a moment of temporary insanity in response to a post on another woodworking forum, chopped a 1" wide mortise in some hard maple just to see if it could be done. That was easier to do than what I did last night, by a lot.

I think what happened is that [1] the growth rings on the wood I used for the bench top are much more closely spaced than the wood I used for the legs, and (b) the benchtop has been sitting around for a while since I chopped those leg mortises, and the residual pitch in the wood has set, making it harder. I know that it's almost impossible to drive nails into old 2x4's that make up the frame of an older house, like mine.

I wound up using a drill and Forstner bit to get rid of most of the waste, but I have 7 more of these to go, not to mention the 2"x2" square for the planing stop.

So I found myself late last night reading up on -- routers. :O

Any suggestions? I figure that if I'm going to get some input on routers, I might as well get it from hand tool enthusiasts.

I'll also take suggestions on alternate ways of chopping these mortises. I'm going to try chopping each side of the mortise with a 1/4" wide mortise chisel, and then wasting out the middle.

Re: Blasphemy

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Blasphemy

Stephen Shepherd

Don't you just love Douglas Fir? And the splinters and festering pustules.

A router plane will be of little help for a mortise. he he

I would suggest you go with a smaller chisel for those mortises, much easier to chop, though you do more chopping, the chips will fly. Only use the 1" to clean up when you are done. I have a 1/2" mortise chisel, but I never chop mortises with it but use a 1/4" or 3/8" for the chopping then use the larger chisel to finish off.

Stephen

Re: Blasphemy

#3

Re: Blasphemy

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wilbur, I think a general rule is to bore out the bulk of the waste if the mortise is more than half an inch wide. However, I have often cut mortises like yours in red oak with just a 1" chisel. I have also cut them by making two narrow mortises and chopping out the center like you suggested. I think you ought to try this double row method.

All of these methods work fine, but to be honest, my first reaction was that your mortising technique was not very good. Deep mortises like this really test your technique. I can't see you being discouraged by the amount of work this ought to be.

Re: Blasphemy

#4

Re: Blasphemy& Doug Fir.

Marv

Hi Wilbur,

The west coast IS Douglas Fir. It is considered a softwood species, but boy is that a misnomer. I use it for testing saws that I have set for hardwoods. Most lumber now days is cut from young small trees. The grain is very coarse and very hard when drid.

When starting your mortises, chisel down only 1/4" deep so you can get a good clean accurate edge, then drill out as much as you can using your forstner bits. Good thing about forstner bits, you can overlap the drilling. Drill the corners with about a 5/16" drill first, then use the forstner.

If you decide to buy a router, get one that uses 1/2" shank router bits. They come with an adapter that allows you to also use the 1/4" shank cutters. You will need a heavy-duty router for that kind of blasphemy. :D

Marv

Re: Blasphemy

#5

Re: Blasphemy

wilbur

Hi Warren,

I'll give the double row method a try. But I'm pretty sure my technique is okay. Like I said, about a year ago I knocked out 8 mortises of the same size in the legs of my workbench for the stretchers. It was the same batch of Douglas fir that I've been using for this whole workbench project. Chopping mortises in the benchtop now is considerably harder than it was back then, and is considerably harder than the 1" mortise I chopped in that piece of hard maple I mentioned.

Re: Blasphemy

#6

Router plane -- now THAT'S funny

wilbur

Re: Blasphemy

#7

No such thing as cheating in woodworking

James Watriss

Driving a 1" mortise chisel with anything less than a sledgehammer is something I wouldn't be caught doing. That's just much wider than I care to use, even when called for.

Maple and other woods that are of more even density are pretty easily cut, because the wood underlying the part you're cutting through will be dense and rigid enough to support the part you're cutting... like a good bench would do. But Doug Fir is both hard, and flexible, with alternating porous and dense areas in the growth rings, so it can flex internally and absorb some of the energy of impact, and keep from getting cut. A lower grind angle might help, if you're really going to do this with chisels.

You can try the router thing, but that's a pretty deep mortise to dive into if you're unfamiliar with the tool. Doable, clearly, but you'd also still need to clear out the corners. My main concern would be that the bit would have to be really long, and prone to vibration as a result. (I would want to run the whole thing from one side... you could come through from two directions, but lining it up would be hairy.)

Suggest you drill out whatever you can, steering well clear of your layout lines. (which should be triple checked against the legs.) Use smaller chisels to clear what you can of the rest, and use rasps to wind it all down. Different woods behave in different ways, and this is not the time to be dogmatic about technique. The important thing is to have the finished product come out well... not to survive with the dignity of your technique intact.

You're working with ornery wood on a large scale... winning is the important thing, not how you play the game.

Re: Blasphemy

#8

Re: Blasphemy

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Stick with the forstner bit process. A router will save you no time. By the time you get a router, set it up, make a jig etc. you would be long done with the drill. As you already have, drill the bulk, then square the sides with chisels.

Tom

Re: Blasphemy

#9

Just my approach

Bob Hackett

I have a couple of those Harry homeowner drill presses(I hate to call them that though) where you take a hand drill and use it as the motor.One of them originally came from Sears.

I rescued them from the dump because I had seen where they were useful for hammer drills and rock work(I`ve never seen a hammerdrill press).

Anyway,I use the drill as it was designed to drill the waste and then substitute a wood block and chisel for the paring action.Instant portable hand morticing machine that always pares plumb.

Leverage helps when you have trouble holding a hammer for long periods like I do now.

The base can be bolted to a board and the board clamped to the work.Unclamp,move,reclamp.

The column is simple plumbing pipe so I rob my pipe clamps for variable, almost unlimited height(within reason).

At least my way I only kill electrons for a small part of the process.

MB

Re: Blasphemy

#10

too scary

Bill Tindall

Stuff happens quick with a 1/2" bit at 18,000 rpm.

You probably never thought you would here this from me, the power tool enthusiast, but I would not attempt what you need to do with a router. Spinning a 1/2" bit , extended 1 1/2"?, results in substantial forces on the machine, which is being hand held, more or less. By the time I figured out a way of securing and confining the machine to the target I could have drilled and chopped by hand the 4 mortises you need.

People make successful mortises with a router, so it can be done. But I tend to make fairly deep mortises and the deeper you go the more problem the router becomes- controlling the cut and minimizing vibration of the bit. I broke a 1/4" bit once doing a deep mortise and never found it. I suppose it is embedded in the block wall somewhere. That was the last deep mortise I ever did by router.

I do do most of a shallow mortise for a lock or hinge with a trim router and remove waste from half blinds similarly. I do it free hand almost to the scribe line and clean up with chisel. But in this case there is almost no force on the bit so control is easy and there is no likelihood of bit vibration.

Re: Blasphemy

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Drill

Jack Guzman from Maine

Wilbur I would definitely drill out most of the waste and then clean by paring.In my opinion,a router is almost never the best tool for the job. I think once I stop doing basic carpentry I'm going to get rid of mine.---Jack

Re: Blasphemy

#12

Another vote for the drill

Frank D. in Montreal

Timberframers use drills for their mortises, then pare. Using a 1" chisel on anything but the softest wood takes at least a small sledgehammer to drive the chisel down. I never use mortise chisels over 1/2" wide, no matter how big the mortise.

Re: Blasphemy

#13

Re: Blasphemy

Alexandre Grigoriev

Now you can see what difference dry DF makes... Those rosin-impregnated growth rings must be a beetch...

Re: Blasphemy

#14

Re: Blasphemy

HankKnight

Wilbur,

Douglas fir is classified as a "soft wood" because it is a conifer, not because the wood is soft - go figure. In any event, I sympathize wiith your problem and agree with others who advise drilling out the waste before paring to the lines.

Having said that, I'll fess up to using routers for mortises on occasion. Routers are my least favorite tool - actually, I hate them - but they work well in some applications, one of which is cutting mortises. You can totally screw up your work piece in a heartbeat with one, but the trade off is that they cut well and quickly and they leave very nice, clean mortises. The trick is to figure out how to guide them to control the cut accurately and carefully. If they slip and get away from you, your work piece is toast before you can blink an eye, not to mention whatever personal appendages are unlucky enough to get in the way. You can use an edge guide with end stops or a template and a template guide. I've used both methods and both work fine. The template method is probably the most secure, but it's finiky to set up to size the mortise properly, at least I've found it to be. For mortising you need a plunge router - getting a clean, controlled entry with a fixed base router is difficult. Get one with a 1/2" collet and use a spiral upcut carbide bit. Cut the mortise in multiple passes, taking a progressively deeper cut each time. I would't cut more than 1/4" deep on each pass in your hard fir. If you try to cut the full depth in one pass, your will have difficulty controlling the beast.

Good luck with whatever methid you choose.

Hank

Re: Blasphemy

#15

Re: Blasphemy - I vote for forstner bit...

John Aniano in central NJ

Wilbur,

If I were you, I'd go ahead, use the forstner bit to drill out the waste. I can lend you a corner chisel to finish out the mortises, if you are interested.

When I made the CJWA bench, I also used donated Douglas fir for the trestle base and it was hard. Wound up using the 1/2" mortising attachment on my drill press and it was none too happy about doing this. Popped the chuck off the quill spindle a few times making the overlapping cuts to produce the 1" wide mortises.

I will be making a similar French bench some time this year. I have 4" x 8" cherry for the legs so this is what I'll be having to mortise. Lee Valley came through with a nice 1-1/2" saw-tooth Forstner bit that will remove most of the waste and the aforementioned corner chisel will finish the job.

In may case, I expect the tenons may be a bigger job since they will be of red and white oak and 2 of them will be ~3" x 5" x 8 foot long (I am planning a ~10 foot bench - the 20" wide top is already cut, see the attached picture). I may be able to b^nd#s%w the tenons but hand feeding an 8 foot piece will be a challenge.

John


Re: Blasphemy

#16

scott grandstaff

Re: Blasphemy

scott grandstaff

Soooo, you just discovered the reason I invented the Whup-ass mallet, did you?

hee heheheheheeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

OK, you drill out most of the waste. 1" is a cakewalk compared to 2". Don't complain!

Then you get some support. Meaningful support to work against. Tree stump solid, whatever you use.

Grind your corner and regular chisel edges back several degrees to a steeper angle. Regular paring angles won't last a second!

You better have some beef behind that edge too.

No prissly little "gents" 4" bench chisel for you!

You want an Underhill with a beer mug socket and a big heavy hand carved hooped handle. Or as close as you can get.

You want at least 2 pounds of mallet.

Hold down your work against your support

and flat ass wallop out that wood.

Reach back and git it with a will!

And people pay money for exercise machines. Ha!!

yours Scott




Re: Blasphemy

#17

scott grandstaff

more pix

scott grandstaff

Here you go. This is what you're looking for.

Tools that don't mess around

yours again Scott



Re: Blasphemy

#18

mea culpa, too.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've made bunches of 1/2" mortises, as deep as 1-1/2" with my router. I take it slow, no more than 1/4" at a pass, and use a spiral cutter. Chisel out the corners, and you're good to go. I use both a jig and the edge guide, a la Tage Frid style.

Re: Blasphemy

#19

I've heard Doug Fir like this it called...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Air hardened. I have some DF 2X4's I got from a company I worked at that were from the 60's during a remodel they were doing. This stuff is so tight ringed and old and dry you can't drive a nail into it. Someday it will be part of my bench.

I'll set up with a few others and go with drilling and pairing route. I'd skip the forsner bit and use a auger myself.

Good Luck!

Re: Blasphemy

#20

Dumb question

Dan Donaldson

I have a lot of them ;-)

The question, actually a couple of questions. (these are probably real blasphemy ;))

First, why do the mortises need to be so deep? That top is heavy enough that the only real structural purpose is to keep the top from sliding around. Almost anything would do that. Make them 1/4 deep and cut off the tenons.

Second, why two? Just cut a shallow hole (square) big enough for the two tenons to fit into and cut them off short. Once the top is in place, it would not go anywhere and would be easy to remove to move the bench.

Re: Blasphemy

#21

Re: Blasphemy& Doug Fir.

L. Hanson

Over the years, I've handled ALOT of doug fir. It's like Marv says - the wood of the west coast. West of the Mississippi, you don't see yellow pine at all. Period. It's all Doug fir or Hem-fir (hemlock and/or doug fir) when it comes to structural pine.

Back in the seventies and even early 80's it was not uncommon to run across 2x8's, 10's, and 12's that were 16' long, completely free of knots, contained no major pockets of pitch, and was quartersawn to boot. At the time, I stashed the really good boards aside, i would dearly dearly love to have those today. Special stuff.

A lot of the wood flooring you run across out in the west is Doug fir.

It's a wonderful wood, but is far more akin to a hardwood than what most are used to when they talk about softwood. You can't hammer a nail in it without expecting it to split - at least not the good stuff. The quality of what you get today is usually quite knotty and sappy, but that's what you get from young trees.

Re: Blasphemy

#22

Re: Blasphemy

Craig D

I also built my bench out of doug fir with big tennons (something like 1" x 2 1/2" x 2 1/2", 4x4 legs) and used a router to cut the mortises (because my skill with a chisel isn't). I used a PC 3101 (yes, a laminate trimmer) and two bits: a long 1/4" straight bit and a 1/2" top bearing bit. That got me to about 2 1/4", I cut the rest with chisels. Worked a treat (nice straight clean mortise) but the straight bit hanging ALL the way out of the collet doesn't inspire confidence. At least it was in a hole at all times, nibbling away. Really makes a mess of the shop. What I did was clamp a board on one edge of the mortise and used the pattern bit to cut that edge, repeat on the other side, then the bit is guided by the mortise itself. Once that bottomed out, I switched to the 1/4" bit and used the shank as a guide (just let it ride on the edge of the mortise).

Re: Blasphemy

#23

Not dumb

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Dan,

Those tenon insertions are part of the rigidity of the bench against lateral forces. Notice there are no upper rails, so those tenons and tenon shoulders will be feeling the load during planing.

Why doubling? This is a great question. In other words, why are two 1" thick tenons better than one 3" thick tenon.

Once the tenon gets to a certain thickness, there is no longer an issue as to whether it will be snapped off by the anticipated lateral loads. At that point, making them thicker brings diminishing returns. On the other hand, if you double the tenons, as Wilbur has done, you double the contact area of each tenon, including doubling the glue contact area.

A further question would be whether the double tenons or a single mondo tenon would be better if you pin the joint. Intuitively, it strikes me that the double tenons would still be better, because they give the pin a third area of support (in the middle). Which means that to make the pin fail or loosen, you have to make it give at 4 points of shear rather than just 2.

Or, if the pin is harder than the bench top, then the pin has to wallow itself loose in three 1" spans of bench top, rather than in two 1" spans.

Interested in other opinions on this question....

Wiley

Re: Blasphemy

#24

Re: Blasphemy

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Are you saying that this douglas fir is as hard as hardwood? Or is it somehow more like ironwood? I've never had problems chopping mortises in walnut. Is it harder than that?

Pam

Re: Blasphemy

#25

Re: Not dumb

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Bill, when I was learning power tools at ACC, I learned to take multiple shallow passes with routers. It doesn't really matter how deep you go, assuming the bit reaches, but it does matter a lot how deep you go in one pass. This was also true for cope and stick frames.

I'd actually suggest making round tenons, which would allow very easy forstner bit drilling.

Pam