Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

Posts

How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#1

How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

wilbur

>So after the tenon fitting thread I started, I thought I'd share how I've been fitting tenons with just a chisel.

First, here's the mortise and the tenon to be fitted. Although I try to get close when sawing the tenon, I typically err towards the waste side because the last thing I want is to have the tenon be too thin off the saw, because then you're just hosed. For the purposes of this demonstration, I sawed a bit wider than I usually would. The tenon as it came off the saw would not fit into the mortise at all, so step one is to put a small bevel on the tenon, because I want at least the tip of the tenon to get into the mortise. Hopefully you can see the bevel at the end of the tenon.


The tenon does not fit. :( Here's proof.


The key to quick and easy trimming a tenon with a chisel is to know where to start chiseling. Luckily, where the tenon gets wedged into the mortise is just the spot to start chiseling. Normally I just eyeball the spot on the tenon where it stops at the top of the mortise. Sometimes you can see a little compression mark in the tenon where it gets stuck. In this picture, I made a pencil mark where the tenon got stuck, to make it show up better. This is where I'm going to start to chisel away a little bit of the tenon. I have the chisel moved to the side so you can see where I'm starting. When actually paring, I use the chisel across the entire face of the tenon so I can pare the entire tenon face at once. This chisel is 2" wide.

Also note that I pare with the grain towards the shoulder, not across the grain.


This is a schematic diagram of what's happening. Basically, if part of the tenon can get into the mortise, it's already the right width for the mortise (or maybe too narrow), so you can leave that part alone. The spot where the tenon gets stuck is just a hair too thick for the mortise. All of the tenon from that point towards the shoulder is also going to be too thick, so that can all be pared away.


Fitting the tenon after paring gets me closer.


I repeat the paring step, only this time I started closer to the shoulder. One more round of paring, and the tenon fit perfectly. All I have to do is square up the shoulder, and I'll be all set.


I don't know how this method fits in with historical practice, but it seems to be really easy and quick. If I didn't stop to take photos, I'd be able to do the 2-3 rounds of fitting, paring, and testing needed to get me to a final fit in just a few minutes. I found that I don't really have to pay close attention to keeping the chisel level while paring, since starting the paring above the spot where the tenon gets stuck sort of auto-levels the face of the tenon to match the mortise. I just make sure that the chisel isn't cutting down too low. The main thing that I pay attention to regarding the chisel is to make sure it's really sharp.

If anyone knows how historical practice differed from this method that I've worked out, I'd love to know what those differences are.

Who needs a shoulder plane? ;)

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#2

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PI

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

That worked out well, and fast too! In that situation, I think your approach works very well.

But let me suggest a situation that's a tougher challenge, and I'd like to ask for your reaction. You're putting together a four-sided frame for a cabinet door. Two rails, two stiles. And just to keep it simple, let's mostly forget about rebates for the panel or glass, and forget about stuck moldings, and just think about the M&T part.

The M&T has to satisfy some tough conditions. One, it has to be dead plumb in the mortise, or else the frame will twist out of its plane upon glue-up. DAMHIKT. Second, the fit has to be pretty good, just for strength. Third, the fit has to be as marked, with the tenon located exactly right, or else one ends up with the stiles and rails 1/32" off at their faces, which means all four sticks have to be planed down to get the match, and you end up IME with a 1/16" skinnier frame than intended, and now maybe it's not rigid. Plus it affects how much meat is there to accommodate the rebate and mold.

Now, with that context in mind, think about sawing fat and paring. Both sides of the tenon will have to be pared to their marked lines, because it's not just getting a snug fit, it's also the location of the tenon. And both sides have to be pared plumb; otherwise, the tenon is going to twist the frame out of shape. And yet a close fit still is required. That's a lot of conditions to be met by paring.

Question: Would your strategy be the same if making a cabinet door, or a bunch of cabinet doors? [Real question; not rhetorical].

Wiley

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#3

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PI

barryvabeach

>Wiley, not to answer for Wilbur, but in the situation you describe, I find a small double square helps a lot. I set it for the distance that should exist between the side of the board and where the tenon face should be, and check that as a pare that gives me a good feel for where to pare, when to stop and also whether I am plumb in that dimension.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#4

Paring plumb and square

Bob Hackett

>Wiley,

For the specs you`ve set I`d use a router plane to trim as it can be set directly off the mortice and then references off the face you want to be flush.

All this assumes that the mortice was square and plumb too,and you know what they say about "assume".

The other thing I`m finding interesting about these threads is that most folks seem to want to fit M&T joinery like visible dovetails.Adam stated that when using hide glue you need alittle clearance and a smooth sawn surface would be preferable to a glass smooth pared surface(I hope I am remembering his post correctly).I can`t help but wonder why we still want to set ourselves up for a glue starved joint,especially now that there`s been a big switch to hot hide glue.

Adam`s post has me rethinking my approach to M&T.

MB

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#5

I am doing exactly what you describe

Bill Tindall

>I am working on 15 cabinet doors and I have made a great many more before these. The following is based on my experience my experience.

I have never been successful in reliably making tenons that fit right using only a table saw in "fit from the saw" "mass production mode".

I make the mortises with a hollow chisel. I may lightly clean up some internal fuzz with a chisel. I cut the tenons faces with a tenon jig on the table saw using a spacer block precisely sized for the hollow chisel. I purposely cut the tenon too thick by the equivalent of about 2-3 swipes with the shoulder plane ( or chisel or what ever) .

I mark the tenon length all around with a marking gauge and saw the waste off nearly to the marked line with a band saw of back saw depending on my mood and the number involved. I then pare to the base line with a chisel stroke.

Finally, I fit each tenon to its respective mortise by planing off some of the tenon face. I am only removing 0 to 0.010" so the issues you raise are not significant.

Like most of my woodworking, the above procedure focuses on reliability at the sacrifice of speed. If I try to short cut any of the steps I wind up with an occasional loose joint that I must then patch. No doubt if I made M&T joints more often I could, and would, use a more efficient approach. ( actually I would buy a router bit based system)

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#6

a potential problem

Bill Tindall

>If I used your approach I would soon encounter a tenon with the grain running downhill. When I made the cut the chisel would dig in and remove more than I intended. Perhaps with more skill and experience I would learn to control this situation. Rather than solve the problem with more skill and experience I solved it with a tool sitting idle on the shelf, a shoulder plane.

On the occasions that I pare a face it is always perpendicular to the grain to avoid this potential problem.

Based on what works for us, and problems we have encountered in the past (what hasn't worked), each of us gravitates to some technique that becomes reliable in our hands.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#7

While you are rethinking.....

Bill Tindall

>.......Consider the fit criteria I describe above. Consider that this fit criteria is based on the experience of having made hundreds of pieces of furniture.

I don't believe the concept of a glue starved joint resulting either from too much clamp pressure or from a joint anything less than so it tight it needs to be driven together with a mason's hammer. Two molecular thicknesses of adhesive is all that is required to form a bond, and in fact this bond will be the ultimate in strength, presuming the adhesive has less strength than the substrate.

As soon as a water based adhesive (and that includes hot hide glue) contacts wood water is absorbed by the wood and the viscosity of the adhesive increases orders of magnitude. Given this situation I don't believe it is possible to flow, or scrape, the first few microns of adhesive from the mating surfaces, and that is all the adhesive that is necessary for a bond.

That said, data I have shared in the past shows that there is not a great price to pay in strength for a loose M&T joint (with the PVA adhesives being strongest in a loose joint). However, assembling a piece of furniture with sloppy joints is difficult and I try to avoid it.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#8

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PI

David Cockey

>I had similar thoughts about Wilbur's method. How do you know which side to remove material from? Which side you bevel, or how much you bevel each side will determine how much material you decide to remove.

Does anyone look at the markings for the tenon on the end grain (assuming the end grain is marked) to decide where to remove material?

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#9

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PI

Dean J in MN

>Does anyone look at the markings for the tenon on the end grain (assuming the end grain is marked) to decide where to remove material?

I for one use the layout lines -- if you remove your marking lines you're off in the weeds when it comes to fitting. Leaving those witness marks is critical, whether you are tweaking with a chisel or a plane, and both on the tenon cheeks and shoulders.

With my 'tenon' gauges (made with fixed pins to match my mortise chisel) I know I have to split the gauge mark to have a good fit. That is what I shoot for, setting out to saw proud and trim just makes sure you maximise your trimming time. As Warren has said, after you cut a few you get into a groove and they come pretty close right from the saw.

-Dean

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#10

Re: a potential problem

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Downhill grain was my bane, too, and also caused me to actually use a wide shoulder plane that had been sitting idle on the shelf.

Pam

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#11

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PI

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

If I understand you correctly, the criteria are:

-- Plumb in the mortise

-- Good fit

-- Keep the faces flush

Now I've made very few cabinet doors, but I have made stretchers for tables/worktables where I wanted to keep the stretcher flush with one of the faces of the table legs, so hopefully that will be a similar enough situation.

First, all of this assumes that I've done a good job marking the tenon and mortise in the first place, and that the mortise is square after I'm done chopping it. If these two conditions aren't met, then my method of tenon fitting won't work, but my feeling is that neither will any other method of fitting a tenon.

Second, as Barry mentioned, a small square helps a lot to check to see that the tenon is square/plumb and in the right position. I've found that keeping the paring between the shoulder and where the tenon gets stuck does a remarkably good job with finishing up with a square/plumb tenon. But for a situation like making cabinet doors, I would also check with a square.

My experience with fitting tenons so that the stretcher is flush with a table leg so far led me to a fairly quick way to assess where the paring of the tenon cheek should be done. Basically, I'll fit the tenon, and see how even the face of the stretcher is with the face of the leg. If the stretcher is proud, I'll do more paring on the side of the tenon that's away from the face of the leg. If the stretcher sits below the face of the leg, I'll pare more on the side of the tenon that's closer to the face of the leg. Eventually I'll bring the face of the stretcher even with the face of the leg.

But once I have that lateral position established, any more paring that I have to do would be only to remove the triangular area in my schematic diagram, which should not affect the lateral positioning of the stretcher relative to the face of the leg, because at that point I'm not paring the entire face -- just the part that is keeping the tenon from fully entering the mortise.

Hope that was clear! Of course, when I get to the point that I am making a bunch of cabinet doors, I'll probably change my mind. ;)

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#12

Indeed....

Bill Tindall

>Being backwards I use a chisel for establishing shoulders, and fixing shoulder problems, which I don't have anymore once I employed the technique I learned in the Headley shop and described above. I was pleased the otherwise unused shoulder plane could be put to some use doing tenon faces. It does have the ability to be easily adjusted to take thin shavings (or thick) so it is not the worst tool for the task.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#13

Re: a potential problem

wilbur

>Regarding downhill grain:

I haven't used highly figured wood for this yet, but my feeling is that if I'm paring the tenon with the grain on one face, I'll have to be paring the tenon against the grain on the opposite face, which should lead to the nosediving problem when paring agains the grain. So far for me, this has been more of a theoretic problem than a real world one.

I think that what helps mitigate the downhill grain problem for me is that I'm taking very light cuts and have a sharp chisel. One thing I learned from bowl turning is that turners are cutting against the grain at least twice with every revolution of the bowl blank, and the turners have very effective ways of avoiding/minimizing tear out. The first person to give me a turning lesson had a saying: "98% of all turning problems can be solved with sharper tools and a lighter cut." That probably has some application here.

And of course, you can always go across the grain with your plane/chisel. My main takeaway point from this method is how to quickly figure out what needs paring/planing on your tenon, and what doesn't.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#14

Re: Indeed....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>We must have very similar styles of working M*T's. You perfectly described my reaction to shoulder planes and how I ended up doing shoulders. I especially love being able to chisel at an angle toward the cheek to create a sharper join line.

Pam

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#15

Re: a potential problem

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, dull chisels are the source of all my tenon trimming tear out problems. :)

You should see how bad the shoulder plane is due to dullness of blade, thus wrecking trims. :)

Honestly, Wilbur, I've been there advocating using chisels for everything, until I hit tear out with very sharp chisels. I faced up to it and changed methods. Now I'm not saying that you've had similar problems, to say nothing of a similar lack of patience; but if you ever face it, please let us know how you address the very real problem.

Pam

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#16

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PI

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Wilbur,

That all makes good sense. Just a couple more thoughts....What Dean said about shaving his marks is where I end up. To do that, I need to do two things. One is to darken my gauge lines with a 0.5mm or 0.7mm HB lead pencil, so that I have a bit of 'witness' left in the good wood, even if I make a perfect saw cut. I can't quite make out the bare gauge line--maybe my light isn't good enough. The second thing is to make the cheek cuts first, and get the cheeks right, before sawing the end pieces. I find this helpful, because my cheek gauge lines are on the 'end pieces'. I like to saw the shoulders first, so when I saw the cheeks, the cheeks fall off. Well that's fine. But if I go ahead and make the rip cuts on the end pieces, they will take the cheek gauge lines with them when they fall off. So I want to make sure the cheeks are right before ripping the end pieces. [All that is avoidable by making the shoulder cuts last, but then that increases the risk--for me, anyway--of slightly overcutting the shoulder line when making the cheek cuts, and leaving a little sawcut on the face of the rail.]

The other thing concerns sawing, with pull saws. My personal experience is that my sawing of tenons was improved by going to a heavier saw. YMMV. Talking about Japanese saws now. Unless it's a quite small tenon, I don't use a rip dozuki anymore. Because I don't want that dozuki to get 3/4" deep into the wood with more depth yet to go. It's getting engulfed by the wood, given its lack of beam strength and zero set. And on a tenon of the width you were/are sawing (4-5 inches?), a 240mm rip kataba is the minimum and 270mm better yet. I don't want a fair fight between the wood and the saw. YMMV, but using 'the next size up' makes things more predictable for me.

Wiley

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#17

Tearout and downhill grain

Bob Hackett

>When using a(very sharp) chisel and getting tearout on figured grain I do the same thing I do with a plane under those circumstances,I skew the cutting edge and the problem usually goes away.For really tough problems there`s always the scraper chisel.

As Wilbur said,when faced with cutting into downhill grain you also do what you do with a plane and cut cross grain(or use a scraper chisel).

Once again I`m wondering why the cheek of a tenon must be surfaced like the show face of an apron.Look at the back of most really old furniture and you can see they didn`t really care about moderate tearout or anything else beyond getting a target thickness.Most of what I`ve seen shows the jack plane was good enough,no smoothing needed.I can`t imagine they took any more care with a tenon cheek than they did with a non show(unless looking up under the table or sticking your head in a drawer)surface.

I understand that some of us hold ourselves to very high standards.Just wondering if some of those high standards are at all realistic or serve any function outside of our own heads.

BTW-Glad to see folks owning up to and discussing mixed(power and hand) WWing.For folks like me the grunt work is almost always a function of sacrificing electrons.Like Todd O.,I use my "Neanderbuddy"(bandsaw) a lot.My shop days would not be near as long if I didn`t.

MB

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#18

Re: a potential problem

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

I already know how I would deal with that situation -- start paring cross grain. And I know that the day will come where that will be an issue. But although using cross grain paring/planing is a great fall back plan if I run into problems, it makes sense to me to pare with the grain whenever possible, and if I can get away with it.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#19

to clarify

Bill Tindall

>If you use a shoulder plane cross grain on a tenon to size it the resulting surface is anything but smooth. And considering the huge gluing surface every part of the tenon surface does not need to be precisely mated to the mortise, which is likely similarly ragged unless it was cut with a router.

However, to aid assembly and fitting it is worth the effort to prepare the joint such that it holds itself together in the dry state, and, when the time comes the joint can be assembled with glue with hand pressure without the stress/risk of mallet bashing (been there done that). The fact that this criteria for fit is practiced by experienced cabinet makers confirms its utility. This criteria does not presume or require a finish planed surface on either the mortise or tenon. In fact some degree of roughness makes meeting the criteria easier. The rough spots hold the dry joint together and the "gaps" enable the joint to easily slip together after it has been somewhat swollen with glue.

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#20

Quick question Bill

Bob Hackett

>Do you fit the dry joint allowing for the swelling when the glue goes on?

Just trying to get a feel for which end of the hand fit spectrum I need to shoot for when working with HHG which is something new for me.

MB

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#21

Re: Tearout and downhill grain

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Well, I never threw away a tenon, even with tear out embedded, at worst they can always be patched. :) However, it was a reliable problem, the solution was at hand, already purchased for other reasons that didn't pan out, and worked more quickly than chiseling.

Pam

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#22

So there. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#23

Re: a potential problem

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>That's fine, but I found it a bit fiddly to avoid spelching with the chisel, had to start the chisel skewed from the edge. For me, the whole chiseling process was too fiddly; but to each his own. Perhaps you've brought some scalpeling technique to the task?

Pam

Re: How to fit a tenon with only a wide chisel *PICS*

#24

Re: Quick question Bill

Bill Tindall

>The dry fit should hold itself together but be loose enough that the M&T can be pushed together with hand pressure. Ditto for dovetails and dados......according to the Headleys. After applying glue the joint will still assemble with hand pressure and/or light mallet taps, and it might take a clamp to pull it tight.

Since learning this fit criteria I have had stress-free assemblies. I used to get joints too tight and then need to resort to mallet bashing or frantic clamping, or both.

The tolerances for this fit criteria are about 0.005". When I was "100% machine made" I had no way of finely adjusting joints to achieve this precision of fit. What I learned from visiting places like College of Redwoods and discussions on WC and Badger Pond was that hand tools enabled controlled, tiny amounts of wood to be removed and this ability enabled precise joint fitting. For me the shoulder plane is a chisel with training wheels.