Re: I have a few questions as well
Adam Cherubini
>Derek,
I can only speculate on the origins of the shoulder plane. It sorta makes sense to me that these planes were used to clean up shoulders. They weren't available in the 18th c and were plentiful in the 19thc. We know a great deal of joinery (imagine a shoulder on a panel door- 8" wide or so)in the 19th c was done with machines. Its possible these planes were just a helpful tool that 19th c manufacturers developed and folks bought. Or it could be that they were particularly helpful for trimming machine sawn tenons. Can't say beyond that.
I guess my take is that they (planes in general) seem to be less helpful when a cut is pretty irregular. They seem to work better when removing a uniform amount (even a uniform taper), which I don't see often with hand tools. My mistakes are almost always irregular. But others may disagree. Their experiences may be different.
"Now, what percentage of 18C furniture used drawbored M&T joints?"
I share your curiosity. I too have asked this question. It's almost impossible to detect draw boring in fine furniture. Stuff shrinks, pegs get replaced. Pegs that are sound don't often get removed for inspection. X-ray is a the way to go. I've seen some, but not enough to say "this is trade practice". Don't think drawing boring gets you out of a tight shoulder tho.
"Here's a third question - think of it as a bonus Why are there "shoulder planes" and no "tenon" or "tenon cheek" planes? What do you think this says?"
I think it says that cheeks were cut on machines. Before machines, both shoulder and cheeks were cut with hand saws and likley fitted with chisels. I've seen a couple tenons out (on formal chairs) and there isn't a lot of evidence of chisel work on the tenons.
"And lastly. No one has mentioned the router plane for tenon cheeks. This is the most accurate method of tuning cheeks of all. Now I could see this as a possible method used in the 18C as it is a very basic tool. Any mention of this anywhere?"
I certainly don't use them. They really require the back side to be accurately surfaced, which on 18th c stuff, often isn't the case. I think they are kinda fincky. By the time you have the depth set correctly the job would have been done with a chisel.
I don't think there are any answers here. I just get the sense that a lot of our conventional hand tool wisdom comes from folks who are relying on machines to do some operations (doesn't make them bad people). What Schwarz calls the "Hybrid" woodworkers, we just need to recognize may have different answers to questions (like which is the best plane or how do you clean up tenons) than a guy sawing and planing stuff by hand.
I think the big problem is that we jokingly have stigmatized (is that a word?) the hybrid guys, who are sometimes now even inhibitied from writing the name of the tool they are using for risk of ridicule or forum explusion. The result is we get the sense guys are 100% hand tool when they are not. We also hear a hybrid perspective. Instead of filtering out the hybrid guys, it would be better if we welcomed the qualifying statements, e.g., "I started this on my router..." "how can I get my band saw to do this so I can plane that...".
We really have to end also the value system that says someone like me is more praiseworthy because if we love using hand tools, it must be better to use nothing but. Pretty sure I've never said that. I think it's different to use nothing but and that my experiences may be more useful to a greater audience because they don't include a point of compromise. You get to get off the hand tool train at any stop along the way to puffy shirtville (if you get my drift). But that doesn't make puffy shirtville more desireable or praiseworthy (at least in my mind).
Adam