Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

Posts

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#26

Re: you got that right, plumbing rant....

wilbur

>Well, the reason I called it a minor plumbing emergency was that I was able to fix it on my own. ;)

What happened was that water was backing out of the drain pipe that carries away the water from our washing machine. Thank goodness we have one of those high efficiency washing machines, so that the water spillage was much less that it might have been with a conventional washer. I found and cleaned out a huge soap plug in the main house trap on the drain pipe just as it leaves our house. I'm not quite sure how to measure a soap plug, but the gunk filled up over half of a 2 quart bucket that I had handy. After clearing the trap out, our washing machine drains well again.

I'm going to have a plumber come out anyway and check our drain lines and vents. But at least I won't need one to come out TODAY.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#27

Re: I have a few questions as well

Adam Cherubini

>Derek,

I can only speculate on the origins of the shoulder plane. It sorta makes sense to me that these planes were used to clean up shoulders. They weren't available in the 18th c and were plentiful in the 19thc. We know a great deal of joinery (imagine a shoulder on a panel door- 8" wide or so)in the 19th c was done with machines. Its possible these planes were just a helpful tool that 19th c manufacturers developed and folks bought. Or it could be that they were particularly helpful for trimming machine sawn tenons. Can't say beyond that.

I guess my take is that they (planes in general) seem to be less helpful when a cut is pretty irregular. They seem to work better when removing a uniform amount (even a uniform taper), which I don't see often with hand tools. My mistakes are almost always irregular. But others may disagree. Their experiences may be different.

"Now, what percentage of 18C furniture used drawbored M&T joints?"

I share your curiosity. I too have asked this question. It's almost impossible to detect draw boring in fine furniture. Stuff shrinks, pegs get replaced. Pegs that are sound don't often get removed for inspection. X-ray is a the way to go. I've seen some, but not enough to say "this is trade practice". Don't think drawing boring gets you out of a tight shoulder tho.

"Here's a third question - think of it as a bonus Why are there "shoulder planes" and no "tenon" or "tenon cheek" planes? What do you think this says?"

I think it says that cheeks were cut on machines. Before machines, both shoulder and cheeks were cut with hand saws and likley fitted with chisels. I've seen a couple tenons out (on formal chairs) and there isn't a lot of evidence of chisel work on the tenons.

"And lastly. No one has mentioned the router plane for tenon cheeks. This is the most accurate method of tuning cheeks of all. Now I could see this as a possible method used in the 18C as it is a very basic tool. Any mention of this anywhere?"

I certainly don't use them. They really require the back side to be accurately surfaced, which on 18th c stuff, often isn't the case. I think they are kinda fincky. By the time you have the depth set correctly the job would have been done with a chisel.

I don't think there are any answers here. I just get the sense that a lot of our conventional hand tool wisdom comes from folks who are relying on machines to do some operations (doesn't make them bad people). What Schwarz calls the "Hybrid" woodworkers, we just need to recognize may have different answers to questions (like which is the best plane or how do you clean up tenons) than a guy sawing and planing stuff by hand.

I think the big problem is that we jokingly have stigmatized (is that a word?) the hybrid guys, who are sometimes now even inhibitied from writing the name of the tool they are using for risk of ridicule or forum explusion. The result is we get the sense guys are 100% hand tool when they are not. We also hear a hybrid perspective. Instead of filtering out the hybrid guys, it would be better if we welcomed the qualifying statements, e.g., "I started this on my router..." "how can I get my band saw to do this so I can plane that...".

We really have to end also the value system that says someone like me is more praiseworthy because if we love using hand tools, it must be better to use nothing but. Pretty sure I've never said that. I think it's different to use nothing but and that my experiences may be more useful to a greater audience because they don't include a point of compromise. You get to get off the hand tool train at any stop along the way to puffy shirtville (if you get my drift). But that doesn't make puffy shirtville more desireable or praiseworthy (at least in my mind).

Adam

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#28

I used a chisel and it worked fine

Nathan

>I did 14 M&T joints in a recent project and the chisel worked fine for me.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#29

Re: boring, boring, boring...

ThomD

>You might be right about people holding back. My main feeling is only about 10% of a forum audience has the time for contributing, and it probably doesn't have much to do with holding back. I often hold back hybrid stuff because it doesn't seem to be the main conversation around here, and one might as well stick somewhat to that. But I don't think I ever get dissed for bringing up a hybrid use, it just may hit the floor with a low interest thud.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#30

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to 

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur and all,

Well, I do different things on the cheeks, depending on mood, and depending on how good the cheeks are off the saw. Usually they're close enough I can give them a couple licks with a joiner's float (a Clark & Williams/LN product). If they're off much, I like a chisel.

For adjusting shoulders, I do like a shoulder plane, but you have to be careful--in fact, I don't ever let the shoulder plane exit the cut, all cuts are from the outside to the inside and don't exit. Because if you spelch the edge of the shoulder, which is mighty easy to do on the exit, you're in way worse shape than when you started out. It's like playing an infield roller into an inside-the-park home run (I know you're a Cubs fan, and probably seen a few of those ;) .

But here's where I'm trying to get to.....I am way-y-y-y-y with you on the essentiality (is that a word) of the wide chisel. A huge favorite of mine is pictured below, courtesy of So Yamashita of Japan-Tool. It's a very hard chisel, 36mm, beveled around 25 degrees or so. It is just so perfect. I use it like a plane lots of times, where I need really close control and want to see the blade cutting. The width lets you make a slicing cut. Thanks for reminding me.

Wiley

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#31

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to

Kevin Adams

>Wiley, great looking chisel and I'm with you 100%. Who is the smith and what steel is used? I have one just about the same size from our friend, Imai-san, and very few projects don't see it at some point.

Btw, have you heard from Kayoko in a while? I need to drop her a note just to say hi and see how things are going with those she has been caring for. (Contact me off line if that would be better.) Probably should figure out something to order, too!

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#32

comment

Bill Tindall

>that thing looks like what we used to chop holes in the ice for ice fishing. Could it be the same? (bill, getting nostalgic for ice fishing)

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#33

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to

wilbur

>

It's like playing an infield roller into an inside-the-park home run (I know you're a Cubs fan, and probably seen a few of those ;) .

Ouch. That really hurt. ;)

That is a gorgeous looking chisel. I'm also curious as to the maker and steel used for that chisel. Also, if you don't mind, how long it is (about 14" is my guess), the wood used for the handle, and if there was a reason why the sides seem to be pretty square -- at least more square than the standard bench chisel profile.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#34

Williamsburg Conference

David Cockey

>Drawboring was mentioned several times at this year's Working in Wood conference in Williamsburg. The Hays Cabinet Shop craftsman generally took the position it was rarely used for (fine) furniture. The Joiners felt it was used for furniture, though how frequently is not known. This difference of opinon may represent more different vantage points than differences in fact. "Joiners" probably made the majority of furniture used in 18th century North America, but not the fine furniture which cabinetmakers made which generally gets more attention today.

A router plane was used to trim tenon faces on wide tenons on the standing desk at the conference. Several sizes of router planes seemed to be getting a lot of use in general.

My guess is some second half of the 19th century furniture was made in factorys with lots of machines, some was made in shops with a few machines, and some was made in shops with few machines. My understanding is that in England there was generally less machinery in shops than in the US.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#35

Bill, Kevin, and Wilbur

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill, do you still have that ice-fishing chisel?! I want to see it!! I think this one would have a hooped handle if it was for pounding. Looks to me like a paring chisel, but the handle is shorter than the modern ones.

Wilbur, the brand is Kiyotada (smith = Shimamura kouzaburo). White steel #1. 12-5/8" remaining, total length. 36mm wide. Handle is red oak.

Kiyotada was a Tokyo smith of some renown--retired some 10 years ago. The Tokyo smiths are either gone or far-advanced in age: So Yamashita has a few Nagahiro (smith = Tanaka) and Kiyotada and even Uchihiro chisels for sale, though the latter are priced like cars now. According to So, the Tokyo real estate is just too high for smithing, so the smithing work has gone to Sanjo and Yoita.

The sides are indeed square. According to So-san (who knows about these things), this is kakuuchi (box) style, and was prevalent before the 1950s, and has since fallen in favor to the shinogi (triangle) and mentori (beveled top ) styles that are familiar to us. I don't know the reason for the box style on a paring chisel; on a hooped chisel, it could double in a pinch for a mortise chisel. This particular chisel is marked 'betsu uchi' (special order), so it may or may not have been typical.

Kevin, go ahead and write Kayoko. She is in Japan through February. She may or may not be able to answer, as she is in the countryside taking care of business. But am sure she'll be thrilled to get your email when she gets back to town.

Wiley

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#36

Re: Williamsburg Conference

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Peter Nicholson, writing about tenons 200 years ago, says this: "if the saw is in good order, it will not be necessary to do any more to the sides; but if the saw has been led away from the draughts, either from carelessness or from its being in bad order, recourse must be had to the paring chisel, so as to take away the superfluous wood to the gauge lines, and lastly to the skew-faced rebate plane." It is a very different thing to plan on making it right the first time than it is to purposely leave extra to trim with a chisel or plane or router.

Someone earlier mentioned that the time setting up the router could be justified if one were making 30 similar tenons. In my experience, when you do that kind of volume, you get on a roll and soon don't need any touch up at all. Eighteenth century routers do not have a handy screw adjustment.

I think it was Williamsburg's Brian Weldy who use a router (conveniently set up ahead) on some tenons for the stand up desk. These tenons were configured in such a way that they could not be sawn or made with a fillister. I don't think the Williamsburg cabinet makers would use this technique on a tenon that could be sawn. Frankly, I am having trouble imagining John Hemmings doing it with a router. When I asked if a router plane appeared on the 1809 inventory of the Monticello joiner's shop (where the original was made by Hemmings), the answer was "No". There are about 130 planes on the inventory, which otherwise seems to have been carefully made.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#37

Re: Bill, Kevin, and Wilbur

Kevin Adams

>Wiley, maybe not a fair question, but do you notice anything different about this chisel than say one from Imai (or any other active smith)? Btw, looks like dark red oak (I thought it was ebony like on mine), but maybe it's just the lighting. Any idea how old the chisel is?

'nother topic...are you able to actually get through to So via email? I know he's seriously backed up and I had given up hearing from him. I ended up ordering some bench chisels from Kayoko a while back.

Thanks.

Kevin

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#38

Re: Bill, Kevin, and Wilbur

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Kevin,

You're right, the handle is red oak that has aged dark. This chisel seems lighter to me than, for example, Imai or Funahiro examples of comparable blade width. Don't have comparable size Tasai's. I haven't done any weighing, but that is what it seems like in the hand. Not as much wood on it as modern ones, and the shank is on the light side.

Every once in a while, the weight of tools get mentioned on this forum. For example, gouges--those who have used both say that the older gouges are more desirable than modern manufacture, in part because they are lighter.

I have a Clark & Williams plough plane that is very light and handy, and prefer it to heavier 19th century screw-arm ploughs, even though I am a nut about the screw-arm ploughs.

This Kiyotada chisel is very hard, but easy to sharpen, so it is like Imai and Tasai in that regard. The Funahiros I have are his alloy steel, and they are a bear to get really sharp; if I had it to do over, I would get his white steel chisels (which is his high-end in the Japanese domestic market).

I have a notion, based on age of the smith and the box shape, that this chisel is from the 1950's or '60s, but that's just an off-hand guess. Why couldn't it be 70's?

Suggest keep trying on So.

Wiley

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#39

Re: M&T fit criteria according to Headley shop

Thomd

>That sounds about right, cool. It sorta becomes obvious if one has ever done a slip joint. That joint relies on glue to a larger degree, and the guts are visible. Also, it is obvious that the oldsters took fit seriously when one examines joins that were not glued as is the case with some wedge door joints I have seen. They are very tight along the cheeks with edges holding them in place. Basically I think that kind of thing is what informs Williamsburg work. They just looked at the stuff around them, for starters. Normally a close source of inspiration than making the trip to a historic site.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#40

Re: Non-tailed machine

Thomd

>I am reminded of an episode in the WWS shop where Roy shows a non-electric machine that shaves both sides of a tenon at the same time. Looked like a good idea if one was trying to pay for a house a few centuries back. I am not sufficiently reminded that I can recall the episode... There are so many round tenon makers that a search wasn't successful on my part.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#41

Headley Confusion

David Cockey

>I suspect when Bill said "class at Headley's" he was refering to a class at the Mack S. Headley & Sons shop near Berryville, Virginia where Jeff Headley works http://www.headleyandsons.com/index.html, not the Anthony Hays shop in Colonial Williamsburg where Mack Headley (Jr), Jeff's brother is the master cabinetmaker. http://www.history.org/Almanack/life/trades/tradecab.cfm And to further confuse matters other Headleys who I believe are cousins of Jeff and Mack have/had a shop south of Winchester, Virginia.

Having said that, my recollection from this year's Working Wood conference is the standard for a mortise and tenon fit in the Hays shop is the same as Bill described for the Headley shop.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#42

Re: Non-tailed machine

David Cockey

>Program 2907 is a visit to a site in Silk Cove, NC which has several steam engines, a saw mill and window sash making machines.

http://flash.unctv.org/woodwrightss/2900/wws_2907.html

Program 2612 is a visit to a factory in upstate New York that uses 19th century machines to produce window sashes.

http://flash.unctv.org/woodwrightss/wws_2612.html

I believe both have tenoners.

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#43

correct on all counts

Bill Tindall

Re: Does anyone NOT use a plane to trim tenons to fit?

#44

Re: Non-tailed machine

Thomd

>Thanks David, I will check those episodes out. The machine I recall was small shop scale.