Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Dovetails made easier

Posts

Re: Dovetails made easier

#26

Re: The best fixed frame EVER *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Kevin,

I should have made this clear. I wasn't recommending 2/0 for those using dozukis. I was recommending No. 2. This is based on the Olson size chart shown in the link. Since size/numbering could vary between vendors, it is the 0.012" blade thickness I am keying on, and recommending.

At the link, scroll down to the following:

OLSON� Regular Skip Tooth - Scroll Saw Blades

The recommended No. 2 saw is 0.012" thick and 20 tpi; the 2/0 is 0.010" and 28 tpi. 5" long; plain end; skip tooth.

No financial interest in this vendor. Other vendors carry these blades as well; however, I have done business with Sloan's and they are reliable.

Wiley


Olson Fret/Scroll saw blades

Re: Dovetails made easier

#27

P. S.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I forgot to answer your question :\ . 20 tpi is about the limit of what is usable for cutting dovetail waste IMO. It would be nice to have 18tpi or 15 tpi. But I wouldn't recommend anything finer than 20 tpi. And the skip tooth helps in terms of having large enough gullets, and not having gullets getting clogged.

Show us some chairs :)

Wiley

Re: Dovetails made easier

#28

Re: blade twisting is not to be avoided

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

Good argument. I've tried it both ways--twisted blade vs. in-line blade. 2-3/4" frame depth and 5" frame depth.

Here's how it works out for me. Even the steel frame saw is light enough that I don't notice the torque. I figure the aluminum frame will be lighter yet. On the other hand, when I twist the blade, I'm never exactly sure where the teeth are, and have to keep feeling for them when I work the saw into the kerf--remember, it's a close fit given a 12-thousandths saw blade and a 13 thousandths kerf. So the orientation has to be right, and it's tedious to feel for it. In addition, I have to saw a little too conservatively, because again, I'm not sure _exactly_ where the teeth are aimed. By having the blade in line with the frame, I can enter the kerf without fumbling, and I can cut closer to the line, because the plane of the frame tells me exactly where the saw wants to go.

Anyway, having done it both ways, I've decided to go with the deeper frame and work in-line with the frame. Am excited about Dave Barnett's recommended frame. It really looks good. A stout frame like that can overcome the issue Scott Burr raised--flex in the blade caused by either a frame that flexes, or a frame that can't be made rigid enough to hold shape under load.

Incidentally, more power to those who chop. I don't want to have that argument. Anyone who wants to chop, have at it ;) . But I'm happier sawing. Part of it is, I just like to saw.

Wiley

Re: Dovetails made easier

#29

Coping saws

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>My parents gave me a coping saw (Trojan No. 18) for Christmas in 1958. I broke the blade in about 2 minutes, but then was so careful I went years on the second blade. Around thirty years later I bought the Eclipse which was a marked improvement in rigidity and ease of securing the blade. I can recommend this saw. I use the saw both push and pull and also do a lot of pierced work where the blade has to be slipped through a hole. I also have two fret saws but I think they both are a little clumsy.

I have had trouble with blades. Twice I had nice mail order suppliers who discontinued the brand I was buying. I bought my last batch from Lee Valley which I will discontinue because they refused to reveal the brand. I think they are Olsen. The are adequate, but very dull and need to be sharpened. David Barnet once recommended Bahco which I will try next.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#30

Re: P. S.

Kevin Adams

>Hi Wiley,

Thanks, that makes a lot more sense! The jewelers' blades (from the Otto Frei site) were more like 33 tp cm in order to get close to the thickness of the Olson #2.

Are you going to get the 5" or 8" saw? I have the same one you do now, so was thinking of the 8", but wondering what you are really gaining with the extra 3" for sawing dovetails. With the Knew Concepts saw I also wonder if you can mount the blade at an angle so you don't have to give it a twist for easier access?

Hope things are well. No chairs in a while, been doing more carving and also reconfiguring the shop. Finally took the plunge and got rid of the table saw and jointer/planer! I'm down to a small bandsaw and a larger one for cutting up logs, plus a drill press. The drill press may be next to go. I have missed the table saw a couple of times when I wanted to make a quick rip in something, but I managed without it. It's amazing how much more room I have now, so I am building a couple more benches, one exclusively for carving with the Tucker vice I snagged (I literally got the last one).

Keep in touch and take care,

Kevin

Re: Dovetails made easier

#31

Re: Coping saws

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Warren. I'll try to group some Bahco blades and Eclipse with another order real soon. I searched locally and found that Woodcraft carries Olsen blades, but if they're too dull....

Pam

Re: Dovetails made easier

#32

Re: removing waste

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Pam,

Well, it's an expensive experiment if you're not already committed to sawing waste. I've taken David's recommendations in the past, and he is always right. So I have no doubt that this is a better saw frame, but it sounds from your description that the saw itself may have been too dull and slow for you. A more rigid frame will make any saw cut better, even a moderately dull one, but it might still be tedious for you.

In my case, I'm already committed to sawing the waste, so I don't see this as much of a risk, since I'm just looking for an improvement over the frame and saw I already use.

Saw sharpness. In light of Warren's comments on dull saws elsewhere in this thread, I just went and did a finger test on a new Olson No. 2 saw. This saw is 12 thousandths thick, just like a Japanese dozuki, so you can reasonably compare the sharpness by feel to a rip dozuki (the Olson saw is straight rip). There's no comparison--the Olson blade is duller. Well, I get by with them, but now I am motivated to search for a sharper saw--not even considering trying to sharpen one of these things under strong magnification.

Sharp scroll saw blade is the next frontier. I'm sure there are some great jeweler's fret saw blades, but these have too many tpi. Gotta be a scroll saw blade for cutting wood.

Wiley

Re: Dovetails made easier

#33

Re: removing waste

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>We agree that David's always right, and I think those Knew saws are gorgeous; but we also agree that it appears a bit expensive for someone who's happy chopping. I've got a coping saw somewhere around, so maybe I'll just try sawing the waste with what I have for the moment. Thanks.

Pam

Re: Dovetails made easier

#34

Re: Dovetails made easier - fretsaw

ThomD

>One thing I do with the fretsaw is take liers and crank it so it sits at 45 degrees ish. (mine {LV} has fixed ends). That allows me to get in and around the socket whatever the width of the board. I often just chop them, but teach using the saw since it makes it easier for some. With my saw blades it won't track well enough to eliminate some chopping.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#35

Not one ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Well, it's an expensive experiment if you're not already committed to sawing waste.

Hi Wiley

When buying a coping saw, I suggest you get two! Not kidding. :)

Twist the blade in one one way, and in the other the other way. Then you do not have to do this every time you saw out the waste.

I was making breadboard ends today.

First I cut the waste out this way ...


... and then I cut it out the other way ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails made easier

#36

Good idea, Derek, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Dovetails made easier

#37

I agree

Ron in Kokomo

Re: Dovetails made easier

#38

First time using the new saw...

Denny

>It's actually better than expected. The blade loading and tensioning system is so superior that even if it doesn't save on saw blades it's worth getting to avoid the typical hassle. The only change I've made to the saw is to cover the handle with a bicycle handlebar foam rubber cover to make the grip a little better. David, thanks for posting the link!

Denny

Re: Dovetails made easier

#39

Re: First time using the new saw...

Neal in San Jose

>Which size did you get? They look like really good tools, and I'd consider one. I was thinking the largest, 8", might have some advantages if it wasn't too heavy. Can it use standard coping saw blades or are you committed to jewler's blades? I've all but given up on "standard" coping saws; if the blade doesn't jump out, it breaks! thanks, Neal

Re: Dovetails made easier

#40

Re: First time using the new saw...

Denny

>Neal, I got the 3" size because I've gotten used to working with that size saw and I like the balance of the smaller saws. Having said that, the saw is really light weight and I imagine the balance is very good for all of the sizes. The saw won't take a coping saw blade, the blades are inserted into a very small hole so only jeweler size blades will fit. There's no way blades will jump out of the saw, the holding mechanism is really excellent.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#41

Knew Concepts saw question

Phil Joines

>How does the blade tension mechanism work? Can't see it well enough in the pic.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#42

Re: Knew Concepts saw question

Denny

>Tightening is screw-driven, and it doesn't cause the blade to twist, the blade holder is locked in position.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#43

Re: Knew Concepts saw question

Thomd

>Great tips. One of the keys to teaching stuff that people don`t pick up easily is to figure out what the key points are, and in particular the ones that really make a difference. One can always add to a long list, and also pick appart the wrong way to do things, but often all this does is add to the confusion and not improve the state of play. I had a seminar worked out that was supposed to hit only the high points but who knows what is really best unless one actually teaches enough people to really boil it down, which I can`t claim to have done.

One thing I have noticed is that often the key is to allow the person to do the thing in a different way, often a way that disconnects the eyes. In dovetails, practice sawing without a line, and also practice sawing with the eyes closed. Address the piece ready to put the saw on it, but close your eyes, get the right feel in your body and then open the eyes, often one will find the saw is nowhere near the cut because the position first taken was too cramped. Sports make use of these kinds of things, skiing without poles shooting with the eyes closed and a target at 3 feet, or dry firing with guns. In sports many people know exactly what the expert should have done, but are completely unable to do it themselves. Beyond a certain point, the issue isn`t how, but why one can`t seem to do what one believes one should, or worse still thinks one is doing.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#44

Re: First time using the new saw...

Ace Karner

>I received the 8 inch model last week, this saw is lite weight to the point of almost unbelievable. The blade holding device is most positive and the tightening mechanism could not be easier.

When I picked up the package it was hard to believe that it had a saw in there it was so lite.

The only thing I didn't like about it was the painted red handle but I will be turning a nice cocobolo handle for it soon.

Re: Dovetails made easier

#45

Natural point of aim

Bob Hackett

>The technique you`re talking about is what shooters would know as natural point of aim.You take up your position,close your eyes,shoulder the weapon and prepare to fire.You then open your eyes and see how far you are from having your sites on the center of mass.You then adjust your entire body to a new position where you are on target and relaxed.The first urge is to adjust the weapon`s position by cranking it onto target using just the hands and arms but this puts you into an unsupported and tensioned position that is neither relaxed nor natural.

The other thing to be mindful of if you`re sighting something is your dominant eye.Many shooters(and persons doing other than shooting) experience troubles hitting the mark because they just watched a right eye dominant instructor show how to do something in a right handed manor. They have trouble getting positive results because they are either left handed or left eye dominant and need to be allowing for this by either closing/covering that left eye and allowing the right eye to sight or switching to a left handed approach.

You`d be surprised how many frustrating problems can be overcome by simply allowing the body to do what it naturally needs/wants to do rather than blindly following a demonstration exactly as you saw it done.

MB