Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Posts

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#26

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Chris Friesen

>It should be noted that 800x in sandpaper is not the same as 800x in waterstones. 800x in ANSI/CAMI sandpaper is roughly equivalent to a 1200x waterstone.

In any case, one of the benefits of going to a finer grit is that the edge stays sharp for longer. In addition to this, it's capable of a finer cut in a plane. This can be useful on wood that is prone to tearout.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#27

I know of someone that sharpens this way...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>My favorite Sushi chef "Genso". He sharpens his knifes on 1K then 8K stones. Can you say Shaved Fish Mr. Lennon?

Never tried it myself, I'm trying to get away from water stones.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#28

Not just hammers

David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast

>I have a large polishing lathe and a leather belt sander just for hammers, stakes and repousse punches. That's before I get after them with the polishing sticks.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#29

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Sgian Dubh

>Chris, I'm aware of all the issues you raised, but my point is that the cost benefit, ie, increased productivity, just isn't there for me. I could spend more time sharpening planes and chisels, but that doesn't make them cut so much better that it's worth the effort.

In part I suppose my attitude to sharpening was set long ago when I started my training as a furniture maker. The experienced old guys in the workshop just dug out an oilstone, stroked the blade up and down a few times and got back to work; that's how I was taught. It worked for them, it had worked for their teachers and I guess the same minimalist approach has worked for me for the last thirty five or so years.

I haven't posted a link to this hoary old chestnut of mine for a few years in this forum. Some newer users here might find it interesting, and the older hands might get a chuckle. Slainte.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#30

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>OK, but why does that hoary old stone have to be 800 grit? One that you go to when you feel the blade dulling? I think dull chisels are quite dangerous to use, not just good enough.

Pam

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#31

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Sgian Dubh

>The ceramic stone I mostly use now just happens to be 800 grit Pam, or at least I'm pretty sure that's what it said on the box when I purchased it several years ago. If I use a combination oilstone, as seen in the web page I linked you to, I use the 'fine' side of the stone to get the edge sharp. I don't know what the oil-stone manufacturer meant when they described one side as 'coarse' and the other 'fine'. The fine side is fine enough to get a good edge for 95% of all the work I do, as is the 800 grit face of the ceramic stone. I have a finer stone or two if I want to to get an edge better suited to final prep work or for particularly awkward grain.

I didn't suggest that dull tools are a good thing- I don't use blunt tools, never have (except maybe when I was an inexperienced beginner back in the late 1960s and probably didn't know any better) and never will. Blunt tools are about as much use as a chocolate fireguard and, as you say, can be dangerous.

I don't believe the discussions that make sharpening a complicated and involved process are very helpful to any furniture maker, amateur or professional, that's trying to be efficient and productive. There's little productive benefit in sharpening if it involves multiple stages and takes a lot of time to get an edge with mirror bright planes leading up to that edge. I can understand that such conversations can be of great interest to woodworkers unmotivated by efficiency and productivity; these woodworkers are driven by a different drum-beat than the one that drives woodworkers that aim to be productive and efficient.

In business, for example, sharpening is, out of necessity, a short process. It generally takes no more than a few minutes to disassemble a plane, touch up the edge of the iron, reassemble it all and to get back to work. If I see a working furniture maker spend more than four or five minutes going through this disassembly, touch up, and reassembly process before making more shavings I seriously question if the maker is skilled enough for all the other tasks required of him or her to make a living. Slainte.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#32

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

wilbur

>I certainly can't say that I am even close to having the skills to make furniture for a living, but it seems to me that everything you say about taking no more than a few minutes to touch up an edge and getting back to work can be done with an 8000 grit stone just as easily as it could be done with an 800 grit stone. In fact, that's been my experience. I leave an 8000 grit stone out on my small sharpening area, and when I feel the tool getting dull, I take a few minutes to touch it up on the 8000 grit stone, and I'm back to work.

Initially, it does take some time to work your way from that 800 grit stone (actually, 1000 grit in my case) up to an 8000 grit stone, but I've found that (1) that really only takes a few minutes of work on a 5000 grit stone and then the 8000 grit stone to get that fine edge, and [B] once I've done that, maintaining that 8000 grit edge seems to be no more burdensome than what you describe with your 800 grit stone, so the 10 minutes or so spent doing the above steps is a one shot time investment, unless I wind up putting a nick in my tool. And like I said above, I don't consider myself to be particularly skilled, so I think that if I can maintain an 8000 grit edge with only a few minutes worth of touch up, anyone can.

By the way, I read that hoary old chestnut of yours a few years ago when I first started woodworking and getting my brain wrapped around sharpening, and it did help me a lot, even if I wound up using an 8000 grit stone for my final sharpening step. :@)

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#33

Re: I know of someone that sharpens this way...

David Charlesworth

>As was said earlier, I move straight from an 800 grit stone to a 10,000 grit stone.

But this is done with very small bevels and a change of 2 degrees in honing angle.

01 steel gets three strokes on the polishing stone and A2 gets four.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#34

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Sgian Dubh

>Wilbur, as long as that procedure works effectively for you, that's all that matters. In my case I generally don't see a need for a very fine edge, with the rider that it does need to be sharp.

Most planing and chiseling isn't seen in the end product. For instance, the pared insides of hand cut dovetail parts aren't seen, nor are the results of the initial truing and squaring of wood if you're working entirely by hand. In the latter case the surfaces don't need to be particularly good as long as they're flat and square. It's at the final prepping stage that these surfaces need to be good. Oddly enough, I generally have four planes on the go at the prepping stage, particularly when working on large panels; three smoothing planes and a block plane.

My smoothing planes are sharpened and set approximately as follows:

* sharp and 'coarsely' set.

* 'pretty sharp' and 'finely' set.

* 'super sharp' and 'very finely' set.

Lastly, the block plane is 'super sharp' and 'extremely finely' set.

I suspect the reason I use this system are fairly obvious-- it saves me a lot of knob twiddling and I just pick up whichever plane is right for the task in hand.

However, I find it always takes significantly longer to keep my 'super sharp' planes 'super sharp' than it takes me to keep my 'sharp' planes 'sharp'. I hope that all made sense. Merry Christmas by the way. Slainte.