Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening
Sgian Dubh
>The ceramic stone I mostly use now just happens to be 800 grit Pam, or at least I'm pretty sure that's what it said on the box when I purchased it several years ago. If I use a combination oilstone, as seen in the web page I linked you to, I use the 'fine' side of the stone to get the edge sharp. I don't know what the oil-stone manufacturer meant when they described one side as 'coarse' and the other 'fine'. The fine side is fine enough to get a good edge for 95% of all the work I do, as is the 800 grit face of the ceramic stone. I have a finer stone or two if I want to to get an edge better suited to final prep work or for particularly awkward grain.
I didn't suggest that dull tools are a good thing- I don't use blunt tools, never have (except maybe when I was an inexperienced beginner back in the late 1960s and probably didn't know any better) and never will. Blunt tools are about as much use as a chocolate fireguard and, as you say, can be dangerous.
I don't believe the discussions that make sharpening a complicated and involved process are very helpful to any furniture maker, amateur or professional, that's trying to be efficient and productive. There's little productive benefit in sharpening if it involves multiple stages and takes a lot of time to get an edge with mirror bright planes leading up to that edge. I can understand that such conversations can be of great interest to woodworkers unmotivated by efficiency and productivity; these woodworkers are driven by a different drum-beat than the one that drives woodworkers that aim to be productive and efficient.
In business, for example, sharpening is, out of necessity, a short process. It generally takes no more than a few minutes to disassemble a plane, touch up the edge of the iron, reassemble it all and to get back to work. If I see a working furniture maker spend more than four or five minutes going through this disassembly, touch up, and reassembly process before making more shavings I seriously question if the maker is skilled enough for all the other tasks required of him or her to make a living. Slainte.