Seconary bevels and BU plane blades *LINK*
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>You said...."BU plane blades require a secondary microbevel off a (roughly) 25 degree hollow grind." Please clarify this sentence, and, why do BU irons require a secondary bevel?
Hi Bill
I was referring to planes other than small block planes, although you may include the latter if the cutting angle is to increase beyond 37 degrees, the lowest angle commonly used.
Some of this is all basic stuff, which I am sure you will recognise when you read it. Some is stuff I take for granted now, as hopefully many do as well, but still may be new information for others.
Here goes ...
The cutting angle of a BU plane comes from the combination of the bed angle and the bevel angle. So a 12 degree bed plus a 25 degree bevel creates a 37 degree cutting angle. This is good for end grain. It is the commonest angle used in a block plane. I just grind a hollow at 25 degrees and hone directly on that. In other words, no secondary bevel needed.
If you want a higher cutting angle, you can simply add a higher primary bevel and hone that. For example, Lee Valley sell blades for their BU planes that are 38 degrees (for a 50 degree cutting angle) and a 50 degree version (for a 62 degree cutting angle). The limitation of these blades is that you can only use them with a straight bevel. They cannot be cambered.
There are two reasons for using a secondary bevel.
Firstly, it is a short-cut to obtaining a high cutting angle. Secondary bevels, especially a micro secondary bevel, require very little honing effort. A secondary bevel lies at a higher angle to the primary bevel. For example, you may want a smoother with a 50 degree cutting angle (York pitch). This will require a secondary bevel of 38 degrees to add to the 12 degree bed angle (the primary bevel angle plays no part here - it may be anything).
Keep in mind that the accuracy needed demands the use of a honing guide.
Stay with me here ...
Secondly, once you want a high cutting angle with a camber it becomes complicated, and you will only be able to achieve this with efficiency by using a secondary bevel. For some years BU planes were considered problematical as the camber required on them was considerably greater than on an equivalent BD plane. This increased camber is due to the geometry of the bed angle.
If you considered just honing the primary bevel at 38 degrees, the result will be a thick bevel that will resist cambering. That is the problem that everyone was experiencing.
About two years ago I came up with a solution, one that made adding a camber to a BU plane blade as easy as adding one to a BD plane blade.
Simply, it is easier to use a 25 degree primary bevel and add a micro secondary bevel of 38 degrees. At 25 degrees, there is significantly less steel to grind and a camber is relatively easy work.
This becomes even more relevant as the cutting angle increases, to say 60 degrees.
I wrote an article outlining all this in some detail a few years ago. I even recruited a mathematician to calculate the accuracy of my logic, which happily was correct. Link below.
Regards from Perth
Derek
The Secret to Cambering Bevel Up Plane Blades