Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Posts

Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#1

Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Nathan Pettigrew

>Somewhere along the way, I remember seeing an article or post about sharpening that suggested that going from 1000 to 4000 to 8000 grit waterstones wasn't necessary. The author suggested that going directly from 1000 to 8000 was just fine.

I can't remember where I saw this, though.

Does anyone happening to know where this comes from or have any first hand experience they could share on that?

I want to say it was from Chris Schwarz, but I'm not certain on that. Googling hasn't turned anything up on it.

Thanks all,

Nathan

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#2

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey

>Last night I happened to be perusing an old (2005?) issue of Woodworking magazine. In it there was an article on chisel sharpening in which Chris says that Charlesworth recently convinced him that it was not necessary. Hope that puts you on the trail to what you're lookin for.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#3

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Going from 1000 to 8000, skipping an intermediate grit, will take more time to clean up the scratch pattern from the 1000. If you are using a microbevel, the time difference will be negligible.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#4

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Ron Hock

>IMO, the only risk in skipping grit steps is that you may need to work on the finer stone too long, wearing it more than you would have if you hadn't skipped. You could do all your sharpening on 8000-grit, but it would be slow and you'd use up a lot of stones.

I've heard complaints that some stones are so soft they need flattening while sharpening a blade. To me, that indicates working too long on that stone. If you find this happening, try adding an intermediary grit. Not sure if it will save any time in the long run but, like rotating tires, your stones should wear more evenly.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#5

Quicker even than that.

Bob Hackett

>I think one of the diamond gurus was saying he went directly from the grinder to either 1 or .5 micron diamond and it still took less than 5 minutes to sharpen.

Perhaps one of them will ring in here to say if my memory is fading or not.

MB

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#6

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Nathan Pettigrew

>Thanks Ben, that was it. Sept 2004 Woodworking Magazine, "Sharpen a Chisel".

Thanks!

Nathan

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#7

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Nathan Pettigrew

>Ron,

Thanks for your reply. I've been looking at improving my basics and started with sharpening. I've got a generic 1000/4000 grit waterstone and wanted to see if I could do a little better. WW funds are tight and I thought if I could reduce the number of stones I needed that'd be more money for tools, wood, books, etc...

Looking forward to your book, it's on my list.

Thanks,

Nathan

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#8

Welcome, Ron, and also....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Great to see you here, Ron! According to your website, looks like the new sharpening book will be out momentarily. Congratulations!

On the original topic raised by Nathan....I happen to like middle stones. Going back to the 3000g waterstone sold by Japan Woodworker. Actually, they still sell it. I about wore mine out one long afternoon on an S53 Holtey blade, before I learned it was an unsharpenable blade with anything less than diamond. Now I have a natural aoto stone, which I would guess is in the 2000 to 5000 range somewhere. Really a favorite stone.

Why is that aoto so useful? For one thing, it is exactly right for knives, if you ask me. All kinds of knives. And hammer faces. And scratch stock blades. I mean, not everything is a plane blade or chisel or gouge. And not all sharpening begins at 1000g....Does anyone else out there like to sharpen chisels frequently as you use them? You're sharpening a sharp chisel. Only takes a couple seconds to touch up on the fly; picked this up from one of James Krenov's books. They never get dull that way, and you never have a handful of dull chisels to go sit and sharpen, like I used to do many years ago. Do the same thing with other blades, where I don't want to use it down to dullness. Couple of licks on that aoto stone, and then a finish stone, and you have your original edge back in under 10 seconds. 4000g would serve the same function.

I basically agree with the contention about 1000g to 8000g, with Ron's caveat, but there are so many other situations where a middle stone is the very thing you want.

Wiley

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#9

I Plead Guilty

Steve Elliott

>While I don't consider myself any kind of guru, I have posted about going directly from my grinder (a Tormek) to my finest polishing stone which is currently a 15,000x Shapton. Even on a 1-1/2 or 2-inch chisel the honing takes less than a minute, done freehand at a slightly greater angle than the bevel of the grind.

My grinding takes longer than five minutes because I'm a fanatic about getting the edge exactly square. I use the standard Square Edge Jig and it takes a few adjustments to get the chisel rotated just right so that the cutting edge will be perpendicular to the centerline of the chisel. (Most chisels taper in width a little toward the handle so each corner should be slightly more acute than 90 degrees.)

To rehone between grindings I lay the concave ground surface on a coarser stone and hone until I have a wire edge, then quickly hone a microbevel at the cutting edge.

I generally withdraw from discussions that focus on how quickly something can be done. Instead I decide on the sort of result I want to go for and look for ways to achieve that result quickly. For sharpening that has made me concentrate on accurate grinding.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#10

Re: Quicker even than that + The real answer.

ThomD

>You can go directly from a grinding stone to the green buffing compound, that is pretty much the fastest, not that anyone is in a hurry. I thin that in the Frid method, and I have used it, on those occasions when the only thing in the clear was my dry grinder with a hard felt and a vitrious wheels.

Also, with sharpening, there is little generalization possibly. You either need to copy very closely or work out your own system. Different tools, often unpredictably will sharpen at different rate. If you chisel is a better match for, say, the King 8000 stone than mine, it may come up quicker. If you are a better sharpener, and round less, etc... There are so many factors that determine what one person will get by with while another will not.

That said, my base waterstone system is is two 800 stones, a 1500 a 4000 norton, and a 8000 King. that's the one that hits the bucket when I travel.

But even after that is said, you can outperform on practical sharpening, most waterstones, most days, with a block of maple and a couple of grits sandpaper. So if money is the issue...

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#11

Hammers?

wilbur

>Um, what do you need to do to a hammer with an aoto? Hammers don't need to be that sharp, I'm sure. :@)

I know there is a reason for this -- I'm just being dense here.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#12

Re: Hammers?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

Sometimes I get real lucky and obtain old used hammers, like blacksmith dogs head hammers, which are great in all sizes. I like to polish the face on these, after sandpapering em smooth. World wouldn't come to an end if I didn't do this, though.

Wiley

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#13

It depends

wilbur

>I think that the issue of choosing between going to 1000 directly to 8000 or making a stop in between at 4000 can't really be isolated from your particular system of sharpening.

It is absolutely true that the only difference between going 1000 -> 8000 and 1000 -> 4000 -> 8000 is time. It's also interesting to note that pretty much everyone who has advocated this uses a sharpening system that culminates in honing a relatively narrow strip of metal: hollow grinding, ruler trick, microbevels, etc. With these techniques, you wind up honing a fairly narrow strip of metal to get the final edge on your tool.

On the other hand, if you don't use these techniques, you'll probably find the 4000 grit waterstone much more helpful. Me, I have a flat bevel on my plane blades and chisels, so I use an intermediate step between the 1000 grit and the 8000 grit steps.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#14

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Nathan, if you already have a 4000 stone, I can't see any reason why you would want to skip it. Making a big jump between stones takes a lot of extra time and there is a big danger that you will be only polishing the tops of the ridges, not completely smoothing out the scratches made by the coarse stone. I think skipping grits was suggested for those who want to sharpen without much outlay.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#15

Polishing hammers?

Bob Hackett

>The biggest reason to polish the face of a hammer is because whatever defects are in the hammer face will be imprinted in reverse on whatever you hit every time you hit it.

The problem with having highly polished hammers,and most serious metalworkers have them,is that they seem to attract unknowing hands.The pretty ones are the first ones to be grabbed in your absence and usually used to beat rocks,bust up concrete,etc. before their return.:^(

MB

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#16

I'm guilty as charged.

victor parisian

>

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#17

Re: I'm guilty as charged.

Bob Hackett

>When I worked in a yacht yard seems like my good hammers were always being loaned to the divers.

I finally caught the guy doing the loaning(one of the managers) and asked him why.It was his opinion that a shiny hammer,if dropped,would pick up the light better and be easier to find.

The next day I made a locking bar to go over my hammer rack,on company time.

MB

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#18

When to skip 4000 grit and when not.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Nathan

Indeed you can skip the 4000 stone, as others have stated, as long as you are honing a microbevel.

For chisels (Western and Japanese) and plane blades I first grind a hollow on the Tormek or an 8" grinder. I only use the Tormek on laminated blades. My aim here is to get as close to the edge of the bevel face as possible, and to do so at the angle I wish to hone. This excludes blades for BU planes, which need a secondary bevel (a bevel at a higher angle to the primary bevel).

The closer to the edge of the bevel face you get, the smaller the microbevel can be. The smaller the microbevel, the less surface area to hone, and the fewer grits you need for the bevel edge.

I use a Shapton 1000 to flatten and straighten the bevel face (I do not attempt to strop directly off a grinder). This requires between 3 and 5 freehand strokes (a hollow grind makes freehanding the edge a doddle). For BD plane blades I then add the camber by leaning on the corner of the blade. This is another 3 strokes. From the 1000 grit I go to a 12/15000 Shapton. Again 3-5 strokes is all that is needed.

BU plane blades require a secondary microbevel off a (roughly) 25 degree hollow grind. The secondary bevel needs to be added with a honing guide, but the size of the bevel and the number of strokes is the same as when freehanding a BD blade.

For the bevel face you can see only 2 stones are needed, and the time taken can be under 2 minutes if the hollow is ground. However, the back of the blade needs to be as smooth as the bevel edge, and this broader area of steel will require more stones. This is where you will need to use your 4000 grit to establish the surface. Once this is done, however, you only ever remove the wire edge on your final polishing stone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#19

please elaborate the BU statement

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You said...."BU plane blades require a secondary microbevel off a (roughly) 25 degree hollow grind." Please clarify this sentence, and, why do BU irons require a secondary bevel?

You make this requirement statement like it is common knowledge but I have not encountered this claim before. Because we all own at least one BU plane ( a block plane) the reasons will be of general interest. I haven't been sharpening my BU irons this way and I am wondering what I am missing. The nuisance of requiring a jigging step would require that the benefit of the secondary bevel be compelling.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#20

Re: please elaborate the BU statement *LINK*

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

Derek is probably talking about a bevel up bench plane, where the bevel angle on the blade can be tweaked to change the effective cutting angle. You could change the bevel angle for the whole face of the plane blade, but it's much more efficient to just hone a microbevel to the angle desired.

I could go on about how and why this is useful, but the Lee Valley folks do a much better job in their instructions for their low angle jack plane.

Actually, you could do the same thing to a block plane, but most people that I know don't tweak a block plane in this way.


Lee Valley instructions for low angle jack plane

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#21

Seconary bevels and BU plane blades *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>You said...."BU plane blades require a secondary microbevel off a (roughly) 25 degree hollow grind." Please clarify this sentence, and, why do BU irons require a secondary bevel?

Hi Bill

I was referring to planes other than small block planes, although you may include the latter if the cutting angle is to increase beyond 37 degrees, the lowest angle commonly used.

Some of this is all basic stuff, which I am sure you will recognise when you read it. Some is stuff I take for granted now, as hopefully many do as well, but still may be new information for others.

Here goes ...

The cutting angle of a BU plane comes from the combination of the bed angle and the bevel angle. So a 12 degree bed plus a 25 degree bevel creates a 37 degree cutting angle. This is good for end grain. It is the commonest angle used in a block plane. I just grind a hollow at 25 degrees and hone directly on that. In other words, no secondary bevel needed.

If you want a higher cutting angle, you can simply add a higher primary bevel and hone that. For example, Lee Valley sell blades for their BU planes that are 38 degrees (for a 50 degree cutting angle) and a 50 degree version (for a 62 degree cutting angle). The limitation of these blades is that you can only use them with a straight bevel. They cannot be cambered.

There are two reasons for using a secondary bevel.

Firstly, it is a short-cut to obtaining a high cutting angle. Secondary bevels, especially a micro secondary bevel, require very little honing effort. A secondary bevel lies at a higher angle to the primary bevel. For example, you may want a smoother with a 50 degree cutting angle (York pitch). This will require a secondary bevel of 38 degrees to add to the 12 degree bed angle (the primary bevel angle plays no part here - it may be anything).

Keep in mind that the accuracy needed demands the use of a honing guide.

Stay with me here ...

Secondly, once you want a high cutting angle with a camber it becomes complicated, and you will only be able to achieve this with efficiency by using a secondary bevel. For some years BU planes were considered problematical as the camber required on them was considerably greater than on an equivalent BD plane. This increased camber is due to the geometry of the bed angle.

If you considered just honing the primary bevel at 38 degrees, the result will be a thick bevel that will resist cambering. That is the problem that everyone was experiencing.

About two years ago I came up with a solution, one that made adding a camber to a BU plane blade as easy as adding one to a BD plane blade.

Simply, it is easier to use a 25 degree primary bevel and add a micro secondary bevel of 38 degrees. At 25 degrees, there is significantly less steel to grind and a camber is relatively easy work.

This becomes even more relevant as the cutting angle increases, to say 60 degrees.

I wrote an article outlining all this in some detail a few years ago. I even recruited a mathematician to calculate the accuracy of my logic, which happily was correct. Link below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Secret to Cambering Bevel Up Plane Blades

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#23

Thank you

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I would not have figured that out for myself! And, as usual your answer was detailed and clear.

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#24

Re: It depends

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It also depends on when in the process you resort to sharpening. When I'm in fine fettle, I sharpen a chisel just as it begins to go dull, and in that case the first stone is 5000 and is very fast. If I wait until it goes dull enough to use a 1000 stone, I castigate myself and go 1000 or 2000 to 5000 to 8000. Really, the only time I need to go to 1000 or less is when I'm seeing a chisel for the first time.

Pam

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

#25

Re: Skipping 4000 grit when sharpening

Sgian Dubh

>All, this is all rather interesting, this talk of going to 1000, 4000 and 8000 grit stones to sharpen plane irons and chisels.

It's fascinating because I seldom go any finer than 800 grit to sharpen any of my tools. I've never found any real advantage to going finer than this except for the final skimming before a bit of abrasive paper in prep work. I've also never noticed any benefit to sharpening chisels finer than this for general purpose joinery work.

I admit to sharpening a bit more when the wood is particularly difficult, eg, one of the Okker species or if the wood is particularly wild-grained, but that's about it. I generally don't find the additional time and effort required to work on the edges to get them that sharp beneficial enough to warrant it. Slainte.