Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Random thoughts: pocket knives

Posts

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#26

Re: The perils of clip knives

Richard Jones

>Bill,

My last on this matter, as it's getting sort of silly.

It's certainly irresponsible to scratch a nice chair with anything, whether it be a knife, keys, jeans rivets, belt buckles, etc. Sounds like they need some lessons on manners or somewhere different to sit.

I really don't consider my knives large, and one blade is all I've ever needed at any given time. I guess you could pull the end blades of a Stockman out at the same time if you wanted, tho' I'm at a loss to know why.

IMHO, if you're able to use your knife for podiatry hygiene, it's not really a knife. And anyway, that's way too much information.........

As I stated previously, simply purchase one of these well designed, great-steeled clip knives and remove the clip. Now you have a great pocketknife and no accursed clip to boot (boot knives are a whole different subject).

You carry what you want, I'll carry what I want. Isn't that as it should be? The perils of pocket vs clip knives is best left for other venues/forums.

BTW, anyone who doesn't use A2 chisels is just wrong. :)

Rich

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#27

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Richard Jones

>I forgot, I also wear a Leatherman all the time. My daughter gave me one for Father's Day years ago and I thought: I'll never wear that monstrosity! A day rarely goes by when I don't pull it out multiple times for whatever. I've worn one out and am on the second.

Yes, good thread. A knife is as good a hand tool as it gets.

Rich

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#28

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Victor Parisian

>I carried a 1957 Case XX large Stockman for umpteen years. Had to mail it to myself from the airport twice, and once left it with a money changer at the airport (when the mail system was closed) where I retrieved it on my return trip. It was usually the first thing in my pocket every morning and the last thing out at night.

Recently replaced it with a more current/quality knockoff, as I got thinking it was stupid to carry the old knife and risk loosing it on a job site or worse yet, break a blade probing joints in concrete. I put it up somewhere safe awhile back and haven't seen it since.

Victor - in Houston

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#29

Re: always; who uses good steel?

James Watriss

>There are a few examples from production places like Benchmade and Spyderco. Their stock in trade is the bigger knives with pocket clips, but if you look through their offerings, you'll find a few that are reasonably made with good steel. You'll pay good money, but they're worth it, IMO.

Google the Spyderco Kiwi, or the Benchmade switchback, for a start...

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#30

not me....I'm a desk jockey and work from home

Chris Friesen

>I guess I'm the exception. I work from home doing software for a living...rarely need a knife at my desk. I've got knives galore in the kitchen and in the shop, so I don't generally carry one in my pocket.

Now going camping or hiking is a different story. Got a Victorinox swisstool and a couple different knives for that.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#31

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

James Watriss

>Almost always.

My typical EDC (every day carry) are big Benchmade knives... big by the standards displayed in here, anyway... usually somewhere between 3 and 4 inches in length. I probably don't need that much blade, but I use them all the time for just about everything. One's got a blade of D2, one of M2, and a recent purchase is made of M4.

I do carry a leatherman from time to time, too. Like Wiley, I have the Wave version, but I had to add studs to the blades for one-handed opening, as the blades are sharp, but they're also narrow enough that I'd end up slicing a thin piece of skin from my thumb when I tried to open the blade. (The Blade would depress into the pad of my thumb, and then rotate around as it opened...)

I stick with the single bladed knife more often than not, since it's generally most of what I need... and because the leatherman comes with a little curse in the box: Whenever you forget to put it on your belt, inevitably you'll need it for something that day. But if you're used to not having it, it's not as much of a big deal.

I will say that the absent-minded habit of loading a pocket knife into my back pocket has come close to getting me in trouble a few times. I've had to take the knife out and stash it under bushes, or in the hole of a jersey barrier, when I'm out and about, and going to visit a place with metal detectors... or when I went down to visit my cousin in DC. My knife AND leatherman spent half the day under a bush next to a public fountain while I was enjoying some of the Smithsonian museums and such. It's amazing what people don't notice sometimes.

Last thought... I'm dismayed by the diminishing prominence that knives have in everyday life. It used to be that the ability to safely use a knife was one of the hallmarks of a boy scout, and having a knife on you was generally perceived as a useful thing. But now, what with zero tolerance for knives and scissors and anything else that's 'obviously dangerous', things have really taken a turn. A twisted newspaper has enough tensile strength to strangle someone... but thankfully, they still allow newspapers in schools.

Even if all I'm carrying is a 2.5" blade, people seem to think I'm a dangerous guy who's going to hurt them... this while they keep an 8" serrated steak knife in their desk at work. Who's kidding who here?

It's a simple case of cart before the horse... Where there's a will there's a way... if someone wants to hurt you, they'll figure out how. But the presence of a way to do so does not imply that there's also the will to do so. I get that people feel the need to be scared or intimidated by various objects. I just wish that a backlash would come around, and people would realize that it's an Angry Person who's dangerous, and not a simple hand tool. I'm more worried about a 5th grade with ADHD, bad parents, and a sharpened pencil than I am about a good hearted high school kid with a swiss army knife. It's the person, not the object that is the problem.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#32

I tend to like the German ones...

John in NM

>I have a tiny Boker my grandfather gave me, and I've recently been carrying a Bulldog that I bought from that same website. I tend to favor carbon blades myself, but I don't think there's really a whole lot to be said against stainless. My only real complaint with Collector Knives company is that they require online payments via paypal, or send a conventional payment.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#33

Re: always; who uses good steel?

Greg B�tit, Vergennes, VT

>I agree with your assessment of the Swiss Army knife steel. Mine takes and keeps a sharp edge very well. I have carried a "Hunter" model for the past 15 years. It doesn't have all the gagetry (a plus from my perspective) and has a respectible 3" lock blade. I'm on my second one- I left the first one on the Post Office counter after using it to open mail a couple years back. I use the blade the most, the corkscrew second most (wife likes wine, and I like popping corks without gizmos). Or maybe the bottle opener, since it is also a screw driver and a can opener.

greg

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#34

scott grandstaff

Asleep at the wheel, naturally :)

scott grandstaff

>There are really bad knives???

I haven't met many, and I've looked! Most every knife is good for something! They just don't come with instructions.

Modern factory knives are plenty good enough. Especially if you like plastic and harder than the hooves of hades the sharpen. I have some. Have had more.

The steel comes in many flavors now as it always has.

If you like the hardest knife that will last the longest, well there are plenty. They will be fragile though so save these for delicate cutting.

Some of it is so hard you probably won't get a really great edge unless you have little else to do with your time and make a project of it.

I am not sure why anyone wants to spend so long on one edge they then have to baby, when a new edge (when you need one) is always better and who wants to work so hard??

I do love the spring assists, and thumb studs and liner locks, front locks, middle locks, tail locks. They're all good!!

But vintage steel was a complete miracle in my opinion. Especially in the 1830-1930 period. People really cared because almost everyone knew how, at least slightly, to sharpen, (not just us weirdos), so the older stuff is softer but at the same time "stickier" of an egde.

Not so soft it won't hold up plenty long, but soft enough to "set" an edge on the fly or resharpen from go, in a hurry.

I would much rather have a truly sharp knife I can redo in moments, that something I could barely sharpen in hours that won't improve as I work.

I think a good knife should be able to deliver a comfortable shave and then accidently hit a piece of barbed wire, and be able to recover back to scalpel sharp in 5 minutes time.

Blades come in about 12 standard blade shapes. Drop points are enormously popular now. Mainly due to a dude name of Bob Loveless who started a fad that has not relented these past 3 decades.

But clips held the reins for the previous 100 years. Most popular in the americas, hands down.

Before that, the sheepsfoot was top dog, especially with sailors when sailors undeniably controlled the world.

And even before that, the simple spear. Back into stones, the spear.

I carry a spear. Its not stylish now, but I find it the most universally reliable. Of course, the drop point is so close there is little real difference. I just like the old styles.

Even in the old days companies made their bones on the properties of their steel. Some was hard to the point of being brittle for those who liked to stone their knives for hours and have the very sharpest edges they weren't ever going to abuse.

Or soft as a putty knife for the paint can opening crowd who would snap a very hard blade the first day.

There is a knife for every man out there, and they don't get that way by accident. Keep looking

I know many will go on and on about the most expensive and use any pocketknife discussion to brag about how much money they have, and how you are nobody if you don't spend the most.

In this modern time when so few actually make anything themselves, shopping new merchandise and spending money is a very big deal. People agonize and get insecure about it constantly.

But for my meager time and money, --every-- knife show, (and there is one within a days drive wherever you are if you can read this in English), will have shoeboxes and buckets full of the pre WW11 German (Solingen), ditto period Case, Wolstenholm, and Swiss/Swedish (they always swapped steel),

that will more than suffice for a blade you can bet your life on, for around $10.

Get you a bone handle.

Stag is prettier and so is pearl but these past 11,000 years have shown simple bone to be the most utilitarian of any material.

Plastic shows promise. I expect it'll be highly prized and desirable as a material, eventually.

If you simply must buy new goods, try a Bulldog.

These are made in the last surviving Solingen factories.

Or a Case. They still make a few chr/vanadium blades and bone handles if you look (Zippo owns them now, but last I saw there were still a few in the lineup).

Stainless has great promise, and I can't wait for it be great knife steel!!

but I suspect it'll be around another 100 years before its truly perfected,

unless someone gets lucky, or already has, that I haven't found it. All I have known can be very good,

but just not great steel yet.

Support your custom knife maker!

yours Scott

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#35

That's what we played

Steve Elliott

>Until your message I wasn't sure the game I knew from gradeschool (which didn't have any name I was aware of) was the same one I'd read about.

A reporter asked Frank Gilbreth Sr. why he wanted to save time and what he used his spare time for�This is what Gilbreth said in reply: �For work, if you love that best�For education, for beauty, for art, for pleasure�For mumblety-peg, if that�s where your heart lies.�

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#36

Jack Guzman from Maine

Case or Buck

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I always preferred Schrade knives.I liked the soft steel,easy to sharpen.Alot of people were raving about Bucks but I never liked them.The edge angle made it hard to sharpen and the steel was too hard.And then I got my first Case Jr Sodbuster.After a few swipes on the stone that thing was razor sharp. Sure it dulls fast,but I wasn't using it to carve with. I also liked the handles.That hard black stuff(no idea what it is-plastic?)felt good in my hand.Plus the knife didn't need a case.It fit nicely in my pocket without feeling it in there.---Jack

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#37

scott grandstaff

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

scott grandstaff

>I got to thinking it was stupid to carry the old knife and risk loosing it on a job site or worse yet, break a blade probing joints in concrete. I put it up somewhere safe awhile back

Here is a man after my own heart!

I have 3 knives I have "retired" in my knife drawers.

I keep 4 drawers btw. Each holds only about 50 knives average. I decided I can spare this much room in my little house, and no more. So when they overflow, something has to go.

I do have one small drawer of "outgoing" knives ready for a new home.

So anyway, I carried a Solingen Barlow so long I replaced the handles three times. The longest carry of my life. 20 years I carried that knife everyday. Every sharpening, especially toward the end, was so soft and delicate, saving my steel.

I got it free. It had been drowned in the great 64 flood and I found it going through/cleaning up the wreckage at my friends place, Milt the druggist.

I carried a Case whittler, a birthday present from my wife, until the second set of handles, when I used abalone to rehandle it, and decided it was too pretty to carry anymore, after trying to a short time.

I had an Eye brand small trapper I favored for a while but it was stag and the stag had worn smooth and real pocket worn smooth stag is also too pretty to risk.

So they are all in the drawer now.

I carry a second knife at all times. It has been perpetually in my pocket these past 35 years. Same one.

3rd set of handles now, and 2nd spring!

It is a very slim "tuxedo" pattern knife. Its main blade I ground paper thin overall and keep dull. It is my toothpick, also opens mail.

The short blade I keep needle sharp and it digs splinters for a living. I get so worried about this one, I have bought and keep about a dozen replacements. Vintage knives from many makers from many countries, in the exact same pattern.

I can't carry any of them though.

They just aren't the same.

I have gone though some pretty funny gymnastics retrieving that little swell center knife when it wanted to get lost.

I can tell if it is out of my pocket for 10 seconds time,

and the search begins

.... again!

yours Scott

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#38

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

John L Blue

>I used to carry a Gerber knife, now have a Smith & Wesson with a regular blade and a serrated blade.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#39

Re: Case or Buck

Todd Hughes

>I never liked a buck knife, the blades are to thick and can be brittle....I have seen many with broken blades. I really don't know how they have kept in bussiness all these years. I would never buy one for myself.

I collect old knives and an older Case is about as nice a pocket knife that was ever made. I used to carry a premium Case "tested" stockman but realised it was to vauable a knife for everyday carry after a friend almost dropped it over the side while fishing.

I also like cattaraugus and the old New York Knife company knives. I still carry a big single blade NYKC hunter sometimes just for kicks.

Modern knives I like a Gerber, when I worked with horses I carred a Gerber Bolt Action, I got one of the first when they came out. Easy to open with one hand and will take and keep a razor edge, I used mine everyday from cutting bailing twine to cutting a placenta once to save a Foal that was born still in the "bag". I was the only person there that had a knife otherwise it would have died. The horse's owner wanted to buy me a fancy knife but I just asked them to have my name engraved on my old Gerber which they did.

Loaned my knife once to a girl that worked for me to cut hay bales and she dropped it in the deep snow....in a 20 acre field. I looked for hours but gave up hope of ever seeing it again.

...About a month later I had a dream where I was a pirate looking for buried treasure in that field. Went through the gate so many paces and then turned and went so many more and found the treasure chest. Next day I go up to the field and figured what the hey and paced off like in the dream and looked down...and there by my foot was my knife!

...when I got out of the Horses I retired my Gerber, it's beat to crap and long ago lost the thumb piece that opens the blade [you can use the little pin it was attached to though]. Blade is sharpend up but still takes a good edge and no wiggle when open

Recently I found a mint old Gerber Bolt action just like my old one and now I carry it while my old one stays in my safe at home waiting till I die to go back on my belt......Todd

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#40

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>I have a soft spot for knives. OK, that sounded like an invitation for a joke! :>)

Seriously, I have always found pocket knives very useful in day to day life. But nowadays if someone around me needs one and I take out your trusty pocket knife, people tend to look at you like your a terrorist.

I carry a small Swiss Army Knife that was a gift from an old employer almost 15 years ago. That little guy has seen it's fair share of use. I also have one Leatherman that stays at my desk here at work, and a one in the car (I guess I took that Boyscout motto "Be prepared!" seriously).

And I still have my Grandfather's pocket knife which sits on my desk at home (out of reach of my 5 year old of course). And I have dibs on my Dad's Buck knives (Mom still has them) that I bought for him when I was a kid and worked for a sporting goods store. Man, those things saw some use! And they are still probably sharp enough to shave with. Dad never liked letting his knives get dull.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#41

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Pat Riley

>First off, I have to say that I agree completely with what Scott Grandstaff had to say.

That being said, I have always been a Boker Tree Brand fan. Probably because it was the first really good knife I ever got when I was in scouts. A gift from a very talented carver of bolo ties - I think he has carved 60,000 of them by now.

I have been carrying some form of medium stockman for years. I have my 'utility' knives - sharpened at a fairly robust angle - and my carving knives - reshaped and sharpened at a very tight angle.

I tend to buy carbon steel blades, but have a few stainless versions.

You can get a very good Boker on ebay pretty cheap. I think they are one of the last Solingen manufacturers. I believe that any current 'Henckels' or 'Hen and Rooster' knives are made at the Boker factory.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#42

Well...

Jeff Schmidt

>....given Derek's profession, it is probably a recommended he not meet with his patients with a Bowie strapped to his side.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#44

Re: I prefer a nice...

Dan Donaldson

>Kinda hard to trim your nails with it though;-)

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#45

I'll pass on dinner......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>........If that is what you clean rabbits with.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#46

pocketknives......

Edward in Vancouver

>One of the biggest things to convince me to carry a pocket knife was my uh.."stint" in the Swiss Army. There I was issued a standard "Soldatsmesser" or soldier's knife. (Both Victorinox and Wenger make these for the Swiss Army.) Nothing special, cross-hatched aluminum scles, one main blade, one can opner, one screwdriver, one awl. The blade could be honed fairly sharp--looses it's edge quickly, but could also be honed quickly too. The can opener was used alot for field rations.... What was special was "Sackbefehl" or "pocket orders", that is, you ALWAYS had to have the knife, a hank of string, ear plugs, and field bandages on your person. Failure to comply resulted in dealing with the mood and creativity of your immediate supervisor....

The habit stayed with me for years. I tend to like cheap knives as I lend them or loose them frequently.