Asleep at the wheel, naturally :)
scott grandstaff
>There are really bad knives???
I haven't met many, and I've looked! Most every knife is good for something! They just don't come with instructions.
Modern factory knives are plenty good enough. Especially if you like plastic and harder than the hooves of hades the sharpen. I have some. Have had more.
The steel comes in many flavors now as it always has.
If you like the hardest knife that will last the longest, well there are plenty. They will be fragile though so save these for delicate cutting.
Some of it is so hard you probably won't get a really great edge unless you have little else to do with your time and make a project of it.
I am not sure why anyone wants to spend so long on one edge they then have to baby, when a new edge (when you need one) is always better and who wants to work so hard??
I do love the spring assists, and thumb studs and liner locks, front locks, middle locks, tail locks. They're all good!!
But vintage steel was a complete miracle in my opinion. Especially in the 1830-1930 period. People really cared because almost everyone knew how, at least slightly, to sharpen, (not just us weirdos), so the older stuff is softer but at the same time "stickier" of an egde.
Not so soft it won't hold up plenty long, but soft enough to "set" an edge on the fly or resharpen from go, in a hurry.
I would much rather have a truly sharp knife I can redo in moments, that something I could barely sharpen in hours that won't improve as I work.
I think a good knife should be able to deliver a comfortable shave and then accidently hit a piece of barbed wire, and be able to recover back to scalpel sharp in 5 minutes time.
Blades come in about 12 standard blade shapes. Drop points are enormously popular now. Mainly due to a dude name of Bob Loveless who started a fad that has not relented these past 3 decades.
But clips held the reins for the previous 100 years. Most popular in the americas, hands down.
Before that, the sheepsfoot was top dog, especially with sailors when sailors undeniably controlled the world.
And even before that, the simple spear. Back into stones, the spear.
I carry a spear. Its not stylish now, but I find it the most universally reliable. Of course, the drop point is so close there is little real difference. I just like the old styles.
Even in the old days companies made their bones on the properties of their steel. Some was hard to the point of being brittle for those who liked to stone their knives for hours and have the very sharpest edges they weren't ever going to abuse.
Or soft as a putty knife for the paint can opening crowd who would snap a very hard blade the first day.
There is a knife for every man out there, and they don't get that way by accident. Keep looking
I know many will go on and on about the most expensive and use any pocketknife discussion to brag about how much money they have, and how you are nobody if you don't spend the most.
In this modern time when so few actually make anything themselves, shopping new merchandise and spending money is a very big deal. People agonize and get insecure about it constantly.
But for my meager time and money, --every-- knife show, (and there is one within a days drive wherever you are if you can read this in English), will have shoeboxes and buckets full of the pre WW11 German (Solingen), ditto period Case, Wolstenholm, and Swiss/Swedish (they always swapped steel),
that will more than suffice for a blade you can bet your life on, for around $10.
Get you a bone handle.
Stag is prettier and so is pearl but these past 11,000 years have shown simple bone to be the most utilitarian of any material.
Plastic shows promise. I expect it'll be highly prized and desirable as a material, eventually.
If you simply must buy new goods, try a Bulldog.
These are made in the last surviving Solingen factories.
Or a Case. They still make a few chr/vanadium blades and bone handles if you look (Zippo owns them now, but last I saw there were still a few in the lineup).
Stainless has great promise, and I can't wait for it be great knife steel!!
but I suspect it'll be around another 100 years before its truly perfected,
unless someone gets lucky, or already has, that I haven't found it. All I have known can be very good,
but just not great steel yet.
Support your custom knife maker!
yours Scott