Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Random thoughts: pocket knives

Posts

Random thoughts: pocket knives

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Random thoughts: pocket knives

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Yesterday I had to cut some string while laying out a structure I'm building. I have misplaced my Case Jr. Sodbuster pocketknife so I had to use the blade on my Leatherman to cut the string.In the process of trying to get the blade unfolded I cut myself .Those blades are sharp!

Anyhow sitting here thinking about replacing my Case I got to wondering. How many of you carry a pocketknife? It seems to me it goes along with the tendency to shape wood.I have had a knife of some sort in my pocket since I was a young boy.---Jack

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#2

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Philip Duffy

>Jack, Would feel naked without at least one pocket knife. Never can tell when you might have to harvest a road kill, or cut a piece of string. Phil

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#3

I've carried a pocketknife every day

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>since I was a kid. Except, of course, when it was inappropriate, e.g., I decided at the last minute to not try to get it into the White House back in 1983.

I've carried SAK, Buck Esquire, Gerber, SAK mini, Spyderco, several cheapie Imperials, and at this moment I have a little SAK and a Laguiole in my pocket. You never know when an apple will need cutting.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I carry a small Swiss Army knife with me virtually all the time, and unless it's a 'dress-uo' sort of event, I generally have a Gerber spring assisted knife clipped to my pants pocket for easy access.

Prior to those two, I've carried, Case, Gerber, Spyderco, and Buck folders. For some of my Marine Corps time, I carried a Fairbairn-sykes, but that was for a different purpose entirely...

Jim D.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#5

always; who uses good steel?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Back to my earliest memory I carried a knife. There was some game we played with knives but I don't remember it. Now days I would be kicked out of school for carrying one and I have to remember when to leave it at home or in the car or it will be confiscated.

We could get into the same discussion with knives as tools. All the ones I own are heat treated too soft for my preference. The steel used in most of the knives I own can't be sharpened to a high degree and they all seem to be heat treated for easy sharpening not good edge retention. One draw across a bone and they are too dull to cut skin or meat. (not so with my custom 3V steel skinner!)Ditto for the kitchen knives. My store bought knife with the best steel is a Swiss Army Knife but I prefer a knife with less gadgets (actually I prefer a Stockman for farm usage).

Does any company make a pocket knife and use one of the best knife steels (note, I said pocket knife not one of the pocket busting clip knives)?

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#6

Re: always; who uses good steel?

Bob Hackett

>Bill,

Don`t know about the new Case steel but the old Sodbusters were always a safe bet for me as were any of the old Schrades or Camillus folders.

AFA new steel goes,I am now carrying a very thin Spyderco that I`ve modded to fit my hand.I like it because it has a serrated edge section and that comes in handy.I find the clip a good thing on this one although on thicker knives I tend to remove them.

If you don`t mind a larger diameter knife in your pocket,the Swedish laminated blade folders with the wood handles are good steel.The bolster rotates to lock the blade in place,simple but effective.

Don`t know about your neck of the woods but there seems to be more than a few knife makers up here.If you like the 3V then I`d look a custom maker up and discuss having your dream knife made to order.I`m envisioning tasteful filework,gun metal bolsters,figured wood scales.

Where`s Scott G. when you need him?Probably off melting babbit,or searching for the right spring I suppose.

MB

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#7

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Dan Donaldson

>I carry two of them. One is the little Swiss army with the scissors. I probably use the scissors more than the blade on that one. The other is a Benchmade with an axis lock. I like that one because it is held in my pocket by a clip and I can open it with one hand. (how many times have you needed to cut something where you weren't holding it in one of your hands? Trying to get into your pocket and then open the knife can be a real pain ;-))

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#8

Good kives *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Bill, Mooremaker uses 1095 as does Queen. Queen's other lines, Schatt and Morgan and Robeson, etc., use D2 or stainless. Great Eastern is a new line that uses 1095 and is making some beautiful knives. All of the above, of course, are American-made. Check out the link below for a look at some of these. And also before I forget about it, Case still makes 1095 knives as well as their stainless offerings.


http://www.collectorknives.net/index.html

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#9

Camillus out of business and I believe Schrade too

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#10

Mumbly-peg

Larry Barrett

>The 'game' I remember was mumbly-peg. You and a friend would take turns throwing a pocket knife to stick in the ground. You had to stretch out your foot to touch his knife, then you threw yours and he had to do same. Keep going until someone fell over.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#11

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I carry a number of different knives depending on what I'm wearing. (Can't have a piece of heavy metal weighing down the suit pants). I have a few Case knives, Robeson, Queen, a few Laguioles, My German-made Cat and a French douk douk. Recently Joel was trying to sell Queen congress knives which are an excellent choice for woodworkers but he dropped them because of lack of interest I presume.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#12

Same here

Frank D. in Montreal

>I have the little Swiss Army knife key chain, so it's always on me. Handiest knife/key chain I've ever had (I'm on my fifth one...it's even got a pen and flashlight). When I travel I carry an old Laguiole and a bigger Swiss Army.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#13

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I used to carry a pocket knife most everywhere; but the airport police convinced me that I no longer needed one. (:

Pam

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#14

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Tony Z

>Must be something in the air! This past Sunday or yesterday, I misplaced a Buck pocketknife (single blade, 3" long, USA made) I've carried for a few years.

About a week or three ago, I saw the local Lowes has a Christmas promotion on Case knives, single blade, about 2-1/2" long with genuine Stag sides. Only drawback is the cost of $69.00!

I'll probably give my search for the Buck until this evening, and then pick up the Case.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#15

A woodworker's pocket knife? *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>There are two designs that are old enough and common enough to have been in this country from the beginning. The Texas toothpick design is very much the same as a style of knife that has been popular in France and Spain since the 15th century. Laguiole is just one example of this design. There is evidence that the Barlow dates back to the 17th century or further and is a jack knife of English origin. Indeed the Barlow was probably the most popular design of pocket knife in this coutry for 150 years. Case has stated in their literature that the Stockman has been their most popular design over the years. See the link below for information about the traditional pocket knife designs. One other thing, pocket knives have been around since the time of ancient Rome. The link below also has great info on how knives are made, the blade designs, etc.


http://www.casexx.com/PatternPageFH.asp

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#16

So,don`t buy new.

Bob Hackett

>Very rarely have I been impressed by a knife made by a manufacturer in the last decade.

I tend to follow right behind Bill T. in being disappointed in steel and temper of mid price folders especially.

I`m won over by what I see in the case and then when I can`t stand to be disappointed anymore I give them away to people I don`t like much.Unfortunately they seem to take it as a sign of friendship,till they try to use the knife.;^)

Old steel is a known commodity.There`s a reason the old Camillus,Case,Old Timer,Tree Brand,etc hold their value in flea markets and second hand shops.

Just cause a company is no longer in business doesn`t mean you can`t buy it anymore.Likewise just because a company is STILL in business doesn`t guarantee their present products aren`t mostly crap.

MB

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#17

being different

Richard Jones

>Well, I'm going to be a bit different here and say that you will never see me without a knife, except in court, an airport and probably the shower. I RR carry a BM mini-grip in 154CM and, in the winter, a Jim Burke Snitch in ATS-34. Both great steels (same recipe, different mfg.), and the mini-grip is one of the best knives I've ever carried, bar none. I carry a BM 710 in 154CM while I'm in the shop in my RR. Both the BM's are clips and the Snitch is a necker.

That being said, I can't imagine carrying an old timey nail-clip knife in a pocket, as they are hard to get to, hard to open, have to dig around in other junk to find them, etc. I'm not sure what the term "pocket-busting" means, other than it sounds like the clip isn't adjusted correctly.

If you want a great knife, just buy a BM or Spyderco with D2, 154CM, S30V, etc, and remove the clip. Now it's a pocket knife.

So to answer the question: No, I don't carry a pocket knife, thankfully.

As always, just my $.02.

Rich (yeah, I'm serious about knives)in VA

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#18

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Stephen Shepherd

>The first two real pocket knives I owned and used were Henkles, the first the 'craftsman' and I don't know the name of the smaller one, but they were great knives and after the craftsman went out of production I sold mine.

I now carry a copy of a Revolutionary War clasp knife with a bone handle, (I also have one with a horn handle). I also carry an inexpensive clasp knife with a locking blade, the style is from the 18th century, I have two of these as well.

On social occasions I carry a small tortoise shell handle pen knife to keep my quill properly sharpened and to prepare a cigar. I have one with an ivory handle and one with an ebony handle. I have to be careful with these knives as they are an inch long and easy to misplace.

Stephen

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#19

Guess I'm just a wuss ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>... compared to most of you lot.

I must admit that I have never carried a bowie across my back or in a sheath on my belt. The bulge in my trousers is the real deal and not a pocket full of Cases, Gerbers, or Bucks. I do not have a collection of pocket knives, and would not know 99% of the brand names (I just learned the one's I quoted). However ..

I do carry a knife in my briefcase. You just never know when you may need to remove a stone from a horse's hoof, or a thorn from a lion's paw. Mainly they get used for minor repairs around the office, opening letters, or slicing apples.

It is either this Leatherman Skeletool ..


.. or a Swiss Army type, similar to this one ..


In the shop I may tuck a little carabiner knife into a pocket. These are cute - tiny but handy to sharpen a pencil or slice open a cardboard box (you know, the one that the postman has just delivered from either Lee Valley or Lie Nielsen)..


Not really good enough ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#20

wusses

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of the psychology faculty at my old university, in the 70s, actually did used to wear a hunting knife to work. I'm not sure if he stopped at the request of the police or on his own - the campus police would certainly not allow it these days.

I never asked Victor what purpose it served him. There are precious few opportunities to field dress anything in psychology - textbooks, once skinned, are not much tastier - and chalk is kind of self-sharpening.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#21

What?!

Bob Hackett

>I thought you live in Australia.

Isn`t it like the wild west over there?Doesn`t everyone carry a knife like Crocodile Dundee?

I can`t tell you how disappointed I am that your post didn`t start with "You call that a knife...";^)

MB

PS-I carry a pocket knife but always wear a Leatherman on my belt.It`s a holdover from my Army/biker days.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#22

I'm in awe

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I checked the link. ( It didn't work with Mozilla which I always find annoying.) I had no idea there were so many knives available. They never show up around here. Nor did I know people collected them. (I really don't understand collectors) Maybe that is where all my lost knives wind up?

In any case I should be able to find something serviceable if I can avoid the "collectors premium" some kinds will likely have.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#23

I'm not Derek

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I do think Oz has the occasional city.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#24

The perils of clip knives

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am presuming a "clip knife" is the kind that has a clip and clips on the pocket so as to not wear out the bottom as large knives with acute corners will do (just ask my seamstress ). Both sons-in-law wear them and before I knew it they scratched two Windsor chairs. So if you are visiting someone, check to see where your knife will be located when you sit in an expensive wooden chair.

Personally, I have never had any use for a "pocket" knife that large, nor one with only one blade. I like to keep the blade I use for foot rot separate from that used for apples, in spite of a good cleaning on the jeans.

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

#25

Re: Random thoughts: pocket knives

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>jack,

Part of my retirement uniform is a Leatherman on the belt of my jeans. Now I'm looking at it, it's a Wave model. I picked it because it has a saw blade, which is always handy in the yard for small pruning just walking around. Am forever using the pliers, and sometimes the wire cutter--the wire cutter jaws aren't very hard, so don't last too long in action. The pliers aren't Klein quality, but for what I do, they're just fine.

Tightened up the gate latch the other day with the Phillips screwdriver. One thing I've never used on it is the diamond sharpener blade--gonna have to look around and see what that can be useful for.

It has two blades, but I use the serrated almost exclusively--it'll soon be sharpened down to non-serrated status and I'll get another Leatherman (or equal). Knife blade opens with one hand, which I never realized how important that was until I had one that would do it--it's now a gotta-have. Steel is way soft in the blades. Oh well, it sharpens quickly and mostly what I do with it involves either green wood or envelopes or somesuch where it doesn't matter if it's good steel. The one thing about the soft steel, it makes the serrated blade easy to get a good edge on, and fast.

Great question, jack!

Wiley