Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Help with eggbeater

Posts

Help with eggbeater

#1

Help with eggbeater

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Well, today I received a Goodell-Pratt #5-1/2 hand drill from an ebay seller. 3/8" capacity chuck.

When I put it together, it certainly appears to be a substantial and smooth-running tool. Makes me think a lot of Goodell-Pratt.

But. There's something the matter with the chuck. Does anyone have a drawing or section through a Goodell-Pratt chuck (or any similar chuck style)?

Here's what I see.....The chuck threads onto the main drive shaft of the drill. However, it doesn't go all the way, and the three jaws are out of whack, one running ahead, one lagging. So I unthread the chuck and look inside to see what's going on. The three jaws appear to be tied together into a unit by three springs. Looking down the other end--the threaded end--of the chuck, there is some sort of stud in there. This stud is floating loose. It has one conical end and one flat end.

Does that sound like the original part that's supposed to be there? I would think 'yes', because it couldn't be an odd or end that someone just dropped in--too specialized.

If it is the right part, how does it go? Looks like it would engage the jaws better, if the conical end were aimed into the jaw assembly. Is that how it goes?

Also, is any part missing? What else is supposed to be in there.

Finally, that little stud thing is turned cattywompus in there right now, with the conical end aimed back toward the threaded end of the chuck. Has anyone ever managed to turn that thing around without taking the jaws out of the chuck? And if not, how do you get the jaws out of the chuck?

All help appreciated very much!

Wiley

Re: Help with eggbeater

#2

Maybe success--more questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>With the help of some needlenose pliers, I seem to have the three jaws working together. This is with the conical portion of the little stud facing into the threaded part of the jaw.

However, the jaws do not spring apart when I loosen the chuck--they just wait to be pushed down into the chuck shell, if you want to mount a larger drill. Is that correct?

Also, there is no way I can see to lock the works up to unscrew the chuck--you just have to to get your thumb around the handle and hold it still--is that right?

The jaws on this one don't come to an airtight union like the little Yankee 1530 from Bill Houghton.

Thanks,

WIley

Thinking that little Yankee 1530 is a great piece of engineering. It was the very thing for getting the holes drilled for glass stops in my wall cabinet yesterday.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#3

Re: Help with eggbeater

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

The parts to the chuck are correct. The three jaws have a small spring between each one. The loose part with the conical end pushes the jaws up and down.

The chuck is taken apart by unscrewing the base, the end with the two little holes. It doesn't look like it should unscrew but it will.

The conical end of that loose part should point toward the main shaft.

Marv

Re: Help with eggbeater

#4

Re: Maybe success--more questions

Marv

>Wiley,

Not all chucks close completely, especially the 3/8 and up.

To tighten onto a drill, yes, you hold the crank on the large gear.

When you get it apart and remove the jaws, use some 400 sandpaper and light oil and sand the inside surface of the chuck housing and also clean the jaws and make sure there are no dings and dents on the sides.

Marv

Re: Help with eggbeater

#5

Re: Help with eggbeater

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks a lot Marv! I saw those two holes on the upper end of the chuck, looks like they're intended for a special wrench. But like you say, even if you look at it real hard, it looks like a one piece machining. When I look under magnification, I can see very fine threads where I suppose the outer shell screw onto the inner one.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Help with eggbeater

#6

Re: Help with eggbeater

Marv

>Wiley,

I just stick a short rod or drill in each of those holes, put the chuck in a bench vise and with a bar under and over the two rods and turn it counter clockwise. Don't clamp the house too close to the part you are screwing off, it will oval the housing and make it more difficult to unscrew that end piece. Clamp more toward the jaw end.

Marv

Re: Help with eggbeater

#7

Re: Maybe success--more questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv,

Thanks for explaining about which way the little conical piece is supposed to be headed.

I injected some lithium grease into the oil holes and sprayed into the chuck shell also. It's running smooth enough now that I think I'll not take it apart.

Wiley

Re: Help with eggbeater

#8

Re: Help with eggbeater

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>As Marv says, not all chucks are designed to take tiny bits. The jaw tips - that is, the edge of the jaw contacting the bit - is necessarily narrower for chucks that can accomodate tiny bits, and I imagine the manufacturers were dealing with strength/grip/bit size tradeoffs.

This type of chuck is supposed to open as you unscrew it because the little springs overcome the friction of the chuck jaws against the chuck shell, and move them backwards. A little dirt, a little rust, a spiderweb or two, and the friction can increase to the point that the friction of one or all jaws overcomes spring pressure. Then you have to push the jaws back into the shell.

You may find that the grease you squirted in solves the problem, although you may find you've complicated your life, because the grease is now on the jaw tips, too, where it shouldn't be because it encourages bit slip (shall I explain how I happen to know this?). If you find the bits slipping, you may want to disassemble the chuck and redo the work.

Disassembly is not difficult, but I recommend doing the final steps of disassembly inside a large tupperware container or something - at the least, don't do it until you've vacuumed the shop floor. When the jaws slide out, there's nothing to retain those little springs, and their desire to escape is often VERY strong. Once you've got the back section of the chuck loose, unscrewing by hand is easy enough.

Degrease all the parts. Clean off each jaw and the inside of the chuck shell with fine steel wool or something similar (crocus cloth is very good, but hard to find). Use a dry lubricant of some kind on the inside of the chuck shell and outside of the jaws.

Reassembly is delicate too, requiring you to assemble the chuck jaws with their springs and then insert them into the chuck shell. Sometimes, this works: assemble the jaws upright with their springs in a happy little family, then carefully slide the shell down, like covering a bird's nest with a canvas cover or a teapot with its cozy; once that's done, carefully turn the package over, insert the centering washer, add the rear body of the chuck, and reassemble.

Tightening bits in the chuck: grabbing the crank handle to hold it still and turning the chuck is fine for basic closing of chuck on bit. Here or on Badger Pond, years ago, someone (I want to say Dave Anderson, but if I'm wrong, I beg forgiveness from whoever said it instead) suggested, for final tightening, turning the crank handle around so that pulling it down would tighten the chuck, then gripping the chuck and pulling firmly on the handle. For me, this does result in a tighter grip on the bits than holding the handle still and turning the chuck. Reverse the process to get bits out.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#9

My friend, you have *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>just confirmed my good sense in leaving the chuck the heck alone.** A masterful disquisition on an insanely complex matter, and one best left to those who don't mind looking for springs in dark corners and sawdust, so they can then try to persuade them to scrunch up and get back into their now-ovalized shell home.

If the bit slips, I will use more horsepower. Don't forget, you can drop a screwdriver down through the fancy pierced metal housing to serve as a spindle lock, in case of slipping bits.

Wiley....who just won a little bitty Goodell-Pratt drill (see link)

**Why? Because inanimate objects are out to get us. (aka 2nd law of thermodynamics)


Ain't ebay great!?

Re: Help with eggbeater

#10

That's a cool drill

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It looks like they may have used the handle structure from their push drill as a bit caddy on this eggbeater - clever.

Speaking of physical laws: I can't recall which law says that objects can't be in two places at once (though, I understand, it's not so clear that this is true at the quantum level). Wiley is here demonstrating that it IS possible to be on more than one slippery slope at a time.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#11

scott grandstaff

Re: My friend, you have

scott grandstaff

>I just heard a good tip for gripping a chuck shell without crushing it. Drill a hole the size of the chuck in a piece of softwood and cut the block in 1/2. Now use it as a clamp in a regular vise.

I have taken a number of chucks apart in my life. Its never a walk in the clouds, buts always possible.

It isn't totally the end of the world if you do lose a spring either.

There are some desperate methods that work.

George, for one, winds new springs.

Not saying he'd do one quick or easy but he's got the stuff and he's done it before.

Wiktor has plenty of experience with eggbeater chuck springs and a note of desperation could always be sent there.

Also, Mcmaster, if you send a spring they will wind you another. They have always offered this. Not fast and maybe not cheap though.

But, of course, you keep a drawer of old springs to root through?? Yes??

Every old spring that crosses your path in a drawer, with assorted bronze bushings in the bottom of the drawer, if you're me.

Just find the same diameter and cut one to length.

A little stretching or crushing may be involved.

yours Scott

Re: Help with eggbeater

#12

Re: Multitasking

Marv

>An eggbeater drill can also beat an egg.

This is a Millers Falls No.980 two speed. Can be used for mixing cookie dough on the low speed setting.

Marv


img

Re: Help with eggbeater

#13

Beautiful example!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Help with eggbeater

#14

It is just amazing to me...

Bob Hackett

>How much time,effort,and engineering went into some of the simplest tools back then.

Looking at that drill it`s plain to see that every effort was made toward ease of use(sometimes multiple uses)and user friendliness.

How,and more importantly,WHY did we ever abandon those qualities in favor of ease of manufacture?

Yet another reminder of why we prefer old iron.

MB

PS-Nice catch Wiley.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#15

Look out chickens!

Bob Hackett

>Those eggs don`t stand a chance now!

I`d show the pic to my wife but she`d go into shock.She`s still finding hidden bits of avacado from last time I made guacamole and grenaded the blender.No more power tools in the kitchen for me(unless you count the metal lathe).

Mainely(make mine scrambled)Bob

Re: Help with eggbeater

#16

whoa.....;-)

Dan Donaldson

>What is this about a metal lathe in the kitchen? Sounds like something we should hear about ;-)

Re: Help with eggbeater

#17

Re: My friend, you have

Marv

>Wiley,

We can see that the jaws do not completely close vacuum tight. The reason for that is, the drill is too big for bits/drills that are small enough to fit that small of an opening. The makers of these eggbeaters made even smaller ones for smaller bits.

Marv

Re: Help with eggbeater

#18

I hear ya

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>For the past couple of days, I've been using a North Bros. 1530 which is a small model, about 11" long and a 3/16" capacity chuck. That chuck closes down airtight. It takes a #60 drill easy, and if I had a #80 I'm sure it would take it too, because the three jaws close perfectly down to a zero gap.

The 1530 is a wonderful drill for cabinetry, for the reasons mentioned above, and also has a setting where the drill turns clockwise for cutting, whether you are winding the handle forward or backward--haven't had to use that yet, but it could be useful in a tight spot. The chuck is small enough that it can drill vertically pretty close to a wall--I just drilled one that is 'vertical enough', that was 1/32" under 7/16" clearance from a wall.

I"m going to be thanking Bill Houghton for a long time for that 1530 (cause there ain't no such thing as an 'extra' one of them).

I'm hoping this small Goodell Pratt will do similarly.

Wiley

Re: Help with eggbeater

#19

Western Feng Shui(sp)

Bob Hackett

>I read somewhere that your decor should flow throughout the house and not just be broken up room by room.

In an attempt to incorporate this into my life I now have a 9" Southbend metal lathe in my kitchen.I feel it more than balances the workbench in the diningroom and the joiner`s toolbox(full) in the livingroom.

I am still in a quandary as to how to properly expand this into the bedroom.I`m meeting even more resistance there than I was in the kitchen.Some people(SWMBO for one) just aren`t open to balance in their life.

Mainely,Bob-Looking for the right saws for the new ceiling fan.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#20

I would have thought a man of your stature

Bob Hackett

>Would have at least 3 drawers of springs(1 extention,1 compression and 1 torsion)and a different drawer for bronze bushings(not to mention nylon,delrin and oillite) are you sure the bushing drawer isn`t behind that stack of babbit ingots over there?

MB

Re: Help with eggbeater

#21

scott grandstaff

Re: I would have thought a man of your stature

scott grandstaff

>Hey Bob, what, me...... with junk??

You have been talking to my wife, haven't you?? heehehehehe

OK, I might have a few more springs and bearings here and there (shhhhhhh) and the babbit is trying to hold some sanding disks flat.

But really, my house is small.

Small place, small shop, small life,.................. little stuff.


yours Scott

Re: Help with eggbeater

#22

Re: Multitasking

David Miller from Iowa

>You know, the older I get the more amazed I am at my stupidity. Even though have "several" egg beater drill and understood the etymology, I never thought of using one for that. I would have liked to do that when I was single.

Kind of like my wife pointing out that I have (insert absurd amount) of woodworking planes that are all razor sharp, but the kitchen knives we use 10x a day can't cut a banana.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#23

OT: "...when I was single."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It's amazing the things we (at least we men) do when we're without sweeties that we wouldn't even consider once we are with our sweethearts.

If I should start riding motorcycles again, I really doubt that my wife would think tuning up the motorcycle in the kitchen was a good idea, but it made perfect sense to me 40+ years ago.

Re: Help with eggbeater

#24

Was it raining?

Bob Hackett

>

Re: Help with eggbeater

#25

Below freezing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>This was in Michigan, when I lived there.

Great place to do a tune-up, actually - warm, coffee always available, a table handy for putting valve covers on...