Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

color of cherry

Posts

Re: color of cherry

#26

Re: The limitations of language

Sgian Dubh

>Perhaps your definition should really be 'semi-transparent' Bob. I accept your points that clear and transparent are essentially the same thing.

The colouring I did to the wood obscures the wood's natural colour. Between colouring the wood with ferrous sulphate and application a final clear finish were a couple of steps. First, after changing the wood colour I applied a thin coat of pre-catalysed lacquer to seal the grain so that paint used in the next step wouldn't alter the colour of the summer grown wood very much. Next I applied a water based wall paint and wiped it off very shortly after application. This hides the texture of the coarser spring growth, yet at the same time emphasises it by making it stand out in a different way than if you could see it in its natural form. Lastly, the whole job was polished with pre-catalysed lacquer to seal and protect everything below.

So, I guess your definitions are about right. However, when I did the job, and even now, I just don't think about defining things quite so precisely. I simply wanted to create an effect in a piece I was working on, knew how to do it, knew what wood species to use to achieve the end result, and got on with it.

It all seemed so simple at the time... but it could become significantly more complex if I let you persuade me to become much more analytical than I thought necessary, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: color of cherry

#27

Very helpful,thanks.

Bob Hackett

>I have used ferrous sulfate in the past(mostly on figured maple).I suppose I really should go back and experiment with it more.I suspect I was using too strong a solution.

One of my big limitations is that I have no spray equipment and have absolutely no intention of going down that very expensive slope.I take my past experiences using other people`s equipment as a warning that my skills are best applied elsewhere.My use of lacquer is confined to what comes out of a spray can,less than high tech.If something requires lacquer I hand it off.That includes my metal projects.

I`m surprised how many times when I ask a question about technique the first answer is"I`ve never really thought about how I do it,I just do it".I take that answer to mean the technique has become second nature and has evolved thru much trial and error till the person performing it has lost track of the progression.

Very few times has there been a straight line answer and distilling one from what was a progression of starts and stops and dead ends,reformulations and experiments becomes a real task,especially with someone like me prodding you.God only knows what really went into(and in what amount) that jar you`ve been drawing off for the last few years.I can count the number of people who keep an up to date and accurate(did you really weigh that powdered dye or pigment)notebook on one hand.Easier to shoo folks like me off than do a past life regression and break things down to thier finer details and measured ingredients unfortunately

I`m reminded of my wife trying to learn cooking from my grandmother who never measured anything.

Her instructions were;"Alittle of this,about this much(show the amount in her hand)of that,and cook till it`s done.Let Bob taste it,he`ll know when it`s right".

There`s absolutely no chance of getting me to taste any finish,water based or not.:^)

Thanks again for taking the time to walk me thru it.

Mainely,Bob

Re: color of cherry

#28

Thanks very much Richard

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>For listing the finishing steps. It's a striking effect, and the wood retains its identity as quartered oak.

Professionals are naturally going to have limited time for sharing their thoughts and bread-and-butter methods with folks an ocean away--so this is all the more appreciated!

Wiley

Re: color of cherry

#29

Re: Very helpful,thanks.

Sgian Dubh

>"I suspect I was using too strong a solution."

Bob, a good place to start with green copperas (ferrous sulphate) is one heaped teaspoon per 1/2 litre (US pint) of water. Make adjustments from their as that measure is generally neither much too strong or much too weak.

I understand the difficulties if spray equipment is not available; but those difficulties can be turned to advantages (of a sort) if you explore the alternatives using hand applied finishes, particularly clear and dewaxed shellac as your primary barrier coat between colouring stages, and under your final protective coat, whatever you choose that to be. Slainte.

Re: color of cherry

#30

Re: Thanks very much Richard

Sgian Dubh

>You're too kind Wiley. However, both professionals and amateurs have lots of other things to do, so I guess we are all in the same boat really when it comes down to sharing what we know with each other. Slainte.

Re: color of cherry

#31

Thanks again.

Bob Hackett

>I was hoping you`d offer an alternatives to the lacquer.

I`m somewhat familiar with using shellac as both a prep/barrier coat and a fixative between steps.

I also like the fact that you can mix alcohol based dyes into the shellac to tint the top coats if needed.

MB

Re: color of cherry

#32

Re: Very helpful,thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Bob, I think the reason most don't give a set of directions for finishing is that they're never sure there wasn't some little deviation the last time out that made the surface pop especially nicely and they simply don't want to mislead, especially in public where so many seem ready to pounce.

Pam

Re: color of cherry

#33

Re: Please reread my post

Sgian Dubh

>"... wife hates the yellow color it morphs to over time.If I can manage it,your finish may be just the compromise we`re looking for."


Incidentally Bob, green copperas doesn't work on ash. You will need to substitute an alternative colourant for ferrous sulphate. A dye of your colour choice will do the job-- you could even do something a bit shocking, like violet dye, seal with shellac, then use water based blue, green, yelow, etc, paint to colour and semi fill the open spring growth. Slainte.

Re: color of cherry

#34

scott grandstaff

Finishing and Comminication

scott grandstaff

>Random ramblings in no particular order, forgive me

Its tough enough... you get this requirement for a project,...

this one is going in a bedroom and protected, that one going to the middle of the kitchen and due to meet cutlery and hot pots and indignities galore. etc etc

Then, you have to try and figure out what you can can get away with, and how to get the wood to look nice in the bargain.

You have to decide how far you are going to polish the finish.... whether one quick splash will do you, or its 98 hand rubbed coats and

then.........

trying to tell it all????

even when you'd be perfectly happy to tell all??

Well its really hard.

Lots of people can't even do it at all.

I have asked. Many times they want to tell me, but can't remember even the heat of the last battle.

And battle it is, to me. Always a struggle. How far is enough? Could it look better?

I don't always feel I get to pick the finish anyway, really hardly ever. Seems other concerns dictate what is appropriate for what kind of wood it is, for its intended use

and how does what I like come into it??

I would love to use more shellac forinstance, but its rather frail. Gorgeous, but not the toughest. I use it as much as I can.

Real laquer stinks to high heaven, but it has its mandatory place.

I hate varnish, but too bad for me. Projects demand it.

Poly has a use.

Everything does, and how many times do I get to actually pick?

Oh, one extra. Ebonizing mostly is making ink. Its basically what what people made ink out of for milliniums (bad spelling I know).

Oak galls and certain barks and teas. Tannin and dissolved iron = ink.

I'd trade a spoonful of tannic acid or a couple oak galls for some tea or bark, just to have the different colors available??

yours Scott

Re: color of cherry

#35

One more shot...

Bob Hackett

>My first lengthy post was just in time to catch the crash soo...

I understand that some folks have trouble articulating things.There are wonderful craftsmen out there who would make absolutely horrid instructors and vice versa.There`s nothing wrong with being up front and just saying "I know how to do it,I just don`t know how to explain it".Usually,with a bit of coaching and offers of help,that can become"Let me show you instead" and you get to spend some time in another`s shop starting a new friendship.

What I DO have a problem with is the folks who I know can communicate and refuse to share.They`re more than happy to suck up info but it`s a one way street with them.

As far as I`m concerned,if I know how to do something or how something works then I`m more than willing to share that info,my skills are an open book and always have been.I feel it`s my way of repaying those who took the time to show me.I`ve never looked on knowledge as currency that`s meant to be hoarded and taken to the grave.

The easiest way to get me going is to tease me with some project(or finish) and then once we`re all interested and appreciative say "look what I can do that you CAN`T",thumb your nose and walk away.

Don`t be surprised if I put on my drill sgt. persona and call you on it in front of the group.Your tax dollars paid to make that voice,just think of it as getting your money`s worth.

Mainely,Bob

Re: color of cherry

#36

Just to clarify things....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bob,

I hear what you're saying, but hope it is not directed at Richard, who explained the process of making the oak green, and then, in response to your questions, went into further detail explaining that ferrous sulphate wouldn't work on the wood you mentioned, and cited options--and also explained that dewaxed shellac flakes would make a good practical resist in lieu of pre-catalyzed lacquer.

I would say he is due some appreciation.

Wiley

Re: color of cherry

#37

No,no,no,absolutely not!

Bob Hackett

>Richard went above and beyond,in my estimation.I thank him again for that.

My post was aimed mostly at Scott,as an agreement that not everyone can explain(or recall) how they do something.

The last part of the post was not aimed at anyone here,far from it.

It was a statement of things I`ve come up against in the past.I don`t think it`s geographic in nature as I`ve encountered non sharing and one way individuals up here,in Texas and elsewhere.It just gets my back up whenever I encounter it is all.

MB

Re: color of cherry

#38

Thank you!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: color of cherry

#39

scott grandstaff

Re: One more shot...

scott grandstaff

>What I DO have a problem with is the folks who I know can communicate and refuse to share.

I am totally with you on this Bob. Nobody I personally know does this, but I know it exists.

Protecting some tiny corner of turf goes back a long long time.

But mostly, its always second raters who try this anyway.

I mean Tommy Chippendale freely gave us everything he had! (not that we can follow it much, heh). Sheraton, Hepplewhite, Underhill, Headley, Maloof.....

The top guys always know there is never a shortage of room at the top.

More really top craftsmen in any field just draws more attention to the craft, and there is more market for everyone.

yours Scott

Re: color of cherry

#40

Top craftsmen`s philosophy

Bob Hackett

>I personally know more than a few up here and they all agree that if you share something then by the time the person you`ve shared with has mastered it then YOU should be on to the next level or above.If you`re not then something`s wrong.

Some people will just never get the Karma thing.I don`t know why I continue to worry about them,but I do.

MB

Re: color of cherry

#41

Re: One more shot...

Sgian Dubh

>Bob, you may find this link to my website useful. It describes a similar treatment of oak using ferrous sulphate and plaster of Paris as a grain filler. You may have seen it before so it could be a bit old hat. Slainte.

Re: color of cherry

#42

Classic Wood Finishing by George Frank

charlie belden

>Don't know if this is the same book Cecil mentioned - with a new name - or with a new name because Sam Allen revised it.

Published by Sterling Publishing Co. Inc.the ISBN is 0-8069-7063-4. Doesn't have a date of printing and I don't recall how long ago I bought it - but is was $17.95 USD.

The photos of wood with various finishes will make your head spin.

Re: color of cherry

#43

Re: Classic Wood Finishing by George Frank

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, not the same book. The first is 88 Rue de Charonne, Adventures in Wood Finishing published in 1981 by Taunton. Frank came to the US sometime during WWII, worked at FWW at the time the book was published. The second book revised edition is Classic Wood Finishing published in 1988 be Sterling, the first edition was called Wood Finishing.

Pam