Re: pigmented stains and dyes discussed
Sgian Dubh
>Bill, I find it perennially interesting that many people repeat the mantra that only a clear finish will do, or that only the simplest colouring techniques should be used prior to a clear finish, eg, a wipe of boiled linseed oil to 'pop' the grain to use the latest buzz phraseolgy, followed by a bit of shellac or lacquer.
Whilst the routine (and other simple routines) is a good one in some circumstances, it's not suitable in others. I have come to the conclusion that many woodworkers just don't understand finishing and all the subtle, and not so subtle, effects that can be achieved through knowledge, skill and practice. Whilst I have a great deal of sympathy for the amateur woodworker that is pressed for time in their endeavours, I have very little sympathy for my fellow professional furniture designer makers that steadfastly refuse to to get to grips with the essentials of finishing; these are the people that palm off their lack of knowledge and ability to their customers with the mantra of only using finishes 'true to the nature' of the wood, and the codswallop about using an oil to 'feed' the wood, and other such twaddle. In some cases their finishing is restricted to a bit of linseed oil, maybe some Danish oil type formulation, waxes, and rather carelessly applied varnish of some sort.
As you rightly point out, finishing is not a task learned quickly. When I started as a trainee cabinet maker back in the early 1970s there were more young lads down in the finishing shop on three year apprenticeships. It was known then that learning how to be a good finisher took a long time. Nothing has changed in that regard; learning how to finish well is time consuming, requires a good deal of study and a lot of practice.
Below is an example of a finish that is clearly not in the school of 'simple is best'. It involves some distinct stages and the use of the colouring agents ferrous sulphate, water based wall paint and pre-catalysed lacquer. Whether the result is to a viewers taste is, of course, subjective and dependent upon why the routine was used in a piece of furniture, the style of the furniture, the location of the finished item and perhaps several other relevant factors. It's certainly the case that American white oak can't be made to look like this with any clear finish on its own. Slainte.
