Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

color of cherry

Posts

color of cherry

#1

scott grandstaff

color of cherry

scott grandstaff

>When I was building my mini ax (its 1/2 size) I rounded up every scrap of cherry I had. (Which is never much, I live around 2000 miles from the nearest steady supply.)

Well, it was pinky white of course. I didn't want pinky white wood.

So, for a whole week I would take it out into the early morning sun and leave it there until it got hot. It was late spring. So around 7 to 10 am in this part of the world. I would alternate sides every other day.

This got me the first pic. From pinky white to strong red.

Now it has been about 5 years later and it is headed toward burgandy.

It would be going faster, but its a guitar so it has about 100 coats of rubbed lacquer.

I can't figure out how to include more than one picture in a post, so the cut n paste link to the early picture is here. The new picture I just took minutes ago is below

http://users.snowcrest.net/kitty/scott/ax.jpg

If you can afford to wait for the sun to do its work, there isn't a better color for cherry than the color it turns on its own. At least to me.

yours Scott


img

Re: color of cherry

#2

I agree....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I almost never color cherry. BTW the guitar looks great! I give all my clients who buy cherry pieces from me a short lecture about cherry so they fully understand the process and the end result. I have gotten calls a year later from clients who were happy with the reults. Yep, that color is definitely worth waiting for.

Tom

Re: color of cherry

#3

Me too!!!

Ron Bauman

>

Re: color of cherry

#4

Time,it`s not just for cherry anymore

Bob Hackett

>I think the same could be said about most wood.

There`s nothing to compare to the beauty of mahogany,figured maple,pine,etc that time has put it`s hands to.

All the tinting,staining,and the rest of the "old in a minute" attempts always come up second when they stand side by side with their older kin.

Just my $.02.

MB

Re: color of cherry

#5

Great Scott!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I wouldn't think it would have evened out so much. I totally agree that time is the best finish for cherry. Well that and a little oil...

Re: color of cherry

#6

In defense of staining wood

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't intend to try to convince those that eschew staining to begin doing so, but there may be some lurking that have not settled on finishing schedules that could be influenced by a contrary opinion. I stain almost everything I make. About my only exception is ash which I turn into more modern looking stuff. A Krenov style cabinet stained and filled wouldn't look right. On the other hand if you are building period pieces, as well as many other styles, then staining is an essential part of the process.

I have always suspected that some avoid staining because they have not been successful with this finishing step. Indeed, staining is something that takes knowledge and practice and in the case of cherry, finding a stain color that is appealing. It is annoying that companies change their stain formulations every few years requiring relearning how to use the product. I am still nursing color from a 30 year old can of Sherwin Williams cherry oil stain because I haven't found anything I like as well. Again in the case of cherry, I think it has a raw unrefined look and lacks depth when it is not stained. Walnut bleaches to an unattractive color if not stained. If you want to accentuate the grain of oak it must be stained. To achieve the color of period mahogany pieces they must be stained and maybe filled, and everyone I know making period furniture does so.

So, there are good reasons to stain your work. But it is something that must be mastered through experimentation and practice.

Re: color of cherry

#7

Stain vs dye

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

A spirited discussion!

Just a clarification....... Are you using 'stain' to include both pigmented stains and colored (but clear) dyes? It would make sense in the context of this thread.

More generally, I think there is a useful distinction between stain containing particles of pigment, and dye which imparts color without filling pores with particulate matter.

I would be interested to hear any opinions you may have--and that others may have as well--comparing the use of pigmented stains versus dyes.

Thanks for a good discussion!

Wiley

Re: color of cherry

#8

A small nit

Bob Hackett

>Bill,

You said that oak must be stained if you want to accentuate the grain.

Some of the best grain accentuation I`ve seen in oak has been thru fuming.There is more setup involved(building the tent etc)but the tone is more easily controlled using fuming than it is with any stain I`ve used.The finished product just feels better to my hand too.

MB

Re: color of cherry

#9

fuming is staining....at least by my definition

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>We could call it chemical staining to include ammonia, lye, chromate and ferrous iron and any other chemicals that react with wood to change their color. (For the record, at least one professional that makes a living from quartered oak furniture fumes followed by pigmented stain.

To clarify, my point is that being able to enhance wood's appearance by additional colorants makes many styles of wood more attractive to many people. So it may be worth learning to do.

A good example is Thomas Mosher furniture. This stuff is just oiled and the company sells the "beauty" of this minimalist finish. They seem to be successful so there is market for it. I think their finish looks "dead" compared to my cherry pieces. Their finish lacks the depth and richness of color that I achieve. Set side by side I think most customers would prefer my stained and top coated finish, but it would substantially increase the cost of the furniture.

Re: color of cherry

#10

pigmented stains and dyes discussed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am fairly new to dye stain. Like many attempting stains, I tried a dye years ago, had a disaster because I didn't have enough knowledge and experience to use it and concluded that dyes were evil. It is all too typical of novice woodworkers to presume something is easy, use it without practice, and fail (and then maybe avoid it forever, or even tell others to avoid it). It was the story of my first many years of woodworking and the issue still crops up occasionally. The value of this forum is that one meets people successfully practicing techniques and that provides motivation and knowledge to try again.

Both dyes and pigmented stains require proper surface preparation and application to achieve attractive results. It takes considerable experience to learn the proper preparation and application techniques. And these techniques take considerable time, which adds considerable time to completing a project. Some may conclude it's not worth it and avoid making styles enhanced by staining.

I historically have used traditional mineral pigmented stain (though recently I have acquired some experience with water based dyes). Mineral pigmented stains were readily obtained 30 years ago. Applied over a properly prepared surface they do not, in my opinion, "muddy" a surface (see picture of a pigment stained oak piece. Not more than two tablespoons of stain was applied to this piece, with a rubber). I have two friends that build period furniture. One dye stains and the other pigment stains and I don't see significant difference in the results.

Modern pigmented stains may not be simply ground mineral pigment in some drying oil base. In the extreme some are like latex paint, while others are a mix of synthetic pigments and dyes (that may fade more or less). It would be easy to become discouraged using some of these products. For example, Bartley cherry stain looks like what one would use to achieve the look of the purple cordovan mahogany. Even worse, companies seem to reformulate their stains every few years.

I have been known to take a piece of poplar (or any white wood) to a paint store and ask to have a dollop of every available stain applied in stripes across the board. From these samples I choose stains for future projects. I am experimenting with making my own mineral pigment stains from LV mineral pigments.


img

Re: color of cherry

#11

Re: fuming is staining....at least by my definitio

Bob Hackett

>Fair enough.

I agree with at least part of your assessment of Moser`s finishing.It`s usually nothing more than heated BLO wiped on by sombody in the finishing dept after one or more employees have sanded the piece to a set standard.That being said,if you walk down the road from any of his galleries and look at the wiped or brushed on poly coating the pieces of most of his production furniture competitors(excluding imports) it looks real good in comparison.All things are relative I suppose.

In the interest of full disclosure,I`ve sold work thru the Moser gallery in Freeport and am fully behind his generous support and promotion of local craftsmen.He`s helped alot of local artisans wherever his galleries have appeared.

You talk about pigment and traditional finishes.You also lament the fact that most mainstream (thinking Borg here) finishing formulas seem to change on a regular basis and without notice(went thru this when Watco changed and then thankfully changed back).

I was just wondering if you had tried traditional milk paint as a pigment?I`ve had some luck using it thinned as a wash or liming type finish and even as an added pigment in home spun oil based finishes when needed.

I understand that there are times when a color or tone change is unavoidable for various reasons.Matching stock from different sources and dealing with sapwood comes to mind as does combining different woods in a single project.

As you may have guessed I tend to be a minimalist when it comes to finishing.Many times a coat of wax suits me fine.When I do need to reach further into the finishing bag I tend to fall back on Flexner`s books and a book I inherited from my dad "Adventures in wood finishing".

Can you suggest any other books that you find helpful and use as references?

Thanks Bill.

Mainely,Bob

Re: color of cherry

#12

I'm agreeable

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I agree with all you said. For the colors I need the mineral pigments -umber, burnt umber, etc.- are what I use. I suspect these pigments are various forms of iron and manganese oxide and as such the color is forever. Original milk paint was also no doubt based on mineral pigments- copper oxide, lead oxide, copper carbonate,e tc.

For some things milk paint followed by a coat of varnish makes a lovely finish, but it is paint and as such does hide the grain more of less.

I don't have a favored finishing book. There used to be many quality furniture factories near by and I have learned from persons that worked at these factories. SAPFM has some members that do awesome reproduction finishes. One lives nearby. Alf Sharp helped me with the Federal French footed thing I have posted. I think Alf is the best finisher I have ever encountered. He got me over my fear and loathing of water soluble dye stains.

Factories used to figure 1/3 of the cost of a quality piece was in finishing. A finishing schedule that involves staining, sealing, maybe filling, top coats and rubbing out can add a lot to the time in a piece. I recently bought some ladder backed chairs and the shop reduced the price by$100 for the unfinished chair (this shop does a very high quality finishing job). It took me 5 hours to put the cherry finish on them that I prefer. Most of this time was meticulous sanding required for a pigment stained finish. I see good finishes on $25,000 reproduction pieces. A lot of gallery work can't support the cost of the best finishes.

Re: color of cherry

#13

Re: I'm agreeable

Bob Hackett

>Is there a book,site, or video you can point to that spells out the prep work you prefer to follow in an in depth manner?

I am very interested to see what`s involved in order to bring things to the level required to obtain the fine level of finish you put on your work.

Up till now my train of thought has been that the best finish is one that is easily repaired,thus I lean toward oil,wax,and other finishes along those lines.Wax doesn`t handle extended exposure to water well and oil finishes also have thier drawbacks in regard to durability.

I`m willing to be wrong here but after raising 3 rough and tumble kids I`m of the opinion that a child proof finish is purely myth.

I have been using a home-made 4+ parts wiping varnish/tung oil brew on things I make for others that require more resistance to wear,grime and solvents but have never really been happy with it.

I suspect if I could get a window into the proper prep and application for other more durable finishes I`d be less reluctant to use them.At the very least I`d have them firmly in my mind and be able to call them up when needed and be happy about it.

Mainely,Bob

Re: color of cherry

#14

Even smaller nit

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bob and everybody,

Question here.....I am under the impression that fuming (which I haven't done) sets the color of the wood. The color. Whereas pore-filling is a separate consideration. The Stickley look (for lack of a better term) was obtained by filling the pores with a dark wax--pigment particles in a hydrocarbon base. One could also fill the pores with blond shellac in order to avoid accentuating them.

It may be that fuming (and other finishing techniques involving chemical reaction with the wood) is sort of a third way. Fuming would not fill pores, but it also sounds like it may have an effect of accentuating grain that goes beyond what dyes accomplish. Depending on who is doing the dyeing, of course.

All thoughts and corrections appreciated.

Wiley

Re: color of cherry

#15

Re: Even smaller nit

Bob Hackett

>You are correct in thinking that chemically altering the color of the wood does not address the pore issue.

One of the lessons I learned from that book I got from my dad was that the author(I`ve loaned it out or I`d look to see the author`s name.I think his first name was George)used the technique of dyeing the wood and then filling the pores with a contrasting color to create quite a stir in Europe a long time ago.That`s how he made a name for himself.The results can be very dramatic.

He also tells the story of altering all the installed and finished oak woodwork in an entire bank by fuming it over a weekend.

For awhile it was a big trick with turners to ebonize open pored woods and then fill the pores with either a metalic or liming wax.Most folks I knew used oak with iron and vinegar solution followed by india ink or shoe dye if a darker black was required.The solutions left the pores open to receive the pore filling wax.The ray fleck figure combined with previous applications was stunning.

Mainely,Bob

Re: color of cherry

#16

Re: Even smaller nit

Cecil Nickerson

>I think the fellow's name was George Frank and the book was Adventures in Wood Finishing. It's been reprinted in paperback (Amazon).

Regards, Cecil

Re: color of cherry

#17

George Frank

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>"Adventures in Wood Finishing". There is a newer book (1990) with his name on it--he lived a long life.

Wiley

Re: color of cherry

#18

Oops. Cecil already named it.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: color of cherry

#19

That`s the man!

Bob Hackett

>

Re: color of cherry

#20

Re: pigmented stains and dyes discussed

Sgian Dubh

>Bill, I find it perennially interesting that many people repeat the mantra that only a clear finish will do, or that only the simplest colouring techniques should be used prior to a clear finish, eg, a wipe of boiled linseed oil to 'pop' the grain to use the latest buzz phraseolgy, followed by a bit of shellac or lacquer.

Whilst the routine (and other simple routines) is a good one in some circumstances, it's not suitable in others. I have come to the conclusion that many woodworkers just don't understand finishing and all the subtle, and not so subtle, effects that can be achieved through knowledge, skill and practice. Whilst I have a great deal of sympathy for the amateur woodworker that is pressed for time in their endeavours, I have very little sympathy for my fellow professional furniture designer makers that steadfastly refuse to to get to grips with the essentials of finishing; these are the people that palm off their lack of knowledge and ability to their customers with the mantra of only using finishes 'true to the nature' of the wood, and the codswallop about using an oil to 'feed' the wood, and other such twaddle. In some cases their finishing is restricted to a bit of linseed oil, maybe some Danish oil type formulation, waxes, and rather carelessly applied varnish of some sort.

As you rightly point out, finishing is not a task learned quickly. When I started as a trainee cabinet maker back in the early 1970s there were more young lads down in the finishing shop on three year apprenticeships. It was known then that learning how to be a good finisher took a long time. Nothing has changed in that regard; learning how to finish well is time consuming, requires a good deal of study and a lot of practice.

Below is an example of a finish that is clearly not in the school of 'simple is best'. It involves some distinct stages and the use of the colouring agents ferrous sulphate, water based wall paint and pre-catalysed lacquer. Whether the result is to a viewers taste is, of course, subjective and dependent upon why the routine was used in a piece of furniture, the style of the furniture, the location of the finished item and perhaps several other relevant factors. It's certainly the case that American white oak can't be made to look like this with any clear finish on its own. Slainte.

oak-fe-so4-paint

Re: color of cherry

#21

The limitations of language

Bob Hackett

>You say that pic is an example that white oak can`t be made to look like that by a clear or transparent(according to Webster`s Dictionary they are synonymous) finish alone.To my eye it is also an example that unless a clear finish is used you can`t obtain that type of effect.Let me try to explain my thought process.

That is definitely not an opaque finish.Straight milk paint is THE true opaque finish in that it is "not transparent" and "does not reflect light".The quoted phrases being 2 of the Webster`s American dictionary`s definitions of opaque.The fact that paint was one part of the finishing process as stated changed from monochromatic and opaque to something else once most of it was rubbed off.

Neither is it a translucent finish.The same dictionary defines this as "Letting light pass through though not transparent" a pickled finish or paint wash is what I think of when I think translucent.This may also be what some folks are seeing when they say a finish has a "muddy" appearance.This is guesswork on my part as I am not them.

This leaves the third and final type of finish-transparent or clear.

For our(finishing) purposes Websters defines transparent as "Transmitting light rays so that objects on the other side may be seen" or "So fine in texture as to be seen through".In my mind the grain and/or wood is what`s on the other side of the finish and we can clearly see that.All the other things done to the wood have been reduced to the point where they are so fine in texture that the wood shows through and while the color may have been altered the grain is unobscured.

That is why,in my mind,this qualifies as an example of a transparent or clear finish.

I invite others to explain their thoughts to the contrary.

Mainely,Bob

Re: color of cherry

#22

Every trade has its language

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think, for most woodworkers, "clear" refers to not just a finish through which light passes, but one that has minimal colorants. It's interesting to me, in this regard, that varnish, oil, and other such finishes are considered "clear," since, with the exception, as I understand it, of some of the water-based clear finishes, most such finishes add amber, yellow, or similar tones to the wood. Howsoever, I think most woodworkers would consider a varnish with, say, red colorants added not to be a clear finish (this, by the way, means that the term "clear" in this context cries out for a more precise definition - why is added mild amber/yellow/brown OK, but red or blue not?).

If I'm correct about this vague perceived definition, the picture Richard/Sgian has offered us wouldn't be a clear finish, unless there's a greenish oak in the world that I'm not aware of or his picture is not color-balanced well.

This could get really confusing; I'm starting to get a little confused. I'd better stop.

Re: color of cherry

#23

Things are confusing in finishing,I get that.

Bob Hackett

>Especially when you hear terms such as "Water white" being used to describe a finish.

If I ever saw water that was white(unless frozen)I sure enough would think it suspicious.

How about all the wiping varnish out there being sold as "Tung oil finish".

How about certified "Food safe" finishes when one of the leading experts in the field(Bob Flexner) has stated time and again that unless it contains lead or other heavy metals pretty much ALL finishes are food safe after curing.

One of my biggest complaints about finishing is the secrecy and confusion being fostered by both the people who make the products and those who have finally figured out how to use them.

Although I haven`t seen evidence of it here most successful finishers seem to treat finishing like poker.Under no circumstances do you get to see their cards.That would be cheating.

That`s why I asked Bill the questions I did.I know his history of freely sharing information.I`ve seen and been impressed by his work and I feel that if anyone is willing to actually communicate how it is done step by step and finally let us other poor dumb slobs in on the secret it will be either him or one of his peers here on this forum.

Forgive me ladies and gentlemen,if I sound frustrated it`s because I am.I`ve lost count of the number of times I`ve shown my work and explained and demonstrated how I do it and finish it in depth and even revealed what my inspiration and references were etc only to have someone else step out of the crowd and show me some finished piece that knocked my socks off and made me want to duplicate the finish only to receive some nebulous answer when I asked HOW that told me nothing and led me nowhere.

I get that some of you know how.I`ve seen the proof in the pics.I know that the prep is more than 1/2 the battle.I know it took a long time to get to the point that you can do what you do(guess what,me too!).

Now please,I`m beggin ya,CLUE THE REST OF US IN!!!

We need titles of books you read and reference that help.Classes you took and names of instructors that you found helpful.Names of videos and where to find them.Names of real world people and where we can contact them.All the things you have freely shared before in the past in regards to other topics.

Catharine graciously posted an OUTSTANDING example of the sort of step by step instruction I`m talking about when we all asked about how she did traditional graining/texturing.

What I personally don`t need is another debate about who`s finish is best or another wowee pic with no explanation as to how it was done.

Tell me already or I`m going back to what I know works for me!

Rant off.

Mainely,Bob

PS-Let me apologize in advance if my frustration has upset anyone.

This post is meant as an honest plea for clarity and enlightenment,nothing more.

Re: color of cherry

#24

Re: The limitations of language

Sgian Dubh

>Bob, I actually said, "that American white oak can't be made to look like this with any clear finish... on its own."

I'll try and respond to the rest of your post later when I'm less busy. Slainte.

Re: color of cherry

#25

Please reread my post

Bob Hackett

>If you do you`ll see that I picked up on that point and restated it in the first paragraph.

I look forward to an explanation of the steps you went thru in order to arrive at that pic.The effect is one that I could see myself using as my wife expressed an interest in it.She is real big on color but not paint.She likes the look of wood just not the natural color of most wood,go figure.

I could see where the finish in the pic may be something that could be done with ash too.Ash is something we have alot of up here.I like working with it,my wife hates the yellow color it morphs to over time.If I can manage it,your finish may be just the compromise we`re looking for.

Thanks in advance.

Mainely,Bob