Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT - gas water heater failing?

Posts

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#26

Re: Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, I suppose we should do that as we haven't drained it once in the 10 years we've been here; but part of me really wants to get rid of that space and energy waster, allow me to incorporate that space into a kitchen redo.

Pam

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#27

You need a vent on an electric heater

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>When the smoke gets out of the wires, it's got to have somewhere to go.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#28

But if you vent it....

John in NM

>You can't smell the magic smoke escaping, so you won't know anything is wrong!

:D

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#29

Gas shale maybe (long, OT)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bob,

This is just an amateur's babbling. But the question is very interesting. First off, explaining the comparative prices of LPG versus natural gas in any given area involves knowing the seasonal price variations of the two fuels, their distribution costs to get there, local availability and competition, etc.

But in the big picture, your question touches on a really exciting (to me, anyway) story developing in America over the past couple of years. And that is an innovation in the natural gas industry, where techniques for extracting natural gas from gas shale have been developed. This has happened recently, and with much less fanfare than I think it deserves. The new techniques open up vast new gas fields, and the extraction and collection is very efficient. It is efficient because gas shale wells will produce at high levels for decades, compared with conventional gas wells which tend to yield big early, but then typically decline over time. The technical breakthroughs have been in horizontal drilling into very hard gas shale formation (think concrete), and then fracturing the rock by forcing a liquid/sand slurry through the well lateral, out through the perforations and into the rock at 8,000psi. This fracturing is done at multiple points along the well lateral. The technology is still actively being advanced. Here is Schlumberger's discussion of it, for anyone interested:

http://www.slb.com/media/services/solutions/reservoir/shale_gas.pdf

Bottom line: the cost of natural gas at the US well head has fallen from $11 per thousand cubic feet as recently as two years ago, to $3 per thousand cubic feet presently, and it's still falling. See here:

http://tonto.eia.doe.gov/dnav/ng/hist/n9190us3m.htm

Don't know if the consumer is seeing the effect--or the full effect--yet. See here:

http://tonto.eia.doe.gov/dnav/ng/hist/n3010us3m.htm

But, to date, propane prices tend to follow oil prices:

http://tonto.eia.doe.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=PET&s=WPRREUS4&f=W

What you read is that propane prices follow oil prices, because propane competes at the end-user level more with oil-based products, for example, LPG versus heating oil.

Anyway, the wellhead price of natural gas in the US has recently plunged, and it isn't coming back.

What I am hoping over the medium and long-term is that natural gas will begin displacing crude oil and its derivatives (gasoline for example, and heating oil), so we have less dependence on imported oil.

Again, I am following this stuff as an amateur, so everything I say can be taken with plenty of salt. For anyone investing, I have watched with interest people buying into natural gas funds (such as the exchange-traded fund UNG) with the expectation that natural gas prices 'Have to go up' in the US. But the price just falls and falls and falls, due to fundamentals in the industry.

Wiley

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#30

I understand fracturing

Bob Hackett

>On more than one level.

That was one of the jobs I started out in when I moved to the oilfield.

I worked for Haliburton`s Pampa camp fracturing crew during the boom.

I was one of the few people to survive an intensifier explosion at close range.I left soon after that.

MB-Who has seen alot of really bad jobs come and go but few as bad as working for Haliburton Industries.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#31

Re: Gas shale maybe (long, OT)

Victor Parisian

>Shale gas is interesting. Just had a conversation the other night with and engineer from a major oil company that feels shale gas is over-hyped, and may be short lived. (I hope not.) Anyway he was saying (as I interpreted it at least) that the wells tend to play out rather quickly, and that yes they are extracting natural in an economically viable manner, but they are driving the prices down which could make it quickly uneconomical to recover the gas. Inventories are at an all time high (by a considerable margin) going into the heating season so prices will continue down for the time being.

Another thing that pushes the price lower is that no energy company wants to be the one to start shutting in wells so that other energy companies can profit from their generosity.

Victor in Houston

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#32

Re: But if you vent it....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>But if you don't vent it, you won't be around much longer to experience the full joy of a fire anyhow; so I'd vote for venting. :)

Pam

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#33

They've drilled thousands of gas wells

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>around here in the last 2-3 years.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#34

You've got a miracle on your hands!

Roy Anderson

>Typically, if you get 10 years out of a tank style water heater you are doing good. They don't last all that long. They're not all that robustly made, and who can remember to go down and drain them once per year. Once per year! Man! Talk about intense preventative maintenance. I hardly wake up once per year. (just kidding!)

I believe another poster mentioned about new regulations in California. Well, it's like a virus. There are new safety regulations in Ohio also. It's all about the vent pipe. And also, there is a lot of cheap but ignorant advice about what is required for your vent pipe. I switched to an electric last year because the installer gave me bum information about what was needed to pass the new codes. When the real inspector came to look at my electric heater, he told me that my existing vent pipe would have passed code as-is. So now, I have a pretty, shiny new all-electric water heater that will probably last a good ten years. If, of course, I do the annual P.M.

Another poster mentioned A.O. Smith. I also have heard good things about A.O. Smith. Check the cost/benefit.