Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT - gas water heater failing?

Posts

OT - gas water heater failing?

#1

OT - gas water heater failing?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We have a gas water heater that wasn't new when we moved in 36 years ago. I've replaced the thermocouple (flame to gas valve) a couple of times, most recently a year or so ago. The high pressure relief valve, which I also replaced, is sound and not leaking.

Just in the last week, although the thermostat is set to maximum heat, the water temp has been dropping. I'm taking my showers on full hot water, and am wishing it were a little hotter, and my wife's baths are similarly not as hot. The heater's cycling appropriately - it isn't, for instance, shutting off and then starting up again ten minutes later.

My first hypothesis is that the thermostat built into the gas valve is failing (either directly or because of built up sediment), which would mean, given the heater's age and the fact that the drain doesn't work so I can't draw off sediment, that it's time for heater replacement. We do intend to replace it as part of our larger home update project; I just hadn't planned to do it now.

Is there some other possible inexpensive failing part or diagnostic step that I'm missing?

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#2

Oh, and

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>any recommendations of brands or models if we do replace it?

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#3

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Bill ... when the tank is reheating do you hear a "gurgling" sound?

Have you tried draining the tank a couple of times to get rid of some of the sediment? If you do this (and never have before) you may find that the drain valve now leaks - if so put a pipe cap on it.

Good luck .... rj (who just replaced his water heater with an instant water heater and loves it).

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#4

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

Paul M.

>Hi Bill,

Have fun on the wild adventure of replacing a water heater in CA. Things you need to be aware of:

1) They changed the design of all water heaters a few years back to reduce combustion danger with outside gasses. The result is they are lots taller than they used to be.

2) There are new codes for venting water heaters. The exhaust stack needs to vent vertically or at up to a 45 degree angle. Longer angles are not allowed. But they made water heaters taller so that you may need a longer angle from vertical depending upon the installation location.

3) Every waterheater needs not only a permit, but an inspection. State law and all that yuck.

I've been seriously thinking that when I hit retirement age I should take up a part-time job inspecting waterheaters. It pays great (the license fees for inspection are really high!) and you have to do almost nothing at all other than drive around the county looking at waterheaters. It's a complete crock, but might as well make it work for me.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#5

Fringe benefits

Bob Hackett

>I bet you`d get a free hardhat and a cool aluminum clipboard from the state too.Maybe a badge and ID card identifying you as one of Ahnold`s crew?

Can`t even imagine having to deal with all the red tape involved in seemingly every undertaking in CA.

Maine is another refuge for aging hippies and eco-warriors and we only have to deal with things like if pot warp needs to sink or float in the coming year.

MB

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#6

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

Jerry Nicholson

>You must have some gentle water out there in CA. Here in KS I have never gotten more than 7 years out of a water heater on well water. I think they last a bit longer on city water but I don't know yet. I had 4 Sears water heaters for the price of one - they all sprung leaks near the end of the warranty period. Over the years I have installed at least 7 waters heaters for me and my in-laws. Last one was under a home warranty - sure was nice to let a real plumber do all the work, including schlepping the old unit up the stairs and out to the truck.

Jerry

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#7

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

Richard Jones

>Venting is per code, but also per the manufacturer's instructions. I know of several water heaters that allow nothing but a vertical stack. No turns, no twists, just out through the roof, thank you ma'mm..........

Rich

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#8

Re: Oh, and

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I went through this very thing last week. Exactly same symptoms, and little sediment build-up in the bottom of the tank. My suspicion was that the dead band on the thermostat control unit was too wide, because when we would run the dishwasher or do a load of clothes the water would heat up fine.

However, I talked with three different plumbers who all assured me the only true fix is to replace the whole shebang. The thermostat and control are tied together with the gas regulator valve and that could be replaced on my heater, but the cost approached that of replacing it all. Besides, we have truly bad water and most water heaters don't last 7 years here.

I got a Kenmore with a 9 year warranty. There are virtually no residential water heaters that qualify for the energy tax credit. They have to reach 82% efficiency, and while there is one, the base cost is around $11,000.

Bruce

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#9

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>What Paul says is true about nanny state California. In fact, everyone who has visited the Lie-Nielsen bench plane lineup may have noticed the Proposition 65 warning about how LN bench planes may bring about your demise (if you vaporize one during a cold-fusion experiment in your backyard, and sniff the whole thing up your nose, including the bronze).

However, it has to also be remembered that, in addition to fires, floods, and mudslides, we have real earthquakes. Lots of earthquakes--big, small, intermediate. They give no warning. We had San Francisco burn down in 1906 due to gas lines catching fire as a result. So it's not too dumb to insist on strict code in regard to gas shutoff and venting. If your house goes up, your neighbor's might as well.

Now back to our regularly scheduled programming: I had a Yankee 1530 show up today (thanks Bill Houghton)--I love that thing. Solid, action smooth as a watch.

Wiley

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#10

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>We've been thinking about replacing our gas tank with an instant on, too, for many reasons; but have heard many complaints, most probably due to their ability to get a temperature only relative to the base line water temp available. I take it you like yours? How does the actual temperature work in real life?

Pam

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#11

Hi Bill, I put in a AO Smith...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>ProMax about 2 years ago. It's energy star approved. Picked it up at the local hardware store after doing my homework. All I had to do was bolt it to the wall and install flex lines. The original one was hard lined. I had a plumber come out to check the gas line and fire it up.

If you have gas, I'd look into the tankless ones. Cost a bit more, but there's mot much to wear out. My neighbor installed one and loves it. One thing about these they want a big vent (5" if I recall). I think you adapt the 5" down to 3" with no problems. I haven't heard good things about the electric tankless units.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#12

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Pam .... we've had no problems with adequate water temp.

We did slightly oversize the unit: we could have gone with a slightly smaller unit, but were close to the smaller units capacity so we decided to use part of the tax rebate to upsize.

We live in a cold climate and all of our pipes are in conditioned space and they are heavily insulated as well - this may help with the need to heat up cold pipes before getting hot water. Also, my shower is only 6 feet from the instant water heater; LOML hasn't complained about water temp though and her bathroom is at the other end of the house.

We rarely bath at the same time, but Diane was doing laundry while I was showering last Saturday morning and I had plenty of hot water.

We went with a Rinnai heater (small town, only one distributor); I've heard from friends in the building business that Bosch heaters are good too.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#13

Re: OT - It's just WIERD!!!

Glenn Madsen

>The notion of having some warning before the thing fails catastrophically bends my head! Being able to do more than go buy what's in stock at the BORG must be a real treat...

I bought my last one there, a GE branded thing, 50 gal energy star gas, and installed it myself. 2002, iirc. Works fine, never runs out of water, in spite of those who take loooooonnnnngggg showers.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#14

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Gas Valve

Jim in Burlington

>Those gas valves only have so many cycles in them. I would bet the burner is not going to full fire. 2nd guess is 2 plus feet of scale buildup in a 40 year old water heater. Make sure someone hasn't pinched in either the supply or outlet valves.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#15

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

Ace Karner

>I recommend you switch to an on demand heater, you cannot believe how nice it is to never run out of hot water and see your utility bill go down at the same time.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#16

Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#17

Re: Hi Bill, I put in a AO Smith...

R Payne

>I'd definatly look into tankless. We have a gas tankless capable of running 2 major users (think 2 showers).

The only complaint I have is that some low flow shower heads don't have enough flow rate to trigger the sensor to turn it on unless only the hot is running. The simple solution is to turn the bathroom sink on hot just a bit.

My brother has an electric one with no complaints about it.

ron

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#18

False alarm - whew!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>False alarm, for the moment: somehow, in all the trips my son and I have been taking through that closet (which is also the attic access) for our current remodel, the temperature setting switch got jiggled to a lower temp.

Hot water restored.

My fingers remain crossed: I know we've been on borrowed time for all 36 of the years we've been here.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#19

Re: Thanks.

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Pam ... I measured the temp of water from kitchen tap (about 60% of longest run) - 165 degrees ... rj

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#20

Re: Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>165� is better than what we're getting from the tank, seems to be failing gradually, which is why I'm thinking about a replacement.

Pam

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#21

RE: Natural Gas

Victor P

>Looks like the price of Natural Gas is going to be down for some time. Over supply and a lot of plant closings contributing to the price decline. This is good for the consumers it is good for everyone. With the natural gas prices so low it is difficult to justify the additional cost of more energy efficient models. I'm suspecting that a lot of people who converted to on demand hot water systems are not factoring in the drastically lower gas prices into their savings. I suspect that most of the cost savings has come not from fuel efficiency so much as from lower gas prices. My 2cents worth.

Victor

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#22

gotcha beat on that one...

John in NM

>Though it was more a case of institutional ignorance than goofy code.

Built house in New Mexico, planned to put in electric WH, as the local electric co-op had some pretty good incentives lined up to do so. Turned plans in to the State for a permit, got a letter back saying they couldn't approve them as the WH was not positively vented. Called them and told them it would be an electric WH, and the guy told me it still had to be vented. I explained to him how an electric WH works and he had me send him a brochure on the WH we planned to use, and he finally approved the plans.

The actual building inspector got a good laugh out of that story though.

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#23

Re: Thanks.

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Pam .... you may see an improvement if you drain the tank and get rid of some of the sediment.

When I still had a water heater I drained my tank twice a year (day light savings time): I think the manufacturers recommend doing this monthly, but I'm too lazy to do that. We've been on well-water for the last 8 years and I do notice a lot more sediment now than when we were connected to domestic water services.

The drain valve on most water heaters are pretty crummy so I always installed a good quality valve when installing a new tank.

That pretty much exhausts my knowledge on water heaters ..... rj

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#24

Re: RE: Natural Gas

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Victor ... I probably wouldn't have gone the instant route were it not for the tax rebate and the fact that I'm on propane - man do I miss natural gas ..... rj

Re: OT - gas water heater failing?

#25

Howisit

Bob Hackett

>That natural gas prices are falling and yet propane is going thru the roof?

MB