OT - gas water heater failing?
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>We have a gas water heater that wasn't new when we moved in 36 years ago. I've replaced the thermocouple (flame to gas valve) a couple of times, most recently a year or so ago. The high pressure relief valve, which I also replaced, is sound and not leaking.
Just in the last week, although the thermostat is set to maximum heat, the water temp has been dropping. I'm taking my showers on full hot water, and am wishing it were a little hotter, and my wife's baths are similarly not as hot. The heater's cycling appropriately - it isn't, for instance, shutting off and then starting up again ten minutes later.
My first hypothesis is that the thermostat built into the gas valve is failing (either directly or because of built up sediment), which would mean, given the heater's age and the fact that the drain doesn't work so I can't draw off sediment, that it's time for heater replacement. We do intend to replace it as part of our larger home update project; I just hadn't planned to do it now.
Is there some other possible inexpensive failing part or diagnostic step that I'm missing?



