Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions
scott grandstaff
>Thanks Marv
The teeth are really all there, (more than mine)
just doesn't show in the pic. :)
yours Scott
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions
scott grandstaff
>Thanks Marv
The teeth are really all there, (more than mine)
just doesn't show in the pic. :)
yours Scott
n�
Pedder
>Hi Pam,
sorry to disagree but sawing a tenon cheek with a laser hardened crosscut saw is a PITA.
Cheers Pedder
Re: What, then, do you use to cut the cheeks?
Marv
>Nathan,
Backsaws have been used for sawing tenons since the beginning of time, it seems, but lots of people just used a regular panel saw for the larger tenons. A crosscut saw will rip, but a rip saw will do it better and more accurately.
Here's a picture on a Disston instructional manual showing some dude trying to saw a tenon.
Marv
Re: Some recommendations
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Pam
I must respectfully disagree with you. Using a saw that is not aggressive enough for the rip cut on a tenon is a most unpleasant affair. I have tried using dovetail saws (with 15 ppi rip), a casecase saw (with 14 ppi crosscut), and they really were poor choices. You end up struggling, cutting slowly, getting frustrated ... and this just ends up with poor accuracy.
I have two tenon saws: a beautiful brass backed 12" Disston #5 with 12 tpi, and I never use it anymore. Too slow.. far too slow. I also have a vintage 14" Nurse with 11 ppi. This one is the one I use for all tenons, but it is also a little slower and shorter than I would like. I plan to get a 16" and 10 ppi.
If one does not have a choice, you make anything work. I'd rather get the right tool.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Thanks to all for the enthusiastic responses
Nathan
>It's nice to know that there are so many people willing to share their experience and suggestions. You have provided an abundance of useful information, and for that you deserve my thanks.
To summarize, I will pass on the saws with teflon coatings and hardened teeth. My teacher showed me how to sharpen a saw, so that's not an issue.
Unfortunately, where I live four decades of Communism really massacred the old crafts and traditions. Many still survive in some form, but WW really jumped on the electricity bandwagon and never looked back. You can still find old planes - especially the really arcane ones for ploughing profiles and the like - and some rudimentary saws, but I've never seen a used backsaw for sale anywhere. My teacher said the old Czech cabinetmakers used frame saws to cut tenons - that might explain it.
I did look into PayPal - last I tried (years ago) they wouldn't let me sign up from here. Now that's changed so setting it up will be no problem. Then I'll try to pick up a saw or two from the U.K. eBay. I'm really surprised at how many tenon saws are on there!
True, I don't have a huge budget but I can certainly afford to pick up a few old saws. It's just a matter of choosing ones that are appropriate for what I'm trying to do, which (right now) is cut tenon cheeks.
I did try cutting them with a small panel saw, but (like all saws sold new these days) it was crosscut. I have to be really careful with how I spend my shop time, so making my own saw is not an option right now, but I can buy a 20" frame saw (and blades for it - there's a local manufacturer who makes saws - they just don't make tenon saws) to go with the 30-incher.
Saws are pretty cheap, so I don't see a problem with acquiring a smallish herd of them. My wife already commented on how many planes I was buying (the other day I brought home four wooden planes that I picked up for dirt cheap at an estate sale - a plough plane, a shoulder plane, a plane where the iron is set nearly vertical and has teeth on the business end, and a really neat rabbet plane - bringing my collection to about 10). I count myself lucky that my teacher showed me how to hone the irons and set the depth of cut, otherwise they'd be useless to me except as "DC units" and conversation pieces. The same goes for saws, if he hadn't shown me how to sharpen them.
Re: Some recommendations
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Well, then, please tell me why before I even knew about rip and crosscut in any thoughtful way, I was able to cut most anything with a standard Tyzack, which certainly wasn't rip, but may not have been cross cut either. At any rate, I cut everything with that saw, smooth cuts, fast, easy, all those good things.
Pam, who has a lot of respect for you, too, and appreciates your articles, but who knows that often very good woodworkers disagree over their experiences
Re: Thanks to all for the enthusiastic responses
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>The tune may change when your fellow woodworkers learn that saw dust is a carcinogen. That's what happened in the US a very few years ago. People either bought fancy dust evacuation systems or moved to hand tools.
Pam
Re: Some recommendations
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Well, then, please tell me why before I even knew about rip and crosscut in any thoughtful way, I was able to cut most anything with a standard Tyzack, which certainly wasn't rip, but may not have been cross cut either. At any rate, I cut everything with that saw, smooth cuts, fast, easy, all those good things.
Pam, it does not surprise me that you made the Tyzack work for many tasks. And why would you not be successful? - I think of you as an experienced and very capable woodworker, and I have no doubt that your skills came to the fore.
I did say (in the previous post) that any saw will work .... just that some will work better than others (similarly, I have cut dovetails with all kinds of saws). If you are curious (since I know that you have long since preferred to pull a saw rather than push one), you could try a dedicated tenon saw alongside that crosscut Tyzack ... :)
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Some recommendations
Dean J in MN
>I'm with Derek, you want a tenon saw to cut fast, 10ppi and a 19" blade is my go to tenon saw. Smaller saws just float on the clogged up gullets, even for a smallish tenons, as this cut is really a resaw operation. Clearing the waste is the key and small saws with high ppi counts just are not efficient. I'm sure no one would rip a 2" thick board with a 14 inch 12ppi saw, I know I'd be looking at my 3ppi rip saw; that "monster" 19" 10ppi tenon saw is quite tame in relation.
-Dean
Re: Thanks to all for the enthusiastic responses
Marv
>Nathan,
Another option in your case would be to refile a crosscut panel saw as a rip saw. All you have to do is file straight across the teeth and file out the fleam or Bevel angle. A 10PPI tooth profile would be best for rip cutting large cheeks. For the shoulders, another crosscut panel saw with say 12PPI would work well or a backsaw.
I recently shortened a full size 10PPI handsaw down to 18" and it works great for deep end grain cuts. It was originally a crosscut. When you refile from crosscut to rip, use an 8 degree rake angle.
Good luck,
Marv
Re: Some recommendations
Nathan
>Hi Dean:
I did cut a couple tenons with one of my teacher's 30" frame saws which was fitted with a resaw blade. (Sorry, I don't know the PPI but I would guess something like 8.) It cut at a nice clip and I was able to keep nicely to the line on both sides. So far, so good. However, I was in for a surprise when when I finished cutting and switched over to fitting, for I found that I still had to remove lots of material. Master said this was because the saw I used was too coarse.
I thought maybe it was because I didn't lay out the joint correctly. So I did another one, but the result was the same.
I suppose everyone arrives at their personal preference over time. Really, you have to just start somewhere and go from there.
Nathan
10 ? Slip-slidding awayyyyyyyyyyyy !
steve mackay
>
Re: Some recommendations
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>We certainly agree that "any saw will work." I'm so glad because it may turn out to be important that beginners only have one saw to start with, that learning to use that one saw in every situation may be the most valuable sawing lesson one has.
Pam
Re: Some recommendations
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>So now you know to take your measure differently, making the tenon narrower than your measurements say.
Pam
Re: Thanks to all for the enthusiastic responses
ThomD
>"Saws are pretty cheap, so I don't see a problem with acquiring a smallish herd of them"
The only problem is all the lost time to fettling, maintaining, and storing the stuff. A few good pieces will get you there.
Re: Thanks to all for the enthusiastic responses
ThomD
>Dust is sorta all bad, but last I heard it was mostly the cedar that was carcinogenic (an presumably other similarly resistant to decay woods). Even then it takes a lot of the stuff over decades to really mess one up. ??
Re: Thanks to all for the enthusiastic responses
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Thanks, I haven't kept up with this issue, feeling comfortable sitting back smugly and not having to breathe dust. :)
Pam