Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

Posts

In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#1

In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

Nathan

>Allow me to introduce myself - my name is Nathan Cutler and, though born and raised in the U.S., I live in the Czech Republic - in Europe, used to be in the Eastern Bloc. I've been interested in woodworking for about the past five years. I thought I could take a "shortcut" and make things by machine, and I now have a garage full of machines. But gradually it dawned on me that the machines make a lot of things even more difficult (not to mention complicated, and expensive). This past September opportunity knocked and I'm now doing a part-time apprenticeship with a local cabinetmaker, who is teaching me to work with hand tools (later, of course, he'll teach me to use the machines, too).

Anyway, this past week we've been doing bridle joints. My teacher told me that, in the days of yore (i.e. the generation before him), a cabinetmaker would cut the joint with a saw and the two pieces would fit together on the first try, without any further "fiddling". I've cut a couple joints, including a twin bridle joint, but mine are either too tight or too loose. Part of the problem is definitely my technique, but my teacher told me it's also in the saw. He recommends either a fine-toothed frame saw or a tenon saw. I have a frame saw but it's too big (80cm/31.5") for the task, so I'm looking at tenon saws.

In the local market, I basically have four choices. Either I can go with a cheap Chinese saw, or I can buy a Stanley, or I can buy a BAHCO (all Western saws), or I can buy a Japanese saw. I don't know if you're familiar with BAHCO - I believe they're a Scandinavian firm, known for high quality. They have three hand-saw lines, the best being the "Superior" line. The BAHCO Superior tenon saw has hardened teeth and is teflon coated.

I read somewhere that hardened teeth can't be sharpened, but it seems to me that they could be if you used a triangular diamond file. Any thoughts on this?

Also, is it worth paying extra for the teflon coating? Seems to me that it would wear off eventually. I read that Alan Peters would run a bar of soap over the teeth to make the saw run smooth.

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#2

The obligatory photo

Nathan

>Here's a somewhat poor-quality photo of my twin bridle joint. It has a rabbet that my teacher cut on the shaper, but you can't see it in the picture. But you can see how rough the cuts are...

Sorry for the rambling post - I have trouble with brevity. To recapitulate, my questions are: (1) pros and cons of hardened teeth (my teacher showed me how to sharpen a saw, so it's not like I want to avoid sharpening), (2) is it even possible to sharpen the hardened teeth, e.g. with a diamond-coated file, and (3) is teflon coating on the saw-blade worth paying extra.

Thanks and looking forward to making your acquaintance.


img

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#3

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

Pedder

>Hi Nathan,

Any of the saws you mentioned are good for your task. They are sharoened crosscut wich is really bad for sawing tenons.

Living in Europe there are many good dealers in Germany or Great Britain you can buy a saw from. If you are in the market for a really cheap saw I would recommend a Wiliam Greaves gent saw from Dieter Schmid fine tools

http://www.fine-tools.com/fein.htm

Be sure to buy a saw file to, because you want to resharpen the saw to lower the set.

A little bit more expensive but a good tool is the Veritas dovetail saw. They are available from

Dieter Schmid http://www.fine-tools.com/fuchs.htm,

Dick http://www.dick.biz/dick/product/703646/detail.jsf

Classichandtools http://www.classichandtools.com/acatalog/Saws-and-Saw-Guides-by-Veritas.html

and many other places.

If you want a high end saw, buy Adria or Lie-Nielsen from the same dealers.

Cheers Pedder

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#4

Need something that will cut deeper

Nathan

>Hi Pedder:

Thanks for the links. Yeah, the Bahco Superior is at the upper end of my price range. I looked at the Gent's saw and I already have a couple of those. They are fine but I'm looking for something with more depth of cut.

I'm glad you warned me the Bahco, Stanley, etc. tenon saws are sharpened for crosscut. You wonder why would they do that on a product billed as a TENON SAW.

Seems to me it makes no sense to buy something with hardened teeth if the first thing I'm going to have to do is reshape them!

Nathan

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#5

For cutting the tenon shoulders

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#6

What, then, do you use to cut the cheeks?

Nathan

>A frame saw, like my teacher suggested?

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#7

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions *LINK*

Marv

>Hello Nathan,

Have you tried searching on eBay? Ebay is a huge auction site where you can bid on things you find that you need or want. Sometimes you can get a bargain on things like saws. Be aware though, some sellers will not ship overseas due to people scamming the system. But some sellers will. Always ask the seller before you bid. Ebay is a great source for most anything you want. You will have to get a PayPal account in order to pay for things you buy. It will take a little time to get setup with eBay and PayPal but once you do, it will be worth it, not just for saws, but most any hand tool you'll ever need.

Good luck,

Marv


Ebay auction site

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#8

Re: What, then, do you use to cut the cheeks?

Marv

>Nathan,

The cheeks are cut with a tenon saw filed with rip teeth. The shoulders are cut with a tenon saw filed with crosscut teeth. Two different saws. The size of your tenons will determine the size of saw.

Mike Wenzloff, a well known saw maker who comes in here quite often can better advise you on teeth or points per inch for what ever size saw you need for what ever size tenon. And he'll even sell you the saws. He'll make the saws to fit your needs.

Marv

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#9

Cheap alternatives

Bob Hackett

>First,I would ask what the man you apprentice under recommends as best.

Makes it easier to learn by example if you`re both using the same tools.

That being said,if you already have a frame saw that`s too big then use it as a model and make a smaller one.There have been some excellent examples posted here,look in the archives.Think of it as doing your part to use up the shop off-cuts.

For a blade just look at some of the broken bandsaw blades from the shop you work out of.As long as they`re not bi-metal or induction hardened you should be able to refile whatever tooth you desire.

I knew an accomplished WWer who used to punch holes in a piece of old wide bandsaw blade and put it in a hacksaw frame and cut tenons.He also used a regular hacksaw blade to cut dovetails.The results were as good as any from a $100+ special saw(he owned a good selection of those too).

Mainely,Bob

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#10

Re: Cheap alternatives

Nathan

>Hi Bob,

Interesting that you should mention the hacksaw. I recently picked up a couple reversible hacksaw blades that have the standard hacksaw teeth on one side and woodcutting teeth on the other side. (Have those in the States? This was the first I'd seen them.) I'll put one in my hacksaw and give it a try.

I did try a normal hacksaw blade on the tenon but all it was good for was starting the kerf. Once I got to about 1/8" deep it was still cutting but the vibrations were terrible - this was because I was working in 2" thick material. For thinner material I think it would work fine.

Nathan

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#11

Euro tools

Bob Hackett

>Haven`t seen any dual purpose hacksaw blades up here in Maine.

The Gent I spoke of used a high tension hacksaw frame,the kind that uses either a crank or cam/lever to really stretch the blade.The old wimpy frame and small wingnut hacksaws didn`t cut it(pun intended).

One of the things I miss about working on yachts from across the pond was looking at the tools in the engine room.I even talked afew of those out of the hands of the crew from time to time,aided by the trade of afew local tools and treats like lobsters right from my friend`s boat.

MB

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#12

Some recommendations *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Nathan

No one has yet said to you what saws you should ideally be using as a guideline.

Well, this is just my opinion ...

Firstly, I do not like any of the options you mention. Stay away from impulse hardened saws (which cannot be sharpened or have the set adjusted).

Secondly, you need a rip-sharpened tenon saw for the cheeks, and a crosscut-sharpened carcase saw for the shoulders.

You are more likely to be successful looking in the UK market for these saws, although there is nothing to stop you looking in either the American eBay market since these days the world is just a click away. Of course you could purchase new, but that was not the message I have been hearing.

For the rip tenon saw (cheeks), 12" would only be used for small work, while 14" would be considered a general purpose size. These days a 16" is becoming the norm, and even longer (19") is used on large work. Look for 10 or 11 ppi.

For the cross cut carcase you want something that is essentially a joinery saw, but 11-12" long. Mine is 14 ppi. You can get away with using a high-tooth dovetail saw here but in the long term you will appreciate the proper tool.

I recently posted a primer on M&T joints, link below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


A Primer for Mortice-and-Tenon Joints

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#13

scott grandstaff

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

scott grandstaff

>Bet you can't eat just one!!

Unless you are planning to do the exact same job in the exact same material forever (like a factory), one saw will never do.

You need saws! Lots of saws!

People don't make different sizes and different teeth and different handles because they are dumb ya know. :)

Each saw excels at what it was designed for, when you get it properly sharpened and set and fettled just so, it does.

Of course this means you need a saw jointer and a saw set and a saw vise because waiting for someone else to maintain your saws is frustration on a stick. Better to buckle down and learn your trade. It doesn't cost much and you only have to learn it once.

So start grabbing saws. Forget retail hardware stuff. Thats the only kind you don't want. Plastic handles and cheezy workmanship you are better off to avoid in the long run. You'll never stick with those.

Try a custom saw from Mike or Eddy or any of the great current sawmakers. Rob(in) makes a good saw, lots of choices out there.

Then start piling up your own. There are saws all around when you start to look. Saws can be repurposed. They can be made from almost scratch, that is take an old blade and make what you need from it.

Saws rock

yours Scott


img

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#14

How much deepth do you need than?

Pedder

>

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#16

AMEN ! . . .

steve mackay

>More saws also make me smarter and better looking ! Didn't notice Mr. Wenzloff's name above as a recomendation. Probably missed it though.

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#17

Re: tenon saws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I agree with Pedder's advice on UK ebay. Look at the vintage saws. This is a way that you can obtain a high-quality saw at a reasonable price. The main advantages of the vintage saws over the current manufactures, is that the vintage saws will have less set--the correct amount of set--not to mention they will be far more comfortable in the hand. It's tough to fix a saw with too much set. If you do elect to buy a vintage saw on ebay, be sure and ask the seller (before you bid) whether the handle is loose--that is not easy to fix.

See Derek's advice as to length and tpi.

Very best wishes,

Wiley

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#18

Oh, come on - this is a beginner here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think the argument that optimal tenon cutting works with both a rip and a cross cut saw is fine - but Nathan will, if he gets hooked on this hand tool stuff, find his way to the edge of the slippery slope soon enough.

I urge those with more experience than I have to offer suggestions for one or two first saws to get, based on the scale and scope of work indicated in his original messages.

Just as it's not necessary to own $10,000 worth of machinery to make first projects, it hardly seems necessary to own a dozen saws for first projects.

Bill, climbing off his soapbox now and shuffling to the back of the room...having meant to offer a constructive suggestion

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#19

Re: What, then, do you use to cut the cheeks?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I use a rip kataba (single sided Japanese saw) usually for longer tenons; but if the tenon is fairly short I might use either the kataba or the LV Pro dozuki that I've mentioned several times. That dozuki works very fast for either cross cut (tenon shoulders) or rip (tenon cheeks), pretty amazing and cheap.

Pam

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#20

Re: What, then, do you use to cut the cheeks?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Forgot to mention that I started cutting tenons and dovetails about 30 years ago with a Tyzack back saw, which also worked very well, to probably about a 4" depth.

Pam

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#21

Re: Some recommendations

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Secondly, you need a rip-sharpened tenon saw for the cheeks, and a crosscut-sharpened carcase saw for the shoulders.

Derek, based on personal experience, and a fair amount of it, this is simply an urban myth. Yes, if the tenon will be 6" long, you may prefer a rip saw, but you don't need it. You absolutely need a good rip saw for resawing; but usually tenons are short and require a minimal amount of work and can be done with any old saw hanging around the shop.

Pam

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#22

Hear! Hear!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#23

Re: tenon saws

Marv

>Wiley,

When you buy on eBay, you can expect to get most anything, including too much set. Most of the old saws I get will have too much set. It's no big deal though if you know how to file the teeth. You just file out the excess set. The UK eBay is a good source for Nathan. I see some really good buys there on tenon saws.

Tightening a handle is not a big problem in most cases. You just clamp across the cheeks of the handle and tighten the nuts. But don't rely on just screwing the nuts into the wood. Clamp it first. For split nuts, be sure to use a forked screwdriver. Better yet, don't buy a saw with split nuts.

Marv

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#24

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

Marv

>Scott,

Nice look'n saw, but ya need ta do some jointing on those teeth and give it a couple more passes with the file. *grin*

Marv

Re: In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions

#25

scott grandstaff

Re: Oh, come on - this is a beginner here

scott grandstaff

>it hardly seems necessary to own a dozen saws for first projects.

I wasn't sending him to yuppie poverty, I was sending him to the Austria equivalent of the Salvation Army!

Swap meet, car boot, I don't know what they have, but they have to have something where the poor people get together and do penny business.

You can get vaguely decent saws here for a dollar if you look. I expect in Europe, where they have another 2 or 300 years of sawmaking to draw on, there much be zillions!

A dozen you ought to be able to round up the first day.

yours Scott