In market for tenon saw, but . . . questions
Nathan
>Allow me to introduce myself - my name is Nathan Cutler and, though born and raised in the U.S., I live in the Czech Republic - in Europe, used to be in the Eastern Bloc. I've been interested in woodworking for about the past five years. I thought I could take a "shortcut" and make things by machine, and I now have a garage full of machines. But gradually it dawned on me that the machines make a lot of things even more difficult (not to mention complicated, and expensive). This past September opportunity knocked and I'm now doing a part-time apprenticeship with a local cabinetmaker, who is teaching me to work with hand tools (later, of course, he'll teach me to use the machines, too).
Anyway, this past week we've been doing bridle joints. My teacher told me that, in the days of yore (i.e. the generation before him), a cabinetmaker would cut the joint with a saw and the two pieces would fit together on the first try, without any further "fiddling". I've cut a couple joints, including a twin bridle joint, but mine are either too tight or too loose. Part of the problem is definitely my technique, but my teacher told me it's also in the saw. He recommends either a fine-toothed frame saw or a tenon saw. I have a frame saw but it's too big (80cm/31.5") for the task, so I'm looking at tenon saws.
In the local market, I basically have four choices. Either I can go with a cheap Chinese saw, or I can buy a Stanley, or I can buy a BAHCO (all Western saws), or I can buy a Japanese saw. I don't know if you're familiar with BAHCO - I believe they're a Scandinavian firm, known for high quality. They have three hand-saw lines, the best being the "Superior" line. The BAHCO Superior tenon saw has hardened teeth and is teflon coated.
I read somewhere that hardened teeth can't be sharpened, but it seems to me that they could be if you used a triangular diamond file. Any thoughts on this?
Also, is it worth paying extra for the teflon coating? Seems to me that it would wear off eventually. I read that Alan Peters would run a bar of soap over the teeth to make the saw run smooth.





