Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

Posts

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#26

A secret lumber source revealed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Bob, you maybe should have kept this a secret but since the cat is out of the bag.......Mills that separate out veneer logs to sell are a source of awesome wood, if you can stand the short lengths. Sometimes a saw log can be improved to a veneer long by trimming off XX feet. This trimming will be coming from what would have been an exceptional saw log, yielding exceptional lumber. Typically a mill carriage will not accommodate anything less than 8' length so these trimmings are worthless to the mill for lumber.These trimmings generally wind up going to the chipper and can often be had for free.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#27

Sanding evens out effect of stain

Steve Elliott

>My experience has been that planing will bring out more contrast between areas of grain parallel to the surface v. ascending or descending grain. The areas of non-parallel grain soak up stain the way end grain does, darker than other areas. The result can be considered as enhancing the grain or causing blotchiness depending on whether or not it's the intended look.

A coarsely sanded surface takes stain darker than a finely sanded one, and a well-planed surface doesn't drink up much stain at all except where the grain rises or falls. This doesn't depend much on the pores; it's more a matter of torn fibers on the surface that give the stain more to stick to.

Just now I took a planed surface on cherry and sanded a small patch with 120x sandpaper (which is pretty coarse for finishing). When I put a drop of water on each surface the drop on the planed surface sort of balled up and the drop on the sanded surface gradually spread into the surrounding wood. To exaggerate, a planed surface is like glass and a sanded surface is like a blotter.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#28

Re: Also depends on what wood

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The same plane will leave similar surfaces on both ipe` and pine but they will take the finish in a completely different way.

I'm sure they take finish in different ways, however it's unlikely that the same plane would be used effectively on both ipe (very hard) and pine (very soft), unless you're talking about powered planers.

Pam

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#29

The yard near Skowhegan was...

Bob Hackett

>Selling the drops from veneer grade BE maple,incredible curly maple in both hard and soft,rippled ash and flame birch for green firewood before I stumbled along and started buying it by the dump truck load.

The smaller family owned mills around here will just kick whole logs off the landing if they discover any metal in them.They used to be free for the taking till firewood prices went thru the roof.

If I was more computer savy I`d try and post a pic of an X shaped piece of oak that`s holding up one end of our kitchen island.Two trees rubbed and then grafted together to form it.It was a gift from Will in Nobleboro after one of my visits to his sawmill.

MB

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#30

I`ve got at least 1 that will

Bob Hackett

>My Stanley low angle block plane w/HSS iron will plane both effectively.

You`re so literal Pam,I just picked 2 woods at opposite ends of the spectrum off the top of my head to make a point.

If I really wanted to plane the figured Ipe` I have I`d use my Knight HA smoother but rather than put us both thru that I think I`d defer to Bill and just grab the belt sander,respirator,ear plugs,face shield,etc.

I haven`t turned any bowls from the Ipe` either for obvious reasons,It was hard enough trying to crosscut with a new(now very worn) chain on the chainsaw.The guys sinking these logs as marine pilings tried to warn me,but did I listen...

MB

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#31

WOW Who would thunk....

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Cherry is not a wood to be died or otherwise violated. All it need is time. Here's a frame I made 1 or 2 years ago. Simple oil finish, nothing dyed in the process...


img

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#32

Re: I`ve got at least 1 that will

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I just didn't want the people who are just beginning to use hand planes to think you were being literal, that they could take one of those standard metal planes and approach two such different woods with it, much less that one should even think of planing ipe. :)

Pam

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#33

Re: WOW Who would thunk....

ThomD

>As you know, you can leave a piece by the window with something lying across it and come back with a "blueprint" on the cherry. I don't know why people stain it.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#34

Re: A secret lumber source revealed

ThomD

>Cool, I am still looking for one of these places. I have 125 acres of trees, and some of them look really nice. Nothing like cutting one down to loose that impression. I don't know where the yards get those veneer logs!!

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#35

OT: challenging your prejudices

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The best training video I ever saw on hiring people stressed the same thing: once you've formed an opinion about a candidate, ask questions that test your opinion.

Way too few managers ever do this, which is why human resources functions enjoy guaranteed employment in most organizations - people hire problems, and HR then gets to help them sort them out.

Bill, proud of 30 years in the HR trade, not unhappy to be done with it

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#36

Re: OT: challenging your prejudices

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>All too often people confine others to fit their personal limitations, and this is why often HR departments seem so abysmal to engineer types. Before I started my own software development firm, I'd gotten to the point of not bothering with companies that asked you to go through HR first (yeah, a long time ago). The "problems" they'd actually not hire may be the best for a given position.

Why are we talking about this?

Pam

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#37

Re: OT: challenging your prejudices

John L Blue

>sorta like electin' Presidents!

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#39

Re: OT: challenging your prejudices

steve mackay

>You must be a saint, Sir. In the ARMY you can identify a bad egg, train it over and over, keep it at a safe distance (most of the time), beg with it, plead with it and even order it but you'll NEVER be rid of it.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#40

Thus proving the theory....

Bob Hackett

>There is no such thing as an untrainable soldier.

One of the army`s favorites.

A favorite quote(it`s stuck to the bottom of my monitor)"In theory there is no difference between theory and practice.In practice there is."

Mainely,Bob-Who swallowed very little of the army`s "proven" theories during his many years in uniform.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#41

HR

Bob Hackett

>Isn`t that where supposedly objective 3rd parties intervene in order to coerce you to do what you knew to be right in the first place but just couldn`t bring yourself to put into action?;^)

MB

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#42

Re: Thus proving the theory....

James Watriss

>Ha! That's the quote I sign some of my emails with. Yogi Berra's hilarious.

And yeah, I remember the army treating people that way. Definitely reinforced the old adage that you can't change someone who doesn't want to be changed.

I did my job well, but I can't honestly say I was the best soldier they ever had.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#43

same idea applies to most things

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#44

Coerce? Heck, no

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of the traps that HR people can fall into at the beginning is to think that they can cause change. What they can do is educate and warn. Occasionally, people change as a result.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#45

It's my shop

roninkokomo

>So much of what we do is a matter of personal preference. In my shop. Cherry does NOT get stained.

You can make the rule in your shop

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#46

Beautiful work, Scott, very nice

Marv

>

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#47

Re: Beautiful work, Scott, very nice

Marv

>Not sure how this post got up here at the top....

Marv

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#48

Realities of time and space on the intertubes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If a thread is far enough down, your response will show up at the top on the message index, as if it were a brand new thread. When you click on the message, though, it'll take its rightful place in the thread.

Once or twice, on other fora, I've gotten surprised by a reply to a message thread that dated back to, say, 2006. The person posting the reply was clearly browsing way back in history. Less likely here, since Ellis moves material to the archives after a while.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#49

Re: Realities of time and space on the intertubes

Marv

>Thanks Bill,

With that information I'll sleep much better tonight....*grin*

Marv