Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>It would seem that many on this site believe without question that a hand planed surface is superior in appearance to one that is sanded. Whether most people would agree with this conclusion depends on what happens next.
I don't question the conclusion that an unfinished hand planed surface looks better than any sanded surface I ever created. The hand planed surface may even look better with the sparse coatings some prefer, for example thinned shellac.
I typically meticulously hand sand surfaces before finishing. In most cases I find it a more reliable, but slower, means to getting a smooth tear-free surface than hand planing . In cases where a finish of typical thickness is applied, for example varnish or lacquer, I can't tell any difference between one hand planed and hand sanded.
For steam bent parts, the hand planed surface is superior because the steaming doesn't raise the grain compressed by sanding.
For what I will call chemically stained surfaces- chromate, ammonia, and the like- there is the grain raising issue with sanded surfaces that is lessened compared to sanded but the appearance is equivalent once a finish with typical build is applied.
For pigment and dye stained surfaces there is a dramatic difference between sanded and planed. I find the hand planed surface to drink up stain like a sponge and I find it very hard to control the "take" of the stain. I stain almost everything I make so this factor is most important to me. The burnishing from 180 or 220 sandpaper (depending on the species) enables me to control the color development of the stained piece (I apply stain with a rubber like shellac).
The bottom line is that in my experience the best surface preparation (planed or sanded) depends on the subsequent finishing operations. It would be well for those not yet settled on a finishing schedule to keep this information in mind.






