Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

Posts

Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#1

Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It would seem that many on this site believe without question that a hand planed surface is superior in appearance to one that is sanded. Whether most people would agree with this conclusion depends on what happens next.

I don't question the conclusion that an unfinished hand planed surface looks better than any sanded surface I ever created. The hand planed surface may even look better with the sparse coatings some prefer, for example thinned shellac.

I typically meticulously hand sand surfaces before finishing. In most cases I find it a more reliable, but slower, means to getting a smooth tear-free surface than hand planing . In cases where a finish of typical thickness is applied, for example varnish or lacquer, I can't tell any difference between one hand planed and hand sanded.

For steam bent parts, the hand planed surface is superior because the steaming doesn't raise the grain compressed by sanding.

For what I will call chemically stained surfaces- chromate, ammonia, and the like- there is the grain raising issue with sanded surfaces that is lessened compared to sanded but the appearance is equivalent once a finish with typical build is applied.

For pigment and dye stained surfaces there is a dramatic difference between sanded and planed. I find the hand planed surface to drink up stain like a sponge and I find it very hard to control the "take" of the stain. I stain almost everything I make so this factor is most important to me. The burnishing from 180 or 220 sandpaper (depending on the species) enables me to control the color development of the stained piece (I apply stain with a rubber like shellac).

The bottom line is that in my experience the best surface preparation (planed or sanded) depends on the subsequent finishing operations. It would be well for those not yet settled on a finishing schedule to keep this information in mind.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#2

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

Chris Friesen

>You make an excellent point.

As a counter-example, for something like selective dyeing of figured wood to "pop" the figure one may be better off using hand planes for surface prep to enhance the absorption of dye in the end grain of the figure.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#3

scott grandstaff

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

scott grandstaff

>There is never a right or wrong.

Your customer, whether it you or someone else, usually dictates more than anything.

Most people, who aren't woodworkers, have ever seen anything besides routine sanded and semi opaque stain.

"But its so -even-." Is the most repeated comment. They expect defect free surfaces and boring color overall.

People who know wood and like wood (as opposed to a furniture store "product") don't want same color wood buecause wood is never really the same color unless it plastic.

Matchy match color to the JC Pennys sideboard??

Uck!

A planed surface is a mark of high distinction whether there is a little tearout or not. But only among woodworkers or antique collectors.

With most products most people see coming off an assembly line, which is the only thing most of them ever see, they are all the same.

Or almost all the same.

Many people figure their life is to Inspector Defect everything they encounter.

To legions, a marginal quality overall, yet "perfect", is totally what they expect.

Sanded slick with flat out opaque stain (paint) is the only thing that appeals to many members of the general public.

yours Scott

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#4

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Bill, you use the terms typical build and typical thickness. "Typical" finishes and techniques are designed to enhance sanded surfaces. Almost all current finishing information is written by people who have little or no experience finishing planed surfaces. In 1978 I realized that sanding was degrading my surfaces and I have not sanded since. I don't want to write a treatise on finishing, but I will tell you that my finishing techniques have gradually become better at showing off the clean and lively hand planed surfaces. So yes, as you surmise the surface preparation and the finishing schedule need to complement each other.

Several years ago Fine Woodworking did an article comparing planed and sanded surfaces after they were "finished" with various products. In each case the author put on a thin wash coat of finish and then sanded the surface, certainly sanding the wood of the "unsanded" samples also. It was no wonder that they looked the same at the end.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#5

response

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You seem to discount the possibility that there is some finish between your ideal of "hand planed" and "factory" that could be attractive to discerning people. If true, I suggest you get out and see custom furniture more, especially reproduction furniture, where minimalist finishes were not favored.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#6

scott grandstaff

Re: Heartened to hear it

scott grandstaff

>Cool! Its great to hear there are more flavors than what I see here in the deep woods.

I will gladly admit to laying down multi coats of sometimes colored shellac (orange, garnet etc) and heavy hand rubbed lacquer. Not exactly a minimal finish. Just no opaque stain when I can help it. No stain at all is my hands down favorite. I only use stain when I am ashamed of the wood (its pasty and ucky) or working for someone else, where it seems I always have to (sigh).

But I would love to get out and see more of the world and its woodworkers. Almost bad enough to do it. hee hehehe

yours Scott

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#7

Warren - perhaps not a treatise, but

Chuck Nickerson

>are you willing to share how your finishing has changed? I'd like to try some semi-directed experimentation.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#8

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

ThomD

>"It would seem that many on this site believe without question that a hand planed surface is superior in appearance to one that is sanded. Whether most people would agree with this conclusion depends on what happens next...

The bottom line is that in my experience the best surface preparation (planed or sanded) depends on the subsequent finishing operations. It would be well for those not yet settled on a finishing schedule to keep this information in mind.

I agree with that for the most part:

- It isn't just a mater off what comes later, it is also a mater of what comes first. Heavy sanding often is worse than heavy planing it dulls surfaces and edges, and for better or worse fills pores prematurely. Of course heavy leveling with the plane can cause terrible tear-out, or be impractical.

- As far as what comes next, the presumption of superiority is strongest when the project is limited to projects that are best completed by hand planing. Hiking is a good way of getting around the mountains, but a poor way of traveling the I95. Fly fishing can be devastatingly effective where casting tackle is limited, and vise versa. It is possible to build a whole woodworking culture (or maybe much of one), as in Japan or rural arts over here, on hand cut finishes. It is hard to see that as limiting oneself.

- There is also the question of better in terms of input. Is it better more demanding and satisfying woodworking to finish with hand tools. Is it better for me, and not just in health. There are value judgments there, but that is the kind of place we will all end up, liking something for the process involved, even if we like different things. Personally I like everything. I enjoy woodworking with a disc sander in it's place, "barking back", and I enjoy shavings measured in the tens. I also have my preferences as far as cleaning up is concerned.

- When it comes to the final finish, I agree sanding is often the better approach, or the only approach. Methods do influence finish a lot though. There are certain results that go hand in hand with planed finishes and can't be achieved otherwise. That needs to be taken into account also.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#9

Example

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You all can judge for yourselves whether you find this finish attractive, opaque, muddy or any other adjective applied to stained furniture. Personally I find unstained cherry raw looking, and unattractive except in a very modern piece. I like this particular mineral pigment oil based stain on cherry. Other than richening some there is little color change over time with it.

The surface preparation was hand sand at 220 with garnet paper, Stain applied with rubber as would be done with shellac. I probably didn't use as much as 2 oz of stain for the whole table.

On a hand planed surface this stain is unacceptably dark and its hard to control uniformity.


img

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#10

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

Sgian Dubh

>Bill, in more than thirty years of working as furniture designer maker, and teacher, and making a living at it one way or another I can tell you that I've only once got a surface prepped ready for polish with only cutting tools, ie, planes and scrapers. It was a small box of some sort if I recall rightly. Everything else has gone, and will continue to go through the same routine until I retire from the game, ie, machine worked as much as possible followed by planing and scraping (but only if appropriate) and sanding, usually from about 100 or 120 grit down to 220 grit at the finest. Some pieces don't even see a plane and they pretty much go straight to the 3 phase sanding machines of various sorts followed by hand held power sanders. After any one of those routines I get the finishing done, whatever form that takes.

I think my surface preparation and finishes are at least passable, and so do my customers. Surface preparation using only planes and/or scrapers is too time consuming and the (alleged) benefits certainly don't outweigh the disadvantages, ie the extra cost due to increased time requirements and all the tell tale marks left behind-- unless the customer wants those marks in the final result of course.

Am I right or wrong? The answer is neither. What I do is right for me and my customers. My methods need not be right for other furniture designer makers with alternative priorities and motives. Slainte.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#11

Re: Warren - perhaps not a treatise, but

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use water stains. Pigment stains tend to unify the color in the same way paint would, but they take away from clarity, depth and chatoyance. Oil based dyes tend to give a greasy look and take a while to dry. I also use shellac, wax, and oil. I occasionally use varnish, but my feeling is that varnishes are usually formulated for sanded surfaces which need considerable build to achieve a finished look.

As with any finishing, an experienced worker will do a better job with a given material than a novice, even if they are following the same schedule. So if you make changes to your finishing habits it may be a while before the results are better than what you now can achieve. The main thing is to be observant and discriminating.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#12

Other Example

Frank D. in Montreal

>Here's one that's hand-sanded, finished with a mix of tried and True and tung oil. I don't think cherry looks bad without stain...at least not with the finishes I use. I always hand sand my pieces after assembly. As well as cleaning up dirt and tool marks (I plane before glue-up), for me sanding allows me to five a final shape to everything, fait curves and sharpen or knock down corners etc. In other words, sandpaper for me is just another hand tool. I've done many finishing tests with hand-plane versus sanded surfaces, and I still can't warrant skipping the final sanding.


img

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#13

Excellent example

Bob Hackett

>Figured cherry really shows off the depth of figure after being planed or scraped as opposed to sanded.Come to think of it,the same could be said of most any highly figured wood.

IME the clarity and depth suffers noticeably when prepped by sanding alone.I can get it to acceptable(for me)levels if I want to spend ALOT of time sanding,but I`d rather pick up a blade and cut my time at least in half.

YMMV,of course.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#14

my take

Adam Cherubini

>I think power planers do stuff to wood that is hard to sand out.

I saw a guy a the designer craftsman show years ago with a table of beautiful curly maple. I took a closer look and the curl was actually planer marks. The table was sanded and finished nicely.

I think machines compress wood when they don't burn it or mark it up. I think it's important to remove that outer layer. In the past I tried to just smooth plane S2S lumber, but you really need to take away more than that. That approach doesn't work all that well. I find S2S typically harder to work then rough lumber.

I also think kiln drying has a large effect on lumber. This may effect surface finish qualities as well.

Tho my friend Wareen may disagree, I leave open the possibility that I may not always be able to tell the difference between finished boards that have been hand planed and those that were sanded. I think the two can look VERY alike. Especially if one intends them to look similar. Naturally boards obviously hand planes (like the work I do for example) are hard to fake and attempts can be obvious.

Adam

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#15

Kiln vs air dried

Bob Hackett

>I also greatly prefer air dried over kiln.The natural color is still in place and not "homogenized" thru the use of steam etc.

AD also seems to be more cooperative,less movement during cuts and seems to respond better to being cut(and sanded too).

It may require more time to let AD acclimate but I feel the results are well worth it.

The selection and price up here makes AD my wood of choice,especially if I drop the trees myself and bring them to the closest bandsaw mill owner(Just around the corner).:^)

Mainely,Bob

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#16

a contrary example?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You stated that " the clarity and depth suffers noticeably when prepped by sanding alone"

I will leave it to those undecided on their finishing schedule to decide whether sanding will result in less depth and clarity by providing examples of sanded work. In fact, my purpose in these posts it to raise doubt in the minds of the undecided whether sanding produces inferior results. Once doubt is raised, then go to shows and see first hand furniture finished various ways. Then make an informed decision.

I had a 6th grade teacher (who I hated and the feeling was mutual) that stressed "challenging your prejudices". It may be the most useful philosophical advice I received in the public school system.

While I am at it, I have worked thousands of bdft of hardwood lumber over the years and I haven't found properly KD lumber lacking in any way. (you can screw up AD lumber just as easily as KD if it isn't done with knowledgeable care).

And, Adam, you won't find machine planer makes in my furniture, or any other evidence of what was used to establish nominal thickness.


img

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#17

Small lumber suppliers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bob and all,

You spoke of the availability of wood suppliers and supplies in your neck of the Maine woods.

Can you recommend any local suppliers or mills who will do mail-order shipping to unforested parts of the world (like where I live)? For example, I once got a recommendation on Badger Pond for a small mill, name of Tuckaway Timber, in Lyme, NH. These folks do not appear in Woodfinder, nor do they have a continuous supply of standard product that they advertise--what they have depends on what they've been cutting. There was some advantage I found in talking to them long distance and paying for shipping--as opposed to going to my local S4S dealer--because I could find out what they had that they thought was particularly choice at that time.

I just mention Tuckaway as an example--good outfits you'd never come across without a recommendation from someone local to them.

Any suggestions?

Wiley

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#18

Re: Small lumber suppliers

Bob Hackett

>Goosebay Lumber & Sawmill inc,in NH is an EXCELLENT place to find both exotics and native hardwoods.

Fat Andy`s here in Maine always has interesting wood ranging from billets of snakewood to containers of real Cuban mahogany.

I used to buy woods such as BE and curly maple and flame birch by the ton as trimmings from veneer logs(some 5 ft or better)and turn them into lumber and turning blanks.When I need a particular type of native wood I don`t have on hand I generally hit one of the local sawmills and if they don`t have it then either Barnaby or Tony(they both own mills)will know where to get it.They always have some interesting wood they`re willing to offload,usually for less than a dollar a board foot for AD hardwood.

For smaller projects I just visit the dump the day after the local yacht yards clean house.Lots of interesting offcuts in the pile on those days.Mostly KD teak,mahogany,walnut and cherry lately.

Have anything in particular in mind Wiley?

Mainely,Bob

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#19

Hard to tell...

Bob Hackett

>Thru a pic,Bill.I sure would like to see that particular board in person though.Nice find!

There`s no denying you have far more experience building fine furniture than I do,Bill.I wish I had the skills in that area that you have,it may well be that I`d feel differently about sanding vs planing if I did.

What I mean to say is that with the skill set I have,figured wood takes on a clarity and depth in far less time and with less trouble if I use a plane and/or scraper.I also find it far more enjoyable to not have to wear a respirator and ear plugs,although the ear plugs may be too little too late in my case.

MB

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#20

Re: a contrary example?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Bill, when you said that a planed surface stained too dark it was really quite shocking to me. It makes me wonder about the quality of your planing. Usually a hand planed surface is so slick that pigment particles have trouble finding a place to lodge.

I am reminded of something that happened twenty years ago. I had a small cherry table at a craft show and the wife of a fine cabinetmaker came around to look at my stuff. She pointed to the table top and said "That's a gorgeous piece of cherry" This really puzzled me because it was straight grain plainsawn cherry with little figure in it. I thought she was saying something to be kind. Two years later at the same show she looks at the table and says the same thing. Then it occurred to me that she had probably never seen unstained unsanded cherry before.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#21

Alternate interpretation

wilbur

>I'll assume that the finish method you choose is such that you really can't tell the difference between a sanded or hand planed surface, and that the two really are equal in depth, color, and figure.

In that case, the deciding point on which method to use really comes down to whether sanding or hand planing is the less obnoxious process for the woodworker. And for me hand planing wins the less obnoxious contest by a long shot. It's as fast if not faster as sanding, there's less dust, and it's much quieter.

Plus, hand planing is just plain fun. There are a lot of folks that get a real charge out of hand planing. I've never seen that reaction from someone using a power sander.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#22

Question of fact

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Warren and all,

I have no doubt Warren does exquisite work, and since I've seen Bill's I know his is. We've all seen it. I have a question about whether planing or sanding results in more evenness of stain or dye uptake. Bill got his planing capability questioned for saying that it led to uneven uptake--but we haven't established whether excellent planing results in greater evenness than excellent sanding. After we get that settled would be a better time to question folks' abilities.

Just to let you know where I'm coming from, I finish with a planed, or planed/scraped surface. In my hands--I repeat, in my hands--the surface seems more brilliant planed than sanded, unless I get down into the burnishing grits, and burnish the surface with worn-out 600 grit. (Which is what it looks like Bill T. did to get that brilliant end grain on his cherry table.)

But I digress. I would like to raise a question of fact--what results in more even (not more brilliant, but more even) uptake of stain or dye? Is it excellent hand planing, or excellent sanding? I've never understood that competent planing resulted in a more even uptake of pigment stain or dye than competent sanding. I have read more than one account from professional finishers to the effect that sanding evens out uptake--apparently by a partial filling or blinding of the pores, producing a shallow penetration of whatever is applied next. Also, I don't equate sanding with a perfectly even and bland finish--I believe that is achieved commercially by pore-filling early on, and then toning at a later stage.

To get specific, suppose we are talking about a highly figured board, with areas of reversing or surfacing grain. Figured cherry for example. It makes intuitive sense to me that sanding will tend to blind open pores and thereby even out penetration and uptake. Whereas a perfect hand planing job will leave the pores minimally torn, and in the ideal condition, wide open for uptake.

Do I have it wrong? Does someone know as a fact whether perfect sanding or perfect planing--of the same piece of figured wood--is more likely to provide even uptake?

Wiley

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#23

Re: Question of fact

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes, sanding will usually result in more even staining. In the case of dye stains sanding exposes torn fibers that are susceptible to stain and planed surfaces stain heavier on places where the fibers are not straight. In pigment stains the particles lodge in the torn areas. Staining can highlight planing flaws also. Probably best to say a different look is achieved. And good finishing technique can enhance one or the other.

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#24

Also depends on what wood

Bob Hackett

>The same plane will leave similar surfaces on both ipe` and pine but they will take the finish in a completely different way.

Like most other things,I suspect that a combination of factors that can differ even from pieces within the same tree(IE;cherry sapwood) need to be considered and applied to get the INTENDED finish as opposed to whatever comes out of a can from the nearest borg.

Unless it`s highly figured I always sand mahogany because I know I`ll be sanding the first coats of oil in to help fill the pores.Most folks around here like their mahogany furniture to look like the "brightwork" on their boats(me too).

MB

Re: Are hand planed or sanded surfaces best

#25

Re: Small lumber suppliers

James Watriss

>Hey Bob,

I'm just now getting ready to start looking for veneer logs and air dried lumber for ongoing bending projects. Shop is down in Lawrence, MA, so I plan to bounce around Southern NH and ME. I know there are mills and such in the area, but I haven't started researching who and were they are. Looking for veneer logs, or just good straight trunks... Thinking Ash, Walnut, Cherry and Oak right now... Mostly Ash, since it's much cheaper, but sources for others would be very useful.

Who would you start with for this kind of thing? Suggestions? Replies here would be great, or PM offline...