It's a small world after all *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi All,
I was moseying over by ALF's Cornish Workshop blog, where she pointed to ...... well, take a look at the link.
What could you do with this?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
It's a small world after all *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi All,
I was moseying over by ALF's Cornish Workshop blog, where she pointed to ...... well, take a look at the link.
What could you do with this?
Re: It's a small world after all
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>There are so few tools that are truly cute, but man, I need one of these. Given what Rob turns out, it's prolly pretty darn good, too.
bruce.
Re: It's a small world after all
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Wiley
No review this time :)
However, you may be interested in the Mesquite and Tasmanian Oak box that I built in which to store the plane ..

Inside is ....

.. and a better picture ...

Regards from Perth
Derek
Rob does it again
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I want one, might even take a chance on an A2 blade.
Pam
Paperweight
Jack Guzman from Maine
>I get updates from Lee Valley in my email.When I saw that one yesterday I bought it on the spot.It looks quite useful(I build clock cases,plenty of mini joinery)but even if it wasn't useful,it's too cute to pass up.I've never seen a neater paperweight.Or desk ornament.---Jack
Re: It's a small world after all
Rob Lee
>Hi Wiley -
This one actually started out as joke (on me), played by our R&D staff, when were finalizing design on the small shoulder plane. I told them to start by scaling down the medium plane, so they printed off a series of smaller and smaller planes (like matriushkas) and gave me the smallest... and I liked it - it just felt right.
So- I challenged them to make it, as an excercise in stretching our capabilities (in cost, size, materials, processes etc). When you make something that's so unlike the rest of the product line (but similar, at the same time), you ineveitably learn something that you can apply to future products.
Really - I never expected it to be so inexpensive, or work so well...
In hindsight - I think I may have set the retail price too low. Not that we're stretched for margin (it's just fine!), but the price may alter how people percieve the product. It's not a toy - yet it's not a part of our plane line. What it is - is fun. The first pre-production version is still sitting beside my keyboard... I still pick it up and fiddle with it just about every day.
It's exactly the kind of product that, once you have one, you want an extra, in case something (or someone!) happens to the first one...
All I can say, is that it makes you smile when you see it - and that smile gets bigger when you pick it up...
Cheers -
Rob
(trying hard not to sound like a copywriter....)
Is Mesquite native to Australia?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Useless
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>There was a time thirty years ago when a shoulder plane was about fifth on my list of tools to buy. But there always seemed to be tools that were needed more. I still don't have shoulder plane and today it would not make the top five hundred tools I would like to have. What could I do with this new one? Put it in a box like Derek.
Re: Is Mesquite native to Australia?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Pam
Mesquite does grow in Oz but only as scrub bush, and all you get are thin branches.
The wood I used in the box was from a USA-based Galootaclaus gift that I received a few years ago. (That was where the Mesquite for a recent jack plane build came from).
Regards from Perth
Derek
Great... Now I'll have to go to the store...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Oh well, I need to replace a few keys in that xylophone kit anyway :-)
DC
"Honest" question
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I can't remember how I came to own one but I have a large shoulder plane. However I came to own it, it revolutionized my M&T making and lead to perfect enough joints for ever after. About the only thing I use it for is shaving off tenon cheeks to get a proper fit. It is heavy, egonomically flawed, but it does shave in a controllable fashion. I rarely use it for shaving "shoulders" as I have a way of making them perfect to begin with.
I make mortises first and make the tenon to fit. I err on the heavy side when making the tenon knowing that I can rapidly shave it to fit with the shoulder plane.
Have I missed a better way.......... or how do you avoid needing a shoulder plane for M&T work?
That said, this plane fits into the question in Ellis's poll. I would not have a use for it and hence would not be inclined to buy it, in spite of its "neatness" appeal. I might look envious if someone let me hold theirs.
Re: "Honest" question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Bill
I am also interested in Warren's reply. In the meantime here is mine ..
If I had the choice of a plane to tune tenon shoulders or a plane to tune tenon cheeks, I would go for the latter. It is possible to avoid or minimise the need to tune shoulders if you saw cleanly and accurately. Minor tweeking may be done with a chisel.
The tenon cheeks need to be parallel to the stretcher and sized to fit the mortice. The best plane to do this is a router plane. A wide shoulder plane, such as yours, is low on my list of preferred planes (as its centre of gravity is all wrong for planing cheeks). Better are block planes, such as a rabbet or a skew. Still, I consider these to be better for the coarse removal of waste. The fine tuning of a cheek is better done by a rasp or float.
Back to the shoulder plane. I think that they are important planes. Given the choice of a chisel or a shoulder plane, I would rather do my tuning with a shoulder plane. The body offers excellent registration to create a square shoulder. Some - like Warren - can get away without a shoulder plane as they have better handskills than I do. Until I get that good, I will continue using shoulder planes. :)
Regards from Perth
Derek
no more space..
Norman
>I have no more space in my plane cabinet for this one :)
Having said this, I'll probably get one anyway.
Norman
You clearly built your plane cabinet too small
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>
Re: It's a small world after all
ThomD
>Actually the price is right. Cheap enough to just grab one. There was a time when I was going to buy every tool you guys made under your own name. For a while that was attainable before you swung into full creativity.
Re: "Honest" question
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>Sorry to create a ruckus, Bill. I was having trouble believing the "remarkably effective ... surprisingly comfortable" of the ad copy.
I use a wide chisel to trim tenons, but if I am doing a lot and really in practice they fit from the saw. And although I have not used it on tenons, I do have a wooden rabbet plane which is much lighter than a shoulder plane.
Re: You clearly built your plane cabinet too small
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>The definition of a tool container is "an enclosed space destined to be too small to perform its job properly."
Pam
That definition also fits
Dan Donaldson
>My shop ;-) (and probably most others as well, no matter how big they are. ;-))
Here is a deal for you *LINK*
Dan Donaldson
>The little plane and a pocket marking gage at a special price.
Special deal
Sure does, thus pointing out the pointlessness :)
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Re: "Honest" question
Dean J in MN
>I've managed to be successful with M&T without a shoulder plane as well. For me, going into the task with "cut it fat and trim" is a recipe for maximizing the amount of time fussing with every joint. So I go at it with, "make it fit off the saw." I screw up from time to time, and when I need to tweak a joint I use a wide chisel. If I need a tiny tweak I turn to a file/float.
As I see it a shoulder plane is set up rather oddly for cross grain work. Typical shoulder planes have bevel up blades (may or may not be low angle cutting geometry), square to the body, and tight mouths. I'd think one would want a boring bevel down, skew blade, and the mouth is non-critical. Sounds like a run of the mill wooden skew rabbet plane is better designed for the task should you want a plane to trim a tenon.
One thing which may separate myself from Bill and others is what I define as an acceptable tenon fit. Most of my m&t joints end up pegged, so the strength comes from tight shoulders and the peg keeping those shoulders tight to the adjoining piece, not from a "perfect" tenon fit.
If I were to rely solely on glue on the tenon cheek to keep the shoulder tight I probably would have to change my criteria. But even then, a chisel is really a fine tool to tune a cheek.
-Dean
Re: "Honest" question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Ah Dean, you're another one who uses a shoulder plane to tune a tenon!
You'd think they would've called it a "tenon plane"? :)
Regards from Perth
Derek
Think I'll stick to my Record 1366.
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>Maybe a wider but, so what...
Dang I was hoping you'd say a...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>A table saw!
Scott, Trick or Treat!
Re: "Honest" question
charlie belden
>"It is heavy, egonomically flawed, but it does shave in a controllable fashion."
While that is trueof most shoulder planes - gripping/holding positions awkward as hell when on its side - the Veritas medium and full sized should planes significantly reduced the gripping problem with a swiveling knob on the back that fits between thumb and forefinger, a nice in the palm of your hand rear "handle" to push against - a bevel to eliminate the sharp corner of the opening around the iron so you can put a finger in the opening for an additional gripping location - and, on the full sized shoulder plane - another knob on the side of the plane near the front - which can be mounted on either side of the plane.
Veritas keeps improving on Tried & True design ideas - their shoulder planes being yet another example. Very innovative designers - and their stuff looks nicer too.