Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Posts

Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#1

Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

wilbur

>I'm sure this is a simple question, but I'm mentally blocked on this one.

What was traditional (c. 18th century) woodworking trade practice for cutting a long cross grain dado (redundant, I know, but I wanted to be unambiguous) in the middle of a wide panel? I've come up with a few methods, but I'm unsure as to which was used historically.

-- Knife the edges of the dado, then use a rebate plane of the appropriate width with a straight edge guide.

-- Use a plow plane without the plane's fence, but with a straight edge guide.

-- Saw the sides of the dado (which saw would you use?), then use chisels and/or rebate plane of the appropriate width to take out the waste

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#2

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Catharine Kennedy

>wooden dado plane against a batten- similar to the later Stanley 39

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#3

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

David Cockey

>And use nails to hold the batten in place. Heard somewhere that Adam Cherubini has seen nail holes in furniture adjacent to dadoes which would have been used to hold a batten in place.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#4

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Wilbur,

It's an interesting question. Catharine's answer is surely correct. However, Whelan, in The Wooden Plane, notes that the dado plane is a relatively recent invention. He places it in the mid-18th century and says that it does not appear in print until Christopher Gabriel's inventories of 1791-93. Moxon (ca. 1700) describes the rabbet plane and its uses, but no mention of dados. It does make you wonder what happened before the mid 18th century.

Josef Greber, in The HIstory of the Woodworking Plane, when describing router planes in the 16th-18th centuries, says.... "Dados for splines or tenons are first cut across the wood along predrawn lines, then chiseled out, and finally smoothed and finished to an equal depth with a router." This wording is actually a translation from the original German, and perhaps the original German contains a bit more nuance as to what is meant by 'first cut across the wood...'. Does it mean knifed in? Or sawn?

Just as an aside, I have found that once the channel sides are knifed below the immediate surface, that chiseling goes really quickly. Take a mortise chisel and make a strike every 1/4" at the rate of one strike every few seconds, and there is only rubble left once you are across the board. I can easily imagine experienced period workers sawing the walls down 1/8" against a batten, make chisel strikes, and rout out waste--and doing this very quickly. The routing could go freehand, with no fence.

Wiley

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#5

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Catharine C. Kennedy

>I have a video clip of making dados with a dado plane, if someone can tell me how to post such!

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#6

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

wilbur

>I'd love to see your video. Probably the easiest would be to upload the video to YouTube, Vimeo, or another video hosting site, and then post the link to the site.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#7

A quick tutorial ... PIC *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wilbur

This is an extract from my review of the Veritas Small Plow Plane (link below):

Dados

Dados are grooves that are cut across the grain. This is not typically the province of a plough plane. I needed to cut a total of 8 dados. Generally I prefer to chisel-and-rout out (with a router plane) the waste.

The weakness of a plough plane lies in its lack of a nicker(s) to score the surface when cutting across the grain. This can be overcome by scoring the wood deeply with a knife.



Knifing the lines.

The next step is to chisel out some of the waste against these lines. This defines the outer edges of the dado and may be used as a fence against which the edges may be deepened with the aid of a backsaw. I chose not to do it this way this time, and instead planned to rely on the plough plane to maintain square sides.



Chiseling the waste.

The next step was to define the depth of the dado, which was done with a cutting gauge at both sides.



Marking the baseline.

The ends of the dados were chamfered to the depth to prevent unwanted breakout. Note the use of the chisel being used bevel down.



Chamfer the ends.

The fence was removed from the Veritas since the dados were to be cut in the center of the board. With a correct dado plane, a baton would be used as a fence. These plough planes could not be used this way as there was no place to use a batten. The plan was to run the side of the skate against one of the chiseled fences.



Running against the chiseled fence.

Planing one way (against the chiseled fence), then the other way (reversing the board to do so), produced very respectable dados.

It is not recommended that one attempt to plane both side of the dado by running the plane in the same direction. The skate running against the fence minimizes breakout. However, the open side of the plane against the fence can easily cause breakout. See the picture below. The right side of the dado is clean, while the left side has evidence of breakout.



Completed dado.

Dado with fitted divider �


How practical is it to cut dados this way? Well it is certainly possible, as demonstrated. And it is quite quick. I timed the last four dados to take a total of 16 minutes is all to go from marking out to fining tweak. But would I do it again? No, I think that I prefer a router plane to remove the waste. It can take a deeper shaving with less threat to break out.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Veritas Small Plow Plane

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#8

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Dean J in MN

>I think the short answer is -- they used dado planes. While there are other methods mentioned which work, the most efficient way to cut dados, even today, is the dado plane.

The thing to keep in mind is you asked about the 18th C. That is quite a large timeframe, and as others have mentioned we don't see dado planes in their recognized form until mid 18th C. This makes a lot of sense actually.

17th C and some early 18th C still saw the use of frame and panel construction for case pieces. There was no need to cut long cross grain dados in that type of case work, so it is no wonder Moxon doesn't mention a dado (in addition Moxon is writing of Joiners).

Along comes William and Mary, and the rise of dovetailed cases. But even here the drawer runners are often simply nailed to the case side; the divider is dovetailed in, but the runner is nailed. (See Greene and others, there is use of shallow dados, but not ubiquitous)

By the mid 18th C Queen Anne is here, and more and more you see runners/dust panels let into shallow dados. It is little wonder that the dado plane makes its appearance on the tool stage here. There was a need to cut dados efficiently, and the tool was refined in the early transition period from W&M to Queen Anne. There must have been embryonic dado planes in this transition, as the final form shows up in mid-18 C, one we'd all recognize it as a dado plane.

-Dean

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#9

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

James Watriss

>I suspect, wiley, that once the dadoes have been sawn, the chiseling is less necessary. Increasingly deep passes with the router plane would do the trick. Much like a jack plane, a decent router plane can be used to do rough work, too.

One of the blades that the stanley router planes came with looks like it was made for the task, ground to a V point, instead of straight across. Seems pretty optimal for this kind of work, I'd think. (Easier to do a v-grind than a camber on such a wee thing...)

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#10

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Sawing, chiseling, and manual routing are the way I've always done them. I suspect that St. Roy does, too, based on his show about sliding dovetails.

Pam

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#11

The router plane is too slow at the beginning.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#12

Re: The router plane is too slow at the beginning.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Right. And if you time yourself making a series of chisel chops 3/16" to 1/4" apart across a case side, it ain't much time and there is nothing left but blocky waste that you can almost rake out (if the sidewalls are sawn or deeply knifed). The guys doing this for a living in 1750 would have done this in nothing flat. And in Germany, for example, that's what they continued to do after 1750 because they didn't use a dado plane other than a router to clean up after the chisel.

For what it's worth, I think the English dado plane, especially woodies, are wonderful. All of this chisel business is just being responsive to Wilbur's original question about what was trade practice back when, and I'm guessing about that using the clues that Greber gives us.

Wiley

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#13

Re: The router plane is too slow at the beginning.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've never owned or used a dado plane; but it's easy to believe they may provide for a faster process. I stick to the sawing, etc. method because I don't have confidence that I could find a good dado plane for every width I may need.

Pam

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#14

an interesting plane

Larry Williams

>Wilbur and Dean,

While all the sources say that Maddox's proto dado was the earliest dado, it's important to keep an open mind and look for new information. A friend recently acquired a dado plane with very early features and a WOODING maker's mark. He sent me several photos and now I tend to think of Maddox's proto dado as an anomaly. It's obvious to me that dado planes similar to the later versions predate Maddox's version.


img

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#15

Re: an interesting plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Amazing! What a find! Larry, where do place this plane in time, based on the Wooding mark?

Wiley

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#16

It's hard to say

Larry Williams

>The plane looks original to me and to its owner. I would guess it's from the first quarter of the 18th Century, more than a generation earlier than the overly complicated Maddox proto dado.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#17

You make a great point

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>that, despite all the passage of time, we are still discovering primary evidence which will rewrite the books we now have.

Wiley

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#18

Various widths

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I am not sure that various widths are necessary, Pam. Nicholson says that dado planes are usually 3/8 wide. The lone dado plane in the Dominy collection appears to be 3/8 or maybe 7/16 wide. It could be that some workers just made two narrow runs to make up the width they wanted.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#19

Re: an interesting plane

Dean J in MN

>Fantastic stuff Larry! I makes sense to me the dado plane predates the first we see in keys, etc. There is really no comparing how much faster a dado plane is compared to all the other methods mentioned. As a matter of economics I have little doubt they were using dado planes to make the joints.

Thanks!

-Dean

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#20

Re: Various widths

Joel

>While I have no actual research to confirm this but considering that wood was hand milled to thickness and therefore thickness on a particular piece of wood would be consistent to itself, and in a range - the chances of being exact are zero. Therefore having a wider dado plane wouldn't help much in getting a perfect fit and it would make sense that two narrower passes to make up a wider width would be easier to do than two passes - the first pretty wide and harder to push, and the second really thin and fiddly. So just having one dado plane around 3/8" makes logical sense.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#21

I don't know...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>if a dado plane is any faster than sawing, rough chiseling to remove the waste and a final pass with a router plane.

I think someone with less training can probably do it faster with a fence and dedicated dado plane, but I know that I can cut a dado faster without a dado plane.

You have a number of passes that you have to do to go to depth. If you set the plane iron too proud, you clog up the escapement. The depth stop must be properly set and the nickers need to be sharp and set deep enough.

Then there is the issue of stop dado's which are quite popular. Also a lot of dado's are made slip dovetail and the dado plane would be of little use.

Stephen

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#22

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Joel

>In the Joiner and Cabinetmaker (around 2 weeks to go before shipping I think) Thomas makes his dados using a saw. This is of course almost contemporary data to the 18th century.

This isn't to say a dado plane wouldn't have been at least theoretically available but tools were expensive and for an apprentice or a smaller shop sawing the margins and chiseling the waste works fine.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#23

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Dean J in MN

>Joel --

How long were the dados Thomas was cutting? I can see smallish dados being nearly a wash in speed between a plane vs. saw and waste. But, when you get to full sized cases with 18+" dados I'm not so sure.

Even more, when I dado cases I place the sides front edge to front edge and cut the dados for both sides of the case in one shot. The nice thing is my case dados always line up this way. :)

Of course, shop practices varied widely in the 18th C. Each shop had its own methods and each master was influence by the culture he brought with him, so there isn't really one "right" answer.

-Dean

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#24

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

Joel

>I have to go back to the text to be sure but there weren't 18" long.

It is also worth considering that a lot of dados were stopped - which really limits using a plane. Also in my own case I have usually used the sawn method because 1) I didn't know you could use a narrow dado plane and use two passes to get an exact width (learned that today) and 2) the spurs on my Dado plane aren't in great shape.

So i would suggest that which a dado plane is faster and a better way than using a saw, a saw is a perfectly serviceable method that has lots of versatility in stopped dados.

Re: Trade practice for cutting dadoes?

#25

Re: Various widths

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>That's fine, no problem; but it implies a significant, and unwelcome, change to my woodworking habits. It means I'd have to worry about exact thicknesses in boards I mill/smooth; whereas I usually mill a board to whatever thickness works, then take measurements directly from that thickness.

Pam