Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

Posts

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

Sounds thin to me`

Ellis Walentine

>I would like to hear the advantages of blue steel that transcend heft. I'm sure a good argument can be made for this iron, but I don't really have much of an idea of what it might be. Longer times between sharpenings? To me, a heftier iron is the real difference.

Ellis

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#3

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

amelon

>Hi Scott,

Tsunesaburo is a famous Japanese plane smith (several generations, I believe the current is III) who carries a wide range of high end to low end products with solid reputation - see link below. That said, I have no experience with these Western laminated blades.

- Bob


Tsunesaburo website - translated

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#4

Lemme 'cplane Ellis...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>The Stanley 51 is a shoot board plane. The frog is not adjustable like bench planes. So, I need a replacement blade for the 51 so it has to be as thick as a stock Stanley blade.

Also I'm not about to file open the mouth of a somewhat rare plane.

Hope that 'cplanes it.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

Makes sense

Ellis Walentine

>...and as much as I buy in to the mysteries of various Japanese steels, I'd like to know what you think the advantages of blue steel are over white or yellow steel, or A2 or O1 for that matter. To me, there are only so many dimensions -- edge holding and potential sharpness being the big ones. What dictates the need or the desire for one over the rest?

Ellis

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#6

Think I'm with Ellis on this one...

James Watriss

>I hear what you're saying, Scott, I do.

Don't get me wrong, I love blue steel, and it does typically take an incredibly fine edge. But it also typically is backed up by a lot of steel or wrought iron to help keep it rigid enough to perform as well as it does. I think if you got a Hock aftermarket chip breaker, it might help, but Ellis makes a good point... it's not clear what the benefit is of this steel over some of the others.

For the money, you can also get A2, D2, and others. D2 is a bear to get sharp, but it holds up incredibly well. Definitely recommend diamond paste for that...

Lastly, I, too, will confess to being curious about how these blades tune up, and hold up. I went so far as to buy a 2" version for a #4 I was going to tune up. I still have it somewhere... but I already have so many other plane irons that it may be a while before this one makes a proper debut. Of the planes I use regularly, I have the following irons in service at various times...

-Holtey S53. Hard as hell, and hard to get sharp.

-Gramercy D2. Sharpens up nicely, and holds it. I think I've been using this one in my L-N high angle #4.

-Academy Saws M2. Tasty. Very tasty.

-Hock A2. (And Lie-Nielsen A2)I beat the crap out of this stuff on a regular basis. It's a good all around blade steel. But I will say that it doesn't get as sharp as some of the others

-Hock HC. I think it was Konrad Sauer who said that he chose HC steel because, despite the fact that it's not as hard as so many other steels, it gets so damn sharp. And it's not too hard to get it back to being so damn sharp.

For the money, and for what you're using it for, I think a Hock HC is probably your best bet. They're not as expensive as the option you propose, and they have a very well earned reputation for being excellent steel.

My .02

J

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#7

James and Ellis...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I have no particular obsession with this blade. I'm looking for a "standard (or stock) thickness" Stanley blade.

James I believe all the blades you listed are thicker than a Stanley blade.

I'm just looking for a good standard thickness Stanley replacement blade.

Any ideas guys? Makers of such a blade?

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#8

Tsunesaburo looks good to me

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Scott,

No experience with this particular blade, but blue steel is good stuff, and Tsunesaburo is a reliable brand. Blue steel is a tungsten steel and will stand up to end grain.

You've explained that you need stock thickness, which I believe is, or is close to the 5/64" that Tsunesaburo ships. Ron Hock, Lie Nielsen, and Lee Valley all ship 3/32" (~0.095"). You could test with a stick of 3/32" wood to determine whether that blade is an option or not.

Of course, there is always the option of obtaining an original Stanley 2-3/8" blade (I assume that is the width you need). But shaving end grain is tough duty, and I would bet that the blue steel blade will stand up to it better than the average stock Stanley blade.

The cost of the competitor 3/32" O1 and A2 blades varies between $40 and $55, so the blue steel blade is in the ballpark. I think it's a good idea.

Wiley

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#9

D2

paul womack

>-Gramercy D2. Sharpens up nicely, and holds it. I think I've been using this one in my L-N high angle #4.

Is that the Ray Iles blade?

BugBear

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#10

Re: Makes sense

wilbur

>Here's a brief rundown of yellow, white, and blue steels, as I understand it.

Start with JIS SK steel. If it goes through a process to remove impurities, you get yellow steel #2.

Go through an additional purification process, and you get white steel #2. This will have a carbon content of about 1.0-1.2%, and is easy to sharpen, and takes a nice edge. Edge holding is pretty good.

Add chromium and tungsten, and you get blue steel #2. This will add wear abrasion, which also makes it a bit harder to sharpen.

Take white steel #2 or blue steel #2, add more carbon so that the carbon content gets to 1.2 - 1.4%, and you get white steel #1 and blue steel #1, respectively. These will be harder than the #2 equivalents, and you can get a harder edge with these varieties, at the cost of some increased brittleness.

A good parallel is to think about O1 vs. A2. White steel is like O1, and blue steel is like A2 in how O1 and A2 behave relative to each other.

From what I've seen, white steel seems to be popular in chisels, and blue steels more popular in planes, primarily because of the improved wear resistance. I've never seen yellow steel used in plane blades or chisels. Yellow steel is used in saws, but I'm not sure if there is something about yellow steel that makes it more suitable for saws.

Of course, the blacksmithing has a lot to do with how these steels ultimately behave in the tool. A really well made white steel plane blade can be more wear resistant than an average blue steel plane blade. It's like talking about whether plum tomatoes or San Marzano tomatoes are better for pasta sauce -- ultimately it's the cook that will determine how good that sauce is.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#11

Chris Scholz

Re: Think I'm with Ellis on this one...

Chris Scholz

>In my opinion the main advantage of laminated blades is that they are easy to sharpen but may not hold an edge quite as well as for example a 1.2379 type steel, aka. D2. (Keep in mind that in addition to the chemical composition of the steel the actual performance depends a lot no how the steel was processed, heat treated, tempered, etc.)

If you are looking for a blade for a scrub plane or a Jack plane, go with the meanest, longest lasting steel.

If you are looking for a blade for a smoothing blade I am a big fan of the most refined, best processed steel you can find. Get a blade that sharpens easily.

With regards to the specific type of blades th OP mentions, those seem to be industrially produced blades. I'd be willing to bet that the hardness numbers the distributor quotes are marketing numbers and not actually measured values (indicating the blade is very hard as compared to most competitors' blades). Also keep in mind that there is no international standard for RC hardness measurements.

Probably a very good blade but I have no first hand experience with these blades so take it for what it's worth.

Chris

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#12

Maybe ...sort of ..... probably PIC*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have a Smoothcut in my #51. I suspect that these laminated Japanese blades are probably out of the same factory.

Mine is set up with a thick Clifton two-part Stayset cap iron (cunningly superglued together after the toe piece landed on my foot FOR THE LAST TIME!!!)



When experimenting with different blades, I did try a Clifton and a LN, but both were too thick. The Smoothcut and Clifton Stayset is a great combination, easy to install and adjust. No modifications required to the #51.


What is the advantage of the Smoothcut over other blades? In theory it should hold an edge longer than the average O1 (such as the Clifton, which is softer steel) or take a keener edge than A2 (such as the LN, which requires a higher 30 degree bevel). In practice I use a 25 degree bevel and the edge lasts a very long time.

Keep in mind that the #51 is primarily used on end grain, and while the sharpest edge is sort, a durable edge is especially important.


Where to get a Smoothcut? I have no idea. I bought this one on eBay about 5 or 6 years ago. Sorry. However, if it is the same as the Tsunesaburo (the rear end looks the same shape), then you are on to a Winner).

One more pic of my proudly restored and rejappaned #51/52, which is in frequent use ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#13

On D2 ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Chris

You really should include a #4 1/2 or #7 size Galoot Tools Chinese laminated blade into your line up. The #4 size I have is a very fine blade. As you will recall, I found it slightly more durable than a LN.

The point you make about D2 being more appropriate for heavy work is one I ascribe to, and the reason I chose it for my jack plane ...

Of course mine is a 5/16" thick MONSTER! :)


There are those who disagree that D2 cannot be used in a more refined smoother - Philip Marcou, for one, and he argues that it is all in the heat treatment. He has a background in knife-making and swears that D2 can take an edge that will compare with anything.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#14

Good cooks

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It's like talking about whether plum tomatoes or San Marzano tomatoes are better for pasta sauce -- ultimately it's the cook that will determine how good that sauce is.

I know of no good cook who prefers inferior ingredients for the application.

Pam

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#15

Re: Good cooks

wilbur

>That's true, but I'm not talking about the difference between using unripe vs. ripe tomatoes. I'm talking about the difference between using two very good tomatoes of different varieties.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#16

Re: James and Ellis...

James Watriss

>I've been using Hock blades as replacement in my stanley planes for a while now. I really don't have any issues.

As long as the yoke will engage, it's all good. Some of the really thick blades, like those that ship in the L-N planes, are really thick, and there's so much backlash in yoke handling that it's not even funny. But regular Hock seems to work just fine.

And while I can understand the desire to keep the setup as close to stock as possible, the added thickness of the blade will add to the quality of the cut more than it will take away from the ability to use the yoke.

And who really cares about the yoke anyway... you'll be storing the blade on its side in the slide, right?

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#17

Re: D2

James Watriss

>Nope... there was a brief period of time that Joel was offering a D2 iron with the Gramercy stamp.

Don't know where he got his D2... CPM, Starrett, ??? But it's been working pretty well for me so far.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#18

Depends on the audience

James Watriss

>If I'm cooking for people that know better, I use the good stuff. If I'm simply intervening to keep them from eating ravioli out of a can, it's a waste of good food.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#19

Re: Good cooks

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, understood; but still, the good cook will choose the best possible ingredients (available, affordable, meets taste/cooking standards, etc.).

Pam

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#20

Re: Depends on the audience

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>What do you care if someone eats ravioli from a can? :) Do you actually go out and buy inferior food for them?

I seldom have dinner parties now; but when I did, I never really knew what/how my guests would eat at home.

Pam

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#21

Re: Depends on the audience

James Watriss

>Inferior is a comparative term, so it's hard to say definitively.

I won't go and buy more chef boy-ar-dee, that's for sure. But I might go for whatever tomatoes are on sale at the supermarket, versus going on a dedicated trip to shop for heirloom tomatoes and fresh herbs to throw into a scratch-made sauce.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#22

All ready tried it Wiley...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I took the blade out of my 606 and fit it into the 51. Nice tight mouth. I can't put a thicker blade in it with out filing the mouth of the plane. As said, I don't want to go there.

Thanks for your input!

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#23

Re: James and Ellis...

Dan Donaldson

>Not sure, but I believe that if you contact lie-nielsen they will make you a blade of a particular thickness for a special application. Hock might do so also.

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#24

Hi Derek, Would you do me a favor?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Would you please measure the thickness of your Smoothcut?

I'd be grateful. Thanks!

Re: Anybody ever use one of these blades? *LINK*

#25

Re: Depends on the audience

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I guess I prefer to encourage those small local farmers who grow organic, so buying regular junk wouldn't be to my long term advantage. Those who eat canned ravioli would just have to go unpunished. :)

Pam