Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

Posts

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#26

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

wilbur

>What would you suggest for a fixed shelf in a bookcase? Is that 1/8" dado depth enough support for a shelf that needs to carry a load?

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#27

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Sounds reasonable, thanks. I guess it all comes down to the strength of the long grain in the sides.

Pam

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#28

Am I missing something?

Bob Hackett

>I understand that the joint is in tension but aren`t you completely discounting the strength the dovetailed horizontal adds to the piece?

The glue isn`t the only thing holding the tensioned case together.You would have to shear both sides of the dovetail AND have the glue fail in order for the joint to fail in this case.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#29

Re: Am I missing something?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes, it appears you are missing some of the earlier discussion. The discussion was about the sliding dovetail weakening the carcass side, not whether the dovetail would pull out of its channel.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#30

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>If you are talking about a bookcase that is a dovetailed carcass with 7/8 sides and a dado that has a good sized dovetail housing at the front like Dean shows and there are back boards nailed on, then I think a 1/8 dado is adequate. If you are talking about a bookcase that has no dovetails, and the dado joints are the only thing holding it together, then there is a trade off between the strength of the dado joint and the strength of the side. In this case the dado should be quite a bit deeper.

I have made utility shelves where some of the shelves sat in shallow dadoes, but also had tenons at the ends that were wedged from the other side. Perhaps that would interest you.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#31

The larger picture

Bob Hackett

>I understand that the deeper cut involving the dovetail weakens the case side when in tension.ANY cut potentially weakens a piece,in theory even carving.

What I`m saying is that the sliding dovetail adds strength to the assembled case above and beyond what a dado and butted and glued horizontal member would so doesn`t that added total case strength more than make up for whatever you lose by making the deeper cut in the side?

I`m taking about integrity of the total case assembly and not just the compromise of a single part.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#32

Reductio ad absurdum

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think everyone would agree that, if Derek were cutting the dovetails so deep that the remaining wood in the side were just 1/8" thick*, the strength of the case sides would be seriously compromised.

Presumably, any thinning of the side members reduces strength over leaving them full thickness.

The discussion, then, is about how much can be removed from the side before the loss of strength becomes significant and outweighs the benefit of dovetailing the shelf. This is something on which folks might well disagree.

*Not that Derek would ever be so silly, although I might well have been when I was younger.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#33

Tage Frid and the tapered sliding dovetail

John H. in Baltimore

>If I recall correctly, for a full lenghth tapered sliding dovetail (a suitable joint for joining a shelf to a case side), Tage Frid (in Vol. 1 of his book) recommends the depth of a tapered sliding dovetail housing to be 1/3 the thickness of the case side. However, for material of any thickness, the tapered dovetail housing should not exceed 1/2".

Thus, by employing this convention, a 3/4" case side would receive a 1/4" deep tapered dovetail housing.

On a further note, I believe that assessing the weakness caused by such joints requires a deeper inquiry into whether the complete assemby is rigid enough to prevent deflection of the case side at this weak point.

For instance, would the failure of multiple joints on the other side of the case be required to cause deflection at the weak point? For a case piece having several drawer assemblies or shelves joined using sliding dovetails, it appears to me that the localized weaknesses wouldn't be a serious problem.

This is fascinating stuff. I'd love to get others' perspectives on this.

Thanks!

John

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#34

Thanks Bill

Bob Hackett

>So I am seeing it the same as you.

MB

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#35

See link  *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>


One way of looking at it