Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

Posts

Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#1

Workshop crisis #1207  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>This follows somewhat on the recent thread about workshop size, and what may be done with it.

I managed to get a bit completed this weekend with the small wardwrobe I am building for the guest bedroom. (Lynndy asked for a small cabinet that could hang clothes as well as including drawer(s). The deal is that it must fit into a small room and, therefore, needs to be quite shallow. So my design arranges the hanging direction forward rather than sideways. There will be a central rail accessed by two side doors. I will show the final result when completed).

I have completed most of the carcass proper. I am thinking of calling it the "dovetailed cabinet". The sides and upper side are through-dovetailed, and the lower two dividers are sliding dovetails. The remainder of the design (two raised panel doors and one long drawer) will be attached to face frames).

Firstly, I can now answer the question (from a few weeks ago) about setting up a moving fillester blade - should it be in line with the outside of the plane body, or should it extend minutely beyond it? The short answer is that it should extend minutely beyond the body and in line with the knicker if planing across the grain. With the grain does not matter (one does not need a nicker when planing with the grain). More on this (with pictures) at a later date.

Secondly, the issue of assembly in a small workshop once again reared its ugly head. The questions for the Learned Readers are how do You cope with largish assemblies (a) on your own, (b) without an assembly table, and (c) in a small shop?

Step one - I attached two sides, balancing the free end on a small ladder while I connected the dovetails at the other side. Sorry no picture. You will have to use your imagination!

Step two - I held the third side by clamping it to the bench, and then brought the first assembly over to it and joined the two. This is easier said than done as it must go in square. Use of levels, corner braces, and much swearing is essential.


Step three - after the glue has dried, turn it on its side and slide in the upper sliding partition. Turn upright, check for square, and clamp until dry.


Step four - this can only take place once I have built the lower section. This is a mortice and tenoned frame (not a solid section) upon which the large drawer will run. This connects via a half-dovetail. Still to be built.

Moving this Tasmanian Oak frame was hard enough. Balancing it was harder ... where is the third hand?!

What would you do differently?

Finally, I did complete a re-write of the article on "Sliding dovetails by hand". There is a link below to my website.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Sliding Dovetails by hand

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#2

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Richard Jones

>Derek,

Reminds me of the old chifferobes, I re-did my grandmother's to house my TV, etc. This one had the hanger track front to back as well. The whole works slid out for easier access.

Your step one: Ladder was fine. I sometimes will clamp some scrap uprights to use as a third leg(s), or deadman. Clamp a scrap across the piece, clamp a leg to each end of the scrap. To me, this allows more movement of the assembly without having it fall off the ladder and risk damage. That ladder reminded me of how we used to nail up KD door jambs in the field years ago.......

Step two: Ditto on clamping some sticks/braces, so that the top of your "assembly" doesn't flop down too much, basically gives you that third hand. A couple of low assembly tables also might come into play, as you can clamp parts to them and slide them around instead of having your case sliding around on the floor, and they can act as they third leg as well.

Step three: Can't see as how I would do this any different.

As far as large pieces in the shop, I believe our imaginations must kick in to overtime to try and envision how these cases will look before they are actually cases. "How hard will it be to move around by myself?" "I may have to get the wife to help me flip this over, and then she'll want to redesign it......" "Will I have to take that door off the hinges to get it out of the shop?" "Will I have to take that jamb out to get it out of the shop?" "How could I not have measured that opening and realize that I can't get this out of the shop?" :)

On the subject of too small of a shop, I have built some pieces that required me to go the KD route, simply because they could not go together inside my shop. They do take some extra planning. Two pieces instead of one may require an additional sub base that wouldn't be necessary if your shop was big/tall enough. Then you have to think about how to fasten them together, the subject of a whole 'nuther thread.........

Sorry to be so long winded. Nice piece, I look forward to seeing more of it.

Rich

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#3

Hanging clothes front to back

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Richard says of the chifferobe he rebuilt, "The whole works slid out for easier access."

I spent part of my teen years using a cabinet in which the clothes were hung front to back. If you can engineer a sliding rod (there may be commercial items available), I highly recommend it. When the clothes are front to back, the item you want is inevitably toward the back, and it's very awkward wiggling a hanger out past other hangers.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#4

Make your overhead work 4 more than lighting

Bob Hackett

>If you plan ahead the overhead joists can be used as anchor points for supports and braces.Having a reference point projected up from the edge of the bench you`re clamping to makes it fairly easy to drop down a brace/support and plumb it so that now both sides of the case are parallel and the proper distance apart to help ease solo assembly.Much less swearing involved,sure beats a ladder.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#5

Re: Hanging clothes front to back

Richard Jones

>I actually think I saved it, will see if I can find it and post a pic.

Rich

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#6

You did fine

roninkokomo

>I don't think there is any way to eliminate the fussiness required to get things square. I think the comment above about using ceiling joists may prove useful. Large projects in small shops require considerable ingenuity. I really think you did well.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#7

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use dovetails on all four corners of a carcase and glue with hot hide glue. I do assembly either on the bench or on a mat on the floor. I glue one corner and assemble, then another corner, then the last two together. The glue is then still soft enough to adjust for square.

I think you make a mistake avoiding traditional designs. I have never seen a full sliding dovetail in a carcass side on a period piece. Such a dovetail would severely weaken the carcass side. Traditional work would have the dovetail portion only a short dovetail housing at the front of the case. And the rare sliding dovetails that we do see (as in a batten under a table top, for instance) are usually tapered sliding dovetails which are much easier to assemble and disassemble. It would be a nightmare to try and take apart your carcass for repair.

It sounds like you are still in the dark about moving fillisters.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#8

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I think you make a mistake avoiding traditional designs. I have never seen a full sliding dovetail in a carcass side on a period piece. Such a dovetail would severely weaken the carcass side....It would be a nightmare to try and take apart your carcass for repair.

Hi Warren

Mine is not a period piece. Nor do I expect it would be taken apart for repair in the future as I am using yellow glue.

The full sliding dovetail went together smoothly. It is only glued at the front few inches.

It sounds like you are still in the dark about moving fillisters.

You will have to explain this statement if I (and others here) are to learn something helpful.

This is a rebate planed with the grain - blade with (very) slight projection and no nicker ..


The vertical sides are square.

This is a rebate planed across the grain - again blade with (very) slight projection and this time nicker in line with blade (ignore the slight double line - that was my poor marking) ..


The vertical sides are square.

Finally, this is a rebate planed across the grain - now blade flush to side of plane and nicker in line with blade ...


The vertical sides are not square - they angle down.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#9

Glad to know...

Stuart Hough

>that I'm not the only one who uses "colorful language" (as my Gramdnother used to call it) to persuade thing to go into place!

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#10

Excellent demonstration!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Derek,

That is the right test, and I believe it demonstrates exactly what Warren and others said previously--that a slight bit of lateral blade projection, and with the blade in the shadow of the nicker, would produce a good vertical wall in the rebate. And that a dead flush blade would gradually walk the plane away from the wall. I might mention that the slight projection is the exact setup that my C&W moving fillister came with, and it gives perfect results also.

I do believe this test bears out Warren's previous comments, but let's see what he says.

Wiley

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#11

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Derek, about the fillester you write "the blade ... should extend beyond the body and in line with the knicker if planing across the grain." No, you really need clearance between the nicker and the blade. You don't want the blade competing with the nicker to form the shoulder. Then you write "with the grain it does not matter." I don't know what you mean by this, but without the nicker, the blade forms the shoulder and there has to be clearance between the blade and the body of the plane.

So you don't expect your carcass to ever be taken apart? Well I repaired a chair this morning. A previous repairer had thought it unnecessary that the chair should ever come apart again. His actions tripled the bill.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#12

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

wilbur

>"I have never seen a full sliding dovetail in a carcass side on a period piece. Such a dovetail would severely weaken the carcass side."

I think I am missing something here. Assuming the fit is good, and you aren't doing something dumb like jamming a too-tight male part of the dovetail into the female part on the carcass side, why would a sliding dovetail weaken the side of the carcass more so than a dado joint of the same depth?

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#13

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Derek, about the fillester you write "the blade ... should extend beyond the body and in line with the knicker if planing across the grain." No, you really need clearance between the nicker and the blade. You don't want the blade competing with the nicker to form the shoulder.

Warren, I am not with you here. I am missing something. You say you really need clearance between the nicker and the blade. You don't want the blade competing with the nicker to form the shoulder.

We are talking cross grain planing, are we not? From your proposed setup I understand that if the nicker is closer to the body than the outside of the blade, then you may as well not have a nicker. Then the blade will break out the cross grain. And if the nicker lies beyond the blade, then the same condition and results occur.

This is the result of a nicker fractionally closer to the body (than in line with the blade) ...


Then you write "with the grain it does not matter." I don't know what you mean by this, but without the nicker, the blade forms the shoulder and there has to be clearance between the blade and the body of the plane.

What I was stating was that a nicker is not needed for with-the-grain planing. I did not think that this would be interpreted to indicate that clearance was unnecessary (My statement was "With the grain does not matter (one does not need a nicker when planing with the grain)").

So you don't expect your carcass to ever be taken apart? Well I repaired a chair this morning. A previous repairer had thought it unnecessary that the chair should ever come apart again. His actions tripled the bill.

Warren, I don't think that we are comparing Apples with Apples. A chair experiences stresses that a cabinet does not. If I was building a chair I would use hide glue in preference to yellow glue. I would be interested in knowing how many cabinet carcases have you had to rebuild over the years?

My choice of a full sliding dovetail was because I wanted a join that would be self locking. Frankly, building a non-tapered dovetail is easier than a tapered dovetail (accepted that it is not as easy to fit - that simply requires a little extra care). It is not traditional, I understand. It is, however, a better joint than a number of possible others.

I do not understand your statement, "Such a dovetail would severely weaken the carcass side". Will you explain please?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#14

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes, you are right, Wilbur. But generally we make a very shallow dado on a case side. Derek shows a dovetail that is about half the thickness of the side.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#15

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>With cross grain planing, the nicker is what forms the shoulder. There needs to be clearance between the nicker and the blade so the blade does not rub the shoulder. There is quite a bit of leeway about where the edge of the blade is, but not "in line with the nicker".

I have not done restoration work regularly for a number of years, but I have probably disassembled twenty or maybe thirty carcases.

Your sliding dovetail is much deeper than a typical dado- that is why it weakens the case side.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#16

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Your sliding dovetail is much deeper than a typical dado- that is why it weakens the case side.

Does it really? I mean, of course it weakens the side itself when standing alone; but when assembled? It seems the slot is well plugged, well fit, thus just about as strong, perhaps stronger than a somewhat more ill fitting dado.

Pam

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#17

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

wilbur

>Is there a rule of thumb for the depth of a dado? Something like, "A dado should be about 1/2 the thickness of the board that the dado is in."

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#18

I've "lost enough religion" assembling stuff

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>that my place in paradise is probably in question.

Bruce in MN

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#19

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>If you bend the carcass side one way the joint is in compression. In this case a well fitted sliding dovetail or dado is no problem. But stressing the side in the other direction puts the joint in tension. In this case what is holding the side together is an end grain to side grain glue joint (weak) plus whatever thickness is left of the carcass side.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#20

Structural details and more pics

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Your sliding dovetail is much deeper than a typical dado- that is why it weakens the case side.

Hi Warren

The dovetail depth is 5/16" in a 3/4" thick casing.

My understanding is that the Rule of Thumb is that it should be between 1/3 and 1/2 the thickness. So my dovetail depth is within the recommended range.

Nevertheless you have a point and may be right. Still, consider the following (just for technical interest) ..

The lower end of the cabinet has another section (a M&T frame for the drawer), which is also dovetailed. This is expected to add further rigidity to the case side (that is, reduce any flex, which would place stress on a dovetail joint).

The cabinet has a 3/8" deep rebate on all sides at the rear for the attachment of the rear panel. The rear panel will be made up of hardwood boards joined with half-laps. This will add considerable rigidity to the cabinet.

I know it is not the ideal way to do it, but I used a stopped rebate at the upper panel ...

Pic 1: Do as much as can be done with rebate plane (until it no longer cuts)...


Pic 2: Finish off with a router plane ...


Pic 3: Completed stopped rebate (of course I later discovered that I neededto extend it by 1/4"!) ...


The front of the cabinet with be reinforced with a 3/4" thick face frame. This is planned to be attached by a dado at the rear of the face frame. The dado will further reduce any twist (and, thereby, any stressing of the dovetail).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#21

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>A rule of thumb for the depth of a dado? It really depends on the scale of the work and the structural importance of the piece that is being excavated. For dividers between small drawers in a desk interior 1/3 thickness might be appropriate. For a dado in a carcass side, maybe 1/4 of the thickness or less is better. For a 7/8 thick carcass side I like a dovetail housing at the very front with a 1/8 deep dado the remainder.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#22

A crude sketch

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Here is a crude sketch of the wardrobe (completed in Paint) ..


The light brown is Tasmanian Oak, and the darker brown is Jarrah. Doors are raised panels in frames. I was originally going to make two drawers side-by-side, but decided it was more aesthetic to have one long one. Alternatively, I may built two drawers and make it look like one.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#23

Re: Structural details and more pics

James Watriss

>I wouldn't sweat that extra 1/4" until you're fully assembled. In school, we ran the stopped rabbet with a dado stack, and left the radius from the stack in place until the case was fully glued up, and finished the rest of it then.

a) I'd rather have the remaining thickness to keep things nice and strong until it's all glued up, and

b) Somehow, glue-ups always come very close to closing where I think they will, but things wiggle and compress. So my guess is that even if you'd cut that extra 1/4", you'd probably have to go back and trim it again later anyway.

Cool project either way.... but I want more pictures of your bench. I like the twin-screw face clamp setup you have going there, and I'm curious to see what other gizmos you've got hiding in the design.

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#24

Re: I've "lost enough religion" assembling stuff

James Watriss

>I think a solid woodworking vocabulary should actually count as part of a well-stocked toolbox.

(note: edit by moderator, deleting a paragraph that edges toward a religious comment).

Re: Workshop crisis #1207 *LINK*

#25

Re: Workshop crisis #1207

Dean J in MN

>I'm with Warren, for a divider the dados are very shallow, the runner just needs that little ledge to support the drawer. The drawer blade itself is fit with the dovetail which locks the case sides together, you aren't looking to the dado to hold the case together.


img