Re: That is fascinating...
Alan DuBoff
>Bob wrote:
"I agree with your observation that the focus for the Japanese plane is in the blade (i.e., the cutting edge). You can expect to pay a lot of money for a high quality Japanese plane blade. The dai is secondary. Caution: This is strictly my opinion and there are experts who will probably disagree with me. Anyway, this is in direct contrast with Western planes. When you purchase a Lie-Nielsen or a Holtey, what are you paying for? In all cases, the cost goes to the plane body. The blades for the most part are identical (A2, O1, high carbon steel, etc.) and can be gotten for not a whole lot."
--------------------------------------------------
Bob,
Yes, this is why it is so fascinating to me. It's a different way of looking at the problem at hand, and I admire this about the Japanese in many regards. Although I will admit I have a love/hate relationship with the culture in general, but I think most things are like that in life. Heck, I have a love/hate relationship with America also...:-/
The value they place on the dai reflects that amount of time/work they will need to put into it.
OTOH, I do admire the Holtey planes, and appreciate that aspect of toolmaking as well. And I do have metalworking machines that I use for the saws I build...:-/
I have seen the picture before, and here's a different pic with a better shot of one. Hard to see what Yataiki is using, although the edge is clear. Most of these sens look hand forged. That might be an interesting project...but I have a piece of 5160 I started to forge into a drawknife, and it could function as a sen with some minor modifications.
