Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

Posts

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#26

Re: What about your NHK plane?

amelon

>Alan,

I suspect they're all made by machines then hand tuned, unless you insist that the master makes them by hands, in which case you'll likely need to pay a higher price. How much higher I don't know since I have never requested for such service. Any difference in performance is probably not noticeable. I presume hand cut dai's (plane bodies) are reserved for workshops and demos.

Using Inomoto-san as a reference point, it takes a master about 1 hour to hand cut a dai. That's pretty fast but not fast enough to make a living...

- Bob

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#27

Re: Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, I also built the plane track into mine; but it's always nagged at me that I did.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#28

That is fascinating...

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

I am fascinated that the dai is really a commodity for the most part, but the blade is where the real crafting take place...not that the dai doesn't require craftsmanship, surely it does. Just that it doesn't seem to be the prime focus for the Japanese.

In looking at the body of the NHK plane, it doesn't look too special, which is why I was asking. It looks like most modern Japanese planes but wider. The blade does look special though...

I wouldn't mind learning how to scrape the saw blades, if you have any pics of a sen, would like to see them.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#29

Re: That is fascinating...

amelon

>Alan,

Quote: "I am fascinated that the dai is really a commodity for the most part, but the blade is where the real crafting take place."

The machine helps with the heavy lifting but all the fine tuning still remains and is specialized, skilled work. In the West, we see mostly quality imports from masters like Inomoto, Kokichiya, Horiba, Nimura, so for the most parts the dais we have are pretty good. It takes a lot skills even with the assistance from machines. But I've seen poorly made dais too.

I agree with your observation that the focus for the Japanese plane is in the blade (i.e., the cutting edge). You can expect to pay a lot of money for a high quality Japanese plane blade. The dai is secondary. Caution: This is strictly my opinion and there are experts who will probably disagree with me. Anyway, this is in direct contrast with Western planes. When you purchase a Lie-Nielsen or a Holtey, what are you paying for? In all cases, the cost goes to the plane body. The blades for the most part are identical (A2, O1, high carbon steel, etc.) and can be gotten for not a whole lot.

Regard saw scraping, Dave Burnard's website has some nice photos of Yataiki using a sen.

- Bob

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#30

Re: Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

amelon

>Why is that, Pam? I'm curious. Thanks.

- Bob

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#31

Re: That is fascinating...

wilbur

>Just to add onto Bob's points, it was expected that the final fitting and conditioning of the dai to the blade would be done by the woodworker who bought the plane blade and dai combination.

Having said that, one of the things that the dai maker is doing for you is making sure that you have a quality piece of wood with appropriate grain orientation for the plane to perform its best. This is important for any wooden plane. Larry Williams spends a fair amount of time going over this very issue in his DVD on making hollows and rounds.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#32

Re: That is fascinating...

Alan DuBoff

>Bob wrote:

"I agree with your observation that the focus for the Japanese plane is in the blade (i.e., the cutting edge). You can expect to pay a lot of money for a high quality Japanese plane blade. The dai is secondary. Caution: This is strictly my opinion and there are experts who will probably disagree with me. Anyway, this is in direct contrast with Western planes. When you purchase a Lie-Nielsen or a Holtey, what are you paying for? In all cases, the cost goes to the plane body. The blades for the most part are identical (A2, O1, high carbon steel, etc.) and can be gotten for not a whole lot."

--------------------------------------------------

Bob,

Yes, this is why it is so fascinating to me. It's a different way of looking at the problem at hand, and I admire this about the Japanese in many regards. Although I will admit I have a love/hate relationship with the culture in general, but I think most things are like that in life. Heck, I have a love/hate relationship with America also...:-/

The value they place on the dai reflects that amount of time/work they will need to put into it.

OTOH, I do admire the Holtey planes, and appreciate that aspect of toolmaking as well. And I do have metalworking machines that I use for the saws I build...:-/

I have seen the picture before, and here's a different pic with a better shot of one. Hard to see what Yataiki is using, although the edge is clear. Most of these sens look hand forged. That might be an interesting project...but I have a piece of 5160 I started to forge into a drawknife, and it could function as a sen with some minor modifications.


img

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#33

Yes, good point Wilbur!

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

That's a very good point, since western style tools don't require that the craftsman do the final fitting, as the Japanese tools do, not just the planes but chisels as well.

It's not that big of a deal, just that the cultures view that aspect differently.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#34

Calling Dave Burnard (or someone)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Need information on the tempering of the sen. And also the edge preparation--bevel angle, is back flat or not, any camber, any curvature in the front view?

Wiley

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#35

Re: Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Mostly personal ideas about economy and elegance, I suppose, as it indicates to me that I hadn't thought it through, given a relative flat bench. But even if I had, I'm still not sure I wouldn't have made the same decision. Mine is fairly large, so it's probably a good idea to have a second board there. Maybe I'd make two, adding a small one for everyday, more casual, shooting.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#36

Along the same lines?

Bob Hackett

>How do these eastern tools differ from the scrapers that we in the west used to hand scrape things like machine tool ways/beds?Seems like much the same kind of work is being done.I ask because I have done some of this work on both cast iron and steel and have access to specs and info on tools for hand scraping.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#37

Principal is the same, style is different...

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

As you know the machinist scrapers are much smaller with a single handle on them, and are typically scraped in a rotating motion, leaving the frosting effect.

From everything I have seen of Japanese saw scrapers (sen), they are used more like a drawknife on a saw that is secured to a board, like the picture of Yataiki that Bob posted (came from Dave Burnard's site).

The principal is the same on both, that you scrape material off the steel, with the edge of the scraper/sen, but the saw makers typically scrape along the entire length of the blade, or at least a good portion of it.

Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#38

Japanese book on planes *LINK*

amelon

>Oops. I just realized I left out the link to the plane book on Amazon.jp.


http://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/4416809115/

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#39

Japanese saw scraping photos *LINK*

wilbur

>Here are some pictures of Mistukawa making a saw, where you can see how he uses a sen, courtesy of an old version of the Hida Tool website on archive.org.


Mitsukawa Japanese saw making

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#40

Forgot to add

wilbur

>Check out the rack of sens that Mitsukawa has! I'm not sure if they serve different purposes, or if they are there for convenience so that he doesn't have to stop and resharpen the sen while working on a saw.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#41

Nice shot of the sen...

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

Nice shot of the sen there, thank you!

Is that the current and/or youngest Mitsukawa making saws there?

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#42

I think they must...

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

I think they do have special purpose, and I'm sure they vary slightly. However, they mostly appear about the same length, my guess is that they may vary slightly for the edge and/or how they scrape.

Also, it might take a few tries to get a really good one, not sure.

They are handmade for the most part.

Thanks for posting the pic.

Cheers,

Alan