Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

Posts

Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#1

Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

wilbur

>A while back I talked to Rob about his shooting board, and about how well they might work with Japanese planes. In many ways, a Japanese plane is ideal for endgrain shooting. It has a square body, a fairly low bed angle, there is virtually no chatter due to the way that the blade is bedded in a Japanese plane, the blade is really hefty, and can be sharpened very finely. About the only thing that I can think of to make a Japanese plane better for shooting is to add a skew to the blade. But this can also be accomplished by a ramped shooting board.

Rob was really willing to talk about and hash out what modifications might be needed to adapt his shooting board to be used with Japanese plane. Here's what we figured out:

1. The fence should be located towards the user, as the plane is being pulled.

2. The height of the top board needed to be increased. The corner of the blade on a Japanese plane is further away from the side of the plane than on your typical western Stanley-type plane, so if a Japanese plane was used on his regular shooting board, which has the runway 1/2" below the top surface, the corner of the blade would ride above the top surface. After measuring some of my Japanese planes, we decided that if the runway was 3/4" below the top board surface, that would be enough.

And that was really it. I also asked Rob to see if there was a way to combine this with his regular shooting board, as I also wanted something to use with western planes, just in case.

So this is what he sent me. For those of you who might not be familiar with Rob's shooting board, it's really well made, and comes with predrilled holes so that you can shoot at various angles.


You can see the two arcs of holes for the fence -- one for using a western plane, and the other for using a Japanese plane. The fence is set for a Japanese plane. The two arcs actually share a hole for 30�, which was really hard to drill accurately. Even though I know Rob took great care in lining everything up, the 30� hole is off a little for the fence in Japanese plane position. But that is really a very minor issue.

So how does it work? Let's start with a piece of freshly crosscut 5/8" cherry.


Not the greatest saw cut I've done, but it doesn't matter. I have a shooting board! Here it is in use with a Japanese plane.


I'm using the Japanese plane one-handed to shoot the endgrain. Actually, I would also be holding the board with my left hand, but I needed it to hold my camera. ;)

I took about a dozen passes or so with my plane, and got this:


Not bad, if I do say so myself, and it was ridiculously easy.

I've been trying to find any information on the use of shooting boards as they might have been used in Japanese or other Asian woodworking, but have come up with nothing. The traditional Japanese planing beam often had a 1x1 or 2x2 attached to the side of the beam so as to make it into a shooting board, but this was really used for edge jointing, and not shooting endgrain. The relatively narrow width of the planing beam (6" or so) wouldn't lend itself to shooting endgrain on boards much longer than a foot, since it would be too awkward to hold a long board across the 6" planing beam.

My guess is that endgrain shooting really wasn't an issue for Asian woodworkers. One of the design traditions in Japanese and other Asian woodworking designs was to try to bury endgrain as much as possible. A tabletop in an Asian piece of furniture would usually be more like a giant frame and panel construction, rather than a straight panel glue up. As such, the need to clean up the endgrain surface precisely wasn't really needed, as no one would ever see that surface, as it would have been covered by a frame member.

In any case, this modification of Rob's shooting board works great with Japanese planes. In speaking with him since, don't ask for a dual purpose shooting board like I have. It's too much trouble to make, due to the need to lay out two arcs for the different fence angles. I have to thank Rob for being silly enough to take on this type of modification. ;) Rob is offering a dedicated shooting board for Japanese planes on his website.

Finally, here's a gratuitous shaving shot, so you can see the super thin endgrain shavings I was able to get with this shooting board.


Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#2

I rotate my home made board

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It's really very simple, shooting board is a couple of feet long and the bench slightly over two feet wide; so for Japanese plans I hang the hook on the opposite side of the bench. Works great, probably because I'm too stupid to know I need different angle holes.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#3

Seems ergonomically backward

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Shooting end grain seems like a clear example of where a pushing plane is in every way mechanically more advantageous for an application where brute force can be essential on thick stock. Again,,, it seems,,, like one can develop more controlled force pushing the plane across the piece while simultaneously pushing the plane into the end grain.

The LV low angle jack has all the advantages claimed for the Japanese style plane and I have no problem shooting 5/4 stock with it. It was recommended to me by some good folks on WC and I found this recommendation validated for my needs. It has the mass to be a good shooting plane and it can be grasped conveniently, unlike Stanley style bench planes.

These comments are not intended to dissuade those using oriental technology, but to provide information to those who haven't made a choice.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#4

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>In practice pushing/pulling doesn't make a difference. My Japanese planes are perfect for shooting tasks, as are my few western planes, they all work if they have flat sides.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#5

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

wilbur

>Ditto to what Pam said.

In practice, the ergonomics of using a Japanese plane on a shooting board are really nice. I have tried using a Stanley #4 and a #5 with my shooting board set up for a western plane, and personally, I like the pull action better. I can develop very controlled force pushing the plane across the piece while simultaneously pushing the plane into the end grain.

Japanese planes don't have as much mass as a low angle jack, but the bottom line is that the blade is so heavy and the bedding is so secure, and the end grain shavings I can get are so thin that mass isn't a critical factor in how well this set up performs for shooting endgrain.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#6

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

Chris Friesen

>I'm curious...how is the bedding more secure on a japanese plane? And why couldn't you just push the japanese plane on regular board (with a lower area for the plane to ride on)?

Also, with a wooden plane it seems like unless you have perfectly vertical or horizontal grain any change in humidity is going to slightly warp your plane body so the sides are no longer 90 degrees.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#7

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, you can push Japanese planes with no problems, at least the ones with flat soles, I do it all the time; but then I also often pull western planes quite effectively.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#8

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

Raney

>The bedding on a japanese plane is not necessarily more secure - but in practice it is extremely secure. It's just a matter of how well the wooden bade and wedge-slots are fitted - and they have to be very accurate for the adjustment to work well on a japanese plane. Metal planes have a little bit more leeway in this, so they aren't necessarily bedded quite as solidly. In practice, though, I don't think it;s an issue with any well-tuned plane. Also - for what its worth, Wilbur didn't say they were better bedded - just extremely well-bedded.

As for the wood movement, it is a very possible issue in japanese planes. Japanese planes require maintenance to the soles rather regularly, and kanna users are very comfortable with making frequent adjustments to the dai (the wooden body) so keeping the sides in square wouldn't be an issue for anyone who uses them regularly. This maintenance isn't a big deal, but it is one of the things you have to adapt to if you use these tools.

Also, there really isn't any reason you can't push a kanna - but ergonomically, the handholding usually makes some use of the back of the blade, and pulling is generally more comfortable. Again, anyone who uses kanna will likely be more comfortable pulling...

Wilbur: I've never seen an endgrains shooting board for japanese planes - other than Odate's use of miter shooting boards (similar use as a donkey's ear board) for making complex-pattern shoji.

I actually asked Jim Blauvelt shooting endgrain once, and he said he knew of no real tradition of it - that when necessary, this is a task he did with a block and very heavy knife. The block is used much like many people might use a right angle block to get perfect 90-degree angles with a chisel when paring the baseline of dovetails. It guided the knife, and left a surface very comparable to a shot end. In softwoods, this works extremely well, though in woods harder than, say, walnut it is much tougher to do well. I've used my knife in cherry, but I'd say that's stretching the capacities of the technique somewhat.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#9

Issues

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Chris wrote ..

so the sides are no longer 90 degrees.

Technically, it is not the sides of the shooting plane that must be 90 degrees to the work, but the edge of the blade. Adjust the blade to suit the setup. Conversely, a squared plane body with a non-square blade will plane out-of-square.

Push or pull? I do not see any issue here. It will come down to what you are comfortable with. However, I would have made one design feature differently - since the mouth of a Japanese plane sits so far back, and nearly all the registration is at the front of the plane, I would have extended the shooting board another 6" - 9" behind the fence. As it stands it will work (well it does, because Wilbur has shown this admirably), however I suspect that it would feel more secure if there was more runway for follow through.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#10

Re: Issues

wilbur

>Hi Derek,

Extending the outfeed for a longer distance past the fence was actually one of the things that I had talked about with Rob when we were hashing this design out, for exactly the reasons that you mentioned. With the 2x2 shooting attachment nailed to the side of a planing beam used in traditional Japanese woodworking that I mentioned, the 2x2 was typically run beyond the plane stop for this reason.

In theory, it might make things a bit tighter in terms of reference, and if I ever have to build another shooting board for myself I might do that, but in practice it doesn't really matter much. I haven't had an issue in wanting more registration with the outfeed that I have on this board.

From a practical standpoint, extending the outfeed of this shooting board would have cost much more in terms of material and shipping costs (primarily shipping costs), so that's why we decided to leave the fence position as is. The other compromise would have been to keep the overall board the same size, but reduce the working area, meaning that the shooting board would have been limited to more narrow boards.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#11

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

Just to see how far I could push this shooting board setup with a Japanese plane in terms of thicker stock, I was able to shoot the end of a 2x4 cleanly without problems. Of course, that's a thick piece of wood, but it's soft. I found a scrap piece of 6/4 white oak I had lying around, and was able to shoot the end of that as well with some difficulty, but no more difficulty than with the western planes I have.

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#12

Re: Seems ergonomically backward *LINK*

amelon

>Raney,

Below link has a few snippets from a Japanese book on planes which shows some shooting jigs. I've also seen them other Japanese woodworking books. I suspect a few of these jigs are Japanese inventions, but others were likely borrowed from the West.

- Bob


Japanese shooting jigs

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#13

Re: Seems ergonomically backward

Raney

>Thanks Bob - The first of the boards is pretty similar to those Odate pictures in Making Shoji, so I would be inclined to think they're a relatively familiar tool to japanese carpenters. I think it's certainly possible that the miter board shown is somewhat of an import... however, I think the 'western' knowledge about japanese woodworking is pretty much completely dominated by the timberframing/carpentry traditions, and I wonder how much from some of the smaller furniture and decorative tradtions there is that hasn't really made it to the US in a broad way.

That book looks extremely interesting. Is it recent, or just a recent acquisition?

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#14

Use of bench as a plane track

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Bob, very interesting photos. The shooting jigs each involve running the plane on the bench directly, rather than having a western type board with two levels, one for the work and one for the plane track. I like using the bench directly as a plane track, also. Bench has to be very flat of course, in the shooting area.

Wiley

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#15

Re: Seems ergonomically backward *LINK*

amelon

>Raney - The book came out middle of this year. The authors are a group of carpenters from Kezurou-Kai group, including Masaru Kamijo who's known for pulling the big beam planes (ookanna) seen here. Kamijo-san sent my teacher, Jay van Arsdale, a copy of the book. Looks like Amazon.jp carries it (link below). I've ordered things in the past from Amazon.jp using a language translator.

- Bob


Kamijo ookanna

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#16

Minimum "outfeed" *LINK*

amelon

>Hi Derek,

My shooting board for Japanese planes has 2.5" on the outfeed. Since Japanese planes have such heavy blades, I haven't had many issue with the plane tipping over when the blade completes the cut (see photos in link below). But in hindsight, I would make the outfeed 3"-3.5" to be on the safe side. That should be enough. I think anything more will start to impede function (e.g., the outfeed will be in the way).

And I would also add a hotdog to my J-plane. Hahaha... okay, just kidding.

- Bob


img

Japanese shooting board

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#17

Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#18

Japanese hot dog

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The through handle on the HNT Gordon try plane is pretty handy.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#19

Re: Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I may be missing your point, but......

If the bench isn't flat, the shooting jig could easily be at a slight angle to the plane. Bob's photos showed the use of the shooting jig directly on the bench, with the plane running directly on the bench top.

Wiley

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#20

What is that plane mortising machine?

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

What type of strange plane mortising machine is that in the pics? Looks like it mortises in the center of the plane for the blade to rest on.

OT for this forum, but was curious...is that how the planes are made in Japan these days?

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#21

Re: Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I should have said "absolute bench flatness" doesn't matter; but of course, if you've got actual hills and valleys it will matter, a lot.

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#22

Re: What is that plane mortising machine?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Inomoto-san often starts the sole side mortise with a drill press. Am I allowed to know that?

Pam

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#23

Re: What is that plane mortising machine?

amelon

>Alan,

As I understand it, that is how planes are made in a production environment. According to the book "Japan - Culture of Wood," the daiya (plane body maker) Inomoto makes ten thousand plane bodies per year. That's a lot of plane bodies and it's very likely that he uses machines for most of the steps except for the final fitting.

That is one scary looking machine...

- Bob


img

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#24

Re: Bench flatness doesn't matter at all.

amelon

>Wiley/Pam,

My J-shooter was inspired by the design from David Charlesworth. I debated for a bit before adding the plane track to my shooter. I don't want to have to depend on the bench top being flat. The bench in my shop is flat but I sometimes take the shooter to classes and those benches are not guaranteed to be flat. Sometimes they also have nails and glue which can cause a bit of problems. Another advantage is that the shooter is ready to go anywhere/anytime. I had mounted it on a Workmate, worked it off the floor, etc.

- Bob

Re: Evenfall shooting board with Japanese planes

#25

What about your NHK plane?

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

But the plane that you have, that NHK commemorative plane, is all done by hand, right?

This is only for modern manufactured planes, right, or do makers sell the bodies separate from the blades?

Next time I go to Japan I'm gonna search out some of these makers and/or find the tool makers prefecture. This is the first year that nobody in my family visited Japan during Summer...in about 23 years...maybe I'll go next year, would be cool to catch some conference with guy running around in their fundoshis and renaissance socks...drinking sake of course, but that's a given...*lol*

Cheers,

Alan