Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

"Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

Posts

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#26

Re: OK Charlie!

charlie belden

>Bob:

Tried to e-mail this directly to you - but the

e-mail bounced. So I'll post my response here

============

Bob:

As you're obviously a Wrecker, surely you've caught a thread or two on Pointy Sticks. Seemed to be a good idea to put together a compendium of info on the subject gleaned from previous posts, or inspired by sleep deprivation, a touch of hypoglycemia and a healthy dose of caffiene (no other drugs, legal or illegal were used during the writing and illustrating of The Pointy Stick Compendium Project web pages).

I had a lot of fun writing the instructions on how to use a viscocity cup - drunks always seem to be a great source for humor - when they're not trying to pick a fight.

As for shop time - if you can clear off the equiptment and bench top you're more than welcome to use them between the hours of 8 am

and about midnight, give or take an hour. And if you break it, youbuy it. Oh - and no bleeding on anything that'll rust and/or stain. No 'sploshuns neither.

charlie b

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#27

Re: Swan

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bob,

Thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience! I think you've put your finger on the main point. These were the top competitors at a time when mechanics made their living with these tools.

Ever wonder what the guys who made these chisels would think if they could see their wares on eBay 150 years later? I'm not sure whether they would be surprised or not. I have a favorite book, "Diary in America", written by a retired English sea captain named Frederick Marryat, and published in 1839. His travels were in 1837, I believe. He had many observations about the people he came across. One observation was about his time in New England. He said that every 10-year old boy on the street had an idea for an invention that was going to make him rich. He was also taken by the fact that all those kids could read and write, and therefore would later participate in business, political, and legal affairs. Well, he had to be exaggerating a bit to say they all had an invention, but that was his take on the dynamism of that place at that time. That would be the overall context of Witherby, Swan, et al.--a very competitive environment full of ambitious people.

I see these tools on eBay and am surprised at the art in them. Do you suppose they had resident artists, like the car companies do now? I doubt it. Surely the look evolved on the work floor under the overall pressure of competition.

I would take you up on your offer of a loan of chisels; however, my hands are full right because the screw-arm-plough bug bit me and I have a backlog to work off. There is a handled Winsted Plane Co. one right now with a coat of grime on it (and some boxwood peeking out) that needs help. And some sets of plough irons that need re-grinding. Why did they put so much great ornament on those ploughs? Cause they sold better that way--then and now.

Wiley

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#28

What a find! Beautiful chisels.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#29

Thanks for the reminder

Bob Hackett

>Finally got cable and high speed internet down here at the cove.

Wiley clued me as to how to update it.Thanks Wiley.

Mainely,Bob

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#30

Re: Swan

Bob Hackett

>I think that back then the tool companies took customer input alot more seriously.

Wouldn`t be at all surprised to find out that the Chas Bucks and Henry Distons read and answered each and every letter addressed to the company and took reasonable suggestions to heart.What better R&D/design department than your own customers?

Mainely,Bob

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#31

Yep, And I love 'em!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Hi Charlie!

I have a full set of 40's-50's hard to tell now days cause I couldn't afford full length ones. It took me about 2 years to put the set together. Not good for pairing, but for anything 'ceptin small DT's

they rock! If'in you like a heavy chisel.

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#32

Chris Scholz

Re: Chris, are you thinking about having

Chris Scholz

>One of or self-imposed principles is that we do not offer the same product that other manufacturer offers. Would not be ethical in my opinion.

...so many ideas so little time...

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#33

Re: Swan

Hank Knight

>Bob,

After your response I feel I must apologize for my flip comment above about the stamped bird. It was in semi sarcastic response to the many, many "what's the best chisel" posts that appear here. Your response to Wiley is one of the most comprehensive and well articulated commentaries I've seen on the old chisel makers and why their tools are still sought after today. Thank you.

Hank