Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

"Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

Posts

"Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#1

"Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

charlie belden

>"Foreign Made" woodworking handtools (ok excluding Made In China) have a certain mystique about them. And admittedly, a mokume japanese chisel looks, and is, kind of mystiquey. And admit it, Azebiki and Dozuki just sound so cool. And brand names like Pfeil or Stubai just seem more exotic than Stanley or Marples. Come on, Marples sounds like they make english gardening tools and Stanley sounds like a british explorer - Doctor Livingstone I pressume?

Zwei Kirschen - now there's a chisels brand name with some mystique - EURO - and expensive!

While in Munich with my son, who was living and working there at the time, we made a run up to Dick's Fine Tools in Messen (I think that's the name of the town). I'd been getting his really nicely illustrated catalogue for a few years and drooled on them more than I do on Lee Valley catalogues.

Was pretty disappointed when I found out Dick's Fine Tools had gone all Japanese - the owner having gotten HEAVILY into bonsai.

Not wishing to be a Looky Lou, I bought a japanese chisel and marking gauge - and asked where I might find some Two Cherries bench chisels (Zwei Kirschen in Germany, probably "deu anne royale").

Arriving at a place down the road I was a bit surprised that it was like a Home Depot, or Lowes over here in the United States. I was even more surprised when I found the Zwei Kirschen chisels a boatload of them, hung from little plastic end caps - on peg board, next to screw drivers and box/open end wrenches. After doing the DM to $ conversion I was even more surprised - $5 to $10 each, based on the width. I was expecting to spend well over a hundred dollars for a set of 8. Surprise, the eight I picked out came to under $70.

As others will note - they come very shiny - but not really sharp. Figure on spending a little time flattening the back and sharpening. Worth the effort when you go to use them though - and they hold an edge pretty well.

Would really have been surprised if I'd found Stanley or Buck Brothers chisels - in a locked glass case.

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#2

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Two Cherries are very good chisels, a lot of value for the money; but I contend that they cost you a lot more than $70 once you add in the cost of just the day trip, saying nothing about getting to Germany and back. :)

Pam

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#3

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have had several friends go on shopping excursions for me in both Norway and Sweden, looking for Berg chisels. Now, how hard can that be? If you can't find them in Scandinavia, where should they be? All to no avail. I'm just glad I didn't have to share in part of their trip expenses.

bh

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#5

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

charlie belden

>Actually, the trip to Dick's, and the quest for Two Cherries chisels, was just an excuse for a chance to rent a Mercedes and drive the auto bahn - at 125 mph (seems even faster in Kph). It's amazing how little of the country side you see when driving at that speed. Was interesting to have to pull over so a Porsche 928 could go by me, probably pushing 180 mph. Now you see him. Now you don't. Kept a close eye on the rear view mirrors after that experience.

Left turn light blinking = get out of the way when it's safe and convenient.

Headlights on = get out of the way quickly

Headlights on and high beams flashing = go under a semi if you have to - but get the hell out of the way!

Having disk brakes the size of large pizza pans and ABS was reassuring as well.

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#6

And picking up Stubai carving chisels in Vienna

charlie belden

>wasn't so bad either.

The cutlery shop was a couple of streets off a main drag - places I like to explore. The middle aged lady who listened to my needs specs was the grand daughter of the guy who started the place - close to a hundred years earlier. Stubai carving tools came unhandled and unsharpened. They did both for another couple of bucks per tool - and I got to watch.

No fancy sharpening machine here - BIG stone wheels - over a long sink - small hose running water over them - then a little work with slip stones - ta-da - SHARP.

Cost was OK - not a deal like the Two Cherries - but the experience - priceless - and the carving tools ain't bad either.

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#7

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Sounds too exciting for these old bones, although I would have loved it 20 years ago. :)

Pam

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#8

Berg chisels

Bob Hackett

>You might try asking Derek where to look.

The bulk of the nice Bergs I see on Ebay are being sold by folks from Australia.

Mainely,Bob

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#9

I've noticed the number of Bergs found in Oz

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and it makes no sense to me. However, they seem to have a bunch. I just thought, heck, since they were made in Sweden they should have some leftovers there.

bruce

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#10

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

Dan Donaldson

>The autobahn is a whole other experience. The really interesting thing is that the cars there are designed for the speeds. I was in Germany once on a business trip. We were traveling at around 240 clicks and there was no noise or symptoms of strain at all. In fact, we were all playing with the radio and it was not obvious that we were going that fast until we realized that it was taking well over a mile to slow down enough to exit. ;-)

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#11

Since nobody told you yet...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>You suck! :-)

Nice catch...

DC

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#12

Thought about Stanley's Everlast chisels?

charlie belden

>

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#13

A Wrecker Heard From *LINK*

charlie belden

>Don't know if "You suck!" has the same meaning

here as it does in the usenet newsgroup rec.woodworking, but there it's meant as an envious compliment or expressing admiration for a getting a good deal and "sharing" that great deal - aka a gloat, distinguished from a "neener" which is just "I've got one of these - and maybe - you don't. Neener, neener, neener.

Other identifiers of Wreckers

DAMHIKT (Don't Ask Me How I Know This)

SWMBO (She Who Must Be Obeyed)

Blurfle/blurffle (a generic term for a specialized tool or machine or jig)

BLO (Boiled Linseed Oil which involved a schedule as follows

1. flood the wood with BLO

2. let it soak in for a bit

3. wipe off the excess

4. wait half an hour and wipe of the BLO

that's come out of the wood/grain

5. wait another hour and wipe of the BLO

6. wait a couple of hours and check for

"sparklies" - more BLO coming out of the

wood/grain

7. wipe off the sparklies

8. wait a day and repeat steps 8 and 9

until either you die, or hell freezes over.

(the more thorough BLO finishing schedule in can be found on the attached web page - part of the Pointy Stick Compendium Project - done to answer most of the questions repeatedly asked on The Wreck about Pointy Sticks.)


BLO Finish Schedule & Other Finish Info

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#14

Not really,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have most of a set of Bergs from 3mm all the way up to 50mm. They just fit my hand really well and I like way they feel. Besides, about half the ones I have came from my grandfather who was Swedish and acquired them about 50 years ago on a trip to his home town (he grew up near Eskilstuna, Sweden). So there's a family connection. They work so well for me that I've seen no reason to switch.

For whacking I got a set of Hirsch firmers on Bill Tindall's recommendation that also work very well.

bruce

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#15

Chris Scholz

Hey, what's wrong with Chinese Chisels?

Chris Scholz

>...ok, of course we all know what you mean.

But keep in mind that for example Fa. Kunz is a German company that, with exception of their latest planes, isn't really know for best quality.

Similarly, there are some amazing products coming out of China lately.

Chris, DFW, TX

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#16

Chas Buck

roninkokomo

>I know that this topic bubbles up about every six months. I still believe that I would put my Chas Buck chisels ( accumulated over a ten year period) up against any for the edge that you can pout on them and their retention of that edge with a littler care. ( I am a frequent stropper)

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#17

Re: Berg chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Where are all the Berg chisels? Heh heh ... I've locked them all away for safe keeping ... heh heh ...

I have no idea why there are so many Berg chisels around Oz. Actually, there are a few Berg plane blades (for Stanleys) floating around as well. Someone must have been importing them?

Where the USA and Canadian Bergs tend to be socket types, the Australian ones tend to be tanged. I do prefer the tanged types myself. They have a better balance and generally feel more delicate feel when used as parers.

I have put together a set over several years that runs from 1/8 through 1 1/4". I also replaced the handles with something that better suited for paring (they were some of my original turning projects a few years ago). The original hooped handles are short and uncomfortable imo.

Here are my Bergs. You can judge the length of the handles against the Japanese parers to the left ..



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#18

Re: Chas Buck

Bob Hackett

>Chas Buck are the best of the Buck line IMO and many up here prefer them(Cecil Pierce was one of those folks). I`d place them right up the with Whitherby and (my personal favorite)Swan.

Unfortunately the quality of Buck Brothers seemed to slide as the company got older and looked to cut mfg costs till we`re left with something that rates right up there with the present tools being cranked out by Stanley.

Wonder what Charles would have thought of the tools now bearing his family name?

Mainely,Bob

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#19

Swan

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bob,

What is it that you particularly like about the Swan edge tools? Swan, Witherby--these are great names, but what is that makes them great names?

Wiley

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#20

Re: Swan

Hank Knight

>The good Swans have that pretty bird stamped on them. ;>)

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#21

OK Charlie!

Bob Hackett

>As of now you owe me at least 4 hours of shop time.

I made the mistake of clicking on the "Table of contents" link and wasted most of the afternoon laughing so hard I shorted my keyboard with tears.

Make that 4 and a half hours,I had to find and install my old keyboard.

Funny stuff!!!

Mainely,Bob

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#22

Re: Swan

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>And you can't buy them new any more...

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#23

Re: Swan

Bob Hackett

>The attention to detail in the manufacturing for one.

The proportions and balance both visually and in the hand and on the work are another point.

Overall you get the impression they were tools designed by someone who had an interest in making an excellent tool for craftsmen who would use them everyday to turn out top notch work.

When I work with some of the old chisels I`ve collected doing a variety of jobs I`m glad there are tools that feel good and right in my hands.Tools that I know are up to the job and there`s no doubt I am the only limiting factor.

I count Berg,Buck,Underhill,Cam,Whitherby,Swan,and afew others(mostly laminated) among the chisels that allow me to stretch my limits and get a taste of what it may have been like when fine and durable tools were the norm and not the exception.

I tended to pick up most everything I could afford that had a socket on it and have had alot of chisels run thu my hands.Some were only good for cutting the sockets off of in order to repair the abused good ones.I always try a new chisel out before giving up on it and have been pleasantly surprised afew times.I`ve even tried retempering afew that visually looked promising.

I know steel,I`ve worked it all my life and some steels are just better suited for the task at hand than others just like types of wood for the handles.Some you can tell just in the grinding.Some take a honed edge quickly and seem to hold it like a miser no matter what the task or wood.Some give up half way thru the job or roll instantly in oak.The shipyards of Maine were a tough place to work(still are) for both men and tools and a good reputation was hard won thru dependability and ability to perform under trying conditions.The folks who made the tools knew if they wanted to compete here then their products had to be up to for task,no excuses accepted.

Alot of the names that are so sought today are whats left of companies who truly knew the meaning of the words "Value for money".Others,Like Thom LN,grew up hunting and using these old tools and recognized the quality and value contained in them.Knew they were a finite resource and stepped up to fill the gap.

Let me just say that Swan,Whitherby,Berg and their (few)peers are to chisels what LN is to planes.

Hope this ramble explained in part why they`re good.

It`s your fault Wiley!You of all people should know better than to ask my opinion on chisels.;^)

Mainely,Bob

PS-Want to borrow afew and see for yourself?

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#24

Chris, are you thinking about having

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>some good ones made available for import? Your plane irons seem to be greatly appreciated by those who have them.

Wiley

Re: "Foreign Made" chisels Mystique

#25

YES,You can!!

Bob Hackett

>Recently there was an old hardware store around Boston that went up for auction.Inside was NOS dating from around WWII and before,4+ floors of it!

Look on Ebay to see NEW James Swan chisels from folks like Liberty Tool and afew other sellers thru New England.When I say new I mean pics of chisels still in the boxes and wrappers.

I picked up several handfuls of chisels(including mortice chisels and gouges) and turning tools for under $10 apiece(no handles) last time I went to Liberty.My brothers and I are pretty well outfitted now.May even have something left over for secret santa this year.

Mainely,Bob