Re: Trapezoidal & Rectangular (not Hybrid)
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Charlie,
I was trying to describe the standard trapezoidal shape, just as you have drawn it. When I referred to the 'face' of the chisel, I meant the flat side, the back, the 'hard steel' side in a laminated chisel.
When any chisel--rectangular or trapezoidal--is driven into wood, wood fibers are sheared by the sides of the face, moreso even than by the blade edge. Why is it, that when you pull the chisel out, the sides of the cut are clean? It is because the bevel has propelled the face of the chisel forward of the point where the edge first entered the wood. The floor of the cut is created by the edge of the chisel (where back meets bevel), but the sidewalls of the cut were made by the sides of the chisel face.
It is the shearing action of the edges of the face which create reasonably neat mortise walls, and this is true whether one uses a trapezoidal section or a rectangular section.
I understood your statement I quoted earlier to be that only the face of the rectangular chisel will have this shearing action; I am saying that the trapezoidal section chisel does the same thing. People can disagree about whether a mortise chisel should have relief behind the face, but there should be no disagreement as to whether the edges of the face are cutting, whether or not there is relief behind the face.
Wiley



