Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Mortise Chisels

Posts

Re: Mortise Chisels

#26

Re: Trapezoidal & Rectangular (not Hybrid)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Charlie,

I was trying to describe the standard trapezoidal shape, just as you have drawn it. When I referred to the 'face' of the chisel, I meant the flat side, the back, the 'hard steel' side in a laminated chisel.

When any chisel--rectangular or trapezoidal--is driven into wood, wood fibers are sheared by the sides of the face, moreso even than by the blade edge. Why is it, that when you pull the chisel out, the sides of the cut are clean? It is because the bevel has propelled the face of the chisel forward of the point where the edge first entered the wood. The floor of the cut is created by the edge of the chisel (where back meets bevel), but the sidewalls of the cut were made by the sides of the chisel face.

It is the shearing action of the edges of the face which create reasonably neat mortise walls, and this is true whether one uses a trapezoidal section or a rectangular section.

I understood your statement I quoted earlier to be that only the face of the rectangular chisel will have this shearing action; I am saying that the trapezoidal section chisel does the same thing. People can disagree about whether a mortise chisel should have relief behind the face, but there should be no disagreement as to whether the edges of the face are cutting, whether or not there is relief behind the face.

Wiley

Re: Mortise Chisels

#27

Re: Trapezoidal, Rectangular & Hydrid

Joel

>Charlie,

what you are using are sash mortise chisels. nothing wrong with that, they work, and of course are all you need on shallower mortises. With an English Mortise chisel, which are ground differently, both bevel and sides, and have different handles, you can work faster with no loss of end product quality.

No reason for you to switch if you are happy, but there is more than one way to skin a cat and some of the issues you see just don't exist when using a regular mortise chisel.

Re: Mortise Chisels

#28

Yes, I clean up to a line, but.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't get too excited about length. I measure the the tenon length from the mortise at hand. That is to say, cut mortise precisely orthogonal to wood surface, cut tenon cheeks to match mortise width, then lay the tenon on the mortise and mark its length what ever it needs to be.

It would be nearly impossible by any technique to locate the end of a mortise with a chisel worse than the BEST one can do with a hollow chisel mortiser .

A M&T can be the sloppiest joint we make. The only real precision issue in making them is to get them orthogonal. The joint is hidden except for the end of a through M&T, and its huge glue surface makes it less important that every part of it be perfect. The mechanics of the M&T is such that a snug fit at the ends is largely irrelevant and for some applications the mortise is purposely over sized in this dimension to allow for tenon expansion.