Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Brace wood choice . . .

Posts

Brace wood choice . . .

#1

Brace wood choice . . .

steve mackay

>Been collecting pics for awhile. Looks like a challenging project. But I'm wondering what wood would hold up. Oak's grain, I think, is too big but wouldn't apple wood be to soft ? I don't know. Was going to start looking around for some stock. Ideas ?


img

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#2

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

Stuart Hough

>Steve, if your goal is utility, I'd say use hard maple or ash. Beech also seems well-suited for the purpose. I have no idea what was used in those ancient times, so I can't give you any history-based suggestions. Good luck with this, you have my interest piqued. Keep posting pics of your progress.

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#3

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

wayne anderson

>Beech was a traditional material. Probably the easiest to obtain as well, (compared to ebony, rosewood, or buffalo horn). I would personally stay away from ash or oak...too stringy and hard to shape. -w

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#4

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

Bob Demers

>I do believe European beech was the wood used, but its only my guess.

I too has been toying with the idea of making one, I love the form.

I have one very similar to your pic, but its mostly a show piece, im almost scare to put it to hard use, hence why I thought I should attempt making one.

The hardest part would be making the button chuck part, im guessing.

If you do make one, ill be curious to see / read about it

Good luck

Bob, whose everyday go to brace is a Spofford brace

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#5

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I've made a few of these. Once you remove the wood in the center, what keeps the bit end and the head end in line? I think you want 1/4 sawn material. Good luck finding beech this big with this grain orientation.

I've made braces out of apple (started with a section of trunk), and soft maple. The trick is getting the part that holds the bit lined up with the head. They need to be coaxial, i.e. their centers of rotation need to be pretty close.

Adam

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#6

Osage Orange

Dave Thompson

>Not traditional, but it sure would be nice. It's very tight grain would make it a real pleasure to hold. Being the hardest wood in north america it would certainly be durable. Don't let the pretty initial orange color fool you. After a year or so, UV will turn it a rich brown, not quite as dark as cocobolo, but would contrast nice with the brass. If you don't have a local source (e.g. arborist), often some is available on e-bay.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#7

Chinese elm

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Chinese elm would be perform well. It is my choise for all my chisel handles and allows me to use a mallet or my palm and not have to use a metal hoop. I also use Chinese elm for my hammer handles and my carving mallets. I have found that it is more resistant to spliting than any other north american wood I have used.

Chinese elm is the one with a scaly bark like sycamore and small elm like leaves. It has a pepery scent rather than the barn yard smell of the other elms.

Robin

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#8

Re: Brace wood choice . . .  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Steve

I think that the traditional woods are Beech and Ebony. Both are going to be difficult/expensive to source.

The two braces I have made to date come from Jarrah and She-Oak. Both are woods with short, interlinked grain. This appears to increase their stiffness and strength, attributes needed in a brace.

The braces I made are perhaps at the extreme of the structural demands (they were forms that had to fill a function). I think that both were successful in this regard.

Is there a local wood that has similar structure to these?

I am not sure how much you can use from the build tutorial I have on my website, but I have a link to it below.



Regards from Perth

Derek


Brace for AWR competition

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#9

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Steve,

The real problem you are going to have is making the spring chuck, it is cast brass probably with a lead or pewter liner in the tapered hole. If you don't make the cast chuck make sure you use a ferrule to protect the end.

My first brace was out of cherry and did not have a ferrule. I had the brace for several years before it broke. The square tapered hole is the hardest part of the brace.

I have made a couple more, both of maple and both with iron ferrules.

Stephen

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#10

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

roninkokomo

>I'd go with curly maple

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#11

Re: Osage Orange

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I agree Dave. I once did some summer work for my Uncle who owned and worked a large farm. He hired people to cut the weeds out of the fields of corn and soybeans to improve yield at harvest. He supplied the tools and provided transportation. He also had an old hoe that had been rehandled with "Hedge Oak" otherwise known as Osage Orange. It got grabbed first every time. The feel of that handle after years of use was indescribable. It was like...ummm...err... real smooth! :-)

Joe

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#12

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Steve .... the only brace I ever made (my son liberated it when he moved east, so I don't have a pic) was made from a piece of gnarly red oak that I found in the firewood pile. It was so crooked it wouldn't fit in the woodstove, but the grain was almost perfect for making the shape of a brace. I think the inlayed brass in the picture you attached will strengthen the cross grain areas sufficiently to overcome the danger of splitting.

Good luck .......... rj

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#13

I never knew that about Chinese elm

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>It was extensively used in North Dakota for shelter belts - wind breaks around farmsteads and between fields. Turned out to be a poor choice because they don't live very long. The thousands of miles of rows of Chinese elms planted in the early 1950's are dying, so there's also miles of chisel handles to be had up there.

Bruce

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#14

Maybe they just can't handle Minnesota weather

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>those hot, humid summers and all.

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#15

actually North Dakota winters

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I don't see them around here much. Too hot and humid, I guess :-)

b

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#16

From a design standpoint....

Marv

>Steve,

From a design standpoint, determine where the most stress will be exerted and make that area of the tool more massive than other areas such as the turn handle where there is compartively less stress. Do this no matter what type wood you use.

For added strength, I would insert a dowel into that stress area.

Marv

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#17

Chris Scholz

Re: Chinese elm

Chris Scholz

>Yumu in Chinese (the first "u" is pronounced as if it had an "umlaut", that's what the "y" does to you!).

There are two main types: Northern yumu and Southern yumu. Very popular with Chinese woodworkers either with a tung oil finish or as base material to apply Chinese lacquer. Considered a softwood.

Re: Brace wood choice . . .

#18

Thanks all . . .

steve mackay

>One step closer. Well, at least out of the day dream stage. After that one on the LV cover awhile ago I've been fascinated.